24: Legacy Season 1 Review - 4 Ups & 6 Downs
No Jack Bauer? No sale.
24: Legacy has just finished up its 12-episode run, so what better time for a post-mortem? It's fair to say that fans and critics alike have been rather divided on the show's Jack Bauer-less return to screens, and with good reason, considering how so much of Legacy's run felt like a pale imitation of the classic original.
It absolutely picked up later on and delivered a few genuinely solid episodes for sure, but fans who've stuck with the show since the beginning may feel their patience running out, especially given the generally uneven quality of the last few seasons.
If 24: Legacy does indeed return for a second season, there are clearly a lot of wrinkles to iron out, but it's not completely beyond redemption either.
Downs...
6. Tony's Appearance Was A Missed Opportunity
One of 24: Legacy's most alluring prospects was the return of series legend Tony Almeida (Carlos Bernard), making him the only original character to appear throughout this entire season.
Unfortunately, though, Tony doesn't show up until the seventh episode and is given very little of interest to do after that, basically working as a generic rent-a-thug who follows the money and little else.
This doesn't feel much like the Tony fans know and love, and little effort has been made to further develop him as a person. And worst of all, just when the series looks like it's going to make good on an epic Eric-Tony teamup, Tony awkwardly slinks away with a broken arm in the season finale, leaving Eric to finish up by himself.
What, honestly, was the point of bringing a fan favourite character back for such a lame, near-pointless bit part? Nothing this season was more disappointing than Tony's damp squib of a role.
5. That Atrocious High School Terrorist Subplot
In fairness, even classic 24 is no stranger to its share of wonky subplots (Kim and the cougar, anyone?), but Legacy came right out of the gate with one of the series' all-time worst narratives, as high school student Amira (Kathryn Prescott) and her loved-up teacher David (Kevin Christy) planned to launch a terrorist attack in the early episodes.
It was an hilariously bad aside that never proved remotely plausible (even for the standards of 24), and by the time it ended in a bloodbath for basically everyone involved, it felt like a considerable mercy that this eye-rolling plot had been put to bed.
Only when Amira finally detonated her bomb on the George Washington Bridge did it get remotely interesting, but of course, 24 has done similar things many times before, so the impact was distinctly lessened.
4. Too Many Villains
This has been a common 24 complaint for years, and the over-abundance of baddies is decidedly exacerbated in this 12-episode mini-season.
The season's three big villains are Jadalla bin-Khalid (Raphael Acloque), his father Sheikh Ibrahim bin-Khalid (Eli Danker) and Asim Naseri (Oded Fehr), not to mention supporting slimeballs Henry Donovan (Gerald McRaney), Luis Diaz (Daniel Zacapa) and Donald Simms (James Moses Black).
It's just way, way too much, especially considering that the three main villains are relatively uninteresting, and more effort should've been put into fashioning one single, truly terrifying and compelling antagonist.
Instead the bad guys were mostly pretty anonymous this season, and only McRaney's ferociously determined oil man made much of a dent.
3. Mariana Stiles Was A Totally Wasted Character
One of the weirdest things about the entire season was the curiously sidelined nature of computer analyst Mariana Stiles (Coral Peña), who did almost nothing memorable the entire season and simply helped direct traffic in CTU.
Considering that she was introduced as Edgar Stiles' cousin, one expected she might turn out to be a far more significant player, but ultimately her role could've easily been combined into the character of fellow analyst Andy Shalowitz (Dan Bucatinsky).
The only reason her character really exists is to give the show another pretty, young face, and it's a damn shame she wasn't allowed to show much personality throughout the 12 episodes.
2. All The Lame Soap Opera Romance
Soap opera melodrama is no stranger to 24, but it reached an exhausting fever pitch this season. From the weird and creepy love triangle between Eric (Corey Hawkins), his wife Nicole (Anna Diop) and Eric's brother Isaac (Ashley Thomas) to Tony's needless romantic past with Rebecca (Miranda Otto) and his new lover Sidra's (Moran Atias) clear jealously, it was all eye-rollingly awful.
Sure, 24 needs some lighter subplots to pad things out between all the action and suspense, but when little effort has been made to actually make the audience care about these characters, doubling down on the terrible romance seems thoroughly misguided.
Contrary to what studio executives believe, most people don't need to sit through cringe-worthy romantic squabbling to get invested in human struggle.
1. The Massively Underwhelming Finale
Even those who struggled to make their way through the season at least hoped Legacy would serve up a suitably bonkers finale, because 24 has always been great at climaxes, right?
Well, not this time. Legacy's final episode was a giant, thudding anti-climax for the most part. There's no big twist here and no Jack Bauer cameo, but rather a ham-fisted 12-hour time-jump in the final moments and an absolute whimper of a final scene.
Plus, with a clear desire to be self-contained, there's little set-up for future seasons, even though numerous plot threads and missing characters have been just forgotten about, which is all the more frustrating as the ratings suggest Legacy may not be renewed for another go-around.
Simply, this is by far the weakest finale of any of the ten seasons to date.
As disappointing as Legacy largely was, though, it wasn't without some merits worth recognising...
Ups...
4. Corey Hawkins' Charismatic Lead Performance
The idea of a Jack Bauer-less season of 24 rubbed a lot of fans the wrong way, and rightly so, but at least Corey Hawkins gave a commendable lead performance under the circumstances.
The on-the-rise Straight Outta Compton star was put in a difficult position and did his best to give a multi-faceted portrayal, even when the script immersed him in bland melodrama or basically just made him feel like a photocopy of Bauer.
Hawkins did as well as could be expected, and if a second season does in fact get the green light, then hopefully Eric Carter might get a little more fleshed-out and harness some of the savage bada**ery that made Kiefer Sutherland's Bauer so ridiculously thrilling to watch.
3. It Totally Feels Like 24
Commendably, Legacy does completely capture the style, feel and tone of the original 24 show, albeit both for better and worse.
The cheesy subplots, anonymously-directed action, ridiculously elaborate CTU sets, political intrigue, sneaky moles, and insane against-the-odds heroism are all pure 24 formula, and though that template can feel quite stale some 15 years after the show first debuted, it can still sit alongside the original Bauer run well enough.
Neither attempting a potentially off-putting reinvention of the series nor clinging too eagerly to nostalgia, Legacy looks and feels like the series never left our screens, even if it might ultimately have you returning to earlier seasons for more consistent thrills.
2. The Solid Supporting Cast
Say what you will about the narrative, but at least Legacy gathered an impressive supporting cast of players.
The easy stand-outs here are Miranda Otto as former CTU head Rebecca Ingram, a strong woman with impressive ambiguity and depth, Jimmy Smits as her very David Palmer-like husband, Senator John Donovan, and Dan Bucatinsky as CTU analyst Andy Shalowitz, who starts off a goofball but quickly becomes one of the show's most likeable characters.
The performances are uniformly solid even when the material is straining interest and/or credibility, so if it does get renewed for another go-around, at least there's a firm foundation of talent to work from.
1. The Big Character Death Has Real Impact
And finally, when Legacy finally decides to go big, it actually works. The season finale has one pivotal character death that actually delivers the desired impact, resulting in the only real moment from the finale that's really much interesting.
It comes with a well-executed subversion of the typical silent clock reserved for iconic deaths, and while it won't stand tall among, say, the demises of Ryan Chappelle and Edgar Stiles from earlier seasons, the death scene is about as close as Legacy ever got to recapturing the terrifically engrossing drama of the Jack Bauer years.
What did you think of 24: Legacy? Shout it out in the comments!