20 Hilarious Friends Spin-Offs (That Never Existed)

The Holiday Armadillo didn’t quite make the cut.

By Jack Morrell /

There’s a long history of the spin-off in American situation comedy, especially with the multi-camera live-audience set-up that ruled the roost for so many decades. Audiences would tune in every week to see the same characters tell the same jokes in the same way; a successful spin-off could either extend the lifespan of the product or (if broadcast while the original was still on the air) even potentially double that audience for the week.

Advertisement

With the huge success of NBC’s biggest hit sitcom Friends, you’d have thought that the network would have been giving the nod to pilots galore, both during the show’s run and after it ended at season ten. Instead, dumb-as-a-shoe actor Joey had a new show greenlit where he moved to Los Angeles to pursue his career.

Despite airing in the old Friends timeslot, the new show was poorly conceived (why was Joey suddenly a lovelorn schlub who couldn’t get a date?) and poorly received (it had halved its viewership by episode sixteen) and was officially cancelled halfway through the second season. It was such a ratings disaster that NBC didn’t even bother airing the remaining eight episodes.

But Friends was a gargantuan hit for ten years, over well over two hundred episodes - were there no other characters that deserved their own spin-off? Sure there were, dozens of them: but here’s twenty to be getting on with, along with a brief description of what their show might have looked like, had it ever been pitched...

20. The One With The Submarine Guy

Appearing in a single episode in season two (‘The One With The Chicken Pox’), Phoebe’s on-off Navy officer Ryan might not be everyone’s immediate first choice for a spin-off… if they didn’t know that he was played by Charlie Sheen.

Advertisement

Hollywood royalty or not, by 1996 Sheen’s movie career had stalled. He wouldn’t find television success until he stepped into a going concern, taking the place of Michael J. Fox on ABC’s Spin City in 2000. That, of course, led onto even greater success with CBS and Two And A Half Men a few years later.

Sheen was television dynamite: he just needed someone to take a risk on him. What might have happened had NBC chosen to take that risk in 1996/1997?

They could have spun Ryan off onto something like… Sweet Home Alabama, a show about the wacky crew of the US Navy Ohio class nuclear submarine Alabama (who go down for two years at a time), and the straight-laced Lieutenant Commander with no choice but to keep them all together.

19. The One With Hair As Bright As The Sun

The most constantly recurring guest character on Friends was, of course, the coffee shop’s long-suffering manager Gunther.

Advertisement

In many ways, spinning off a show called Central Perk straight after Friends finished should have been a bit of a no-brainer. The Central Perk set is iconic, second only to Monica’s apartment, and given that Chandler, Monica and Joey had moved away, it’s not like that sofa would have been in use going forward.

Of course, as far as comedy goes, Gunther himself is a bit of an unknown quantity. An oddball obsessive, he might have worked best as the eccentric foil to a whole new cast of characters, like Woody in Cheers or Kramer in Seinfeld.

But there would definitely have been some potential there. Keep the lugubrious voiceover of his innermost thoughts going as a comedic device. Have him regularly and inventively swearing in Dutch. Have guest stars almost without exception comment on his stunning attractiveness and/or sex appeal, to the obvious bafflement and increasing frustration of the other regulars.

18. The One With The Doppelganger

At the end of ‘The One With Russ’, we see a lovelorn Russ and Julie (recently dumped by Rachel and Ross, respectively) bump into each other at Central Perk. Sparks fly, and it’s implied that the two are instantly smitten with one another.

Advertisement

Russ, of course, is Ross’ doppelganger: the joke is that neither Rachel nor Julie recognise how similar he is to Ross in looks and personality.

In Girlfriend In Canada, set right after season two, Julie and Russ are living in Toronto - she works at the Royal Ontario Museum and teaches part-time at the University affiliated with it. The title has a double meaning, referring to Julie herself and also to her relationship with Russ. You see, this is Lauren Tom’s show: the running gag is that David Schwimmer (who plays Russ) is not in it.

Much like Mrs Wolowitz on The Big Bang Theory (or other ‘invisible’ characters like Maris in Frasier or Ugly Naked Guy in Friends itself), we never actually see Russ on screen. We hear his voice through the bathroom door, or on the phone; scenes cut away as soon as he is about to enter, or as doors are about to open.

However, no one else in Julie’s life seems to have met Russ either, with hilarious consequences as Girlfriend In Canada goes to increasingly elaborate lengths to keep that situation going.

17. The One With The Physicists In Minsk

Again, this feels like a no-brainer, largely because Hank Azaria is so good that he should be in everything.

Advertisement

Before Mike Hannigan came into Phoebe’s life, David was the Mike that nearly was: the love interest that everyone rooted for. Back in the first season, there was no intention of having any of the characters settle down properly; it just wasn’t David and Phoebe’s time.

There’s a world of potential in awkward, sweet and kind David’s character, especially in a fish-out-of-water comedy like An American In Minsk, which details David’s life and relationships while working on an increasingly farcical physics research project in nineties Belarus.

His colleagues are former political dissidents and hippies, his best friend is a barman obsessed with US pop culture and his next door neighbour may be a former KGB agent. As his work gets more and more confusing, weird and Kafkaesque, David tries to navigate life and love in this foreign culture, with the expected clashes and horrendous misunderstandings.

16. The One With The Excitable Manchild

You could probably fill an entire fall schedule of new shows with Phoebe’s ex-boyfriends alone: and there’s no way in the world you can reasonably pass up an opportunity to put Alec Baldwin on screen.

Advertisement

In The Bright Side, having been committed by the state of New York (the grumpiest state in the US, as everyone knows) due to his relentlessly sunny, antic disposition and inability to play anything down, Parker finds himself having to handle life on the psych ward, with one doctor convinced he doesn’t belong there and another convinced he’s delusional and needs in-patient treatment.

Parker drives everyone crazy with his over-the-top personality and seemingly irrational urge to look on the bright side of everything, but offers a unique perspective to those who are prepared to set aside their cynicism. Or he could be completely broken. You decide.

15. The One With The Seven Sisters

We first meet Joey’s seven sisters in ‘The One Where Chandler Can’t Remember Which Sister’, the plot of which should be self-explanatory from the title.

Advertisement

There’s Dina, Gina and Tina, Mary-Therese and Mary-Angela, Veronica and Cookie. Obviously the world saw more of Gina and a new version of Mary-Therese in Joey: but as no one watched that show, ‘the world’ in this case isn’t a whole lot of people, so we can feel free to ignore whatever happened there.

Coming from a Catholic Italian-American family, the Tribbiani girls are fiery, passionate, occasionally violent and fiercely loyal… and woe betide you if you mess with them or anyone they care about. In Sisters Before Misters, we get a Friends spin-off with an almost completely female cast, providing a perspective seriously lacking in network situation comedy.

14. The One With The Manny

The perennially underrated Freddie Prinze Jnr gets his own show in this spin-off set just after season nine of Friends, playing Sandy, the male nanny or ‘manny’ that Ross can’t deal with in ‘The One With The Male Nanny’.

Advertisement

Hired by a rich upstate family to be live-in nanny to their three children, Sandy has to deal with absentee parents, the spoiled kids themselves and a household staff deeply entrenched in their own ugly Cold War and intent on establishing their dominance on the others - none of whom want an enthusiastic, new age and highly emotional male nanny suddenly thrown into the pot.

So far, so pedestrian - but the 'com' in The Manny’s 'sit' is enlivened by the actors playing the rest of the cast.

Tim Curry is the butler, obsequious and ever so slightly insane, forever obliquely referring to his time in some unspecified war and The Things That He Did.

Betty White is the cook, a sweet-appearing ruthless manipulator who rules her kitchen with a rod of iron.

Kate Beckinsale plays the young English maid who everyone thinks is having an affair with the father, and who is far smarter than she likes to appear.

13. The One With The Soap Opera Queen

Susan Sarandon’s Cecilia Monroe was the queen bee on Days Of Our Lives, playing another queen bee, Jessica Lockhart. By the end of ‘The One With Joey’s New Brain’, Sarandon’s Monroe’s Lockhart was Drake Ramoray, enabling him/her to live again!

Advertisement

Of course, in reality Monroe had simply been written out of the show, after twenty years as the daytime soap opera world’s preeminent drink-throwing, face-slapping diva. Following a torrid affair with Joey, she leaves for Guadalajara to chase the Mexican movie career she missed out on as a veteran soap star.

In All The World’s A Stage, Susan Sarandon plays Cecilia Monroe who, having realised that the movie in Mexico was a money laundering front for a major drugs cartel, is now living in Des Moines under witness protection.

An actress all her life, Cecilia is now being forced to play the role of dowdy waffle waitress Trixie-Mae Ermintrude to avoid being recognised as a formerly major talent of the small screen. Under orders to stay inconspicuous, Cecilia can’t help letting the diva out, to her long-suffering DEA handler’s chagrin...

12. The One With The Sad Sack Stoner

Former Saturday Night Live cast member Jon Lovitz made a memorable appearance in both season one and season nine as Steve, a restaurant owner and pothead who loses everything in the intervening eight years.

Advertisement

Well, in Sad Sack Steve things go from bad to worse to oh good grief, as he loses two toes to frostbite, pisses off a local Colombian cartel composed of high schoolers, and drops his house to his maid in a game of poker.

A farcical cautionary tale in human form, Steve can’t help screwing up whatever he does, usually with hilarious, cringeworthy consequences. He’s the only man in history who managed to Home-Alone himself while trying to break into his own home after losing his keys.

11. The One Where You Meet The Parents

Who wouldn't want to see more of Ross and Monica's parents, played by the peerless Elliott Gould and Christina Pickles?

Advertisement

In wry black comedy Give 'Em Geller, Jack finds retirement unbearable and seeks out increasingly outlandish ways to keep himself occupied: hang gliding, cigar smuggling and his bourbon review blog, which is engaged in a bitter feud with a rival whiskey blog written by a local teenager.

In the meantime, Judy goes off the reservation completely and begins lying to Jack about everything - her kleptomania, her affair with the parish priest, the seventeen cats she keeps in the summer house…

Think of it as an American 'One Foot In The Grave', but played by two of the most charming actors in television.

10. The One With The Love Machine

Originally agreeing to appear on Friends for free after losing a bet with Matthew Perry on the set of The Whole Nine Yards, Bruce Willis initially played to type as the alpha male, intimidating Paul Stevens, father to Ross’ new young girlfriend.

Advertisement

That changed when Paul started seeing Rachel and finally learned to let his emotions show. Willis revelled in finding his comic chops again, playing a man crumbling like wet cake under the onslaught of forty-odd years of real feelings.

In The Love Machine, Paul is single and looking for Miss Right - but the emotional floodgates opened by his experience with Rachel have caused him to need therapy, and he finds he’s developed a twitch when feeling anxious which develops into a full blown spasm if anyone mentions the words ‘chicken’ or ‘surfboard’.

9. The One With The Terrible British Accent

Jennifer Coolidge's wonderful, horrible character Amanda Buffamonteezi is a freakin' nightmare.

Advertisement

An ex-roommate of Monica and Phoebe's, Amanda’s loud, obnoxious ego would be bad enough on its own... but like the lunchtime special at the world’s sh*ttiest restaurant, it comes paired with the vinegary white wine of an excruciating fake English accent.

Now, in How To Get Amanda, she's married above her station: she’s just wed nonagenarian shipping magnate Benny Sipatero, who's almost blind and deaf and so believes her to be young, high class British totty.

It’s a marriage made in golddigger heaven. That is, until Amanda discovers that, in Sicily, 'shipping magnate' means 'mafia’…

8. The One With The Dead Agent

Playing Joey’s scrunched-up, weird-ass agent Estelle all the way through season two to the end of season ten, the phenomenal June Gable probably deserved a little better than having her character die off screen.

Advertisement

But what if Estelle wasn’t dead? Down on her luck (and down to her last two clients) and probably in significant debt from her chainsmoking habit alone, what better way to start over than faking her death?

In Starmaker, Estelle heads to Hollywood and establishes herself as an agent by masquerading as her more successful (but fictitious) twin sister Esther, thereby enabling herself to cash in on Estelle’s contacts in the industry while avoiding Estelle’s dodgy reputation.

Having quit smoking, ‘Esther’ is desperate for nicotine, often going to outrageous lengths to get a puff of a cigarette or some secondhand smoke. In the bright, shallow, fake world of LA her caustic New York personality makes her a novelty.... but can it make her a starmaker?

And can she avoid bumping into anyone who might actually know her - like a certain Joey Tribbiani?

7. The One With The Handsome Optometrist

Tom Selleck played everyone’s favourite love interest on the show - possibly joint favourite with Paul ‘Mike Hannigan’ Rudd - but what might have happened to Richard Burke after Monica rejected him at the end of season six?

Advertisement

In order to forget about Monica, put the past behind him and get a fresh start, everyone's favourite tall, handsome optometrist retires to Hawaii, 2500 miles from the west coast, pretty much as far from New York as you can get while remaining in the USA… but can he stay out of trouble?

In Eye Candy, Richard decides to open a cigar shop and moustache grooming parlour... but with his dog, a pug called Higgins, ends up investigating crimes on the side, most of which can be solved using his advanced knowledge of the human eye.

6. The One With The Obsessive Millionaire

The rich head of a massive software company, Pete Becker was always described as a millionaire, but was presented by the show as more like a billionaire. Had Monica stayed with Pete Becker, her whole life might have been completely transformed.

Advertisement

Of course, she would have had to deal with Pete’s obsessive nature. This might have been the secret to his success (and you could argue that his persistence was what got him the girl), but his insistence that he could become a UFC champion caused them to break up.

He was a terrible MMA fighter - but what else might Pete choose to go after? In Billion Dollar Baby, Becker and his long-suffering staff pursue oddball vocations galore - deep sea driller, rodeo clown, astronaut, sword swallower, brain surgeon - as the ambitious, frustrated Pete struggles to find something that makes him happy.

5. The One With The Sisters From Hell

This one pretty much writes itself: in Little Rich Girls, self-obsessed professional daughters Amy and Jill Green are cut off from Daddy's money and have to move in together to make ends meet.

Advertisement

Played by Reese Witherspoon and Christina Applegate, this would have been a match made in heaven… although it was never meant to be. Witherspoon was supposed to be reprising her role as Rachel’s younger sister Jill in season nine but was unavailable, so the writers invented a second sister, Amy - and Applegate ended up winning an Emmy for her performance in that role.

Imagine the two of them together - it’s television gold. It would never have come about: by the time Friends finished, Witherspoon had just made Legally Blonde and her movie career had exploded. Still, it’s fun to dream.

4. The One With The Diva Dad

The glorious Kathleen Turner takes centre stage as the former Charles Bing, Chandler's father, in Helena On Wheels. It's Will & Grace meets The Golden Girls; Grace & Frankie by way of The Birdcage.

Advertisement

As we know, Friends couldn’t make up its mind at the time whether ‘Helena Handbasket’ was gay, a transvestite or a transwoman, and back between 1994 and 2001, the writers clearly didn’t have the wherewithal to make the distinction.

In an effort to make up for Friends’ awkward ignorance of transgender issues and terminology two decades ago, this putative spin-off show would have avoided the pitfalls of casual homophobia that previously scuppered the character, presenting her as a successful Vegas lounge act with a happy life and a host of friends.

3. The One With The Crazy Eyes

In A Hawk From A Handsaw, Chandler's volatile ex-roommate Eddie (played by Adam Goldberg) sometimes has only a tenuous grip on reality thanks to the borderline personality disorder he was diagnosed with a few years ago.

Advertisement

Eddie is married to Erika, Joey's former stalker (played by Brooke Shields), who also has borderline personality disorder: they met in a support group. They’re both on meds, both carefully managing their symptoms as they try to maintain their integration with the world around them.

Erika is a college literature teacher in love with Shakespeare (hence the title). Eddie thinks he works in a bar in the East Village, but really he just turned up every day and served drinks until they decided to start paying him.

The show mines the couple’s occasional skittery relationship with the real world for warm chuckles but crucially, invites us to laugh with them, not at them: this isn’t a comedy that punches down.

2. The One With The Terrible Triplets

In Hyperventilating, Frank Buffay Jnr (Giovanni Ribisi) and his wife, Alice Knight-Buffay (Debra Jo Rupp), are constantly hanging by a thread… with hilarious, weekly consequences.

Advertisement

Not only are they a May-December couple with a mutual low tolerance for stress, but they have insane seven year old triplets Leslie, Chandler and Frank Jnr Jnr. How do they cope? They do not.

In episode one, the girls lock Alice in the bathroom and she has to negotiate for her own release. Why is the bolt suddenly and inexplicably on the outside? Because they're evil geniuses, that's why.

Meanwhile Frank Jr leaves Frank Jnr Jnr in the car while he dashes to the ATM: when he returns minutes later he can’t find the car, and breaks into every Toyota in the lot until he's arrested for vandalism, while seven year old Frank Jnr Jnr is fine, but has been arrested for impersonating a police officer.

Rupp and Ribisi are a perfectly matched manic pairing, as their characters engage in increasingly farcical schemes to keep their family together and sane: schemes which inevitably cause even more chaos and confusion.

1. The One With The Laugh

She might have the most annoying voice - and laugh - in recorded history, but Janice has a heart of gold. There’s a reason why, despite their aversion to her, none of the protagonists of Friends have ever told her to just leave them alone - the woman is a sweetheart who genuinely likes them.

Advertisement

The same, unfortunately, cannot be said of her husbands. Janice is fine in small doses, but it’s harder to live with her. By the time of the pilot episode of Oh My God, Janice has gone back to her maiden name of Hosenstein, having exhausted five ex-husbands (as well as the possibilities of a hyphenated surname). But hey, they were no picnic either...

Finally deciding to raise her six children alone, the show follows her slow, defiant path back to equilibrium again, navigating the pitfalls and obstacles of a life with an annoying personality, too many children and much, much too many ex-husbands. It’s enough to make you scream OH. MY. GOD.

Advertisement