5 Reasons Why True Detective Is Going To Be Cancelled

50% of a perfect television show.

By Alex Leadbeater /

As I've already (somewhat incredulously) written, it's kinda weird that people are surprised about today's new that True Detective is unlikely to be getting a Season 3 at all, but given how strong the reaction has been maybe it's worth taking a look at just why this is happening and what the fallout is going to be.

Advertisement

This was, after all, the pinnacle of the Golden Age of Television. When Season 1 aired in 2014 to rave reviews and the sort of cultural impact saved for zombies and dragons, it was treated like old fashioned watercooler television. Matthew McConaughey and Woody Harrelson (the former of whom it's been alleged won his Oscar partly on the back of what the show did to his profile) were embroiled in a deep, stylish crime thriller that was dense in its meaning as it was its plotting and it was near perfect.

The second season was just as big a talking point, although for quite the opposite reasons. I'll get into the whys in a little bit, but there's little disputing it was a disappointing step down (if not lacking in ambition). Since then, all's been quiet on the front of grizzled cops and world-weary criminals. Until a report on the future of HBO suggested the show's fate hung in the balance and the key creative threatened to depart. It's a long time coming, and here's the signs the writing's been the wall for a while.

5. HBO's Not Doing Amazingly

They may have the biggest show on television right now, but aside from Game Of Thrones HBO isn't really knocking them out of the part. Many of its recent massive hits - True Blood, Boardwalk Empire - have wrapped up and many of the shows brought in to replace them - Vinyl, The Newsroom and The Leftovers (which has had a critical upturn but remains niche) - haven't hit as big as expected. It's still incredibly high quality television and there are exceptions of course - comedy-wise the channel's doing strong with Girls, Silicon Valley and Last Week Tonight - but in terms of audience engagement it's down compared to the likes of Netflix.

Advertisement

True Detective has been the one resounding counter to this. The first season was an incredible success on all counts and was enough to ensure the second chugged along view-wise. However, if they're desperate for an up-turn, the channel can't really afford to put time, effort and money into backing an iffy horse. They need a smash hit, especially as Game Of Thrones is entering its final act, and True Detective no longer seems to be it.

That's what new head of programming Casey Bloys is looking for, and it's hardly surprising this rumour started from internal HBO sources.

4. It Takes A Long Time To Do Right

If True Detective Season 3 was commissioned today, by all estimations the earliest it would be on our screens is 2018, and that's if you want something as sloppy as Season 2.

Advertisement

You see, one of the biggest suggestions True Detective Season 2 would live up to the first was that it came out over a year-and-a-half after the first season, suggesting Nic Pizzolatto had been given the time to develop a whole new sprawling story. However, while he had six months more than most seasonal television, it still fell far from the mark.

And that's because Season 1 had been gestating for years before it finally made its way to the screen; it was the writer's passion project, something he'd built and dissected from every angle in his mind before actually putting any words on the page. There's no real measure of the time he put in previously, and so to develop a new season right could take him through to the end of the decade. That's not really going to help HBO and ensures interest will have only waned more.

3. Nobody Really Cares About It After Season 2

There was something off about Season 2 from the first episode and the problems only increased as it rolled towards its... there was a conclusion, right? If I'm being honest, I didn't hate it as much as some of the show's biggest critics, but by the time we got to what should have been intense scenes like the street shootout or sex party heist the lack of tension made clear something integral had been bungled.

Advertisement

There was an alternatively dry and sloppy approach to the storytelling, with nothing to really draw you in, while the cultural inflections and expansive themes felt like they were applied with Pritt Stick. There was a sense of effort in there and it's certainly not cheap, but the result almost felt like a parody of itself - Taylor Kitsch's Paul Woodrugh and his hidden demons were so painfully presented he's a joke unto himself.

The upshot of this is that it's completely soured the brand. True Detective is now a 50:50 show, with as much cack as there is greatness. And while it's not fair to say a TV series is only as good as its most recent season, does anybody really want to risk getting a repeat of last year's run? Thought not.

2. Nic Pizzolatto May Have Nowhere Left To Go

The time Pizzolatto spent developing the show doesn't just show how long a good season takes to produce, but suggests that he may actually not have any more True Detective in him.

Advertisement

Season 1 was self-contained and so tightly wrapped that a follow up was impossible, hence the decision to make True Detective an anthology series. Which is good, but you need a strong, steady flow of ideas that keep things rejuvenated. If Season 2's anything to go by, his second-best idea wasn't as strong on a base level (even refined, the LA land scheme doesn't match cults in the bayou) and that may have been because he was stretching himself.

The question of True Detective's future was somewhat prompted by the suggestion from HBO insiders that Pizzolatto was looking at starting a totally new project in the channel, and maybe a totally blank canvas would be the best thing for him.

1. They're Never Going To Top Season 1

One thing running through all the previous points is the idea that Season 1 of the show was a landmark of television that casts an almost unfairly large shadow. And with it being such an untouchable run at this point, maybe it's worth just accepting that they're not going to top it.

Advertisement

There's an element of lightening-in-a-bottle to it. The development stage was so protracted no business would approve it and while we'd already started to see movie actors make the leap to TV, this was the first time where they'd done so in elevated material that used the episode structure to do something a movie couldn't. It was a dense show, with countless influences from across culture and a story that required its actors to really push their characters. It was (and still is) like nothing else.

There's very little hope of topping it and maybe we were wrong to see it anything more than a one-off in the first place. If we definitely aren't getting a Season 3, maybe that's how it should have stayed.

Advertisement