20 TV Characters Who Deserve Their Own Spin-Off

By Nick Fulton /

Whether it be good or bad, the TV spin-off show has become a consistent part of the cultural zeitgeist. From Mary Tyler Moore and Rhoda to the successful Cheers spin-off of Frasier, and even lesser spin-offs like the Friends show without the other five members called Joey, TV spin-offs are easy for networks to get behind because it's dealing with a character that audiences already have a relationship with. Though some - perhaps the majority - of spin-offs have a connotation of being a lazy re-packaging of a formula that already ran dry, some of the best TV shows in history began as parts of other series. Most famously, perhaps, is what I consider to be my favorite show of all time: The Simpsons. What began as relatively short cartoon vignettes on Fox's The Tracy Ullman Show, the Simpsons managed to land themselves their own program in 1989. Not only the most successful spin-off ever, The Simpsons is now the longest running scripted TV program ever made, with over 24 seasons and over 500 episodes worth of the TV family that began as just a brief snippet of Tracy Ullman's program. But the Simpsons are an entire family. Meanwhile, characters like Frasier Crane and Family Guy's Cleveland were believed to be strong enough to venture out on their own. So let's take a look at another 20 great television characters who should've branched off to do their own thing....

20. Gale (Breaking Bad)

Poor Gale Boetticher. All he wanted was to become an expert at chemistry, and damn if he didn't do it. Perhaps becoming the second leading man in his field, he's afforded the opportunity to work alongside - and learn from - the first: Walter White. And while Walter is a tough nut to crack, Gale manages to do it with his odd charm and molecular-based coffee skills. Unfortunately, due to certain... we'll call them "misgivings," a Gale Boetticher spinoff can't exactly happen. But who wouldn't love to see a show on Gale: The Early Years, as he karaokes to Major Tom and learns how to cook methamphetamines. Frankly, Gale was the most likable character on Breaking Bad, as really his only flaw was getting into the drug business. At least he wasn't whiny like that monstrous Skyler.

19. Xander (Buffy the Vampire Slayer)

Though Xander starts off the series as being a geek with a fruitless crush on the titular heroine, over the course of the seven seasons of the show, he grows up and becomes nearly cool. He manages to hook up with Willow, Cordelia, Anya and Faith over the course of the series. He even nearly closes the deal with Buffy herself in the episode Bewitched, Bothered and Bewildered on account of some witchery. Of course, things don't always come up roses for Xander. He almost married a vengeance demon. He has military flashbacks, despite technically never having served in the army. And worst of all, when he has a run in with Nathan Fillion's preacher, he gets one of his eyeballs plucked out. But regardless, we'd all love to see a spinoff with Xander, who managed to be the cynical and sarcastic voice of reason throughout the show.

18. Salvatore Romano (Mad Men)

Salvatore Romano, better known as Sal, is a former employee of the Sterling Cooper ad agency. Using his keen eye, Sal helped bring an aesthetic quality of the work conducted by Don Draper and crew as the art director for the company. Unfortunately, Sal's life was more complex than simply boozing and man-whoring around while dealing with a horrible wife and unhealthy dose of self-loathing. Being a closeted gay man must always be difficult. Even more so when you're in the less tolerant 1960's and trying to juggle a sham marriage with your career. But Sal even has to contend with the unfair standards set by Sterling Cooper. Ultimately, he's fired when he refuses to give into another man's sexual advances. Sal would've deserved a full series on his own, setting out to discover his identity in an era and profession that was remarkably intolerant in its faux civility.

17. Jess (Gilmore Girls)

The second of Rory's three boyfriends on the series, Jess certainly provided the most source of drama. Not meekly pathetic like Dean, and not spoiled douchey like Logan, Jess managed to be compelling by playing the James Dean bad-boy angle. With his leather jacket and disdain for authority, Jess managed to briefly capture Rory's heart. Though the two separate, Rory bumps into Jess again during her college years. During their separation, he'd gone off on his own and matured some. He'd even written a short novel. Jess would be a great character to have been able to follow as he matured from a rebellious punk to an intelligent and artful man who was able to take care of himself. Also, any opportunity for Alexis Bledel to guest star in something works great for me.

16. Kenneth (30 Rock)

Kenneth Parcell, the wide-eyed hick page working at 30 Rockefeller Plaza in New York, in a consistent source of naive entertainment. Born in Stone Mountain, Georgia, Kenneth takes his southern hospitable charm to the Big Apple, thrust into the world of television he loves so much. Continually confronted with the dramatic misgivings by the show's stars Jenna and Tracy, Kenneth is often exploited due to his innate kindness. But underneath the niceties lies a darkness in Kenneth not exposed in the remainder of the cast. In a particularly memorable episode, Kenneth is thrust into a drinking contest with the teamsters, finding himself a natural after discovering that the alcoholic beverages he'd previously assumed were inherently evil is simply what his family calls "hill people milk," a drink he's enjoyed his entire life. And not only mysterious due to the nature of his absurd religious affiliations, Kenneth is also enigmatic in that he may in fact be considerably older than he lets on. In fact, it's possible that he is a veteran of the Second World War. Having recently wound done, Kenneth would be a perfect opportunity for NBC to make a good programming decision in continuing with the life of this character, a man out of place in the big city.

15. Carlton (Fresh Prince of Bel-Air)

In the Fresh Prince of Bel-Air, Will Smith finds himself relocated from West Philadelphia to the upper class district of Los Angeles known as Bel-Air. While there, he becomes acquainted with his uncle, two versions of his aunt, a butler and two female cousins. But Will becomes closest with - whether or not they like it - his cousin Carlton. While being similar in age and blood relatives, Will's lax and carefree attitude are at such polar opposites to Carlton's neurotic and conservative prep-student that their differences are matched in television by few outside of Felix and Oscar. Career-driven, Carlton is portrayed as a perennial go-getter, a conservative youth not seen since the likes of Alex Keaton. Vying for Princeton, Carlton's trek to the Ivy League is bereft with pit stops. Among these are a love of Tom Jones, with a patented dance to the hit "It's Not Unusual." We also learn of Carlton's heart, as he bares his soul to Will and his father regarding the effect the tragedy of Trix commercials had on him as a child; these worries are just, as those damn kids really could've just given the rabbit some Trix. Ultimately, the Fresh Prince legacy misses out on following Carlton to the east coast as he transferred into Princeton in the show's final season.

14. Phil Myman/Lem Hewitt (Better Off Ted)

The mad scientists from the short-lived series Better Off Ted, Phil and Lem provide a compelling contrast between the more callously capitalist rest of the corporation Veridian Dynamics. Whereas the nameless higher-ups, Veronica, and to a lesser extend Ted himself have Machiavellian tendencies when it comes to the business world, Phil and Lem are purists. They are content with themselves, willing to make crazy inventions simply for the pursuit of science and discovery, regardless if the company they work for uses them for evil. One of the best examples of their inventions was a machine that could be used to translate any language, a babelfish which Ted uses to his advantage to seduce one of the attractive German visitors to Veridian. Unfortunately, the mood gets killed in the bedroom as her dirty talk via the machine is translated with the voice of Phil. But, as we can see from the technical success of the device, a spinoff between these two with more wacky inventions is something we'd all love to have gotten to see.

13. Alex P. Keaton (Family Ties)

We've already covered his Bel-Air counterpart, but there would be no Carlton Banks were it not first for Alex P. Keaton. Growing up in a family full of hippie-liberal types has to be difficult when you are-- by nature-- a Reaganite republican. Alex's struggle throughout the series is to find his own identity on the right of center in a house full of Jimmy Carter apologists. Of course, Alex's character wasn't simply limited to politics. He was a driven, fastidious individual. And before Lisa Simpson was ever shown to get hooked up pep pills, Alex had his own struggles with speed in order to get ahead in school. In one of the first examples of a family sitcom to deal with actual struggles, Alex hits bottom the way so many other neocons have, with the bottom being the bottom of a bottle of pills. Fortunately for him, Alex cleaned himself up. And while we never got the Alex Keaton spinoff, we were fortunate enough to have Mr. Fox at least grace us with another great and underrated sitcom in the '90s, Spin City.

12. Toby (The Office)

The H.R. representative from the American remake of the Office, Toby, for whatever reason draws Michael Scott's ire through the duration of the series. Perhaps it's because he works in Human Resources. Or perhaps its because Toby is constantly in a position to play police for Michael, including running harassment seminars and forcing the boss to tone down his over the top jokes. Or maybe it's because, unlike everyone else in the office, Toby isn't technically one of Michael's employees. But regardless of Michael who hates everything about the way Toby chooses to be, the audience can sympathize with him. He's forced to work in the Annex next to Kelly Kapoor. And like the rest of the world, he has a crush on Pam that just can't possibly come to fruition. When he flees the workplace of Dunder-Mifflin to go live in Costa Rica, he's not there a month before ending up in traction due to a zipline accident. But given that Toby is played by one of the head writers and its former showrunner Paul Lieberstein, we can trust that a Toby spinoff would be in good hands (even if NBC didn't believe the Lieberstein spear-headed Dwight spinoff wasn't a good idea).

11. Conrad (Weeds)

Played by the awesomely-named Romany Malco, Conrad Shepard is a low-level pot dealer who works with his aunt to supply Nancy Botwin her ganja in the early seasons of the show Weeds. Conrad proves himself to be not only strikingly calm and level-headed when compared to the other criminals depicted on the show, but quite intelligent. In fact, were he not stifled by his aunt, it's apparent that Conrad could've been something of a Walter-White-of-Weed. But unfortunately for the show, Conrad gets written off when Nancy and her family move out of Ren Mar. Not only did the show suffer due to a lack of Conrad, but the brutal sexual tension between Conrad and Nancy perhaps the most compelling subplot of the first three seasons, which was unfortunately never fully fleshed out. I think that many people would've preferred to stay in California with Conrad than travel around with the increasingly obnoxious Nancy.

10. Eddard Stark (Game of Thrones)

Not to spoil anything for you, but this is a spinoff that would need to take a different route in order to be successful. So what better way to go at it than to take a trip through the past. Isn't everyone a little bit curious about the history between Ned Stark and his history with the late king Robert Baratheon? Though we know that Robert trusts Eddard, even proclaiming him the Hand of the King, the depth of their relationship is still mysterious throughout the series. We gather pieces here and there. We know that some of Ned's family was killed at the hands of the Mad King. Then, with the help of Ned himself, Robert managed to dethrone the psychotic Targaryen and captured the throne for himself. Through that long, vicious battle, surely Ned and Robert managed to find themselves some adventure and excitement. And best of all, if we got to see a Ned Stark prequel series, we would go into it beforehand not having to wait for Sean Bean's character to die like we do in every other role he plays.

9. Cigarette-Smoking Man (X-Files)

Maybe one of the most perplexing TV characters not created by David Lynch, the man known simply as the Cigarette-Smoking Man is an enigma wrapped in a riddle, wrapped in a haze of cigarette smoke. Though we learn scant more details about him as the series continued-- he was named C.G.B. Spender and may have been Fox's biological father-- he still remains one of the most mysterious aspects of a show chock-full of mystery. The Cigarette-Smoking Man has a complex relationship with the protagonists Mulder and Scully, but is generally considered to be one of their main antagonists. A member of the government group known as the Syndicate, the Smoking Man is one of the puppeteers in the conspiracy to cover up the existence of aliens. But he also believes that his job serves greater good, protecting the people from the evils and horrors he knows exist in the world, ours and others. But given the amount that he knows, we would have loved to had a Cigarette-Smoking Man spinoff before he met his untimely (or, given the amount of tobacco abuse, timely) demise.

8. Barry Zuckerkorn (Arrested Development)

Barry Zuckerkorn is not a great lawyer; he's basically one tiny step above the Simpson's Lionel Hutz. And he's not really a great man either, with his sexual proclivities for man dressed in drag while simultaneously being incredibly homophobic. But while we all got some enjoyment out of the Bluth family's second lawyer Bob Loblaw (who has an incredible Law Blog), he didn't quite match up to Barry. This was, after all, the man who got the family out of a possible bind related to WMD's because he was able to recognize a man's junk on a cell phone picture.

7. Audrey Horne (Twin Peaks)

Although she initially appears to be a typical catty high school girl, the character of Audrey Horne in Lynch's epic series Twin Peaks quickly develops into one of the most fascinating characters the show offers. The daughter of the corrupt businessman Benjamin, Audrey seems to be a typically irresponsible teenager, gossiping about Laura Palmer's murder callously. However, Audrey later lets on that she had a soft spot for Laura, who helped her handicapped brother. Audrey, played by the classically beautiful Sherilyn Fenn, oozes jailbaity sexuality with a noir-era femme fatale charm. She develops a crush on the protagonist Dale Cooper, and the two maintain a palpable sexual chemistry for the majority of the series. She even attempts to help him in his investigation of Laura's death, finding herself being nearly prostituted out to her own father. Though her character's fate at the end of the series finale is somewhat ambiguous, Fenn herself has claimed that Audrey would've made a re-appearance in Season 3 had there been one. Unfortunately, one of TV's greatest dramas ended too soon after only a meager two seasons.

6. The Todd (Scrubs)

Before there was Barney Stinson, the surgeon from Scrubs referred to simply as "The Todd" re-introduced the world to the subtle wonders of the high-five. The Todd epitomizes the stereotypes that exist within the walls of hospitals that surgeons are dim-witted and single-minded. Aside from his work in the operating room, which we learn early on in the series that he actually excels at, the Todd is focused merely on sex. While his antics verge on sexual harassment with essentially every syllable uttered, the Todd is a constant source of double entendres ("I'd double her entendre"). With his banana hammock in toe, the Todd tears through the halls of Sacred Heart hospital, propositioning anyone within earshot, his sexual preferences spanning both sexes, claiming to appreciate hotness "regardless of gender." Since its finale, there has been a noticeable lack of Todd-like characters on television, a hole which is in desperate need of being filled.

5. Professor Frink (The Simpsons)

In the episode 22 Short Films About Springfield, the end credits interrupt the infamous Professor Frink, as he laments the fact that he will not be able to tell his story; he claims to be able to both make you laugh and think. Professor Frink, one of the most absurd characters on one of the most beloved cartoons, is brilliant but little explored man. We do know that at one point in time he developed hamburger earmuffs. In fact, he has no worries that Homer will develop it independently of them before Frink can get them on the shelf, as he realizes Homer will have to grapple with the harrowing "Pickle Matrix". Professor Frink is also an expert in the field of microcalifragilistics, one of the most difficult fields of science known to man. In fact, the only challenge he's been faced with that he could not overcome with the formation of some sort of... rebigulator.

4. Cake Boss (Comedy Bang Bang)

IFC's Comedy Bang Bang, essentially itself a spin-off of the comedy podcast of the same name, turns late-night talk shows on their heads in a way that hasn't been done since The Larry Sanders Show. Its host, comedian and writer Scott Aukerman (Hot Saucerman), invites a series of real-life and fictional characters on his program to create some of the most absurd comedy ever filmed. One of his most famous guests is the Cake Boss, Buddy Valastro. Portrayed by stand-up superstar Paul F. Tompkins, the Cake Boss is really only a slightly exaggerated version of the actual reality TV star. Buddy is a man who constantly repeats the phrase "cake boss" (cake boss!) when it is spoken. And, unfortunately for him, he has the gift-slash-curse of having been bitten by a cake-bug, which rarely bite humans but do grant the power of the second-sight. If only the real TLC program with the real-life Cake Boss contained moments in which its host was able to see into the future and witness the death of television hosts, merely for saying that they like pie better than cake.

3. Beadie Russell (The Wire)

Before she was Oscar-nominated actress and starring as Steve Crrell's love interest in The Office, Amy Ryan portrayed Officer Beadie Russell in the hit HBO series The Wire. Though she began as a lowly Baltimore beat cop, she very quickly found herself immersed with the homicide department in the second season of the show. In fact, Beadie was an integral of the investigation of a string of murders, as she herself was the first to stumble upon the dozen dead bodies. After this season of the show, she gets demoted to only being a tangential supporting character. And while we learn of her relationship with the show's main protagonist Jimmy McNulty, we are only given brief glimpses into their troubled relationship together. Without spoiling the way the show ends, I will just note that there is not a happy ending for everybody. However, Beadie could've been given that opportunity. With a spinoff of The Wire, we would be able to get a deeper look at a struggling female police officer in the harrowing city of Baltimore portrayed by David Simon. Plus, Jimmy McNulty would be alongside Beadie for comic relief, as well as a little bit of drama.

2. Galen Tyrol (Battlestar Galactica)

Galen Tyrol, affectionately referred to as Chief, is the deck chief on the reboot Battlestar Galactica. While he begins the series in a relatively simple position, juggling a successful job and a secret relationship with the smokin hot Boomer, the Chief's life gradually collapses throughout the four seasons of the show. First, his love interest turns out to be a Cylon, a member of the treacherous cyborg race that nearly wiped out mankind. Later, he finds out he himself is a Cylon sleeper agent. Then, his wife is murdered by one of his cohorts, being thrown out of the airlock. When the series concluded with the habitation of Second Earth, Tyrol separates himself from the crowd, and possibly ends up inhabiting the future area of Scotland. While he forages away from the other surviving humans and cyborgs, it'd have been nice to spend a couple years with the Chief, seeing how he acclimated to a new life, and mostly just make sure that the dude ends up okay.

1. Sally Sparrow (Doctor Who)

Before she was an A-list celebrity making critically acclaimed art-house hits like Shame and Drive and filming big budget versions of beloved novels like the Great Gatsby, Carrie Mulligan starred in a single episode of Doctor Who. The episode, Blink, introduced the world to the monsters known as the Weeping Angels. And while being a statuesque quantum-locked group of aliens that can only move while not seen, and that kill you by sending you back in time provided ample entertainment, the episode would not have quite the same emotional impact were not for Mulligan's protagonist Sally sparrow. Mulligan's sweetness and innocence come into play as she casually transforms into the character of Sally, an inquisitive and adventurous girl who sets out to solve the riddle of her friend's disappearance. In the end, we learned that Sally and her friend's brother get together, both romantically and form the store Sparrow and Nightingale. We witness their one last chance meeting with the Doctor, which sets the entire story in motion from both the beginning and the end. However, we can't help but wonder about how it would've been if Sally Sparrow had her own series of adventures, both those of the mysterious Doctor Who world, battling aliens and monsters, and those within her own social life and relationships attempting to form a new business and romance. Fortunately for viewers, Carey Mulligan has made it big, so we're afforded the opportunity to see her in countless films, even if we are left with only an hour long episode of the great Sally Sparrow. Thoughts? Leave a comment below and check out the Beast Duels Radio Hour for more movie lists, including Top 5 Movie Mob Hits and Best Man-Made Monsters.