As a rule, when some is dead, they're dead; unless of course you're in The Walking Dead, in which case you'll be back in a few hours very hungry but not necessarily looking your best. Because in TV land, characters are brought back from the dead all the time. There are a few ingenious ways in which this can happen but more often than not, their resurrection is far less successful. From TV shows going with the big flashy 'a character dies in the season finale cliff-hanger' to actors making a triumphant return to the show long after we've mourned their character's death. TV is littered with the corpses of ridiculous scenarios where all plausibility is broken and audiences leave confused, irritated or just plain bemused by the events on screen. In this article we look at 12 TV character resurrections that bordered on the ridiculous as we ask ourselves, what were the writers thinking?
12. The Medical Mysteries Of A Fifteenth Century Philosopher Healed Me Allison Doren (Alias)
In what was one of the most shocking twists in Alias's five year history (and there were a lot of them), Sidney Bristow's best friend Francie Calfo was shot in the head...by herself. Or as it turned out, the villainous Allison Doren, who was surgically altered to resemble her victim. The 'evil Francie' story line bubbled along nicely in the latter half of season two, leading to the epic confrontation between Allison and Sidney in one of the longest and most brutal fights in TV history. Fortunately Sidney won the day, shooting Allison in the chest several times and killing her. Not only that, the apartment they were in burned down and Sidney vanished for two years, waking up with no memory of what had happened to her in Hong Kong (another fantastic plot twist). However it wasn't just Sidney that returned from the grave...Allison did too. How did she survive being shot in the chest? Well it turns out the new big bad, The Covenant, had access to the works of the show's mysterious Fifteenth Century Philosopher / Leonardo Da Vinci wannabe, Milo Rambaldi. Like many of the McGuffins in the show, Rambaldi's creations not only allowed Allison to live, but it also gave her an uncanny healing ability. After all that had happened in season two it felt ridiculous to have 'evil Francie' back the following year. It undid all the drama and suspense of season two. Fifteen Century medical miracles aside, sometimes when a baddie is killed, they should just stay dead, no matter how good they are.
11. My Long Lost Love Has Returned But Only I Can See Him Denny (Grey's Anatomy)
Surgeons are capable of many great things and those at Seattle Grace / Grey Sloan Memorial (or whatever the hospital is called these days) are some of the very best on television. It's what Grey's Anatomy really excels at; ground breaking surgeries and bizarre medical cases. The many angst-ridden relationships are just window dressing. However there is one thing even these doctors cannot do; bring a character back to life two years after he died. You'll be forgiven for thinking I'm talking about Supernatural, where ghostly resurrections are two a penny. But Jeffrey Dean Morgan wasn't playing Sam and Dean's father John Winchester in this case; he was Izzy's long lost love Denny, the man whose LVAD wire Izzy famously cut in order to save his life in season two, only for him to die anyway. Everything about his return in season four is frankly ridiculous. The impact of his death was ruined by bringing him back into the show. A hallucination caused by her metastatic melanoma, we witnessed week after week an intelligent, skilled surgeon ignoring her symptoms and having invisible sex in her room with a two-year dead / ghost lover instead. Denny's return wasn't a bittersweet reunion; it was a stupid, drawn out plot that took the show off the deep end. Thankfully with all that mess dealt with and Izzy's treatment underway, the show would get back to what it was good at.
10. I Didn't Really Shot Myself In The Head! I've Gone Undercover Fox Mulder (The X Files)
Season cliff-hangers are tricky things to resolve. They need to leave audiences stunned, desperate to find out what happens next. 'I am Locutus Of Borg' in Star Trek: The Next Generation season three. The aforementioned 'two years later' and 'My name isn't really Michael Vaughan' in Alias season's two and four. 'We have to go back to the island' in Lost season three. I could go on about big, bold cliff-hangers forever. The trouble is, following that up with something equally spectacular in the following season's opener often has the tendency to fall a little flat. As a season cliff hanger, the death of a main character creates a wonderful WTF moment in a show. But resolving it...well...that's a different matter. Take the season four cliff-hanger of The X-Files. Chris Carter had an ambitious plan turn Mulder into the sceptic by making him belief aliens were just a conspiracy, conjured up by the Cigarette Smoking Man and his mysterious cohorts. It's a brilliant twist on the Mulder / Scully dynamic and helped keep the show going into season five. But to get there, Carter had to make us believe that Mulder's first reaction would be to give up on his quest totally. As season four drew to a close and Scully recounted Mulder dying that morning from a suicidal gunshot to the head, we didn't know where the show was going next. Except... ...Audiences knew Fox Mulder wasn't dead. It was still a WTF moment, but it didn't have quite the same impact that the show had intended. The X Files was still at the height of its popularity, with no sign of going anywhere and there was also a movie on the way too. All could be forgiven if Chris Carter had engineered an ingenious resurrection but instead we got something rather...mundane. Fox Mulder kills a mysterious government employee and makes it appear that it is his body in his apartment. Then Scully lies to protect him, so that Mulder can go undercover to discover the truth. (He doesn't). Which makes it a lot of sparkle and not much substance. Mulder doesn't really die. It's all a fake out and his 'death' felt plain hokey.
9. I Survived Being Impaled /Shot / Burned To Death Because I'm A Cool Villain And I Need To Keep Coming Back: Sylar (Heroes)
Definitely a case of over-egging the pudding and indicative of a show that didn't progress; instead it was doomed to repeat its mistakes and use the same characters over and over again, even when they had outlived their purpose. Nathan Pertrelli was one (how many times did he switch sides in season three?) and surprisingly Hiro Nakamura was another. (His child-like nature went from adorable to irritating far too quickly after the first season). But worst was Sylar who kept coming back again and again and again... Sylar is kind of representative of the show in general. He was menacing and mysterious in season one, and when he was impaled in the season one finale that should have been the end of this awesome character. Not only because he needed to be defeated after all the death and destruction he had caused, but because that defeat gave the heroes purpose. What was the point of it all, if he came back? And come back he did, with a missing memory and uncertainty over which side he was on. Random and directionless...just like chapter two. Come season three, he was in full villain mode again, but his mystery was gone. He was a stock villain, just like all the other forgettable baddies in chapter three. Being stabbed in the head by Claire and then burning to death in the fire at Primatech Research that should have been his ultimate defeat, but no, he kept coming back, killing Nathan at first but eventually turning good in season four. By the end, audiences didn't care about this once cool and monstrous character, and like the show he fizzled into nothingness. His resurrections were ridiculous even pointless. As to whether he'll be back in Heroes Reborn we'll have to wait and see. (Though you can find my thoughts on it here).
8. My Wife Was Killed In An Explosion and I Flat-Lined On The Operating Table...Now'm Back And I'm Kind Of Evil Tony Almeida (24)
Season five of 24 may have had the most traumatic season opening to a show in TV history. Former president David Palmer is shot dead, Michelle Dessler is killed in a car bomb and fellow protagonist (and Michelle's husband) Tony Almeida is critically injured and dies himself a few hours later on the operating table at CTU. These deaths mark a shocking progression in the show and made season five one of the best. Sure it was a tragic end for these characters, and Tony in particular, but as audiences had witnessed with Teri's senseless murder in the closing moment of season one, the show wasn't afraid to make brutal choices. In fact, season five's massacre showed audiences that no one, except maybe Jack Bauer himself, was safe from the chopping block. Yet those tragic moments were undone with the resurrection of Tony Almeida in season seven. What's more, the manner of his return was ridiculous. Season five villain Christopher Henderson faked Tony's death in order to turn him to the dark side and entering season seven, it appears to have worked. Tony was reworked as a villain, working for a terrorist group whose goal was to kill President Allison Taylor. It didn't quite sit right with audiences and even his 'reveal' as a member of former Head of CTU Bill Buchanan's black ops unit, didn't quite satisfy us, because his return felt fake and unnecessary and because season seven, as great as it was, ended with Tony succumbing to revenge and being dragged into FBI custody. Dying in the midst of season five would have been a far more tragic and noble ending for Jack's former CTU ally.
7. My Ship Exploded But I've Returned As An Angel Or Whatever Starbuck (Battlestar Galactica)
Starbuck's death was one of the most shocking elements of season three and her subsequent return in the season finale gave birth to a number of great theories, each more elaborate than the last. She was a Cylon. No, she was the original Cylon. She encountered aliens. She faked her death. She was actually the superhero Ms Marvel. (Okay, maybe not the last one...at least maybe until Marvel's Phase 3). Fan's didn't have any issue with Starbuck's resurrection. Her character was a force of nature on the show, thanks in no small part to Katee Sackhoff's riveting performance and she would have been greatly missed if she had not been part of that final season (or was it two final two seasons?). The mystery of how she survived her exploding viper and her connection to the long sought-after Earth was a key part of the final years. Then came the final episode. (Personally I love 90% it, despite its bad rap). The biggest issue was not with the arrival on our primitive Earth, the death of Laura Roslin or the conclusion of the human / Cylon war. It was the ridiculous, sort-of-but-not-really-explained-reveal of who or what Starbuck was. A guardian angel, guiding the last remnants of humanity to Earth or a figment of everyone's imagination? It didn't really make any sense and it left audiences perplexed. It makes you wonder if she really should have died and stayed dead at the end of season three.
6. I Survived An Attack By Mutant Turkeys, Having My Arms Ripped Off By Cattle And Being Run Over By The Fonz Kenny (South Park)
Ridiculous and acceptable in equal measure, looking forward to the next elaborate death of Kenny Mccormick was part of the charm of the early seasons of South Park. They may seem tame compared to recent years, but there was still plenty to laugh about...whether you should have or not! 'Oh my God they killed Kenny! You bastards!' was a phrase quoted week after week as the kid in the orange parka met his maker and the following week he was back in the group, unaware that death was going to come calling any minute. It's a ridiculous concept, taking the reset button mentality of shows like The Simpsons and throwing it into overdrive. And they sure were fun to watch! Here's just a few of the best as a taster... Knocked into a microwave oven with a chair and cooked by a mutant clone of Stan. Crushed by the MIR Space Station at the beginning of the episode. Revived as a zombie via Worcestershire sauce embalming. Head explodes due to the intensity of a planetarium demonstration when Stan and Kyle examine the control booth. Trampled in a mosh pit in Cartman's tree house. Ozzy Osbourne bites his head off. Destroyed by a snow speeder while wearing an ED-209 costume His insides explode due to the pressure buildup from a tampon stuck in his anus. Dies as a result of autoerotic asphyxiation, after choking himself with a belt while dressed as Batman upon the suggestion of a Center for Disease Control agent testing for sex addiction.
5. A Centuries-Old Vampire Fed On Me and I Drowned In Shallow Water...Hold On, A Bit Of Mouth To Mouth Does Wonders For The Body Buffy (Buffy The Vampire Slayer)
If this article was flipped on its head to become the 12 best ways TV characters were brought back from the dead, Buffy's resurrection in season six would absolutely be on there. Audiences may have not been over the moon with the darker, grimmer nature of the penultimate season, but the consequences of her return form the dead were astonishing; ripped out of heaven and enabling the First Evil to gain a footing in our world. At the other end of the scale we have Buffy's first death and resurrection in the season one finale 'Prophecy Girl'. Again the consequences of her death were brilliant; the opportunity for second slayer Kendra and subsequently Faith. But the manner in which it is handled is miles away from the magic and trauma of her second fatal ending. Bitten by the Master, allowing him to break free and start the second apocalypse of the year, Buffy's falls face down into a pool of water and she drowns, fulfilling the prophecy of her death written in the pages of the Pergamum Codex. In comes Angel and Xander, ready to save her. Even if you ignore the fact that Buffy has been dead for some considerable time, the manner in which she is brought back from the dead is just ridiculous (though in keeping with the lighter, camper tone of season one). Xander gives the slayer mouth to mouth for a couple of minutes and voila, she's back! If only all vampire / drowning victims could be brought back from death so easily....
4. Sure The House I Was In Exploded / I Was Poisoned...But That Was Just For Dramatic Season Finale Purposes Chloe Sullivan And Lex Luthor (Smallville)
This continues the theme of season finales being viewed as the perfect excuse to kill of principal character for the shock value, only to bring them back just as quickly. From Picard to Fox Mulder to Sherlock; sometimes the death of these characters can be resolved satisfactorily, others are ultimately disappointing. And for sheer shock factor, no TV finale was quite so brutal (and ultimately pointless) as the season three finale of Smallville, 'Covenant'. The episode itself had plenty of cliff-hanger moments. As Clark meets a possible Supergirl and vanishes, an imprisoned Lionel Luthor exacts his revenge on his enemies. Chloe Sullivan and her dad, witnesses against Lionel in his trial, walk into their house which explodes spectacularly around them. His son Lex Luthor fares no better, as he succumbs to a poison and dies gasping for breath. As Lionel shaves his head, audiences wondered if we were witnessing a clever twist where he will become the ultimate nemesis of Superman, rather than his son. But then it all falls flat in season four. Not only is Clark back in the first few minutes, Lex is revealed to be alive, off hunting an ancient artefact. He might need to have his blood purified every 72 hours or his organs will shut down, but that wasn't really a satisfying resolution. As for Chloe and her dad; apparently it was all a ruse to get them in witness protection and even she is back by the end of episode two. (Surely there are simpler ways to fake someone's death then to stick them inside an exploding house?) It makes all the dramatic moments in the season three finale utterly pointless and suggests the show was afraid to make bold choices in its storytelling. Hey it takes a 100 episodes to kill off Clark's dad!
3. An Alien Brain Has Been Implanted In My Head...Oh No Wait, I Married Brian Blessed Peri (Doctor Who)
An example of turning one of the most shocking companion departures into one of the worst. The Trial Of A Timelord series was an ambitious undertaking; some elements worked such as the non-linear approach to the Doctor's off-trial adventures and the revelation of the Valeyard himself (even though we still don't know where he fits in moving forward). Yet some elements didn't work at all the introduction of shrieking, hyperactive red-head Mel and the rubbish ending that didn't make a whole load of sense. In all of this we have the departure of equally irritating Peri and she fits into both categories. Companions deaths had been far and few between, with only Adric biting the dust in recent years. That supposedly changed with the shock fate of Peri on the planet Thoros Beta. The Doctor was stolen away before he could rescue his companion from the villain Kiv and placed on trial. With no one to help her, Peri was strapped to a bed, gagged and murdered as Kiv replaced her brain with his own. It was brutal and brilliant at the same time and stands as one of the greatest companion departures of all time... ...Well it would have if it hadn't been so spectacularly retconned in the closing moments of The Trial Of A Timelord saga. Turns out, the Timelords pulled her out of that time stream just in time, allowing her to stay on the planet and marry warrior king Yrcanos. Leaving all her adventures with the Doctor behind and despite having no ounce of chemistry between them, she lives out her life married to Brian Blessed. This makes Leela staying on Gallifrey to marry Andred in The Invasion Of Time the most epic Doctor Who romance of all time!
2. They Chopped Off My Head...My Mistake! It Was Just A Flesh Wound Sara Tancredi (Prison Break)
So infamous that even those who haven't even seen all of Prison Break know about. Despite being the romantic interest of series lead Michael, her character was written out at the end of season two due to the actress Sarah Wayne Callies falling pregnant. Rather than taking the Gillian Anderson-approach to storytelling and writing the story arc around her pregnancy, Sara Tancredi was written out of the show; first as hostage of the series' evil organisation The Company and then killed off screen early in season three. To make sure audiences certain there was no question of Sara returning to the show, they even had her head turn up in a box. As gruesome and tragic as it was, there was no question that her time on the show was over. Audiences simply had to move on. Oh wait, there was season four and suddenly Sara was back in the show. It turns out her death (head in a box and all) was faked, making the whole premise surrounding her murder last season ridiculous. Had the writers chosen to kill her off screen with no evidence to suggest otherwise, the open question over her death may have made her resurrection all the more believable. But physically showing her decapitated head? The show had written itself into a corner and they had no choice but to retcon their mistakes.
1. I Died In A Car Accident...Or Did I Just Dream A Year's Worth Of Story Lines In The Shower: Bobby Ewing (Dallas)
That was a very long shower. Thinking retconning a character's death was bad enough? What about retconning an entire season? Lost without a Nikki and Paulo season? Supernatural without the whole Sam has no soul story line? Dexter not having to deal with the rather dull Miguel and jumping straight to the Trinity Killer after the highs of season two? Doctor Who that follows up The Caves Of Androzani with Remembrance Of The Daleks? Frankly, the possibilities are endless. But also utterly ridiculous. You can't just ignore what happened before, not matter how much of a failure that story line was. Any suspension of disbelief with the audience is utterly lost (aka Sara Tancredi). However no-one told the writers of Dallas that little nugget of information. Realising they has written out one of the show's biggest stars, Bobby Ewing, with his death, they decide the only route they could take was to pretend a year's worth of story lines were all just a dream. No character resurrection is ever going to be as ridiculous as this one. It was so daft they forgot about spin off show Knots Landing which had to continue to acknowledge Bobby's death even after his return in order not to invalidate their own plot. As for the main show, how could it ever be taken seriously again? Yes I know it's the jewel in flashy 80's soaps and you could argue it was all style over substance anyway, but even for a show with ridiculous story lines, 'it was all a dream' was just ludicrous. And there you have it. 12 ridiculous ways TV characters were brought back from the dead. Do you agree or did you find their resurrections completely plausible? Is there a character you think I've missed off the list? Please let me know in your comments below and I'll be back soon as I follow this article up with some character resurrections from the dead were just plain brilliant!