6 Things Netflix’s Live-Action Cowboy Bebop Remake Must Do
I’m not going to Netflix to die. I’m going to find out if I’m really alive.
Netflix have recently announced a live-action remake of the 1997 anime Cowboy Bebop, and reception has been mixed to say the least. On one hand, it’s incredibly exciting to think that there’ll be new, fresh stories involving the likes of Spike and Faye, with debates already swirling about dream casting. But on the other hand, anime to live action is not a path paved with gold. A bad remake could ruin the chances of an anime reboot, Blu-ray update or any future releases from the show.
Netflix has a few clunkers in its back catalogue, and brilliant sci-fi shows are few and far between. While there are the obvious reasons to be concerned (Westernisation, poor casting, changing core characters, ignoring the source material...), there are a lot of reasons to be excited too. And if it’s terrible, at least the original will still be there to enjoy.
But let’s be optimistic. The show might very well be not terrible, it might even be great. As long as Netflix gets a few basic things right in the live action version, they can satiate at least some of the fan base.
6. Character Over Set Pieces
While the original had some action sequences, most of the time was spent building up character. Spike, Jet, Faye, Ed and even Ein all felt like family by the end of the show’s original run. The problem with a live-action version is that it invites comparison, and every fan will remember their favourite differently. It’s possible (likely, really) that Netflix’s Faye could be perfect for some viewers and utterly wrong for others.
However, the show must still be built around them. Though action will obviously feature with fight scenes, chase sequences and gunplay scattered in there, character must be at the heart. As there are only ten episodes to build these characters, we must feel like we know them a little better by the end of each one.
It remains to be seen whether we’ll get updated versions of the original plot or totally new stories involving old, familiar characters. But however it’s done, what makes Cowboy Bebop special was the cast. A remake invites all sorts of pressure that an original series would not. In order to make the most of that, Netflix must keep character development at the forefront.
5. Faye & Ed From The Start
In the anime, both of these characters were picked up along the way. With only 10 episodes now, we need to see them from the start. It’s difficult, because that already feels like changing or truncating the story down compared to the original. On the other hand, though, Edward doesn’t even appear in the first ten episodes, with Faye arriving in episode 3.
If it starts with Faye in the crew and picks up Ed around episode 2-4 that would still work, depending on the storylines and pacing of the show. The original always had longer plot strands running through the more episodic nature of the storytelling. Fans will want to see their favourites in live action, they’ll want to experience them on screen again. If Ed is part of a cliffhanger for Season 2, especially when that is by no means confirmed, it’ll feel like they’ve wasted a great chance to involve Ed in the story.
There are sure to be casting debates. Keanu Reeves was everyone’s pick for Spike last decade, but he’s too old now. At least by having the gang all feature though, Netflix can make sure they’re keeping the fans happy in one way.
4. Don’t Follow Death Note
This entry could just be called ‘Don’t Be Terrible’ and be done with it, but there is more to the comparison than that. Death Note is one of the most high profile anime to live action adaptions to date, and easily the biggest disappointment.
Either to help the movie’s pacing, to substitute tension out for action or to make the storyline more palpable for Western audiences, Death Note changed almost everything from the source material. The Nat Wolff led movie wasn’t all that great anyway, but as a comparison the Death Note it came off worse in every way.
There is no point butchering Cowboy Bebop so much; why remake it if you’re going to change it? There are several things in Cowboy Bebop that might seem like they need toned down, but Netflix can’t pick up a show like this then try and sand it down into something rounder with a mass market appeal.
The original Cowboy Bebop features a Blaxploitation bounty hunter who constantly carries a coffin around with him to bury his enemy in. This is what Netflix have bought. This is what Netflix needs to give us.
3. Keep It Weird
The original show was completely off the wall. There was a grittiness to it, but it was wrapped up in so many weird and wonderful plot threads that the show became almost of its own genre. Like Twin Peaks, there was nothing that could possibly follow it, and so now it has to follow itself.
It’s highly unlikely this will be a mega hit for Netflix the way Orange Is The New Black was. It simply doesn’t have that wide an appeal. But if Netflix understands that, it’ll do fine. There’s still a massive market for offbeat shows on the platform, as Maniac and Big Mouth show in their own way. Cowboy Bebop must be true to its roots.
Original director Shinichiro Wantabe is back on board, with writing from Chris Yost confirmed too. Yost wrote Thor: Ragnarok, which gives fans a huge reason to be excited, but also wrote Thor: The Dark World, which encourages more caution.
Wanatabe back on board is the biggest victory though. It remains to be seen if the new show can live up to the anime, but with the same director, you can be sure they’ll go about it in the right way.
2. Keep The Spirit, But Redesign
Even prior to the Netflix announcement, Cowboy Bebop was a popular choice for cosplayers. Maybe less so than the likes of Harley Quinn or Jon Snow, but most major conventions would feature the gang at least once. To fans of the show, they’re instantly recognisable. There’s only one problem; they look a bit stupid.
The character designs are brilliant for a cartoon. But one glance at the cosplayers will tell you Spike’s hair was not made for live action. Faye’s costume too is probably in for a redesign. It’s natural that as they cast the gang and start making the perfect look for each actor, the outfits will change slightly.
Remakes rarely please everyone, but one way Netflix can soften the blow of the redesign is by keeping the spirit there.
Spike’s messy but stylish look, Faye’s confidence and Ed’s youthful freedom must still come through in a rework. They face the challenge of having to create new costumes that are different from the ones before yet still keep the same feel. It’s a challenge many Batman movies have faced over the years. And if there’s one thing to be learned from Batman, it’s this: no nipples.
1. Keep The Characters Poor
Lots of sci-fi shows are post-scarcity, with technology able to replicate resources as needed. Setting a show into the future often means regular day to day concerns get put aside for flights of fancy. And in general, that’s completely fine; Star Trek and Mass Effect wouldn’t be improved if you had Kirk, Picard or Shepard walking around in rags.
But in Cowboy Bebop, the crew were frequently struggling for cash, eating only ramen noodles and living pay cheque to pay cheque. It had a kitchen sink feel to it, mixed with the sci-fi backdrop. There was amazing technology in the show, the crew just didn’t get to use it very often. And those pay cheques weren’t boring labour work, they were intergalactic bounty hunts.
Since Bebop’s cancellation before its time, only Firefly has really stepped up to the plate as a replacement. Guardians Of The Galaxy maybe, but as a movie that feels more like a designated hitter in this baseball metaphor.
By having Bebop’s characters be poor, they were relatable and gave the show a gritty, noir feel. That has to remain for it to be the same show in live-action.
What do you want to see from a live-action Cowboy Bebop? Let us know down in the comments.