5 Fall TV Shows That Are Doomed To Fail
The new TV season's worst of the worst.
With success rates in recent years for new shows as low as 35 percent, you don’t have to be a TV psychic to predict which shows don’t have the legs to make it past season 1 - though a ‘legless TV psychic’ sounds like it could be something in the works as a mid-season replacement.
While there is plenty of excitement about new CBS series like Star Trek: Discovery, not so boldly going where many TV execs have gone before, and S.W.A.T. which audiences hope stands for “Shemar Moore-Without-A-Top”, there are just as many shows that viewers are already hate-watching before they’re yanked from the schedule in the coming weeks – or by the end of this posting, whichever comes first.
In the meantime, enjoy these shows while they last – or better yet, don’t bother watching these shows at all, because they won’t last.
5. The Good Doctor
ER, Grey’s Anatomy, Nurse Jackie - all make the hospital seem like a dramatic, sexy place to be. But when you visit The Good Doctor, you will want to be St. Elsewhere. Okay, dated 80’s reference, but the show feels as dated as Doogie Howser, MD.
Here’s the concept: a young, brilliant surgeon tries to prove that he has what it takes to be a real physician. The twist is, Dr. Shaun Murphy (played by Bates Motel’s Freddie Highmore) isn’t just a genius, he also has autism. While it’s a positive step to feature characters with mental health issues as highly functioning, this show takes things too far, literally taking us into Shaun’s mind to show how he feels when faced with a difficult or tense situation. These cutaways inside his head take you out of the drama, and make your head want to explode with frustration.
Executive Produced by David Shore, who has a strong track record of featuring gifted doctors like Hugh Laurie’s House, the lead character in The Good Doctor suffers from a bad case of being way too good. Not only is Shaun able to use his savant skills to heal the sick, he is able to heal those who didn’t even know they needed healing.
ABC hopes their new ‘genius medical drama’ fares better than CBS's cancelled Pure Genius, though this seems like a clear-cut case of a medical drama that needs to heal thyself before it is cancelled, stat.
4. Me, Myself And I
When the best part about your show is that it has Urkel in a minor role, well, you, yourself and the other I’s who greenlit this gimmicky comedy, are in trouble.
Saturday Night Live alum Bobby Moynihan plays entrepreneur/inventor Alex Riley in the present day, and it also flashes back to when he was 14 (played by It’s Jack Dylan Grazer), and flashes forward to when he is 65 (played by John Laroquette).
While time-shifting shows can work, it is a stretch to believe that Moynihan, best known for playing ‘Drunk Uncle’ on SNL, has sobered up, hit the gym, and become as dashing as Dan from Night Court.
Creator Dan Kopelman, who wrote Malcolm In The Middle, sets the kids scenes in the 90’s, Moynihan’s middle-aged scenes in 2017, and the future scenes in the most generic and boring depiction of the future a TV production budget would allow. The show deserves kudos for attempting to weave a different kind of structure to a traditional TV comedy, yet they also use tired plot devices like introducing the teenaged love interest with slo-motion over music, or the cliché of finding your wife in bed with another man.
The message here is that things that happen in your past, have an impact on your later life, but that shouldn't take three generations, or a whole series of television, to explain. And after losing almost 30% of its lead-in (Kevin Can Wait) for its recent premiere, viewers appear to agree.
3. Wisdom Of The Crowd
Thanks to roles in Mr Selfridge and Entourage, Jeremy Pivon is a proven talent that audiences like . That said, he should question the wisdom of his agent to allow him to star in Wisdom Of The Crowd.
Upon first glance, Piven’s character Jeffrey Tanner borrowed the thick black glasses and stubble of Michael Weatherly’s Bull and started rolling without giving much thought as to whether the show would work.
Wisdom Of The Crowd is a drama about a tech mogul who develops a crowdsourcing app to solve his daughter’s murder. And if he happens to revolutionize crime-solving at the same time, hey that could be fun too.
Executive Producer/showrunner Ted Humphrey (The Good Wife) hopes that audiences will be attracted to the concept that, when it comes to solving any problem, a million minds online are better than one. This mob rule of justice may work for Reddit, but they have proven not to be successful in achieving accurate information and can result in some crazy conspiracy theories – or in this case, a crazy television show.
Yet again, networks seem to be pulling from the failed Pure Genius, a procedural set in a technology-driven hospital, and APB a high-tech police procedural. Neither lasted a season.
2. The Orville
By now, mentioning that The Orville, created by Seth MacFarlane, is NOT in fact a Star Trek sci-fi parody, but rather a normal TV drama, is not noteworthy. What is noteworthy, however, is how this straightforward drama misses the mark.
The show features MacFarlane as Captain Ed Mercer, a man who’s granted the opportunity to helm his own spaceship. Sounds farfetched to have Peter Griffin as a space pilot? Keep in mind this takes place 400 years in the future where anything is plausible - maybe even this show.
MacFarlane’s space shipmates include Gordon Malloy, the wisecracking ginger (ER’s, Scott Grimes), security officer Alara (Halston Sage from Neighbors), Isaac the racist robot, and his first officer/ex-wife Kelly Grayson (Friday Night Lights’ Adrianne Palicki), who gets assigned after cheating on her husband with a blue alien.
What The Orville teaches us is that, in spite of a big budget, bigger musical score and bigger push by the network, Seth MacFarlane is not a leading man, not a dramatic writer, and not immune to making shows that Family Guy has so brilliantly poked fun at over the years. And with the most recent episode suffering a 50% drop in its key demo, and 39% drop in total viewers, MacFarlane's latest work is destined to join A Million Ways To Die In The West as a failed effort.
1. Marvel's Inhumans
Marvel’s latest series feels like it’s aiming to be its last series. If so, mission accomplished. If not, watch any of the Mission Accomplished movies, instead of wasting your energy sitting through this two-hour pilot. Oh wait, you saw it and hated it on IMAX already? Well, it will look better on the small screen, right? Or on your phone? Or your watch? Oh who are we kidding, there is no device small enough to hide the fact that this thing is a major mess.
The highly anticipated television is based on the fan-favorite comic book series about The Inhumans, a race of superhumans with unique powers that explore the never-before-told epic adventure of Black Bolt and the royal family. Perhaps the never-before-told should be more of a ‘never should have told’.
When the only nice thing you can say about a show is that it features a teleporting CG dog named Lockjaw, then maybe you shouldn’t say anything at all. Nah, that’s no fun. The writing is wonky, the acting is stiff, the costumes are cheap, and the editing is terrible.
Attempts at generating buzz by showing the first two episodes in theatres have backfired - The Guardian say it is "destined to be the TV disaster of the year" - and have given this show a certain death sentence.
Do you think these shows will fail or succeed? Any others that are doomed? Let us know down in the comments.