12 Greatest One-Off Simpsons Characters

We never saw them again, but they left a real impression.

By Josh Mills /

No show in TV history has a bench as deep as The Simpsons’. Over 30 years of broadcasting has given them a whole town’s worth of weird and wonderful characters to play with, and they’ve been eager to add real depth to most of the roster. Springfield residents may debut as stereotypes or quick gags, but in due course they're often given real depth.

Advertisement

Sometimes, though, they bring out a one and done character. They show up, they do their bit, and they leave town, never to be seen again. This may be due to a guest voice who they can’t reasonably bring back, or simply come down to the limitations of the characters - not every creation has to have a fleshed out backstory, a family history and so forth - there just aren’t enough hours in the day.

The brevity of a character’s life span does not necessarily have any bearing on the quality, though. Some of The Simpsons’ most indelible creations stuck around for no longer than the one episode - their runs were as brief as they come, but the jokes and impressions left are as memorable as any the show has had.

12. Roy

Roy is a complete one joke character. He’s a parody of Scrappy Doo and the like, characters injected into an established show in an attempt to freshen things up and skewer towards a younger audience. He’s a product of the radical ‘90s; by the end of the half hour he’ll go off to live with two sexy ladies, and that’ll be that.

Advertisement

As such, he’s essentially a nonentity in the episode “Itchy And Scratchy And Poochie”, and his blandness is all part of the gag. He suddenly appears in the Simpson household, a cool college kid in backwards cap and shades whose presence no one questions.

As well as a counterpoint to Poochie, the hip new canine addition to Itchy And Scratchy, Roy was a response to a real life network note from a Fox executive who felt it was time the show mixed things up a bit with a new member of the Simpson clan.

Roy’s appearance, and everyone’s acceptance of it, is hilarious, but the daftness of this new edgy character suddenly materialising in a beloved show is the most creative way to dismiss a frankly terrible idea from the network suits.

11. Lucius Sweet

The Don King spoof admittedly makes a couple of background cameos outside his main appearance, but the character was only ever really used meaningfully in “The Homer They Fall”, in which Homer becomes a boxer, fighting against a Mike Tyson parody under Sweet’s stewardship.

Advertisement

In a neat meta gag, Homer describes Sweet as being exactly as rich and famous as Don King, and looking just like him too. Sweet was formerly Moe’s manager during the bartender’s abortive boxing career, and he serves to fill in much of the character’s ever evolving backstory.

Sweet is a particularly colourful character - culture clashes are a frequent source of comedy on The Simpsons, and it’s good fun to see the sleazy and small time worlds of Moe and Homer come up against this epitome of glitz and glamour.

Even eight seasons in, the writers were still building Springfield up, adding new areas and cultures we had not yet been exposed to, and Lucius Sweet is a perfect example of that. While he seems like little more than a playful spoof, he actually adds a lot to the mythology of one of fiction’s greatest creations, Springfield.

10. Mindy Simmons

Homer and Marge’s marriage comes under scrutiny and attack more often than most unions. We’d seen Homer withstand the advances of country songstress Lurleen Lumpkins by this point, but his workplace crush on Mindy Simmons proved to be far greater a temptation for the Simpsons patriarch.

Advertisement

Mindy is, essentially, the female Homer - she gets away with as little work as she can, she loves doughnuts, and generally has the same slobbish approach to life as our hero. Voiced by Michelle Pfeiffer, Mindly is pitched as the perfect woman for Homer (whose own family have, through various ailments and incidents, as one become particularly unappealing in the short term).

Pfeiffer is given a good bit of character to work with, and she and the script ensure that Mindy is more than just a stock villain. She and Homer find themselves drawn together, but both know that they need to fight their urges, and make every effort to do so while fates conspire to keep them close.

Mindy is ultimately just the obstacle to a Homer and Marge reunion, but she’s a strong character all the same. She could be little more than a fantasy for Homer - instead she gets a perspective of her own and the semblance of a life outside The Simpsons.

9. John

There are elements of “Homer’s Phobia” that don’t stand up too well to modern scrutiny. It’s a well meaning episode, with Homer and his intolerance the butt of the joke throughout, but it undeniably leans on some hoary, even offensive depictions of gay characters for cheap laughs.

Advertisement

This doesn’t apply, however, to John, the proprietor of an offbeat tat shop around whom the episode revolves. Voiced by, and modelled on, outre writer/director John Waters, John does embody a number of cliches, but there’s far more to his character than his sexuality. He’s a delightful presence in The Simpsons, delivering witty asides and befriending Bart before an unusually vociferous Homer demonstrates a surprising level of intolerance.

While John is present to make a point in the episode, he’s no strawman or token offering. He is given a great deal of character to work with, and Waters’ effortless voicework makes for one of the best guest performances in the show’s history.

Indeed he’s among the most well rounded characters the show has created in general, despite only getting one episode in the spotlight.

8. Malloy

The pilfering pensioner is one of the most likeable one shot characters in The Simpsons’ history, which is unsurprising when you consider that he is portrayed by the being of pure goodness that is Sam Neill.

Advertisement

“Homer The Vigilante” is an especially packed episode of prime Simpsons, with a plot driven by Neill’s catburglar character. He creates a panic in town by robbing the folks of Springfield blind, but once he works his charms - winning the angry mob round with the assertion that the town stole his heart - they’re happy to have him around, thief or otherwise.

The character is another outsider who rolls into Springfield and effortlessly outsmarts the town’s residents. Homer, in his role as catburglar hunter, manages to detail him briefly, but the wily thief sends the venal residents off on a wild goose chase while he slips out of jail.

It’s a lovely turn from the always enjoyable Neill, and a key example of a character who only really needed to be the catalyst for silliness, but instead was lovingly fleshed out to create a great anchor to the episode.

7. Sherry Bobbins

Unlike a lot of these characters, we can be sure we won’t be seeing Shary Bobbins again, as her starring episode ends with the Mary Poppins spoof being sucked into an aeroplane propellor, a surprisingly grizzly ending for an otherwise toe tapping musical episode of The Simpsons.

Advertisement

“Simpsoncalifragilisticexpiala(Annoyed Grunt)cious” asks what would happen if a character like Mary Poppins, a being of pure positive energy, were to find herself in the Simpsons universe. The answer: quickly become dispirited and resort to drinking with Barney.

Shary Bobbins leads the family through some of the best songs in the Simpsons canon, with heartwarming songs about alcoholism and laziness. This is Mary Poppins updated for the cynical ‘90s, encouraging negative behaviour so long as it gets you the desired results.

Demonstrating the effort and attention going into this period’s episodes, the character of Shary Bobbins goes beyond the simple gag of a Mary Poppins spoof to actually consider how the character would get on in this world. The answer: not very well.

6. Rex Banner

"Homer vs. the Eighteenth Amendment" follows a classic Simpsons format: public outrage in Springfield leads to an overcorrection making sweeping changes, only for it to be reset at the end of the episode. This prohibition-themed instalment might be the best of its kind, though, primarily down to Rex Banner.

Advertisement

An uptight cop based on various portrayals of Elliot Ness, Banner appears to have wandered into The Simpsons from a different show altogether. He slings the ever ineffective Chief Wiggum out of office and takes over Springfield’s law enforcement. He’s morally upright and unbending, but his prohibition-era slang makes him indecipherable to many of the city’s rubes and oafs.

Banner makes a great foil for Homer, the hard working, officious cop vs the happy go lucky chancer making a buck bootlegging. His hilltop argument with the beer baron is a great moment, as is Banner’s unhappy birthday at the ice cream parlour.

A plot-heavy episode, it rushes to a conclusion in order to wrap things up and get rid of Banner, but the character and the premise had real legs, and could possibly be put to further use.

5. Very Tall Man

At its peak, The Simpsons could be the smartest show on TV, weaving deft satire with pop cultural savviness and a razor sharp critique of the modern American family. Sometimes, though, all they needed to do was create a very tall character with a very silly voice and they’d have nothing short of gold.

Advertisement

The Very Tall Man shows up at the end of "22 Short Films About Springfield", one of the most gag-heavy episodes ever made, and pretty much steals the show. The sketch is beautifully simple - Nelson laughs at his hunched appearance driving an insufficiently sized car; the Very Tall Man chases the bully through the streets, and gives him a public dressing down and humiliation.

The beauty is in the voice, a daffy drawl beautifully performed by Hank Azaria. It’s a high concept episode, but its biggest laughs come from comically simple sources, like a big beanpole of a man exacting revenge on the town bully.

The Very Tall Man makes a few further background appearances, but there was really nowhere else to go with the character. He’s a one joke creation - but what a joke it is.

4. Stacy Lovell

A seriously underrated episode of classic Simpsons, "Lisa vs. Malibu Stacy" is elevated by a great guest turn from Kathleen Turner. The smoky voiced actress is the perfect choice for Stacy Lovell, the jaded, hard drinking creator of the titular Barbie-spoofing doll.

Advertisement

Turner brings a lived in feel to the character, who is impressively well fleshed out over a small amount of screen time. Lovell is deeply cynical, lacking the motivation - or sobriety - to assist Lisa in her quest to create a more empowering role model for young girls than the cliche-spouting talking doll that drives the plot.

Stacy Lovell is a lesson in not meeting your heroes - Lisa is shocked that the creator of such an important product to her has become so bitter over the years. But Lovell is re energised by Lisa’s well meaning dedication, and commits to the cause of creating a more socially conscious doll, before learning the dispiriting lesson that you can’t beat big business.

A great example of the underlying downbeat air of early Simpsons, the character - and Turner - hit all the right notes, a richly detailed invention accomplishing a lot in just one appearance.

3. Lyle Lanley

Few actors outside of the main cast have contributed as much to The Simpsons as Phil Hartman. The late Hartman was effortlessly funny, and made characters like Troy McClure and Lionel Hutz among the show’s best.

Advertisement

More rarely, he performed as one-off characters, and the best of these is Lyle Lanley. Inspired by the film The Music Man, Lanley is a born performer, breezing into Springfield and convincing them to spend a recent windfall on a faulty monorail with a rousing song and dance number.

Hartman tended to slip an edge of sleazy scheming into his creations, and Lanley is no exception. A confidence trickster in a natty bow tie and boater, he is the catalyst for one of the all time great episodes, “Marge Vs The Monorail”, and demonstrates just how easily the folks of Springfield can be led astray by a dumb idea with slick presentation.

Lanley ultimately gets his comeuppance, inadvertently returning to another town he’d flogged a faulty monorail too, and may even end up killed. He managed to contribute a hell of a lot in his brief time.

2. Hank Scorpio

Albert Brooks is a hit machine when it comes to Simpsons characters, with Jacques, Brad Goodman, and movie antagonist Russ Cargill under his belt. Most would likely agree, however, that his greatest contribution as Hank Scorpio, the Bond villain who becomes Homer’s best ever boss in “You Only Move Twice”.

Advertisement

A fast talking, gleefully insane bad guy, Hank Scorpio runs the outwardly benign Globex Corporation while trying to take over the world simultaneously. He is prone to some twisting, turning trains of thought, eager to discuss the phenomenon of a man saying goodbye to a shoe, and his views on Cypress Creek’s hammock district.

Brooks, a true comedic talent, was given license to ad lib parts of his dialogue, giving Scorpio’s conversations with Homer a distinctive vibe as the performers bounce off one another in a manner rarely seen.

The larger than life character would be out of place in The Simpsons’ regular universe, but his episode is a perfect showcase for a performer of Brooks’ wild talents, and the scene in which he has Homer hang up his coat is one of the funniest ever.

1. Frank Grimes

One of the darkest episodes in The Simpsons’ canon was built around the premise: what if a real life person stumbled into the show? We all enjoy Homer’s oafish failings, but working alongside him, the episode posits, would be a nightmare.

Advertisement

Frank Grimes is a lesson in the unfairness of life. From a difficult beginning, Grimes put himself through college and earned an impressive set of qualifications, only to find himself working alongside a man as stupendously unsuitable for the job as Homer.

From there he develops a deep loathing for Homer, who lives in a spacious house with a loving family (while Grimes lives between two bowling alleys) and cruises from one adventure to the next, while Grimes grafts for what meagre money he makes.

Modelled on Michael Douglas’ Falling Down character, Frank Grimes couldn’t be more perfect an enemy for Homer, a man so ignorant of the world around him that he doesn’t even realise he has a mortal foe.

The ending sees him frazzled to a crisp and Homer, again without meaning to, getting the last laugh at his funeral. It’s an exercise in cruelty, but we laugh because we can all recognise a little Frank “Grimey” Grimes in ourselves.

Advertisement