4 Best Comedy Central Roasters (And 1 That Sucked)

By Edan Nissen /

In 1998, Comedy Central began airing the annual roast from the New York Friars Club, and after 5 years Comedy Central launched its own celebrity roasts. Over the annual roast, Comedy Central has produced the roasts of several celebrities including Hugh Hefner, Pamela Anderson, Donald Trump, Charlie Sheen, David Hasselhoff and James Franco. The intention is for celebrities and comics alike to get together and make fun of each other for the entertainment of those watching. While some consider the tradition of roasting mean spirited and nasty, it's also a great exercise at not letting the egos of celebrities to get too big, and making sure they have their feet on the ground. While the tradition of Comedy Roasts has been going on since the 1920's, where the tradition of roasting honoured members at the New York Friar's Club and was eventually brought to mainstream public attention in the 1970's thanks to a series of televised roasts hosted by Dean Martin. However, it wasn't until the New York roasts were picked up by Comedy Central did the audiences start to boom, reaching a peak in 2011 when 6.4 million people tuned in to watch Charlie Sheen roasted. Of course, this popularity was influenced by Sheen's very public drug addiction, rehabilitation attempts and recent departure from the show he headlined €“ Two and A Half Men €“ after publicly falling out with the producer Chuck Lorre. The most recent roast of James Franco was an incredible ensemble of Judd Apatow's pet projects, Freaks and Geeks graduates and other stand up comedians. Amongst the those at the dais was roast regular and top shelf roaster (mainly because he is starting to look more and more like the sun) Jeff Ross, as well as members of the "Apatow Crew" in Seth Rogan and Jonah Hill, the SNL crew in Bill Hader and Andy Samberg, with the stand up prowess of Aziz Ansari, Nick Kroll, Sarah Silverman and Natasha Leggero adding their mix to the roast. It was the first real event without the presence of Comedy Central's "Celebrity", which has been used in previous years to varying success. While rap superstar Snoop Dog was the best, The Situation was just awful, as his jokes failed during his performance at the roast of Donald Trump.

Honourable Mentions - Greg Giraldo and Patrice O'Neal

The Comedy Central Roast hasn't been without both drama and losses in the family. In Greg Giraldo and Patrice O'Neal they ahd two incredibly talented comedians, but unfortunately for the world both men where cut down far too early in their lives. Greg Giraldo was one of the roast specialists, meaning that outside of the annual roast he was pretty much unemployed. Along with Lisa Lampinelli, Jeff Ross and Gilbert Godfried, Giraldo was a regular member of the dais for the Comedy Central Roasts, involved in 8 roasts from the roast of Jeff Foxworthy to David Hasselhoff. Unfortunately, Giraldo's life was cut short due to a drug overdose. Giraldo's battles with his drug addiction had been well-publicised and had gotten in the way of his career on more than one occasion. On the other hand, Patrice O'Neal had two appearances at the Comedy Central Roasts, the first roasting Jeff Foxworthy in 2005 and the second with Charlie Sheen in 2011. O'Neal's performance, and ability to take hits about his weight and diabetes, was noted by many of the other roasters after the performance. Patrice's routine was praised by critics as an honest but hilarious assessment of his fellow roasters comments but also about the roast concept as a whole. Not long after the 2011 roast of Charlie Sheen, O'Neal passed away due to complications from a stroke he had suffered. Still, back to the article at hand, this is looking to identify the 4 best roasters that have ever graced our screens on the Comedy Central Annual Roast, and 1 that bombed.

4. Seth MacFarlane

Technically MacFarlane shouldn't be on this list as he was never specifically a Roaster, but was invited to be the Roast Master General on 3 separate occasions, which means that I'll give him a free pass this time. Seth is best known for being the creative talent behind Family Guy, as well as large roles in the production of American Dad and Family Guy's spin-off the Cleveland Show. MacFarlane was the Roast Master of the David Hasselhoff, Donald Trump and the Charlie Sheen Roasts in succession. MacFarlane played the role of the Roastmaster to a tee, insulting all comers with his tenacious zingy wit that was apparent in all of his work. MacFarlane uses a mixture of both clean and dirty jokes to insult the various daises (according to Wiktionary this is the plural of dais), while for most of MacFarlane's jokes on lesser known comedians are regularly about how no one knows who they are, BestJoke Introducing Former Heavyweight Champion Mike Tyson €“ "Tyson has beaten every opponent he has gone up against, apart from the letter S."

3. Norm MacDonald

In the 2008 Roast of Bob Saget, of Full House fame, the Dais was once again filled with genuine funny people ready to make the audience laugh at the expense of not only Bob Saget but also his former Full House co-starsJohn Stamos and the Olsen twins. The standard was to try and make the funniest jokes possible, so people would laugh as much as possible. Norm MacDonald would go on to do one of the most infamous, and innovative routines that would ever be seen on a roasting stage. MacDonald bucked the trend of the increasingly disturbing and offensive material that was being used in Comedy Roasts and delivered a routine of anti-comedy jokes. These jokes were straight out of the 1001 joke books and were delivered with MacDonald's ever deadpan expression and voice. MacDonald's routine would go on to become a viral sensation in the fallout from the roast and is possibly the single most identifiable roast routine that has been seen. In the 2013 Comedy Central Roast of James Franco, SNL comedian Andy Samberg tried a routine similar to that of MacDonald, but didn't quiet have the same effect as MacDonald's routine. Samberg attempted to deliver a "kind roast" making jokes at his own expense rather than at the expense of the roast subject or fellow roasters. Best Joke On Cloris Leachman €“ "If people say you're over the hill, don't believe them. You'll never be over the hill, not in the car you drive."

2. Lisa Lampanelli

The queen of mean herself, Lisa Lampinelli, was a member of several Daises and was the Roast master in the 2009 Roast of Larry the Cable Guy. Lisa was the first female to be the Roast Master and, after Jeff Ross and Greg Giraldo, is the most common roaster at the Comedy Central Roasts. Lampinelli got her first big break at the Comedy Central's 2002 Roast of Comedy Central and had since appeared in 7 different roasts, including the Roast in which she was selected to be the Roast Master. Lampinelli is one of the foremost insult comedians in the game, and pulls no punches in a Sarah Silverman style routine. Lampinelli uses a mixture of insults, compliments and self-deprecation to have audiences members laughing out loud and rolling in the aisles, even if the subject matter is slightly shocking. Lampinelli uses a very sexualised humour as well, often making jokes about gender and sexuality. Best Jokes - On Mike "The Situation" Sorrentino and his book "I tried ordering your book on Amazon dot com. Amazon said 'Customers who bought this book also bought rope and a stool'."

1. Jeff Ross

The Roast Master General himself, Jeff Ross is the youngest person to ever hold the position as head of the Friar's Club, a position usually reserved for geriatric comedians who are almost at their expiration date. Jeff Ross has been a roaster in almost every single Comedy Central Roast and has not missed a roast since the Comedy Central roasted Pamela Anderson in 2005. In more recent Roasts, Ross has taken more and more to donning various costumes, from dressing up as former Libyan dictator Muammar Qaddafi at the roast of Charlie Sheen to donning corn rows to resemble James Franco's character in the "Spring Break" movie at the roast of James Franco. Ross is an exceptionally funny insult comedian, using several different jokes to take his targets down several notches. Jeff's routine is a mix of very insulting comments, self-deprecation and €“ very occasionally €“ racial humour. Jeff has often made light of his own "Jewishness" and the Jewishness of his roasters or targets when appropriate. He also has impeccable timing with his jokes, and has also been able to ad-lib many insults and has the ability to come up with quick disarming retorts that can disarm comedians. Best Jokes - On Donald Trumps assertion that he would run for President €“ "Personally, I hope you win because I can't wait for the assassination... I mean inauguration." On Jon Lovitz €“ "Jon Lovitz signed up to match dot com and was paired with a couch and a bottle hand lotion. Thats a 3-way for him." On Charlie Sheen €“ "Charlie's nostrils are so snotty and full of coke he calls them the Hilton sisters." And now 1 worst performance at the Comedy Central Roast was without a doubt the attempt at roast by none other than...

1. Mike "The Situation" Sorrentino

Jersey Shore's Mike "The Situation" Sorrentino, was a memorable guest of the Donald Trump roast for all the wrong reasons. The Situation was at the butt of several hilarious jokes from the other roasters on the night, including a gem from Roast Master Seth MacFarlane saying that he had been asked by the producer that he needed to explain a joke to the handicapped member on the dais €“ which included deaf Academy Award winning actress Marlee Matlin €“ "rich guy have funny hair." While comedian after comedian nailed The Situation with jokes about various topics, such as his stupidity and claiming that he has a homosexual relationship with fellow member of the Jersey Shore Pauly D. However, the "Situation" really hit the fan when the Reality TV star stepped to the microphone to deliver his speech. He certainly didn't start well €“ "Sitch" made a blunder within seconds of reaching the mic, accidentally calling Roast master Seth MacFarlane "Jeff", possibly confusing him with fellow roasted Jeff Ross. His roast didn't get much better from there, as he constantly mispronounced "Trump" as "Chump". It slowly denigrated further and further as the speech progressed, with even the incredibly friendly audience turning against him by the end, booing several jokes and remaining silent in response to others. Worst Joke - About Donald Trumps wife at the time Melania Trump €“ "The best part is she married you for love. Yep, she loves money" (The joke actually received several loud boos)