15 Best How I Met Your Mother Episodes

The most legendary episodes in Ted Mosby's epic journey.

By Aidan Whatman /

Running between 2005 and 2014 for nine epic and winding seasons, How I Met Your Mother captured the hearts of audiences worldwide thanks to its great characters, inventive narrative approach and moving, relatable storylines.

Advertisement

Like all long shows, it began to lose steam in its final moments, and the finale is still regarded as one of the worst ever put to the screen. But as Ted says: "Even if you know how something's going to end, that doesn't mean you can't enjoy the ride."

And what a ride it is. Funny, clever, heartbreaking and bursting with some well-place twists and turns, it's a sitcom that has more heart than many other shows in the genre. The emotional journeys of Ted, Barney, Lily, Marshall and Robin are exquisite, heartfelt and endearing, and the themes of friendship, love, fate, and hope are always front and centre and handled brilliantly.

Sure, it has its issues (few shows don't), but even with its ill-advised tendencies it's still a masterful achievement of TV and storytelling.

Whether breaking your heart, causing you to bend double with laughter, or both at once, here are the fifteen greatest episodes of How I Met Your Mother.

15. Three Days Of Snow (Season 4, Episode 13)

"We should buy a bar!"

Advertisement

Three Days of Snow showcases just how good How I Met Your Mother can be when it comes to telling a good story in a unique and fun way. On the one hand, you've got Ted (Josh Radnor) and Barney (Neil Patrick Harris) taking over the bar; and on the other you've got Marshall (Jason Segel) and Lily (Alyson Hannigan) trying to get to each other in a snow storm.

HIMYM has always been about Ted, and how he was before he met his wife, but the show would often deviate from this and focus more on this friends. Whilst watching Ted and Barney realise their dream of owning a bar is somewhat flawed is great fun, this episode belongs to Marshall and Lily, who try to convince themselves their relationship has "matured" passed their previous relationship traditions.

It's a funny, sweet look at one of TV's most lovable and sappy couples, as they decide to keep up with their cute little routines, told in a non-linear and twisting narrative that keeps you guessing right till the end.

14. Game Night (Season 1, Episode 15)

"My life rocks! Money, suits and sex? These are tears of joy."

Advertisement

Barney was always the break-out star of HIMYM, and season one's Game Night is a key example of his scene-stealing power. A womaniser of the highest order, wealthy and arrogant, the episode sees his hidden past uncovered; a past that shows him not as a charming bachelor, but a peace-loving hippie whose longtime girlfriend broke his heart.

Whilst the episode also offers fans the chance to see Marshall's love for games, and sees Ted admit his past feelings for Robin (Cobie Smulders) to his new girlfriend, Victoria (Ashley Williams), Barney is the star.

The joy of the episode comes in its final moments, when expectations are defied and instead of growing as a person from his heartbreak, he leans into his sleazy ways and proclaims his love for his life and his womanising ways. He also gets the gang to admit their most embarrassing secrets, and proves that not matter how slanderous and smarmy he can be, Barney is a lot more than meets the eye.

13. Tick Tick Tick (Season 7, Episode 10)

"Sometimes hours can feel like minutes, and sometimes a single second can last a lifetime."

Advertisement

Barney and Robin's relationship forms the backbone of the show's later seasons, and as strong and moving as it often was, it didn't get off to the best start. Back in season three, they sleep together and Barney finds himself falling in love with her. They then date in season five before amicably breaking up, and by season seven, things had been building for a while for them to get back together.

Only, they were both in relationships with other people. In a moment of passion, the two sleep together again and plan to tell their partners about their mess-up, only for Barney to realise that he still loves Robin and that he doesn't want it to be a one-time thing. He breaks up with Nora (Nazanin Boniadi), but Robin decides to stay with Kevin (Kal Penn), visibly breaking Barney's heart.

The episode also features a funnier sub-plot that sees Ted and Marshall getting high, but other than that Tick Tick Tick is almost pure drama - sad, moving, and heartbreaking, with one of the toughest episode endings to watch on the show.

12. No Tomorrow (Season 3, Episode 12)

"My luck was about to change."

Advertisement

No Tomorrow is an episode that stands as a turning point in Ted's journey to meet the woman of his dreams. Going to a Saint Patrick's Day party with Barney, Ted gets drunk and starts to act out-of-character. Using someone else's bar tab, kissing a married woman and taking Barney's questionable advice, he spends the night living in the moment, not worrying about the next morning.

He gets punched and loses his phone, but in the end the biggest slap in the face he receives is from Marshall, who shares some accidental voicemails with him and proves that Ted was out of order during the party. Put in his place, Ted laments about how his future wife was at that party, and he's glad they didn't meet because he wasn't ready to yet.

The episode doesn't paint Ted in the best light, but that's exactly the point - he's not meant to be endearing, he's meant to be flawed and represent how everyone grows from their mistakes, and it's pretty powerful to watch.

11. Girls Vs. Suits (Season 5, Episode 12)

"Nothing suits me like a suit."

Advertisement

For its one-hundredth episode, HIMYM really went all out, offering up one of the funniest and most re-watchable scenes in the entire show. Realising his suits remind the bar's new bartender of her exes, Barney stops wearing them around her in hopes that she'll go out with him. Watching Barney suffer withdrawal symptoms from not wearing his suits is absolutely hysterical, but things get even better in a hurry.

After his secret is found out, he's forced to chose between his prized suits and his date, a decision which causes Barney to imagine himself breaking out in song, singing about how much he loves suits. Neil Patrick Harris gets a chance to show off his singing chops, and Barney gets a chance to choose between his two biggest loves.

That's not all the episode offers, mind, as Ted dates student Cindy (Rachel Bilson), who turns out to be the roommate of his future wife. Here, Ted hears about his true love for the first time, showing the two getting closer and closer with every passing episode.

10. The Pineapple Incident (Season 1, Episode 10)

"I drank all five, bitch!"

Advertisement

The Pineapple Incident is arguably Ted's funniest episode, and is certainly one of his most relatable. We've all had a night out that's ended with a blocked memory or mysterious mementos, and this episode captures that idea beautifully.

Sick of hearing Ted talk about Robin, Barney dares him to drink five strong shots and let himself go. Pushed to do it by his friends, his downs the drinks and blacks out, spending the entirety of the next morning trying to figure out what happened. For starters, there's a woman in his bed, and a pineapple on his bedside table, and he's sprained his ankle.

Using accounts from Barney and bar owner Carl (Joe Nieves), Ted slowly begins to piece together his messy night, leading to some hilarious revelations. Whilst No Tomorrow sees Ted at his most unlikeable, The Pineapple Incident shows him at his most silly and endearing, and gives Josh Radnor the chance to show audiences just how funny he can be in the role.

9. Swarley (Season 2, Episode 7)

"I hate it! I hate it! It's not funny, it's never been funny!"

Advertisement

There's a lot that goes on in this season two gem, and it's all brilliant, balancing the show's odd humour with its ability to move and surprise seamlessly. At its core, this is an episode in which Barney gets called "Swarley" after someone writes his name incorrectly on a coffee cup. This leads to some of the show's best humour (including a dig at fellow sitcom Friends).

Underneath all the typically silly but fun jokes, Swarley also sees Marshall go on his first proper date since his season one break-up with Lily, only to realise that he doesn't want to move on, he wants to be back together with Lily.

So, whilst it's funny and off-the-wall, it's also one of the show's most heartfelt entries, complete with a long awaited reunion that hits all the right notes.

8. Symphony Of Illumination (Season 7, Episode 12)

"There was one thing your Aunt Robin never was: she was never alone."

Advertisement

From season six onward, HIMYM began hitting audiences with more emotional episodes, and season seven's Symphony of Illumination is easily one of the show's most evocative and moving. It sees Robin take over narrating duties from Ted as she recounts the time she fell pregnant with her own kids.

The episode then sees her come to terms with the possibility of having children, despite the fact that she never wanted any. At the doctors, a major twist comes when it is revealed she can't even have children. It's then shown that Robin isn't talking to her future kids about their birth, but is sat on a park bench in the snow, trying to come to terms with the news.

The reveal is heartbreaking, but the episode reaches another level when Ted steps up and makes her a massive Christmas light display to cheer her up, despite not knowing what's being bothering her. It may be a sad episode, but it's very hopeful, promising fans that although Robin never became a mother, she did become very successful in her career and is happy with her life.

7. Slap Bet (Season 2, Episode 9)

"Let's go to the mall!"

Advertisement

In what is arguably the show's most iconic episode, Robin tries to hide the reason she doesn't like shopping malls from her friends, causing Ted, Barney and Marshall to do some digging into her secret past. Slap Bet is full of shocking and hilarious revelations, and introduces fans to the titular slap bet, which would continue to play a big part in the show until the finale.

Up until this point, Robin has been shrouded in mystery. She comes from Canada, she works as a reporter, and that's about it. In a series of bizarre and funny sub-plots, in which Barney thinks she used to be a porn star and Marshall thinks she was once married, it is revealed that Robin used to be Robin Sparkles - a teen pop star in Canada who had a major hit called "Let's Go to the Mall."

The revelation comes complete with a full music video, and one of the funniest scenes in the show, as Cobie Smulders is seen dressing like an 90s pop icon and singing what might just be the world's worst song. It's brilliant through and through.

6. The Playbook (Season 5, Episode 8)

"For those of you keeping score, the Ted Mosby works."

Advertisement

The Playbook sees Barney Stinson at his most insane, manipulative and entertaining. The titular book details every ploy the serial womaniser has ever used to pick up women, from dressing up like Mrs Doubtfire, pretending to be left at the altar (like Ted), and pretending to be an inappropriate genie.

As a whole, The Playbook hasn't aged particularly well, but watched as a ridiculous and fun slice of comedy is close to unrivalled. Barney tricks his friends, shows no real sympathy for his actions, and yet thanks to the energetic performance and general likeability of Neil Patrick Harris, it's pretty hard not to love him as he struts his stuff.

The episode also teases Robin's next major relationship with her co-host Don (Benjamin Koldyke) and gives a deep - albeit nuts - look at how the pair cope with their big break-up.

5. How I Met Everyone Else (Season 3, Episode 5)

"Think of me as Yoda. Only instead of being little and green, I wear suits and I'm awesome. I'm your bro. I'm Broda."

Advertisement

How I Met Your Mother works brilliantly well with flashback episodes, and How I Met Everyone Else perfectly captures the tone of the show and how great it can be from a narrative standpoint. As he tries to introduce his date to the gang, Ted and the others recount the stories of how they each met one another.

This opens up a lot of doors. Not only do fans get to see the famous Lily-Marshall meet cute, but they also get a deeper insight into how Barney managed to wriggle his way into the gang. The Lily-Marshall backstory stands as the episode's best, full of sweet anecdotes and hilariously over-the-top sappiness, but Barney and Marshall's introduction is definitely the funniest, with Marshall convinces his new "Broda" that he's great at picking up women in bars.

Like all great HIMYM episodes, this season three high-point is equal parts crazy and touching, showing how the gang came together and showing how they're still friends after all this time.

4. The Time Travellers (Season 8, Episode 20)

"Look around, Ted. You're all alone."

Advertisement

The Time Travelers is one of the show's most emotional entries. It serves as an almost-bottle episode, in which Ted and Barney sit in their usual booth and converse with past and future versions about themselves. Barney wants Ted to go to Robots vs Wrestlers, but Ted isn't sure until their future selves put them on the right path.

At first, things seem pretty normal, with Barney trying to drag Ted out for another wacky adventure. Along the way, Marshall and Robin fight over who created the bar's new drink, and at one point Ted spots a woman he knew years ago but never asked out.

It is here that cracks begin to form, as he realises there's no point asking her out because his relationships all end the same way. Then, much to Ted's surprise, Barney reveals that everything that's been happening that night has been his imagination, and that he's alone, the odd one out of the group.

The Time Travelers is a perfect encapsulation of the show - Ted's sure fate will bring him to The One in time, but he's lost hope as his friends are all moving on with their own lives.

On a plus note, it ends with Ted and Barney's rendition of Billy Joel's "Longest Time", so it's not all sad.

3. Legendaddy (Season 6, Episode 19)

"If you were gonna be some lame suburban dad, why couldn't you have been that for me?"

Advertisement

Oh, Barney. Always the cocky, lucky, narcissistic ladies man. Except, that's unfair, because as this episode perfectly demonstrates, Barney is much more than the bad boy of the gang. Rather, he's a victim of abandonment, growing up without a father and always wondering, deep down, where he comes from.

In Legendaddy, his estranged father comes knocking. Played by the fantastic John Lithgow, Jerome and Barney seem to hit it off despite their estrangement, only for it to be revealed that Barney isn't happy with who his dad has turned out to be. Worse than that, Jerome has a family away from Barney, with a son called Jerome Jr.

This revelation causes Barney to berate his father in one of the show's most surprising moments, as he lays it all on the table and says goodbye, stealing Jerome Jr's basketball hoop and giving it to Ted, wanting Ted's kids to have the childhood he never had.

2. Bad News/Last Words (Season 6, Episodes 13/14)

"My dad's dead? I'm not ready for this."

Advertisement

If this list has proven anything, it's that HIMYM is at its best when its breaking hearts. Neither Bad News nor Last Words is complete without the other, as they form a two-parter in which Marshall must face the death of his father.

As with Legendaddy, both episodes sum up season six's theme of family and parents. Bad News is harmless enough, as Marshall and Lily try for a baby and go through some tests to see if they can go through with it. But with its craftily placed countdown and ominous title, it's clear something's going to go wrong.

Only, it's nothing to do with the baby, but Marshall's beloved father, who has died off-camera from a sudden heart attack. Marshall's reaction to the news is tear-jerking as hell, improvised by Jason Segel. Segel then shocks again in Last Words, where he proclaims his confusion with the idea of death and tells his friends how much he loved his dad.

If it doesn't make you cry, chances are that you're not human.

1. How Your Mother Met Me (Season 9, Episode 16)

"I believe that each of us only gets one. And I got mine already."

Advertisement

Season nine is a mess, but How Your Mother Met Me is anything but. In fact, it's the very best that the show has to offer - a clever, sweeping, emotionally devastating masterclass of storytelling that hits all the right notes and finally gives fans an in-depth look at Tracy (Cristin Milioti), aka The Mother.

As it turns out, Tracy has had her ups and down in life. Her boyfriend died in an accident, she swore off men, she went to school (where she was briefly, accidentally, taught by Ted), and she broke up with her second long-term boyfriend after realising she can't let her first love go.

It's great to see how close Ted and Tracy were to each other throughout the show, and it's amazing how much detail has been put in the episode. Tracy's life mirrors Ted's, driving home the fact that they're meant for each other.

And Milioti's rendition of La Vie en Rose is a perfect cap-off to a perfect episode.

Advertisement