12 DC Characters Who Were Wasted In The Arrowverse

They're the heroes we need, but they don't always get the adaptations they deserve.

By Ashley Tuchin /

Having served up numerous shows since Arrow's humble beginnings, and with several new series on the way, the Arrowverse has introduced mainstream audiences to many of DC Comics' lesser-known characters. However, adapting characters from the crazy world of comics to the small screen can be difficult and as such there are many characters that have not been used to their full potential in the Arrowverse.

Advertisement

Yes, while they might have made the likes of Green Arrow and Black Lightning household names, not every character adapted for this TV universe has been so lucky. For every underrated hero given their own show, there’s an equally deserving character who was denied the chance to shine.

Sometimes it's a matter of the character being butchered in the adaptation process, in an attempt to make them fit in with the established universe. Other times it might be a matter of them being so underutilised that they never get to reach their full potential, leaving fans to wonder why the writers bothered using them at all.

So slip into your muted leather outfit and grab your nearest techno-babble plot device, as we take a look at 12 DC Comics characters who could do with a little more love in the Arrowverse.

12. Most Of The Legends

Including multiple characters together here may be a bit of a cheat, but that's perfectly fine when highlighting how so many Legends have been wasted in the Arrowverse.

Advertisement

Over the course of its five-season run to date, the Legends of Tomorrow crew have seen a rotating roster of characters who have ranged from the obscure and inconsequential, to some serious mid-range heroes who could surely have been better utilised elsewhere.

Most notable are characters such as the Atom, Firestorm, Hawkman and Hawkgirl, who, in the comics at least, are all pretty major players in the Justice League and Justice Society.

Then you have Isis, or Zari as she's known on the show, who has the potential to open up the Arrowverse to the Shazam family, but has been increasingly removed from her comic book inspiration. Even the ever-lovable John Constantine, who was offered a lifeline by the show after years of bobbing in the wake of his own show's cancellation, feels like he's just been tacked on because the powers at be wanted to do SOMETHING with him.

Then, of course, there's the loveable rogue Heat Wave and his dead best pal, Captain Cold. But we'll get to them in a moment.

11. Dr. Alchemy

The beginning of The Flash's third season was mainly concerned with the Flashpoint storyline, but we were quickly treated to hints that the big bad for the season was going to be long-time Flash villain, Dr. Alchemy. This was an interesting prospect ,as it marked the first time that the main villain of the season wouldn't be a speedster. The idea that one of The Flash's regular Rogues could be the big bad was exciting, especially the way he was altered to work in with the Flashpoint storyline. Plus, his weapon of choice was the Philosopher's Stone - and that opens up so many possibilities!

Advertisement

Things continued to get more interesting as we learned that not only was Alchemy actually Barry's new co-worker Julian, but the poor guy was completely unaware of his criminal alter ego, a key aspect of the character in the comics. However, we soon discovered that Julian/Alchemy was just a puppet for Savitar - yet another speedster villain - and Alchemy quickly fell by the wayside.

To say that it was disappointing to see Alchemy supplanted by Savitar is an understatement, no matter what twists were worked into Savitar's identity. But even worse, is the fact that Julian completely disappeared offscreen between seasons after settling in as a member of Team Flash. Perhaps we could use the Philosopher's Stone to transmute a better screen role for our hooded friend.

10. Doctor Light

For the uninitiated, there are two major characters named Doctor Light in DC Comics. Firstly, there's the villainous Dr. Arthur Light, then there's the heroic Dr. Kimiyo Hoshi. Both characters have strong histories in the comics, yet the Arrowverse has used them in some pretty weird, mismatched ways.

Advertisement

First, Arthur Light was namedropped by Caitlin Snow in her debut appearance back in Season Two of Arrow. Then we got our first Doctor Light proper (kinda) in Season Two of The Flash, where she was an Asian-American woman, similar to the Japanese Dr. Hoshi, but was actually the villainous Earth-2 counterpart to Barry Allen's one-time girlfriend Linda Park.

Finally, in The Flash's sixth season, we got the actual Kimiyo Hoshi version of the character, only rather than the heroic scientist of the comics, she was an assassin working for the criminal organisation, Black Hole. It's beyond mortal comprehension why the gods of the Arrowverse seem so determined to use Hoshi and characters based on her as villains, when they already have a villainous Doctor Light available for use. What's more, in an age where diversity has become a hot issue in the arts, you'd think a powerful, comic-accurate Japanese female hero would be an easy pick for adaptation.

Sadly though, it seems that this version of Doctor Light is destined to have her good name tarnished by the Arrowverse, while her evil predecessor barely even warrants a mention.

9. Connor Hawke

Oh boy, poor Connor Hawke. Here's another character, much like Doctor Light, who has had an unusual history of adaptation in the Arrowverse. You see, Connor is a pretty significant character in the comic book world, being the son of Oliver Queen, and being the second person to take on the Green Arrow mantle. Now, if somebody told you that a Connor Hawke character and Oliver's son were both introduced into the Arrowverse, you'd assume they were one and the same person, right? Well, you'd be wrong.

Advertisement

That's right, for some unknown reason, those rascals behind Arrow decided to introduce Oliver's long-lost son, only to name him William Clayton. Then, creating further confusion, Connor was introduced in Legends of Tomorrow when the Waverider crew took a trip to Star City, 2046. Only, rather than being Oliver's son, he was John Diggle's. Things continued to get more confusing further down the track, as the writers flip-flopped between making Connor the biological or adoptive son of Diggle.

It was all pretty moot though, as this version of Hawke served little except for a bit of fan service and to try and help set up an Arrow spin-off called Green Arrow and the Canaries. However, since said show was set to feature an adult William, as well as Oliver's Arrowverse daughter Mia in the role of the new Green Arrow, one can't help but wonder why they couldn't have streamlined things by just giving us the Connor Hawke/Green Arrow of the comics.

8. Count Vertigo

In the comics, Count Vertigo usually ranks as one of Oliver Queen's most persistent and well-known foes. A deposed former ruler of the fictional European nation of Vlatava, he was born with an inner ear condition that affected his balance. This was rectified with a special implant he discovered could be used to affect another person's balance and alter their perception, which he then used to embark on a life of crime.

Advertisement

So to say that his drug-dealing Arrowverse counterparts have little in common with their source material would be an understatement. To be fair though, back when Arrow was first devised, it was envisioned as a grounded and mostly realistic show, so the changes make sense. Plus, you've got to give them credit for finding a creative way to keep the character's name.

Now, there's no denying that Seth Gabel was brilliant in his campy-yet-terrifying portrayal of the character, but he was gone all too soon. His Peter Stormare-played successor was much less memorable though, and seemed to be gone just as quickly as he arrived. In the end, the Count just never seemed to reach the heights of his comic book inspiration, a victim of those attempts at grounded realism.

You'd think that at some point in the five seasons that followed, after opening up the Arrowverse to metahumans and aliens and Flashpoints and Crises, that they would have been able to give us a Count Vertigo that could do his comic book counterpart proud.

7. Ragman

Season Five of Arrow saw an influx of new characters, as Oliver trained up a group of new vigilantes to join his crusade. One such hero was Rory Reagan, a.k.a. Ragman.

Advertisement

While this version of the character was quite different to most comic book interpretations, the Ragman of the Arrowverse was still shown to be incredibly powerful, utilising ancient rags imbued with mystical powers. This easily made him one of the most formidable members of Team Arrow and one of the very few to actually possess superhuman abilities - which is why it is understandable, yet also an incredible shame, that Rory was swiftly written out from the show, never to be seen again.

Rory's primary reason for being seems to have been to create tension with Felicity, given that his hometown of Havenrock was destroyed partially due to her actions. Besides this, his mystical powers made him the clear heavy hitter of the team, with his Devarim Rags being able to withstand all sorts of abuse, including gunshots and, oh yeah, a nuclear bomb!

Despite being such an asset to Team Arrow, Rory made a swift exit from the show after said nuclear incident, which sapped his rags of their power.

Even without his comic book power of collecting wicked souls within his rags, Ragman was still an incredibly powerful and interesting character. It's just a darned shame that they never managed to do anything more with him.

6. Wild Cat

Debuting in the Golden Age of Comics, Ted Grant was a heavyweight boxer who fought crime under the costumed identity of Wild Cat. He was a member of the Justice Society of America and is well known for having trained several younger heroes in the comics, including the second Black Canary.

Advertisement

This backstory more or less remained intact when Grant made his Arrowverse debut in Season Three of Arrow. Here, Grant had been a vigilante well before Oliver's return to Starling City and took to training Laurel Lance in her early Black Canary days.

Ted had a fairly prominent arc throughout Arrow's third season, but ultimately only appeared in a handful of episodes before disappearing without any explanation. Much like Ragman, he was barely mentioned again after his exit, which is a major disappointment because Grant could have been a valued member of Team Arrow if given the chance.

Having been a vigilante before the days of the Hood, Wildcat could have filled a role as a mentor to Oliver and other heroes, as he's done in the comics. This could have been tremendously handy in Season Five, where Ted could have stepped up to help train Oliver's batch of new recruits. Sadly though, 'twas not meant to be and we'll be left wondering what became of Ted Grant forever more.

Oh well, at least now we have Stargirl's Yolanda Mortez to fill the Wild Cat-shaped hole in our hearts.

5. Captain Cold

Ah, now this is where things really start to hurt and the frustration of what could have been becomes too much to bear.

Advertisement

In the first season of The Flash, a great amount of care was put into Leonard Snart, a.k.a. Captain Cold, being shown as a truly charming and effective villain who shared great chemistry with the Scarlet Speedster. Although Eobard Thawne was the big bad of that debut season, Wentworth Miller was an absolute delight as the Master of Absolute Zero and we couldn't help but cheer whenever he showed up on screen. Snart was a perfect recurring adversary/uneasy ally who had a fascinating moral complexity, and it was clear that there were big things planned for him.

However, those plans were cut short when the Captain and his fellow Rogue, Heat Wave were shipped over to Legends of Tomorrow to serve as founding members of the Waverider crew. And while, yes, Snart did have a pretty prominent character arc in that show, ending with his death at the end of its first season, one can't help but help but wonder... was it worth sacrificing all that Snart could have brought to The Flash? Fans deserved to see Captain Cold's relationship with Barry Allen evolve, but as it stands it feels like it ended prematurely.

Of course, different versions of Snart have popped up since, but that momentum from the early days of The Flash has well and truly been lost, leaving the Captain out in the cold.

4. The Rogues

The other tragedy of Captain Cold and Heat Wave being shuffled over to the Legends crew, is that fans never got to see the proper formation of the Rogues. Throughout the first season of The Flash, it was made clear that viewers were witnessing the gradual formation of the iconic team, which consists of some of the Flash's most colourful enemies. The first season saw the introduction of several Rogues, but it was ultimately all for naught, with the concept of a collected group of Rogues seeming to fizzle out after Captain Cold and Heat Wave took their leave from Central City.

Advertisement

On top of that, several potential Rogues were drastically underutilised on the show. For instance, one of Sultan of Speed's most iconic villains, Captain Boomerang, only ever appeared in episodes of Arrow (even if one was part of a Flash crossover), never actually appearing in The Flash itself. Then there's the Sam Scudder version of Mirror Master, who fans were desperate to see appear in the show, but ultimately only appeared in a couple of episodes, before being eclipsed by a new gender-bent Mirror Master further down the road.

For a show that relies so heavily on the villain-of-the-week formula, you'd think the showrunners would make better use of the vast and colourful rogues' gallery that The Flash has to offer. Heck, it might have even been cool to see a season where the Rogues served as the big bads.

3. The Justice Society Of America

The Justice Society of America was the first superhero team in comic book history, representing a collective of some of DC's greatest heroes of the Golden Age, with a legacy that has lasted to this very day. However, in their first foray into the Arrowverse, this fan-favourite super team was pretty well butchered, with fans being treated to a JSA that was a shadow of its comic book self.

Advertisement

After being teased in the closing moments of Legends of Tomorrow's debut season, the JSA made their first full Arrowverse appearance at the beginning of the show's second season. However, despite initial excitement, many fans were left disappointed by what they saw. Consisting largely of legacy characters who had no place being in a WWII version of the team, such as Obsidian and Stargirl, this JSA completely lacked the charm and character of the comic book team. Rather than a shining homage to the Golden Age of Comic Books, they just seemed like another group of Arrowverse heroes in muted leather costumes. The worst part is that the group was clearly only used to introduce a new version of Vixen, despite the fact that she has never been affiliated with the JSA in the comics.

Still, at least now we have the Stargirl series to breathe fresh air into the Arrowverse and offer fans the live-action JSA that they actually deserve.

2. Geo-Force/Dr. Brion Markov

Chances are that even the most ardent Arrowverse fan will take a look at this name and say "Who?" That's because Dr. Brion Markov only appeared in a single episode of Arrow's first season, though he did have a big impact on the show, being the man responsible for creating the earthquake device which Malcolm Merlyn used to level the Glades.

Advertisement

Okay, so you're probably still wondering why that earns him a place on this list, especially in such a high position. Well, that's because the Brion Markov of the comics isn't a scientist, he's the prince of the fictional nation of Markovia - oh yeah, and he's a superhero!

That's right, going by the name of Geo-Force, Markov has a laundry list of geokinetic powers ranging from gravity manipulation, to the ability to create earthquakes. What's more, he was a founding member of the Outsiders, the rebound team set up by Batman after he left the Justice League that one time.

Yes, it's pretty obvious that the Arrow writers only used that name as a throwaway reference, given that they needed a scientist who specialised in earthquakes. And yes, this was a fairly common practice in the early days of the Arrowverse, with even Felicity Smoak initially being a throwaway reference to a comic book character. But come on, to take a hero as powerful as Geo-Force and reduce him to a throwaway charcater? That's no way to treat royalty.

1. Wally West

Oh dear, poor Wally.

Advertisement

In the comics, he served as the original Kid Flash, before eventually stepping into Barry Allen's golden boots to become the third Flash. This was a mantle Wally West wore for decades in the comics, before the return of Barry and several timeline shakeups left Wally adrift and struggling to find a place in the new status quo.

That's still better than how the Arrowverse version fared, though.

While Wally did still become Kid Flash on TV, that's really all there is to say about him. He was introduced as a long-lost member of the West family, caused some drama, got super-speed, did a stint as Barry's sidekick and then buggered off. It's obvious that the writers had no idea what to do with him, since the Arrowverse has sort of made the concept of sidekicks redundant with their hero support team structure. Not to mention the fact that, unless they chose to follow the comics and have Wally take over from Barry, then there was only so much that could be done with him. And let's face it, that was never going to happen.

So Wally suffered the fate of all unwanted Arrowverse supporting characters: he was shipped off to the Waverider for a spell, before drifting off into obscurity, only popping up for the occasional guest appearance.

It's a pity that a character who spent decades in the comics proving himself to be a hero in his own right, has been all but forgotten onscreen.

Advertisement