18 Most Memorable Evil Twins In TV History

By Chantelle Barton /

There are a few plot devices that crop up time after time in our favourite TV shows, including the shock killing of a favourite character, the flashback and the 'it was all a dream!' twist. They throw one TV trope after another at us, but there is always one twist that draws in a crowd €“ the addition of an evil twin. Evil twins are intrinsically fascinating €“ an evil reflection of our favourite characters, who usually look just like them but often have decidedly more sinister motives. When the chips are down and the writers are scratching their heads for plot ideas, they'll often throw one into the mix. They're an easy win - evil twins can easily played by the same actor as the good twin, except with a slight visible variation, a distinguishing marker of their evilness like, say, a beard (a sure sign of evil) or a bit of a scowl. To celebrate all of those lazy liars, and also the fact that being so unimaginative can actually lead to good moments, we've compiled a list of the most memorable evil twins in TV history, including a number of notable variants along the way, such as the 'brother-from-another-mother', parallel universe versions of our favourite characters and a pair of twins who are just plain evil. Naturally, there are spoilers ahead...

18. Buffy The Vampire Slayer

After all that attention Buffy wallowed in throughout the first two seasons, season three pushed faithful sidekicks Willow and Xander into the limelight, and in a brilliant move, both got their very own kinky vampire twinsy selves to mix it up a little. After Cordelia hastily wishes that Buffy had never come to Sunnydale, Anya (the veiny and slightly limp looking vengeance demon) grants her wish in a move that in no way ripped of Charles Dickens or It's A Wonderful Life. Naturally as a result, Sunnydale is plunged into an even more hell-ridden version of itself, overrun with leather-clad goth-vampires led by the Master. What's memorable about Vampire Willow particularly is that she acts a stark reminder of what could have been, had Buffy not been around. Additionally, the character traits Vampire Willow displays arguably foreshadow some character developments Willow undergoes later on in the series. Vampire Willow was so popular with fans that she makes another appearance in the episode 'Doppelgangland', which was apparently one of Alyson Hannigan's (Willow) favourite episodes to shoot. Vampire Willow also wins points for being able to establish a memorable catchphrase in a single episode...'Bored now.'

17. Bonanza

For some really old school evil twins, you have to look as far back as Bonanza, the popular 1960's Western series, and in fact, this show spawned the whole 'evil twins' concept for the first time on TV. The series ran from 1959 €“ 1973, and was highly influential €“ but perhaps its greatest legacy was the birth of the 'evil twin' paradox. Little Joe's evil twin in the episode 'Alias Joe Cartwright' is memorable for being one of the first evil twins on popular TV. In the episode, an escaped prisoner who inexplicably look just like Little Joe Cartwright uses the old 'switcheroo' to cause mayhem. Unlike lots of shows later on this list, Bonanza as a Western doesn't fall into the 'fantasy' genre that usually lends itself nicely to the introduction of an evil twin.

16. The Simpsons

Over The Simpsons' long reign as king of cartoons, it's had a number of different doppelgängers, including Herb Simpson, Homer's far more successful half brother and Bart and Lisa's rivals Lester and Eliza. The best of the lot is undoubtedly Hugo, Bart's evil conjoined twin in the 'Treehouse of Horror VII'. Hugo is left to his own devices alone in the attic with nothing but a 'pigeon rat' for company, while Bart skateboards and pranks his days away. It's only at the end of the episode that Homer and Marge realise they've made a terrible mistake €“ Bart is in fact the evil twin. While this might not be surprising to viewers, this still makes for an unusually good storyline, especially when compared to the other more recent 'Treehouse of Horror' plots. Whereas recent 'Treehouse of Horror' plots have basically become unwatchable with their inexplicably random plots, this evil twins episode is actually pretty good story telling for a very short cartoon. Nice use of a famous TV trope, Matt Groening. In any case, Hugo is memorable for being really quite likeable despite the fact that he's a little gross.

15. Gilligan's Island

Gilligan's Island is like a more light-hearted and far less trippy precursor to Lost, following seven castaways surviving together on an island. While Bonanza may have started the evil twins trend, Gilligan's Island was the first TV show to really own it €“ literally half the characters have an evil twin in it at some point in the series. The chance of having an evil identical twin is small enough €“ the chance of three out of seven characters on a small island having an evil twin must be minimal. Still, Gilligan's Island embraced these minuscule odds and made it a staple story arc of three separate episodes. The evil twins in Gilligan's Island are memorable for both their variety (one was a Russian spy, one was a woman chasing Hollywood fame and another was a money-grabber) but also simply their sheer numerousness and defiance of all odds. Not only are the three sets of twins able to reach Gilligan's Island in the first place, they are also able to leave it again by the end of the episode.

14. Star Trek

Star Trek also threw in an evil twin trope, with its parallel universe themed episode 'Mirror, Mirror.' Amusingly, Spock's evil twin from the Mirror Universe is distinguished from his more benevolent counterpart simply by having a beard, in keeping with the other Mirror-crew's more flamboyant looks and dress-code. Not technically an evil twin, but actually a doppelgänger from a parallel universe who just happens to be a tad more brutal and ruthless than our serious Spock. The Mirror Universe episode is one of the most memorable in Star Trek and Mirror Universe Spock well deserves his place on our list, as he has set something of a precedent for all evil twins in pop culture since. Facial hair is now a requirement for all malevolent carbon copies.

13. Futurama

Like it's older, more yellow-hued brother The Simpsons, Futurama also threw in a couple of double-acts along the way. Futurama launched the crew of the Planet Express into various alternate universes, where they come across multiverse versions of themselves in 'The Farnsworth Paradox'. This included a blue Zoidberg, Leela and Fry as a happy couple and a gold version of Bender. The question is, which team is the 'evil' team? Unlike most characters and their evil twins, Bender's bling-twin is memorable for getting on with Bender like a house of fire, and becoming inseparable from him by the end of the episode. Finally, you might also remember Bender's other evil twin 'Flexo', who is also distinguished merely by his goatee. Beards aren't coming off well in this.

12. Knight Rider

Apparently, even cars can have evil twins! Our hero KITT in Knight Rider has its own villainous alterego, KARR. KARR was a prototype of KITT, but due to a computing error, it was accidentally programmed to be unstable and rather threatening. Pretty careless. In a pre-Transformers era, clearly audiences everywhere were crying out for more evil vehicles/robots on TV. KARR was so popular after its introduction in the incredibly named 'Trust doesn't Rust' episode, it was brought back for another episode in season 3. KARR is very advanced for a motor vehicle €“ it has actual malignant intentions and seeks revenge for nearly being destroyed in season 1. KARR well deserves its place on this list as it is the only vehicular evil twin, and was a very popular character. KARR's character was developed as a longer standing antagonist in the more recent reboot of Knight Rider in 2008.

11. Sabrina The Teenage Witch

Sabrina The Teenage Witch is easily among the best ever witch-themed shows, refreshingly different in its representation of witches (ie. not warty or overly sexualised) and highly amusing, and the Spellman family has a secret €“ every single member has an evil twin, which has got to win an award in the 'evil twin' stakes. After finding out that she has a twin, Sabrina goes off to meet Katrina. They are inexplicably put through a series of tests to find out which one is the evil twin (they were both were absolutely fine before this revelation, so why bother to find out?), and it starts to look like Sabrina may actually be the more malevolent of the two. Just when it looks like Sabrina may be sent of with all the other evil twins to a prison in 'Twin Cities' in another Realm, Katrina reveals herself to be the sour grape and Sabrina happily gets to go back to high school. All's well that ends well. Katrina may well be a precursor to all of the characters of Mean Girls, memorable for her sass, and evilness on a high school level - she's bitchy, witty and out to ruin Sabrina's life socially.

10. I Dream Of Jeannie

Next up is the hit 60's show I Dream of Jeannie, in which a 2,000 year old genie serves a strangely unremarkable man called Tony with an outrageous day job (astronaut) in 1960's surburbia before eventually, and rather disappointingly, settling down to become his housewife. But, before her retreat into mediocrity, she managed to fit in some downtime with her evil twin €“ weirdly also called Jeannie. The main difference between them? Evil Jeannie wears green rather than pink, which is definitely an indication of pure evil. While both the Jeannies are troublesome in their own way, evil Jeannie is memorable for being more seductive, causing a lot of confusion in the episode 'My Sister, The Homewrecker', when everyone mistakenly thinks that good Jeannie is cheating on Tony due to evil Jeannie's antics. Awkward.

9. Fringe

If you're a writer for a sci-fi show, and you want to throw in an evil twin here or there, what plot device do you go with to explain it? Parallel universes of course. Fringe is my favourite pseudo-science show, and following in the footsteps of its fore-bearers, 'Fringe' goes for the parallel universe explanation to throw in the 'evil twin' trope. It's up for the debate if the Alternate Universe alter-egos of the main characters of Fringe are corrupt. The most memorable evil-twin moments in Fringe are the ones that highlight what Walter could have been in another dimension - cold and calculating. The major arc of series three is the exploration of the twin trope, with Walter and Olivia's twins dubbed Walternate and Fauxlivia. Walternate is a pretty nasty character, and after a couple of tragic mistaken identity incidents, chaos ensues.

8. Shameless

Some evil twins serve as 'foils' - a character whose traits complete contrast with the traits of other key characters, in order to highlight the failings/strengths of the corresponding character. Shameless has a good example of a twin serving as a foil, with a variation of the evil twin as a good twin, to correspond with the character Paddy Maguire. Paddy is a homophobic violent gangster - who just happens to have a well spoken, well intentioned, gay identical twin brother called Noel, who sticks around for just one episode, but who is memorable nonetheless for being Paddy's complete opposite.

7. The Vampire Diaries

It's no surprise at all that evil twins have made an emergence in The Vampire Diaries, TV's most simultaneously clichéd and yet watch-able vampire-laden series yet. Following in the footsteps laid by Joss Whedon more than 10 years before, the sudsy Vampire Diaries has introduced an evil vampire twin version of Elena into the mix, Katherine. Again, the main difference really is the outfit. Oh, and that Katherine is one of the undead. As we've seen from Willow's evil twin, vamps love to dress all bad-ass and stuff, and Katherine uses this to full effect to demonstrate her vampness. What I'm getting from all this is that if you ever come across your evil vampire twin, she's probably going to be a hell of a lot more sexy, confident and bad ass than you are. Unless you're a guy. In which case, your evil twin will probably just have a beard. Katherine is memorable for demonstrating to us that Elena could be far less of a wet blanket than she is - if only she allowed herself to become a creature of the night.

6. Battlestar Galactica

Battlestar Galactica is a fantastic show, and is one that took the evil twin twist and decided to make this the basic concept of the series. Each humanoid Cylon character is simply one of many, and this is best demonstrated when Boomer, a loyal soldier of Galactica finds out not only that she has a whole cohort of evil twins wearing the same skin as her, she is actually a Cylon herself. Creepy. Her main 'evil twin' through the show is Athena, who happens to be the same cylon model as Boomer. While most shows use the evil twin concept as a plot that can usually be wrapped up in one or two episodes, we actually get to see some character development between Athena and Boomer. At the beginning of the series we are suspicious of Athena and see her as the malignant twin - but by the end of the series, we're not so sure. Athena and Boomer are memorable for the complexity of their character development but also the crucial importance of their story arc to the series as a whole.

5. Doctor Who

Back in the days when the Doctor wasn't embodied by a hipster sporting bow ties and instead was portrayed by the very-British Tom Baker, the Doctor ran into trouble on the planet Tigella and ended up acquiring a body double. Meglos is a shape shifting cactus creature with a penchant for mimicking the Doctor's form (they say imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, after all). Unusually, this evil twin was easy to spot €“ not because of a beard, or a bit of a scowl, but because he was covered in cactus spines. Subtle. It didn't take long for Meglos to reach his demise at the hands of his Timelord twin €“ but it was fun while it lasted. Meglos makes it onto our list of memorable twins for being probably the least subtle of evil twins.

4. Supernatural

The writers of Supernatural granted all the teenage girl fans of the show their one wish - two Deans! Even if one of those 'Deans' is an evil shapeshifting demon. 'Shapeshifter' Dean is the spitting image of his demon-hunter lookalike, and like any good evil twin worth his/her salt, the Shapeshifter wearing Dean's face causes all sorts of trouble posing as our favourite Winchester brother. The evil twin trope has been used here as a bit of a fan wish fulfilment. We've always thought Dean could make an awesome bad guy, and without his younger brother Sam keeping him grounded, he very well could be. Through the power of the evil twin trope, we get to experience that side of Dean, even if its just for an episode or two. Finally, this evil twin is also memorable for having a very, very disgusting ability to shed its skin, all at once. Gross.

3. Misfits

One of my favourite British TV shows in the last few years, Misfits's twist on the super hero genre took a bunch of juvenile delinquents and gave them superpowers, making them Super Hoodies. But not even a show as original as this one could escape the evil twin concept. Rudy, a humorous, rough around the edges layabout, with absolutely no social filter has a multiple personality disorder €“ very literally. He is able to reluctantly split into two polarised versions of himself, his most unshakeably happy-self full of misplaced confidence and his emotive, much less selfish and more self-doubting alter-ego. While nether of these characters is Rudy's evil twin, its this original twist on the concept that makes Rudy one and Rudy two so memorable. Rudy two is downright lovely and brings out the best in Rudy one, best demonstrated in the final season.

2. South Park

Of all the characters in Southpark, Cartman was an easy choice to designate an evil twin to. Well, more accurately, a nice twin. In a nod to Spock's evil twin, Cartman's twin from a parallel universe (again!) also sports a dashing little beard in the episode 'Spookyfish'. At the end of the episode, Cartman's friends decide to rid themselves of the mean Cartman €“ but accidentally fall for one of his tricks and instead kill the newer, nicer Cartman. Oh well. Cartman's twin is memorable for showing us a 'nice' version of Cartman - plus, this is probably one of the only examples of an 'evil' twin that we actually prefer to the version of them that we know well.

1. Friends

After all these sci-fi shows, you'd be forgiven for thinking that evil twins were exclusive to the fantasy genre. However, even America's most popular sitcom threw one in, in the form of Phoebe's sister Ursula. Ursula is just as much an odd-ball as Phoebe, but the complete opposite to Phoebe in all other ways. Ursula is mean, selfish and cutting. She also stars in dodgy 'Buffy' themed porn films using Phoebe's name €“ if that's not the act of an evil twin, I don't know what is. Ursula is memorable because she is most like a real life evil twin. She's not really pure evil but in fact epitomises the opposite of everything that makes Phoebe great. Additionally, that 'Buffy' themed porno is just hilarious. Bonus points if you remembered that after a bad break up with Ross, Rachel starts dating Russ. There's something similar between the two, but I just can't put my finger on it...
Which other evil twins from TV history deserve to be on this list? Share your picks below.