I dont think theres anything more disappointing than when a formerly-favorite TV show becomes lame. There are so many mixed emotions involved with the disappointment of a show. In some sort of strange way, its almost as if youre watching the slow death of a loved one. Or, maybe, its like being in an abusive relationship of sorts you feel that you owe it to the show to stick it out and see it to its natural end. Sure, you may take some time off and catch up by binging on a season during a bored summer day, but it is almost impossible to cut the show out of your life completely. Every show on this list is one that I loved at some point in the past, but that also disappointed me along the way with a dip in quality. If you disagree, or you think there is another show that should be included, leave a comment!
5. Weeds Season 4
Weeds always had somewhat of a ridiculous plot. Its tough to imagine an incredibly attractive suburban housewife peddling marijuana throughout the neighborhood, who is not particularly good at hiding her activities, being able to grow her business (pardon the pun) to such a grand scale. Thinking about her dangerous activities, such as dating a DEA agent or getting involved with major drug cartels, her business really should have been shut down pretty early on. But at least when Nancy and the Botwins lived in the suburban community of Agrestic, the show made a little bit of sense. Once the family left Agrestic, the show plummeted into ridiculousness, highlighted by Nancys involvement with the drug-kingpin Mayor of Tijuana, and their subsequent child together. The show became less enjoyable to watch in the later seasons, and this downfall began during Season 4.
4. The Office Season 6
Clip show. Do I really have to say anything more? I probably dont, but I will anyway. This season of The Office began the downfall in creativity and enjoyment that permeated the final few seasons of the once-great show. Once known for incredibly memorable episodes, Season 6 provided very little of the genius from the first five seasons of the show, so much so that individual episodes are hard to pick out from this particular season. This was the season that Jim and Pam got married, but it is also the season that the Jim and Pam story became just about the only story that was told. Perhaps that is why Dwights character seemed to change so much during this, and subsequent, seasons he was frustrated that the spotlight shined on just a few people, rather than the entire ensemble cast. Michaels character development stagnated. In fact, almost every characters development either got worse or grinded to a painful halt. This was the season when almost nothing happened. In the history of The Office, it will be known only for the wedding episode and for the sale of Dunder Mifflin to Sabre. It was a filler season. Plus, there was a clip show episode. Ugh.
3. How I Met Your Mother Season 6
Another Season 6 on the list. When I flip through the channels during bored afternoons and catch random episodes from the first few seasons of HIMYM, I fall in love with the show all over again. But there has just been something missing from the past few seasons of the show. HIMYM was tough to include on this list, because there hasnt really been a particular event that disappointed me so much to take away from my love of the show. There has just been a sort of stagnation of interest associated with the past few years, and I think Season 6 is when that began to happen. The Zoey Pierson story was a little frustrating. It seemed to last much too long, and I think everyone, including the rest of the gang, knew that it was never going to work out for Ted. The Barney/Robin story took much too long to get going during the season as well. But, like I said, it was tough to include HIMYM on this list. Some of my favorite moments in the show came during this season Marshalls reaction to his fathers death provided further evidence that Jason Segel is a very talented actor. The episodes when he is dealing with the death are some of the best television Ive seen in recent years.
2. Community Season 4
Dan Harmon called it an impression, and an unflattering one. I cant argue with the guy on that one. Season 4 of Community took the parts of the show that everybody loved the witty parodies that actually had a point and Abeds oddness, among others and exploited them. For a comedy, it did a pretty terrible job of actually being funny for almost half of the season. I dont think I laughed until episode 3. Dont get me wrong, there were good episodes Alternative History of the German Invasion and Economics of Marine Biology stick out in particular but, on the whole, the season was a disappointment. But if it wasnt for these episodes, as well as Jim Rashs incredible and consistent portrayal of the Dean, the season would have been a complete waste of time. And that puppet episode. That awful puppet episode. It was one of the worst episodes of a good TV show that I think Ive ever seen, and it taints my view of the entire season.
1. Californication Season 5
Californication probably should have turned the Season 4 finale into the series finale, with Hank riding into the sunset as the lasting image of the show. Instead, it limped on, and continues to limp on, with almost no meaning left in the show. The reason why original fans loved the show is because of the complicated nature of Hanks relationships with his family and friends. The entire mood of the first season was incredible and as close to perfect as a show has ever come during its first season, but by the time this season aired, almost all of that had changed. There was a time when Hank was resistant to having his treasured novel turned into a movie. There was a time when Hank was picky about his projects, when he refused to compromise his artistic freedom by churning out popular writing. And then there was a different time when Hank would be completely fine with writing the memoirs of a rapper that he doesnt even know, and when he would be able to write a pop song without any prior experience in the art. My biggest problem with Californication during Season 5 is that the show turned into a cartoony version of itself. There are no consequences for actions during the season. Hank goes on a ride-along with Runkel and Apocalypse, they end up stealing a police car, and at the end of the episode they get arrested. Season 1 of the show, Hank would have been in jail until he faced the consequences of his actions. Season 5, however, and its as if it didnt even happen. I hope that Californication can return to its glory days, but with its rising popularity, I fear that the show is playing to its audience, and I guess I cant blame it for that. I just wish things were different.