5 Times Arrowverse Threw Shade At Superman

The CW sets up an Anti-Superman campaign worthy of Lex Luthor.

By Jeffrey Misener /

Tyler Hoechlin's Superman is a fascinating case of a studio that made a 'product' far more popular than they wanted it to be. The Man of Steel was never intended to be seen on TV's Supergirl, but rather a hidden presence they could occasionally name-drop. However, a much-needed publicity boost for the Supergirl's relaunch on The CW was a job for Superman. Hoechlin's Superman was an instant hit, and fans wanted a new series for him. What they didn't want was the character being shoved back into Pandora's Box.

Advertisement

The network shied away from the character, but Arrowverse fans didn't forget. Once 'out of sight, out of mind' failed, the writers instead tried staging stories with the intent of convincing viewers that we shouldn't actually want to see him. So they used a weapon against Superman even more dangerous than Kryptonite: the script.

As part of this Anti-Superman campaign, they've written stories that make him look ineffective, they had other characters throw shade at him, and worst of all they made him insult himself. Not even Lex Luthor himself could manage that.

5. Supergirl Knocks Him Out Cold

The writers seem overly concerned about fans asking why doesn't Supergirl call Superman when faced with overwhelming odds. It is technically a fair question, but doesn't that also hold true of all the Arrowverse characters? Why didn't Barry Allen call in Supergirl to beat Savitar? Why didn't The Legends call in The Flash to help fight Reverse-Flash? Or any speedster for that matter?

Advertisement

Super-powered help would certainly have helped Arrow on more than one life-risking battle. Audiences understand though that the drama of any series is lost if the hero doesn't overcome great adversity. Viewers don't really expect weekly crossovers.

The writers know this and don't bother to justify these absences usually; it's just something that is understood. So why did Supergirl's writers try to explain that Superman doesn't help more because he isn't equipped to? In the second season finale, Superman blundered straight into a trap at left him thinking Supergirl was General Zod. Thus he engaged in full force against what he mistook for a lethal threat, and she knocked him out.

Cold.

Later, he lets Kara accept the mortal combat against the Daxamite Queen because he says she is better than him. She very well could be, but this was the beginning of Clark starting to let himself off the hook when danger arises.

4. Newest Power: Super-Self Depreciation?

Clark Kent is famous for having bags of humility, but there is a line between being humble and completely insecure. The writers constantly make Superman declare his awe for much stronger Supergirl is. Now there is being supportive...there is being secure enough to acknowledge another's strengths...but this isn't that.

Advertisement

This happens with such repetitiveness that it goes beyond those other admirable traits into seeming odd and insecure. This is the heavy-handed puppet strings of the writers trying to tell you that Supergirl is way better, so just stop asking for Superman.

In the Elseworlds crossover, The Flash thanked Clark for his help defeating Amazo, and Clark looks down and says he didn't really do anything. When Clark Kent first appeared back in season two, he had modesty, but also a refreshing playful sense of confidence regarding his sway over Cat Grant. Now he has turned into the Charlie Brown of the crossover.

3. Explicitly Identified As Not "My Favorite Kryptonian"

It is natural that the Arrowverse characters would be closer to Kara given their history with her, but Arrowverse was still unusually chill toward her cousin. The problem is that the network knows that Superman meeting Barry & Oliver is something they would have to do to satisfy fans expectations before they could successfully retire Clark for once and all. So they did the meeting, but it was all carefully written to be sure not to start any new friendships that fans would want more of.

Advertisement

The Arrowverse characters outside of Kara barely interacted with Superman. The heroes of Earth 1 do not have the built-in familiarity with him, but it still feels very odd the characters didn't seem at all impressed. How was it that Cisco wasn't geeked out by the preeminent hero of DC Comics? Weirdest of all for the CW, which usually loves to hint at fan's hopes for the future, was that there wasn't a single allusion to the Justice League when this was as close as it gets.

To make it explicitly clear who we the viewers should like, Cisco spells it out for us when he refers to Supergirl as his favorite Kryptonian. He doubles down on it by saying "Yeah, that's right. I have a favorite". Brainiac 5 echoes this sentiment for a third time when he confirms that Cisco chose well. Supergirl is then given the line, to hammer it home a fourth time for anyone not listening, "Peace out from your favorite Kryptonian" as she leaves. Notice even how the shot is arranged to put him in the background where he appears diminutive, while she is front and center.

2. Somebody Save Him

Smallville's theme song "Save Me" takes on new meaning with this Clark Kent. As part of CW's ongoing campaign to make Superman lesser than their series stars he always requires their rescue.

Advertisement

Martian Manhunter saved him from Metallo. That was early in season two, not to be confused with the end when Supergirl beat him silly, then saved the world while he cleaned up after her. After a year and a half break fans were rewarded with seeing him lead the heroes into battle against Amazo where he launched an opening salvo of super-punches ...that all failed to connect.

Not even one.

Amazo swatted him aside, and he seemed to sit out much of the fight until the end when he was one of several heroes who helped pin Amazo down for Barry's Elseworld Green Arrow to finish him off. Maybe Clark was right to refuse credit for that. Elseworlds Part 3 saw what may be the final fight for Superman which featured a great battle against an evil Superman...which ended with Supergirl saving him. He got back into the action though, but only for Amazo to return to knock Superman down again. He was saved by the sudden appearance of Lois Lane, Brainiac 5, and Martian Manhunter.

1. Superman Ends The Never-Ending Battle When Convenient For Himself

The final goodbye scene between Clark, Lois, & Kara was The CW's closing argument to their campaign to kill interest in a Superman series. Clark reiterates yet again how much more effective Kara is before announcing Lois is pregnant and they are moving off-world to Argo City, where she will be safe from the baby having powers. Kara asks if they will be back after the baby is born, and they exchange an awkward look before Clark admits this is long term.

Advertisement

Clark is given the line "The world doesn't need Superman when it has Supergirl" which makes the character now embarrass himself. It ignores the essence of why Superman does what he does: because he can. Not because others can't. Just because the world has Superman, would that mean it doesn't need Batman? It is another example of the script using a reasoning limited to Superman that isn't applied to anyone else.

Further insult to injury was making him state part of his reasoning was that his new family has given him too much to live for. So...his own life is too precious to risk now? The concern regarding being absent from providing for your child is entirely understandable, but that he chose to acquiesce to that fear is not. Do police officers or soldiers quit when their family has a baby? For that matter should reporter Lois Lane, a pioneering example to girls of the last century that women can have careers, so casually abandon her career? The script could have added one or two lines showing their continued commitment to Earth, but the writers didn't give us that.

Their job was to send Superman off to live in a great alien farm upstate where he can run around and be happy. The show treats the viewers like children to whom they think they can dictate what we want and do not want. They do not want us to want Superman, and have gone out of their way to convince us.

What do you think of The CW's treatment of Superman? Do you want a Man of Steel series? Share your thoughts down in the comments.

Advertisement