13 Reasons Why: 9 Reasons It Ultimately Fails
The show's attempts at tackling tough subject matter are admirable, but not successful.
13 Reasons Why is already the most tweeted about TV series of the year so far, and it doesn't take 13 tapes and the Sherlock Holmesing of Clay Jensen to figure out why.
The series tackles subjects rarely put on screen, in teen suicide and rape, and frames them around a mysterious premise: Hannah Baker, a teenage girl, has killed herself, which is how the show opens, and left behind a series of tapes for her classmates explaining the part each of them played in her suicide.
You can immediately see why a show tackling that subject is going to get people - and especially teenagers - talking, and it's certainly admirable to even attempt to take on those themes when so few shows try to. You can also see areas where it works: the cast, a mix of unknowns for the kids and established, recognisable names and faces for the adults, is solid, and there's some really interesting directing going on. And, of course, being a Netflix series it does lend itself to some compulsive binge-watching.
The issue is that this isn't just a binge-watching show, because of those subjects it takes on. It needs to do a lot more than that, and have a lot more to say. It works on a very basic, superficial 'here's a new Netflix series' level, and 'here are these tough subjects', but beyond that (where it really needs to work) it falls pretty flat (contains spoilers).
9. Too Long And Repetitive
Starting with the most basic problem with 13 Reasons Why, it's something that'll be familiar to anyone who's watched, well, pretty much any other 13-episode Netflix series: it's just too long.
Netflix produces some excellent TV series, and yet even those that are significantly better than 13 Reasons Why (from Jessica Jones to House of Cards) suffer from issues of bloating and 'Netflix Drift', and it's certainly prevalent once again here.
The show takes a relatively thin book - 288 pages - and stretches it out across 13 episodes. You can see why, obviously, but it falls down when each of those episodes is well over 50 minutes long, and there isn't enough narrative to sustain it.
To that end, the series also gets very repetitive. Such is the nature of its premise, really, because it follows the same formula with each tape, but it means that it starts to sag by the time you're halfway through, and characters hit the same beats over and over again. It's not its biggest flaw, but it is the one that stands well outside of anything to do with its subject matter.
8. Too Contrived
Stretching the episodes out also leads to another big problem, which is that the whole story feels far too contrived to have as much impact as it needs to, and this happens on a couple of different levels.
The first is with Clay, our de facto protagonist of the series and entry point into the drama. Unlike all of his other classmates, Clay doesn't listen to the tapes in one go (in the book, he listens to them all in a single night, and the story only plays out between him and Hannah). You can see why that decision was made, even beyond fleshing out the characters and the increased episode length, as it could play on a feeling of not wanting to let go to a loved one.
The show doesn't really get that across though, because it has Clay listen to one tape, and then get angry and question the person involved and demand retribution, only to be told to "listen to the tapes." So he listens to the next one, and the whole process starts anew. "Listen to the tapes." A few episodes in, you'll be screaming it at him yourself, because it's not believable by this stage that he wouldn't just listen to them all straight away.
The responses of those around him aren't much better either, and again it all feels like a way to get the story to a certain point, rather than telling a real, relatable teen story, while watching horror after horror unfold (especially in binge-watching fashion) makes it harder to buy into, because each of the things that happens to Hannah is serious and worthy of real study, not just as some ever-increasing pile of misery - to take note from a different Netflix show, A Series of Unfortunate Events.
It takes inspiration from the likes of Heathers and My So-Called Life, but lacks their wit and deftness of touch. Finally by the end of the season we do get some movement from the other characters, such as Jessica, but it's left deliberately late and open-ended just to setup a potential second season.
7. Shock Value
13 Reasons Why is, at times, very uncomfortable, even almost impossible to watch. There are two different portrayals of rape, and one of suicide, all of which are graphic and have you wanting to look away.
Of course rape and suicide should be hard to watch if they're being put on-screen, but I don't think the show fully succeeds in its messaging here, because there's no real necessity to showing these things happen. We don't need to see Hannah being raped, for instance, so what is it that's left? The show is clearly attempting to strip away the male gaze - even directly referencing it early on - and yet it also plays into it as well.
The reason for putting it on screen, then, comes across more as being for simple shock value; it creates the male gaze it seeks to avoid, and while unintentional the way it plays will inevitably, to some, feel like a sexualised moment. Sexual abuse is of course an important topic, and especially for younger people there needs to be more information and education around consent and what constitutes abuse. The show does aim for that with Hannah's voiceover during the assault on Jessica, but because of the shocking imagery it largely and unfortunately gets lost in the shuffle.
It also shifts perception of the characters, who no longer become simply flawed: we learn that they know of Jessica and Hannah both being raped by Bryce, and yet are insistent in their covering up of the events. Which, yeah, is the Bystander Effect, but the show doesn't really seem to understand how that shifts the portrayal of these characters and how sympathetic we can be towards them.
6. It Attributes Blame
"We're all to blame."
It's a line spoken by Tony in the show, and it's a theme that is repeated throughout the series: As Clay makes his way through the tapes, he wants to know who is at fault for Hannah's death. He of course blames himself, but then by the end he agrees that he didn't do enough, the councillor didn't do enough, nobody did enough, and each and every one of them in some way contributed to Hannah's death and must share the blame.
It's a very dangerous and irresponsible line to take, because it states that in suicide there is a blame to be appropriated. Let's make it clear: there isn't.
Friends of people who commit suicide are likely to feel some sense of guilt as it is, and the show doubles-down on that by actively shifting blame around various characters, and essentially seems to fall on the message that, if people had just been nicer, Hannah wouldn't have killed herself. Sure, 'be nice to people' is something everyone could do with remembering, but it's a massively reductive statement when it comes to something as complex as suicide.
5. Clay Is The Victim/Hero
Of all the people to feature on the tapes, Clay Jensen is the only one to actually be absolved of any blame by Hannah herself, even though he does come to question his role in her life and death. Dylan Minnette does a good job playing the stoic Clay, and is convincingly sympathetic and conflicted, but it's nonetheless an issue having his character serve as the series' protagonist.
He's the closest thing we have to an outright good guy in the show, and as such is positioned almost as a potential saviour of Hannah, and her suicide frames him as a figure of tragedy.
Because he gets the tapes at the beginning of the show, and then the following 13 episodes are about him (gradually) listening to them all, it becomes too much about him, and veers far too much into 'if boy had told girl he loved her, girl wouldn't have killed herself' territory.
4. Alex's Suicide Attempt
One of the series' big twists, which comes right at the end, is another suicide, or rather a suicide attempt, as Alex - formerly one of Hannah's close friends, and someone mentioned in the tapes - shoots himself in the head.
It's not an inherently bad development, because the show could frame this around the notion of copycat suicides and more explicitly the dangers of them, as well as the fact Alex is shown to be a troubled character with impulsive actions. However, it doesn't really work for a couple of reasons. One is that it happens so abruptly, and is just totally shoehorned in at the very end of the series, which means there's no weight to it beyond the potential for Season 2, and the initial shock value and added drama in a series that has already had a LOT of both.
It also means that it's showing the consequences of Hannah's tapes, because the implication is that him being named in them, and the circumstances that arise from their existence, lead to his own suicide. So if he were to leave his own tapes, one of them might be for Hannah. Again, it's an overly simplistic take on suicide, using it for drama rather than analysing the reasons behind it, and making it overly sensationalist too.
3. Suicide As Revenge Fantasy
I don't think there's any one clear or definitive reading of the show's depiction of suicide, but I do think that its messaging is both confused and irresponsible, and a big reason for this is in the way Hannah's decision - and it is her decision, despite the blame-game being played - is framed over the course of 13 episodes.
While the show is attempting to depict that reasons that led to Hannah's suicide, a far more troubling one emerges: revenge.
She is doing this knowing it'll hurt everybody who hurt her, with potentially far-reaching consequences - Alex shoots himself, Courtney is unwittingly outed as gay, everyone knows Jessica was raped - and does so in a way that has a strange air of nostalgia to it: she uses cassette tapes, coloured in with nail polish. Hannah killing herself is not a rash action, but one that is meticulously thought-out and even written down, creating a web of people who serve as 'targets' of the tapes. Revenge can be a motivating factor, but here it's presented as largely the reason, as Hannah is framed as clearly wanting to hurt these people back, and even achieves it, which is not a good message to send out. Does someone like Bryce deserve punishment and justice? Of course. But suicide should not be shown to be a way of getting even or extracting revenge.
It's a revenge fantasy that plays out like a game, with Hannah creating rules for how the tapes must be followed, and has now even become a meme (which isn't the show's fault, but it's not like Netflix haven't contributed to it).
Its graphic depiction of suicide is also troubling. On the one hand, it is extremely horrific to watch, and is intended to show the horrors of such an act. And yet, it can't get away from that 'shock value' notion, and the fact that we see it in so much detail basically offers a how-to guide for anyone thinking of doing the same. That might be a minute percentage of people who watch the show, but if anyone sees that and is inspired to copy it, that's too many.
2. It Doesn't Analyse Its Subject Matter Deeply Enough
For a series that centres itself around a suicide, there's really not a lot of examination into what moves a person to take their own life. Throughout the course of the series we see suicide, self-harm, sexual abuse, slut-shaming, and bullying, all of which factor into the wider narrative and some of which form the reasons for Hannah's death.
As I've said before, the show should be admired for taking those on and certainly helping to open up an important and necessary dialogue around topics like suicide and rape, but that doesn't mean it succeeds in dealing with them.
What we see are a series of events, and these events are why Hannah killed herself. It's 'X person did this, Y person did that, so Z person commits suicide'. But while something like bullying can be a contributing factor in someone choosing to end their own life, there's more typically a myriad of reasons, many of which we'll never truly know, and the show doesn't explore them. On the matter of self-harm, for instance, we hear Skye say that it's "what you do to not commit suicide." Again, this kind of messaging - suicide is bad, but self-harm is ok I guess as long as you're not going any further? - just feels really off.
The most glaring omission is the complete lack of conversation around mental health. Of course you don't need to be someone has mental health issues to commit suicide, but there are studies that show it is a major factor, with one report finding 90& of people who commit suicide have a diagnosable mental illness. The fact that we don't hear terms such as 'mental health' or 'depression' come up even once is startling, and a failure by the writers to address the real underlying causes of suicide.
1. Not Enough Focus Is On Hannah
Who is Hannah Baker? Or rather, who was Hannah Baker? Why did she kill herself?
These are hugely important questions for this series, because it's framed around Hannah's suicide, and yet it doesn't delve too deeply into the answers. The series unfolds as a number of terrible things that happen to her, and in turn the tapes she leaves behind unspool in various ways for those mentioned in them. She is a series of events, both the one doing the action and the one whom they're being done to, but what about Hannah as a real person? What was she like before all of these things started happening? Because she's already dead, we don't get to see that change take place, and thus don't get to full realise how much these events impacted her.
Going further still, the show offers no analysis of her psyche. This reverts back to the previous point, and the glaring lack of conversation around mental health. Was Hannah depressed? Did she suffer from another mental illness? We can speculate, but we don't get to find out the answer; Hannah is instead just a mystery to try and solve, and someone who could've been saved had people been a bit nicer.
What did you think of 13 Reasons Why? Share your thoughts down in the comments.