4 Sci-Fi Franchises That Need To Be Rebooted

By Xavier Santana /

"Reboot" seems to be a dirty word among media fans of all stripes and for good reasons. Plenty of them have either started off well and fallen apart or just been terrible from the beginning. But for some franchises, a reboot is a way to clean the slate and take advantage of squandered potential. In general, science fiction franchises have a higher chance of benefiting from a reboot than other properties, thanks to modern production techniques making it easier to create high quality special effects on a TV budget. Not only that, but genre fiction has benefited from the entertainment industry being a bit more willing to experiment with ideas in order to find the next big thing (as long as it's not too expensive). So here are four franchises that could benefit from a reboot.

4. seaQuest DSV/2032

Back in the early 1990s, someone had the idea to make a series about submarine patrolling the oceans of the near future, keeping pirates from raiding colonies and keeping aggressive nations in check in a post-World War III world. Then, if the stories are to be believed, Steven Spielberg became a producer, chucked the military angle for 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea in the future, and got the show on NBC. After the ratings came in for the first season, NBC began making changes to cut costs and add more action, which involved moving the show's sets and cast to Florida and forcing aliens, mythological gods, and other bad scifi ideas into the show. With ratings tanking, NBC gave seaQuest one last shot, casting Michael Ironside as the new lead and focusing on a military storyline involving a cold war. While this was a massive improvement, NBC was determined to write the show off and often preempted it for sports, which further screwed with its ratings and gave the executives the excuse to cancel it. So why reboot it now? Contemporary and near future science fiction is in a strong position right now, thanks to the fact that you don't need to spend as much money on making locations look futuristic. seaQuest's near future setting (originally 2018, which obviously has to be adjusted unless they go the alternate history route) grants them that ability, while also giving them the ability to come up with cool sci-fi tech to give the action component some extra pizzaz compared to thousands of gun fights we see on TV these days. Then there's the novelty factor €“ a properly executed military sci-fi show centered on a submarine will standout, even as a reboot. As long as the writing's more competent and coherent than Last Resort's, there's a good chance people will be hooked.

3. Andromeda

Andromeda was a troubled show from the beginning. Conceived from a mishmash of notes from Gene Roddenberry and produced by a meddlesome production company at the tail end of the '80s €“ '00s syndication renaissance, it never had an uphill struggle to be competent, never mind good. However, it had former Star Trek: Deep Space 9 writer Robert Hewitt Wolfe as a head writer, who managed to get strong corps of writers on the show and create a fairly in-depth universe bible. Unfortunately, star and co-producer Kevin Sorbo managed to get Wolfe off the show partway through the second season, which led to an insane decline in quality. Eventually the fifth season of the show, produced primarily to hit the ideal 100 episodes for syndication, had to eschew the title ship for a good chunk of episodes to save money. After a lackluster finale, the show passed into the annals of mediocre and forgotten scifi shows from that era. The main problem with Andromeda was that kicking Wolfe off the show also took the show's premise with it €“ Andromeda's quest to rebuild the government that collapsed while the ship and her captain were trapped near the event horizon of a black hole. With Sorbo at the helm, Andromeda wound up being the equivalent of Star Trek V €“ a love letter to Sorbo's character Dylan Hunt (who was pretty much a low rent Kirk clone in those final seasons) - and a generic Trek clone to anyone who discovered it after Wolfe's final episodes aired. Figuring out how to reboot Andromeda is a bit difficult, because on one hand, there's a ton of untapped background universe information out there that wouldn't necessarily lend itself well to a TV show, but might work in a video game. On the other, the Andromeda premise works best if you closely follow the crew trying to rebuild a fallen society. One way to solve the problem might be to reboot Andromeda as a TV/game hybrid like Defiance, with a Star Trek Online like MMO handling the in-depth exploration of the universe, while the TV show focuses on the overarching plot and occasionally references plots and characters from the game.

2. Stargate

Dean Devlin and Roland Emmerich initially conceived Stargate as a mashup of Lawrence of Arabia and Chariots of the Gods (which said aliens helped the Egyptians build the pyramids). Eventually MGM got the rights from Devlin and took Stargate to TV, where it lasted for about 13 years (chronologically) before the latest iteration of the franchise, Stargate Universe, was cancelled after 1.5 seasons of dreck and half a season of decent to good stories. What started as the story of Earth being underdogs in a secret war against aliens posing as gods ended with Earth being top dog in three galaxies within a decade and the general population still being ignorant of that fact, despite two huge space battles in Earth orbit. The problem with Stargate was that most of it was made up as they went along and interstellar politics was ignored unless it could provide a convenient and easily solved problem. As time went on, both Earth and the villains had to keep growing stronger to keep things balanced, which was achieved by upping the technology available to both sides and forcing the writers to rely on deus ex machinas to defeat the bad guys. At the same time, Earth was never allowed rally its allies and form a faction capable of defeating those enemies through force of arms or reveal the stargate, because that would make the show "unrelatable" in the minds of the writers. Rebooting Stargate isn't that tough. Keeping the Goa'uld, the franchise's initial villains, and their mythological focus is a no brainer, but dividing them into factions based on Earth mythologies gives them more longevity and helps mitigate rapid power escalation by keeping the bad guys busy with each other. Having Earth build spaceships and fighters on other planets avoids the ridiculousness of keeping the Stargate a secret when hundreds of thousands of people are involved in constructing ships that are larger than aircraft carriers and reverse engineering all sorts of alien technology, especially in an age of hackers and leakers spilling secrets all over the place. The main thing is that the right tone needs to be set €“ something too dark and serious will keep people away, while making it too humorous and lighthearted makes it a caricature that no one will treat with respect.

1. Robotech

Back in the 1980s, a man named Carl Macek wanted to bring a Japanese show called Super Dimension Fortress Macross to America. After a few failed attempts to sell the show on VHS, he and Harmony Gold, one of numerous corporations getting in on the animation boom at the time, decided to get Macross on syndicated TV. But the rules at the time forced Macek to combine Macross with two other shows, Super Dimension Calvary Southern Cross, and Genesis Climber MOSPEADA, whose only similarities were alien invasions and giant transforming mechs. Despite having a production cycle of about 9 months and a large crew of writers, Robotech turned out to be a mostly coherent and well executed product for its time. Kids and teens liked the epic sci-fi storyline involving three separate alien invasions of Earth that didn't shy away from showing death, like other shows from that era, giving the show a large fanbase that still lives to this day. And while Macross has spawned its own franchise in Japan, there's little argument that Robotech is the more accessible version for western viewers, as its more military scifi presentation jives better with mass audience tastes than Macross's heavy focus on pop music, romance, and mysticism outside of the original Macross and one spinoff (Macross Plus). Rebooting Robotech is mostly a matter of practicality. The animation used in the source material is horribly dated, especially Macross (the first part of Robotech and a show that suffered budget problems in its initial release). In addition, a lot of the writing comes across as stilted and stiff, with a perpetual narration that leaves little to the imagination. And then there's the bizarre rights issues surrounding Macross, which are best summarized here. The main obstacle to rebooting Robotech is Harmony Gold. Due to its investments in real estate, Harmony Gold doesn't really have an incentive to do anything with Robotech beyond re-releasing DVDs, licensing comics, and occasionally producing a new Robotech cartoon or game. And due to the rights issues, a live action movie is totally impractical, because of the international rights issues €“ a death knell in an era when international revenue makes up a huge chunk of a film's profits. Unless Harmony Gold resolves the issues with Japan or someone buys the IP from them and settles the legal dispute, Robotech is trapped in limbo, unable to move forward or restart. And for the people who love Robotech and want to bring it back, that's one bitter pill to swallow. Got any other suggestions for scifi franchises that should be rebooted? Feel free to drop them in the comments below.