We've all been there. Watching some soap opera, a kids' show, HBO powerhouse when all of a sudden something doesn't seem right. None of your beloved characters has flat out said it. You haven't seen any blood. The culprits are technically innocent until proven guilty. But nonetheless, there is still an uncomfortable creep up your spine as if something is just...not okay. There have been a number of articles and opinion posts about disturbing television scenes, endings, and characters (hello, Trinity...) But what about those scenes when something feels wrong, disturbing, or dangerous, but it's not essentially in front of your eyes? The genuine scare factor of horror films like The Blair Witch Project (1999) and Paranormal Activity (2007 the first film only, of course) is the camera fall, the cut to black, the unknown. Our imaginations are sometimes scarier, creepier, and more disturbed than what is on the screen in front of us. The implications of the following five television episodes have left audiences reeling for years after their debuts. By the way, there are SPOILERS here.
5. ALF's Cliff-Hang-Nail (You'll Get It Eventually)
Show: ALF Episode: Consider Me Gone (S5 E24) Intended to be a cliffhanger before the show was inexplicably cancelled, the fate of the Alien Life Form (ALF) shacking up with the Tanner family (no, not the Tanners from Full House) for his own safety was one that shook viewers everywhere to the core. In the episode "Consider Me Gone," ALF attempts to rejoin his own species asnd create a life on a new planet, but he is caught by the very Alien Task Force that he has been hiding from all along. While this in itself isn't as disturbing as some TV scenes discussed in this article, one cannot help but think back to the original admission of the Task Force that they have cultivated a number of experiments for ALF involving "intense heat, freezing cold, high voltage, toxic substances, pain, sleep deprivation, inoculation... and, of course, dissection" in order to "see how responds." As much as ALF's sass (and attempts at eating the family cat) made our love for him a slow process, the implication of his outnumbered capture by the Task Force leaves viewers in a depressed slump imagining how ALF likely lived a short life of pure torture thereafter. While there was a movie that resolved this depressing implication, it wasn't made until 1996. With the original series having ended in 1990, fans spent six long years losing sleep over the though of ALF having his toenails pulled out... do you get the title now?
4. Dinosaurs Killed The Dinosaurs-Stars
Show: Dinosaurs Episode: Changing Nature (S4 E7) The well-known, well-loved, (semi-remembered) show from my generation's early years actually had one of the most subtly disturbing endings of all time. After four seasons of wittily exploring issues including but not limited to environmentalism, women's rights, civil rights, and body image using the main cast of the leathery-skinned Sinclair family, the show ended with what would essentially be the end of the species. Perhaps this isn't surprising, as most viewers past the age of three understand that dinosaurs no longer walk the earth (nor do their puppet doppelgangers), but what was disturbing about the extinction of the creatures was its self-inflicted nature. In an attempt to stave off a swarm of "Bunch Beetles" eating some of the species' main vines, Earl Sinclair decides to spray the planet with a "defoliant." This chemical, however kills off all plant life on the planet. Thinking that clouds will bring rain and thus resuscitate plant life, the dinosaurs decide to drop bombs into volcanoes, but this in turn causes global cooling - ie. The Ice Age. The community understands what this winter will last for tens of thousands of years (Ned Stark was right!), and the show ends with Earl apologizing to his family and dinosaur-kind for killing them off. The most disturbing implication of this finale is, for me, not the idea of our beloved dinosaurs slowly freezing to death, but the suggestion that any species including ours will eventually find a way to extinct ourselves via the misuse of nature. The episode of course was written to teach viewers an important lesson about environmentalism, but leaves audiences with feelings of doom: one misstep, one wrong diagnosis, one wrong suggestion from one wrong pseudo-scientist and we're all goners. That's a pretty disturbing moral lesson, if you ask me (Thanks ABC!).
3. Buffy, Interrupted
Show: Buffy The Vampire Slayer Episode: Normal Again (S6 E17) In this episode, the baddies of the sixth season The Trio (of evil-ish nerds) inject Buffy with a hallucinogenic venom that causes her to switch back and forth between the world she knows and saves, a lot and her possibly more nightmarish reality in a mental hospital. In alt-world, the Buffster is actually a patient who has created this entire world on Sunnydale in her mind. This has some serious implications for the beloved cult characters in the show: The Scoobies don't exist, Dawn was never created (possibly the only silver lining) and Buffy was never going to be the one to stand against the forces of darkness, because these forces of darkness exist only in her mind. The end of the episode shows Buffy choosing to save her friends from the weekly demon and take the antidote found to cure her of her hallucinations. In the alternate reality, however, the camera pulls away from a doctor's assertion that they've lost her as Buffy sits unresponsive in the corner. The episode itself one of the best of the series, showing some major acting chops from Sarah Michelle Gellar, while making a classic Whedonesque sardonic commentary about the "and then she woke up!" television trope. The beauty of the episode is in the end and what follows. The possibility of this alt world is never spoken of in the series again, but audiences and Buffy herself are forever left wondering about Buffy, Sunnydale, and its sexy-brooding/peroxide-headed vamps.
2. A Desperate House-Predator
Show: Desperate Housewives Episode: The Miracle Song (S3 E10) No classic primetime soap opera would be complete without the laissez-faire handling of a suspected pedophile, amiright?! In a multi-episode arc of Desperate Housewives' third season, Lynette Scavo easily the most likeable of all the series' main characters finds herself in the mucho creepo basement of seemingly lovely new neighbor Art, assessing the skin crawling collection of train sets and arcade games, and Polaroids of shirtless young boys. Left with nothing but his excuses (and an empty basement) when she confronts him, Lynette takes action the only way she knows how: by telling everyone on the street. This, of course, becomes a major cause in common for the residents of Wisteria Lane to take up and handle by making angry signs and throwing rocks at both the potential pedophile and his handicapped sister. Unfortunately, as the suburb begins to raise arms to the pervert, both the audience and Lynette begin to question whether Art is indeed the predator he seems to be. The audience feels especially guilty for their hasty judgment when his handicapped sister Rebecca has a panic-attack in response to the rioting on their lawn, and passes away due to complications soon after. After finding out about Rebecca's fate, Lynette's guilt and general good nature leads her to apologize to Art for his loss (and her life-ruining gossip). The end of the episode ends with this interaction, and the final few words from Art essentially admit to Lynette that his "urges" have always been subdued by the love for and guilt involving his sister Rebecca. Now that she is gone, he thanks Lynette for "freeing" him to be who he truly is. The episode ends with Lynette's disbelief and Art's departure, and the situation is never updated or discussed for the audience' benefit again, leaving viewers to forever assume that a pedophile has freely left Wisteria Lane to prey on young boys in a different suburb somewhere near by.
1. The Sopranos' "Whack" Black Screen
Show: The Sopranos Episode: Made In America (S6 E21) The confusing series finale of one of the greatest television shows of all time has been discussed time and time again by professionals in the industry, critics, bloggers, and over an everyday water cooler (then and now). My final submission to this list is easily one of the most debated, but also one of the most effective if your mind is as disturbing as ours. Despite having been discussed to death (pun intended), the ending of one of HBO's most emotionally draining originals still has the most painfully disturbing implication for new and old audiences alike: that after everything is said and done, and the family seems out of danger, Tony Soprano " even hear it" when it happened. The "cut-to-black" seen on television sets around the world was the blackness Tony would see after being shot in the back of the head at a diner right in front of his family. There isn't enough time or energy to discuss all of the implications of this episode in this article, but the artistic and painstaking proof suggested and discussed by thousands of fans around the world (specifically the camera angles' changing point of view, Meadow's terrible parallel-parking skills, and the "Member's Only" jacket) is enough to give me the willies. There will always be counter-arguments, suggestions that the black screen was a cop-out ending on David Chase's part, and that's what television is all about. But when you think about it... really think about it, do you think we'd hear it coming? Or would will our lives cut-to-black before we understand what's happened? Even just talking about these unknowns has given me the creeps all over again. I'll be in fetal position, if you need me.