With last month's Curtain, ITV and actor David Suchet concluded a mammoth 14 year undertaking in which they adapted every single story and novel featuring Agatha Christie's famous Belgian detective Hercule Poirot. While the recent cancellations of Whitechapel and Ripper Street show how short the lifespan even of a generally well regarded crime drama can be, Poirot has simply carried on. Its conclusion now leaves something of a gap in the market. Its labelling as "cosy crime" and the kind of advertising and sponsorship ITV gives it suggests an audience firmly in the stair lifts, bladder weakness and life insurance brigade, but this is doing the quality of classic mystery writing a disservice. The great detectives from the Golden Age of Mystery Writing between the wars are the products of truly entertaining and creative writers and have the potential to engage a much wider audience than the unpleasant conservatism of the likes of self proclaimed "last bastion of Englishness" Midsomer Murders. While the source novels of the latter emerged from the Thatcherite 80s, Christie's Poirot enjoyed success making an asylum seeker into a beloved hero. This list counts down some of the great detectives of the Golden Age that are perhaps a but less familiar on screen in the hope that one of them could be the next enduring TV crime classic. SPOILERS: Obviously this article is about mystery stories, so there's going to be spoilers for classic novels from around 80 years ago.
5. Roger Sheringham
Created by: Writer and reviewer Anthony Berkeley Cox initially anonymously and then under one of his less imaginative pseudonyms: Anthony Berkeley. He also wrote classic "inverted detective story" from the murderer's perspective Malice Aforethought under the name Francis Iles and was published as A. Monmouth Platt. Berkeley founded the Detection Club with other popular mystery writers including Christie, Dorothy L. Sayers and G.K. Chesterton. He wrote ten Sheringham novels from 1925's Layton Court Mystery to 1934's Panic Party. What's his appeal?: On occasion every bit as confrontational and abrasive as Sherlock Holmes, reporter and amateur investigator Sheringham distinguishes himself by not being right nearly so often. Although he writes with a light touch, Berkely is interested in a certain amount of psychological plausibility in both the cases and their solutions. As a result Sheringham is quite capable of failure, often providing a very reasonable solution only for a final twist to prove him wrong. It's this fallibility that is likely to appeal to a modern TV audience who'd rather their heroes weren't perfect and constantly successful. Sidekicks and supporting cast: Many of Sheringham's cases see him investigating the same crimes as police Inspector Moresby. While presented as something of an everyman, Moresby is equally far from the Lestrade archetype of a professional policeman well behind the interested amateur. He is a capable mystery solver and his relationship with Sheringham is more one of friendly rivalry than one being inherently superior to the other. There always seems a genuine possibility that Moresby may solve the case before Sheringham does, something that would keep TV audiences used to the sidekick as sounding board on their toes. Any on screen previous?: Short story The Avenging Chance was adapted as part of 60s mystery anthology series Detective with Hammer horror star John Carson as Sheringham. Trial and Error, which does not feature Sheringham but does share characters with his novels and so can be perceived as occuring in the same "world", was filmed as Flight from Destiny in 1941, the same year as one of Berkeley's Francis Iles novels Before the Fact was adapted far more successfully as the Hitchcock-Cary Grant picture Suspicion. There is plenty of unrealised potential, then, in a screen version if Sheringham. If they only made one: The Poisoned Chocolates Case features the Crimes Circle, a group of armchair detectives including Sheringham that are clearly a lightly fictionalised version of Berkeley's own Detection Club. Each character offers their own solution to a case that has recently baffled Scotland Yard and this Rashomon-like structure and illumination of different methods of investigation and deduction is as likely to feel novel and modern to a TV audience used to the formula of the genre as it did to its original readers in 1929. In one further almost post-modern twist, the set-up and Sheringham's proposed solution is the same as the aforementioned Avenging Chance. The correct solution, however, surprisingly is put forward by the most meek and mild of the whole group.
4. Gervase Fen
Created by: Composer Robert Bruce Montgomery (he wrote the scores for the early Carry On films) under the nom de plume Edmund Crispin. Crispin wrote nine novels and two short story collections about Oxford don and amateur sleuth Gervase Fen from The Case of the Gilded Fly in 1944 to the posthumously published Fen Country in 1979. He is probably the last great writer of classic mysteries. In his own author biography he described his favourite pastimes as including: "excessive smoking, idleness, and cats", while expressing a strong disliking for: "psychologically realistic crime stories and dogs". What's his appeal?: Doctor Who writer Gareth Roberts (one of his episodes was, naturally, the Agatha Christie one) described a Fen mystery as: "more like Doctor Who than Doctor Who". What this means is an egocentric eccentric dashing about all over the place, always seeming one step ahead of the audience even while narrating his thoughts as he makes them up. Unlike Berkeley, Crispin is uninterested in the psychologically plausible. His stories are created purely for the fun of it and are full of imaginative silliness and a fair bit of fourth wall breaking. It's this pace and sense of joy that would be great to see on screen. Sidekicks and supporting cast: There are not really any recurring assistants in Fen's world. Each story is essentially standalone, which might make adaptations easier. He's usually wading in to help a fellow academic or writer, though, and a new supporting cast of colourful characters tends to get swept along with his enthusiastic mystery solving in each story, not always in a fashion that's pleasing to them. Any on screen previous?: Aside from the Carry On films, Crispin's on screen legacy is almost identical to Berkeley's: an episode of the Detective anthology starring a Hammer regular and a loose Hitchcock adaptation. In the case of the former, Fen mystery The Moving Toyshop was the first episode in 1964 and featured Richard Wordsworth, who had had a bit part in The Quatermass Xperiment amongst other things, as the Oxford don. The Moving Toyshop's carousel based finale was also pinched for the climax of Hitchcock and Raymond Chandler's version of Patricia Highsmith's Strangers on a Train. The rest of the film, though, came from Highsmith so there was no Fen in it. If they only made one: There's a reason why The Moving Toyshop is the Fen story already to have some screen pedigree. It stands out as the most thoroughly entertaining Crispin novel and could definitely use another screen outing. The bizarre plot is delightfully bonkers as poet Richard Cadogan discovers a dead body one night in a toy shop, only to return the next morning with the police to find not only no dead body, but also that the shop is a grocer. It turns out it's all part of a murder scheme related to an old woman whose money has been left to strangers referred to only through limericks.
3. Alan Grant
Created by: Scottish novelist and playwright Elizabeth Mackintosh, who wrote the first novel featuring police inspector Alan Grant, The Man in the Queue, under the pseudonym Gordon Daviot while caring for her invalid father in 1929. Five more novels featuring Grant followed, this time written using the name by which all her works are now credited: Josephine Tey. The Singing Sands in 1952 was the final part. When Tey died that year her whole estate and royalties from her books were left to the National Trust, so they have a vested interest in getting some screen time for the beautiful landscapes and properties that they own. What's his appeal?: Not to be confused with the dinosaur guy, Inspector Alan Grant is the only character on this list who is an actual police detective. Keen on rational deductions and paying attention to seemingly trivial details, he is noted for his interest in never accepting received wisdom without adequately questioning it. Grant is, however, also peculiarly fond of the less scientific approach of reading people's personalities in their faces (and, on occasion, their handwriting), something that an adaptation to a visual medium could have fun with. Tey is one of the very best writers of the mystery novel's golden age when it comes to constructing a well thought out and consistently engaging narrative in which Grant plays the role of the Scotland Yard detective we'd all like to believe exists, rather than one that's too real. Sidekicks and supporting cast: Grant's stories feature a few recurring characters and this regular supporting cast is one of those things that always makes for more appealing episodic TV. Most notably Grant repeatedly relies on the assistance of Sergeant Williams to do his leg work and evidence gathering. A contented family man, Williams has no great ambitions beyond his current station but clearly hero-worships Grant. Stage actress Marta Hallard will usually make her presence felt at some point in the narrative, increasingly appearing to be Grant's only really close friend as the books go on. More than either Williams or Marta, though, Grant relies heavily on lengthy debates with himself, an ongoing inner dialogue that would be tough but interesting to realise onscreen. Any on screen previous?: The second Grant novel, A Shilling for Candles, was the basis for a Hitchcock film (see the pattern here?), in this case 1937's Young and Innocent. As tended to be the way with Hitch, the final film was a very loose version of Tey's novel. It focused on the classically Hitchcockian character of the wrong suspect on the run from the law and changed the central mystery. Thee murderer turns out to be a completely different character. Not only does the novel's murderer not appear in the film at all, neither does Grant himself. Tey's most adapted novel has been The Franchise Affair, a take on the real life fake kidnapping of Elizabeth Canning, which was filmed in 1951 and has been adapted for TV in the 60s and the 80s. Although Grant appears in the story it is only in a very small cameo and the screen adaptations reflect this. Once again then, Grant's only leading role has been in the 60s Detective show. In fact, in the 1969 episode that adapted The Singing Sands Grant was played by the same actor, John Carson, as had previously played Roger Sheringham. If they only made one: The penultimate Grant mystery, The Daughter of Time, was once voted the greatest mystery novel of all time by the Crime Writers' Association and remains one of the best loved classic mysteries to this day. It is also ripe for a TV adaptation by being curiously more topical now than at the time of writing, given that it's principal suspect was exhumed from a car park earlier this year. Yes, the main character in this unconventional murder investigation is the oft-demonised King Richard III who Grant, bedridden after an accident chasing a criminal, sets out to prove innocent of the murder of the Princes in the Tower after taking a shine to his portrait. This ultimate cold case investigation would strike a chord with the current penchant for archaeological forensic documentaries and its pro-Richard stance is bound to appeal to the surprisingly many admirers who have come out of the woodwork since his body's discovery.
2. Peter Wimsey
Created by: Oxford educated essayist, poet and translator Dorothy L. Sayers. Sayers considered her translation of Dante's Divine Comedy to be her finest work, but most readers are likely to profess a preference for the 11 novels and 5 short story collections starring aristocratic amateur sleuth Peter Wimsey. From 1923's Whose Body to Busman's Honeymoon in 1937, Sayers' mysteries are the most consciously intellectual and literary of the mystery novel's Golden Age and have made her second only to Christie as the best regarded of the Detection Club. Many of Wimsey's stories are rooted in Sayers' own experiences: from The Nine Tailors' bellringing to Gaudy Night's Oxford women's college. What's his appeal?: Lord Peter Death Bredon Wimsey is in some ways an archetypal upper class fop and in others a man of unreasonably extensive talents and intellectual brilliance: sort of two parts Hugh Laurie as Bertie Wooster to one part Hugh Laurie as the Holmesian Gregory House. Full of easygoing wit and charm and a very sharp mind, Wimsey verges on the overly idealised superman, essentially Sayers' ideal man. However, she is smart enough to give her brilliant hero equally deep scars and flaws. It becomes increasingly apparent that Wimsey's service as an officer and intelligence operative in the First World War have left him with an abiding case of post traumatic stress disorder. His flippancy is actually a method of keeping himself from forming any meaningful attachments. So, a genius level investigator with deep psychological issues: sounds like many of the most popular TV characters of recent years. Sidekicks and supporting cast: Wimsey's valet Mervyn Bunter is occasionally the Jeeves to his Wooster, with Sayers including a dash of class satire. More than a master-servant dynamic, however, Wimsey and Bunter share a far deeper bond forged in their disturbing war experience together. Perhaps better known, Harriet Vane is the other significant recurring role in the Wimsey books. An Oxford educated mystery writer, Vane is one of the most blatant author surrogates in literature. Her first appearance, in Strong Poison, has her falsely suspected of murdering her lover and Wimsey proving her innocence. Eventually Vane marries Sayers' hero and their honeymoon is the final story for both. The writing is, however, enjoyable enough that Vane never becomes an outright Mary Sue and the audience are able to engage with the relationship and be genuinely happy when Vane accepts Wimsey's proposal at the end of Gaudy Night. Any on screen previous?: Unlike the previous detectives on this list, TV audiences are likely to have a passing familiarity with Wimsey through a couple of previous TV adaptions. During the 1970s five Wimsey mysteries were filmed as a sequence of miniseries starring Ian Carmichael, previously best known for the role of Bertie Wooster and bringing some similar quality to Wimsey. Later Edward Pethebridge, the lead in 70s M.R. James Ghost Story for Christmas - The Ash Tree, would star in 1980s TV versions of three of the Wimsey-Harriet Vane novels, although never getting to the final one, Busman's Honeymoon. If they only made one: Gaudy Night, in which Harriet Vane returns to her Oxford women's college and finds a poison pen campaign against the female scholars, is usually cited as Sayers' best mystery novel, engaging with debates about women's roles in society, class and academia. It is Vane who is really the protagonist here, with Wimsey not appearing until half way through and a version of the story would probably benefit from an audience familiarity with the two characters and their relationship. A better one-off might be Murder Must Advertise, in which Wimsey goes undercover as "Death Bredon" in an advertising agency. Arguably the most fun Wimsey novel, the advertising setting would gain some audience attention post-Mad Men.
1. Hercule Poirot
Created by: Literally the best-selling novelist of all time, Agatha Christie, whose novels have sold over 4 billion copies and whose 1952 play The Mousetrap is the world's longest running piece of theatre. Her best loved character, egg headed (both literally and figuratively) detective Hercule Poirot made his debut in The Mysterious Affair at Styles in 1920. The book was rejected by major publishers and it was not until 1926's The Murder of Roger Ackroyd that Poirot became a household name. In total Christie wrote 33 novels and more than 50 stories featuring Poirot before his death in 1975's Curtain (as well as 12 novels starring elderly spinster Miss Marple). Like Arthur Conan Doyle, Christie tired of her detective creation long before the public did, describing Poirot as: "a bombastic, tiresome, ego-centric little creep". What's his appeal?: OK, I'm aware that the purpose of this article is to suggest classic detectives to replace the finally finished Poirot series, but who better to replace Poirot than Poirot? If audiences can get excited for three simultaneous Sherlock Holmeses (Downey, Cumberbatch and Miller), then another Poirot is a definite possibility. Poirot is second only to Holmes when it comes to detectives with instantly recognisable style. A 21st century Poirot could, like the BBC's Sherlock, bring him into the modern day whilst retaining everything from his fastidious personal grooming and neatness to his obssession with "the little grey cells". It's important to maintain the character's status as a foreign observer, a police detective in his own country, a nation whose war torn destruction has caused him to flee to Britain and a job as a private detective. These elements are more key than being Belgian specifically and open the door potentially to a more racially diverse cast and an African Poirot. That way he could maintain the characters Francophone tones whilst still being indignantly "not French". Sidekicks and supporting cast: Captain Arthur Hastings (or Lieutenant at first), Inspector (later Chief Inspector) James Harold Japp and Poirot's secretary Miss Lemon are largely analgous to Holmes' Dr. Watson, Inspector Lestrade and Mrs Hudson, something that was fairly deliberate on Christie's part given how indebted she was to the tropes of her mystery writing predecessors in the early days. As the likes of Martin Freeman or Lucy Liu's Watson or Rupert Graves' Lestrade show, these supporting character tropes are easy to play with and adapt for new versions that stay true to elements of the originals. Any on screen previous?: The ITV-Suchet series is far from the first version of the moustachioed Belgian on screen and it will almost certainly not be the last. Perhaps the best known version was Albert Finney's Oscar nominated turn in Sidney Lumet's 1974 film of Murder on the Orient Express. Finney's Poirot appeared opposite an all-star cast including Lauren Bacall, Ingrid Bergman, Sean Connery and John Gielgud. Poirot was once again surrounded by stars, this time including David Niven, Maggie Smith, Bette Davis and Mia Farrow, for 1978's Death on the Nile in which he was played by Peter Ustinov. Ustinov, never the most faithful interpretation of the character, would go on to appear as Poirot in two more all-star adaptations for the big screen as well as three TV movies updated to the present (one of which featured Suchet as Inspector Japp). Just this year, as the Suchet TV series finished, Ridley Scott was attached to produce a new film version of Murder on the Orient Express, although whether it actually gets made along with all of Scott's other mooted projects remains to be seen. It does, however, indicate a continued appetite for new versions of the famous detective on screen. If they only made one: The previously mentioned Roger Ackroyd is generally regarded both as Christie's masterpiece and as the great novel of mystery's Golden Age. However, its ingenious twist - the Watson/Hastings type narrator turns out to be the killer - has meant that there has never been an entirely satisfactory screen version, including the Suchet version. Christie's novel is a masterful piece of editing and ommision. Everything that Dr James Sheppard reports is accurate and with a documentary reliability such that the audience never questions whether we might be being given the truth and nothing but the truth, but perhaps not the whole truth. Conventional screen narratives struggle with this kind of story structure, but it would lend itself perfectly to a mockumentary or found footage style in which the film is Sheppard's assembled footage of events. Not only could this be a creative take on a classic story, but would also make a salient point about the subjectivity of factual documentary footage.