20 TV Show Pilots That Are Totally Flawless

When it came to starting strong, these shows didn't disappoint.

By Aidan Whatman /

Recently, Seinfeld finally made its way onto Netflix, promising to introduce a whole new generation of audiences to the unethical and hilarious world of the New York Four. The only problem? They're going to have to sit through its famously bland pilot.

Advertisement

Featuring little of the sitcom's trademark humour and unrecognisable characters, Seinfeld got off to such a poor start that the first season only aired five episodes, and Larry David was forced to seriously rejig the show's tone and character line-up.

Unfortunately, Seinfeld is only one of many shows that has started out unsure of their identity, and terrible pilots are so common that it's worryingly rare for one to kick things off on the right foot.

Of course, TV shows are bound to change over time, and the pilot by definition is there to help the writers work out how to proceed with their vision, but even so it's quite remarkable how so many pilots drop the ball and leave the rest of their shows with a weak foundation.

With that in mind - since here at WhatCulture we've already taken a dive into great finales - this list will focus on 20 rare TV show pilots that are totally, 100% flawless.

20. Truth Be Told - Alias

Created by filmmaker J. J. Abrams, Alias was a show that thrived on fast-paced and action-heavy storylines, and loved to end on a maddening cliffhanger. These traits are clear for the get-go, when the show's first episode introduces Jennifer Garner's CIA agent Sydney Bristow and throws her head-first into a deadly conspiracy.

Advertisement

Truth Be Told holds nothing back. It introduces Sydney as a tough spy with a big heart, and then spends the next hour systematically breaking it and turning her life upside down. She loses her boyfriend, is confronted by her estranged father, and learns her employers the SD-6 are actually a terror cell.

Soaring with Garner's star-making performance and Abrams' focussed direction, the episode promises big things to come whilst setting up countless mysteries and relationships. It's gutsy, slick, and utterly original, and serves as a reminder all these years later of just how great Alias was during its run.

19. Pilot - Arrested Development

Arrested Development started as it meant to go on: By airing a pilot that introduced more ideas, characters, themes, recurring gags and family drama than basically any other sitcom before or since. The episode broke all the rules and made it look easy, as well as astonishingly fun.

Advertisement

On its own, the introduction to the hazardous world of the Bluth family is a stunning watch, requiring unwavering attention but reaping many rewards for those willing to take the journey. But the true genius of the episode comes from the jokes it sets up for future episodes, and the foreshadowing peppered throughout.

Simply, Arrested Development's pilot is a treasure trove of humour that's actually better on a second viewing. It introduces recurring jokes such as the man with the "freedom" sign and the idea that Tobias is gay - despite his objections - and sets up an hilarious and compelling narrative in the process.

18. Pilot - How I Met Your Mother

The initial set-up is simple: In the not-so-distant future, Ted Mosby sits his kids down and prepares to tell them the winding, hilarious, and seemingly never-ending story of how he met their mother. The first episode makes it clear this is going to be a long story, but one with heaps of potential and emotional payoffs.

Advertisement

In the pilot, the structure of Ted's ramblings is set, and in just twenty remarkably tight minutes it introduces us to his hopeless romanticism, the playboy antics of constant scene-stealer Barney Stinson, and the wonderfully gooey relationship of high school sweethearts Marshall and Lily.

In terms of character, the How I Met Your Mother pilot is inspired. The core gang's personalities and quirky traits are there from the get-go, but the very best part of the episode comes from how it manages to make Ted such a likeable protagonist, in spite of his mountainous flaws. It's funny, sweet, and promises big things to come.

17. Offred - The Handmaid's Tale

Few shows have ever started with such harrowing intensity as Bruce Miller's visceral dystopian drama The Handmaid's Tale. Throwing viewers into a world where fertile women are forced to bear children for wealthy, childless couples, the show's pilot is dark and emotionally bleak, but incredibly engaging.

Advertisement

Directed by Reed Morano, Offred focusses on the eponymous handmaid, played with tragic and powerful empathy by Elisabeth Moss, as she becomes accustomed to the changed world and attempts to grapple with mysterious memories. She encounters her fellow handmaids, and struggles with the horror of her new life.

Though far from an easy watch (the entire series is certainly one of the most horrific currently on-air), The Handmaid's Tale opens with such ferocity, creativity and unique power that it's close to impossible to look away from. It may be hard going, but it's also rewarding and arresting, making watching on a no-brainer.

16. The Long Bright Dark - True Detective

Before he decided to turn it into an anthology series, Nic Pizzolatto envisioned True Detective as a novel, and that original idea shines through the show's first episode in the way it plays with time and its deeply engrossing themes of memory, age, and the human condition.

Advertisement

Though the way in which it sets up the season's haunting mystery suggests that the show will just be another admittedly great crime procedural, The Long Bright Dark makes it clear that the main drive of the story comes from the relationship of veteran detectives Rust Cohle and Marty Hart.

With unblemished, career-best performances from both Matthew McConaughey and Woody Harrelson, the episode moves between past and future to tell an epic tale of friendship against the backdrop of a tantalising Louisiana murder mystery, and the results are both profound and utterly compelling.

15. Deadwood - Deadwood

David Milch is undeniably one of TV's greatest writers, and the way in which he lends his unique voice to Deadwood is what makes its pilot episode such a revelation. From the very first scene, the tone is set, the dialogue sings, and the characters are fully-formed against the show's expansive set pieces and gritty tone.

Advertisement

Through series protagonists Seth Bullock and Al Swearengen, the episode expertly introduces audiences to the eponymous town's growing lawlessness, its scheming locals, and the threat of everyday frontier life, and does so with sharp historical detail and some of the most impressive production design ever seen on the small screen.

For all its visual splendour, though, Deadwood's self-titled pilot thrives best with its cast, which includes stars Timothy Olyphant, Ian McShane and Paula Malcolmson all on top form as they effortlessly sell the vulgar poetry of Milch's energetic and daring script.

14. Smoke Gets In Your Eyes - Mad Men

Much like Deadwood, the pilot for Matthew Weiner's period drama Mad Men initially stands out because of the detail that can be found in its 1960s setting. Featuring gorgeous set pieces, era-appropriate costume design and a fiery script rife with twists, Smoke Gets In Your Eyes is first and foremost a visual feast.

Advertisement

But the best part of the pilot doesn't come from how great it looks, but from the way it introduces series protagonist Don Draper, a genius ad executive who has the world at his feet, but is hiding a series of devastating and gasp-inducing secrets, the best of which appears in the final moments of the episode.

Bringing Draper to life in the performance of a lifetime, Jon Hamm instantly shines, as does frequent scene-stealer Elisabeth Moss. It's an hour of set-up that introduces its characters one way, and ends by showing them in an entirely new light, and pulls it off without making the episode feel crammed.

13. My First Day - Scrubs

It's difficult to think of many sitcoms that started their run as confidently as Scrubs, a medical dramedy that followed the ins-and-outs of Sacred Heart Hospital with both increasingly wacky humour and poignant drama. The show's pilot finds its voice and tone instantly, and the results are fantastic.

Advertisement

Told through the narration and daydreams of Zach Braff's quirky medical intern J.D, the pilot spends a day in the life of the hospital as a new batch of interns attempt to survive their first shift. What follows is a frequently hilarious comedy of errors which ends with a moment of quiet contemplation and shock.

Like the rest of the series, Scrubs' pilot is a striking mix of hysterical weirdness and tragedy, and the way in which it introduces so many characters, establishes their relationships and reminds audiences the story isn't all sunshine and rainbows is seriously impressive considering it's only twenty minutes long.

12. Space Pilot 3000 - Futurama

What if you were cryogenically frozen and woke up a thousand years in the future? That's the premise for Futurama, which follows directionless pizza delivery boy Philip J. Fry as he wakes up in a world unlike his own, befriends a suicidal robot and slowly comes to terms with his place in the world.

Advertisement

From the mind of The Simpsons creator Matt Groening, Futurama's pilot makes the most of its futuristic setting whilst it tells Fry's hilarious story, incorporating sharp social satire with awkward and downright bonkers characters and dialogue to paint a vivid portrait of the show's expansive, unpredictable setting.

As a show, Futurama had its ups and downs, but there's no denying it knew what it was aiming for from day one. The jokes fly at rapid pace, Fry, Bender and Leela instantly feel true and compelling, and everything about the story comes together beautifully with them.

11. Days Gone By - The Walking Dead

Adapting Robert Kirkman's spotless comic series to the small screen was always going to be a difficult task, but filmmaker Frank Darabont made it look easy when he directed Days Gone Bye back in 2010. Not only did it set of the stage for the next ten seasons (and its various spin-offs), but it's still one of the show's best episodes.

Advertisement

The story is simple, following Rick Grimes as he wakes from a coma to find that the world has ended and the dead have risen. Desperately searching for his family, he's forced to adapt to a life he could never have foreseen, whilst attempting to stay away from the dangers of the undead in his path.

Opening with the shocking death of a zombified child and highlighting the horrors of the new world with gritty violence and spectacular practical effects, Days Gone Bye sports two formidable performances courtesy of Andrew Lincoln and Lennie James, and begins Rick's journey without fault.

10. Pilot - Homeland

After being rescued from an al-Qaeda compound, long-missing marine Nicholas Brody is returned home to his family, but his miraculous survival puts him in the crosshairs of determined CIA officer Carrie Mathison, who believes Brody has been turned into a sleeper agent for the infamous terror organisation.

Advertisement

Homeland spent its entire run thriving under the complexities of its character-driven mystery, and its pilot episode sets up every dramatic twist still to come, whether its Carrie's struggles with bipolar disorder, Brody's supressed memories, or the constant unpredictability of whose side he's truly on.

With a daring script from creators Howard Gordon and Alex Gansa and arresting performances from Claire Danes and Damian Lewis, the pilot is an arresting and constantly shocking journey into a world of international espionage and secrets, and one that makes sure never to give away too much, with fantastic results.

9. 1:23:45 - Chernobyl

HBO's phenomenal miniseries detailing one of history's greatest disasters, Chernobyl holds nothing back in its first episode, taking audiences inside the titular power plant on the day it was destroyed and recounting the lead-up to its tragic demise with both harrowing and engrossing testimony.

Advertisement

Beginning with a shocking suicide before taking a deep dive into the origins of the disaster, 1:23:45 goes step-by-step in explaining what happened in Chernobyl on that fateful day in 1986, and how it was allowed to get so out of hand. The results make for a frustrating and enrapturing viewing experience.

Whether it's digging into the flaws of chief engineer Anatoly Dyatlov (played by the late, great Paul Ritter) or detailing the heroics of those doomed by the explosion, the intensity, visual beauty and unrelenting horror of the episode makes it a viewing experience you're not likely to forget.

8. City Of - Angel

After leaving Sunnydale at the end of Buffy the Vampire Slayer's third season, Angel relocated to Los Angeles to front his own show and escape his past. In City Of, he comes into contact with a demon, Doyle, who can occasionally see the future, and reconnects with fellow Sunnydale alum Cordelia Chase.

Advertisement

Sporting a much grittier tone than Buffy, the spin-off starts by brilliantly separating itself from the image of what came before, focussing not on romantic teen drama but the hard-hitting realities of the supernatural. It's like Buffy, only darker, moodier, and the bad guys are a law firm.

With great new characters and the odd but welcome pairing of Angel and Cordelia, City Of is one of the finest episodes of the series, as well as a perfect testament to the worldbuilding and character-driven melodrama of the franchise. From the first scene, Angel proved it could be just as good - if not better - than its predecessor.

7. Pilot - Breaking Bad

Breaking Bad opens at full speed, with Walter White crashing his RV in a ditch before leaving a pitiful message to his family about how he's not a bad guy and everything he did was for them. He then stands in the road with a pistol and no pants, ready to accept whatever his fate may be.

Advertisement

As far as narrative hooks go, Vince Gilligan's crime drama probably has the best ever put to the small screen, as Walt's story then double backs on itself to reveal how this mild-mannered and intelligent family man ended up in such a strange and precarious situation.

Moving with relentless energy through Walt's family life, his cancer diagnosis, his decision to cook meth with former student Jesse Pinkman and his daring attempt to escape the clutches of two violent drug dealers, Breaking Bad's pilot is perfectly performed, paced and surprising, and starts Walt and Jesse's stories flawlessly.

6. The Sopranos - The Sopranos

The Sopranos might just be the best TV show of all time, and it's place as an all-time classic was solidified long before its divisive (but brilliant) finale. In fact, it was clear the series was something special right from the very first episode, which introduces mob boss Tony Soprano in both violent and moving fashion.

Advertisement

Whilst the episode makes it clear Tony is a dangerous and violent man, it spends most of its run emphasising the fact that he's also stressed, worried, and suffering from panic attacks because of his work, so much so that he's starting attending therapy.

It's a stunning hour of character development that uses Tony's predicament to introduce audiences to his family, loyal acquaintances, enemies and scheming mother, all of which is boosted to greatness by James Gandolfini's unflinchingly honest performance and David Chase's sublime direction.

5. Give Me A Ring Sometime - Cheers

Written by creators Glen and Les Charles, Give Me a Ring Sometime serves as the perfect opening to a show about people in a bar, fumbling through life and falling in and out of love. It introduces all the main characters like they're old friends to the audience, and brings them together in a sweet, funny and low-key mini-adventure.

Advertisement

The main focus of the episode is Diane Chambers, who gets left by her husband and is offered a job - somewhat out of pity - by bar owner Sam Malone. The build-up to her accepting the job and losing everything of importance in her life is the drive of the pilot, and its comic engine.

Brought to life by a whole host of perfectly cast stars, including Ted Danson as Sam, Shelley Long as Diane, and Rhea Perlman as waitress Carla Tortelli, Give Me a Ring Sometime is surely one of the best sitcom openers ever written, and one that gets more enjoyable with every re-watch.

4. Winter Is Coming - Game Of Thrones

Though it came to a seriously underwhelming end in 2019, Game of Thrones spent much of its run being rightly lauded as one of the best things on TV, a trend that was started with its epic, awe-inspiring pilot, Winter is Coming, as directed by TV legend Tim Van Patten.

Advertisement

Instantly leaning into the sweeping fantasy lore of its source material, the episode follows Sean Bean's weathered and apprehensive lord Ned Stark as he attempts to find his footing in Westeros' rapidly changing political landscape whilst balancing his commitment to his family.

Introducing countless prominent characters and giving everyone a chance to shine, Winter is Coming sets the grim tone for the wars to come, countering Ned's tale with the Targaryen family's thirst for vengeance and the Lannister's horrifying secrets. It's tense, beautiful and harsh, and it starts the series on a high it rarely surpassed.

3. Pilot - Lost

Lost's two-part pilot signalled the beginning of one of the most daring, enraging and intensely watchable TV shows ever made, by plunging audiences head-first into the wake of plane crash that's left its passengers stranded on a mysterious island with secrets to spare.

Advertisement

Directed by the great J. J. Abrams in his second appearance on this list, the episode portrays the dread, uncertainty and horror of the survivors' predicament with harsh, palpable intensity, and juggles the complexities and mysteries of its characters with both confident and relentless energy.

Certainly one of the most engaging and influential modern TV pilots you're likely to see, the rest of the show may have periodically failed to live up to what it promised, but that doesn't mean that Lost's first episode should be overlooked. As far as TV episodes go, it's a masterpiece.

2. It's Summer And We're Running Out Of Ice - Watchmen

It's Summer and We're Running Out of Ice would make this list for its first scene alone, which kicks things off with a visceral portrayal of the Tulsa Race Massacre and its effects on those who survived. Luckily, Watchmen's pilot actually manages to be much more than its opening, in more ways than one.

Advertisement

At once a stunning assessment of race, law, history and identity in America, the episode makes it clear that whilst the show is a thrilling superhero story based on Alan Moore's classic comic book, it's also a timely look at the world we live in, and the horrors we still have to face.

With gorgeous special effects, brutal violence, confrontational drama and a rousing performance courtesy of star Regina King, It's Summer and We're Running Out of Ice holds nothing back, and says what it has to say without feeling melodramatic. From here, the miniseries only got bigger and better.

1. Northwest Passage - Twin Peaks

Who killed Laura Palmer?

Advertisement

From the moment her body was found by poor old Pete Martell - "dead, wrapped in plastic" - Laura's life and death dominated the central mysteries of David Lynch and Mark Frost's surreal crime drama, and came to effect everyone in town in strange and harrowing ways.

Called in to investigate Laura's murder, FBI Special Agent Dale Cooper is introduced to Twin Peaks' eccentric locals whilst he tries to find the clues needed to solve the case. The characters are what make the episode great, each of them more bizarre and compelling than the last, all of them brilliantly written and expertly performed.

Twin Peaks is a bewildering viewing experience, and Northwest Passage, with its uncertain mystery, strange characters and dreamlike execution is no exception. It's utterly captivating from the off, and makes for a perfect start to one of TV's most unique and influential shows.

Advertisement