6 Times Gotham Improved Batman's Mythology (And 4 Times It Failed)

For better or for worse, Gotham certainly had an impact on the legend of Batman.

By Andrew Pollard /

Fox

One of the biggest genre shows to come to a close during 2019 was FOX’s Gotham. After five seasons, it was time for Gotham to hang up its proverbial cape ‘n’ cowl and call it a day.

Advertisement

What had initially started as a series centred on Jim Gordon being transferred to a Gotham City Police Department that was rife with corruption, the show became that and so much more over its five-year run.

Featuring a who’s who of Batman comics, Gotham gave audiences a glimpse at skewed versions of so many familiar characters – some great, some not so great. But regardless of what it got right and what it got wrong, Gotham was completely and utterly its own world in every way possible.

Advertisement

Taken as a snapshot of an alternate Batman world, Gotham worked on a multitude of levels and ticked a slew of the right boxes. Was it flawless? Of course not. But taken on its own merits, Gotham was well worth the five-year investment audiences gave it.

Here, it’s time to reflect back on Gotham and take a look at ways in which it improved – and failed to improve – on the larger, grander mythology of the iconic Caped Crusader.

Advertisement

Improved Batman's Mythology...

6. Made C-Listers Matter

FOX

While the early buzz around Gotham made it clear that we’d be seeing the descent into madness of big-name villains like The Penguin and The Riddler, the show also managed to handle some of DC Comics’ supposed C-list rogues in an impressive way.

Advertisement

A prime example of this is how Gotham served Victor Zsasz.

Even on his good days, Zsasz is never anything more than a supporting C-list rogue of the Dark Knight’s. His story of carving a scar into his own body each time he kills somebody is a chilling one, yet Victor is always a throwaway bad guy who Batman disposes of with ease.

Advertisement

In Gotham, Anthony Carrigan’s take on Victor Zsasz saw the character positioned as a truly vicious, twisted, and clinical threat who was so good at being bad that he was the go-to hired hand of so many other nefarious sorts across all five seasons of the series.

Other similarly 'lesser thought of' villains who were fleshed out brilliantly in Gotham were no-good sorts such as Carmine Falcone, Sal Maroni, The Mad Hatter, and the show’s unique takes on Solomon Grundy and Firefly.

Advertisement

5. Allowed The City To Breathe

Fox

Across a wide variety of mediums, over multiple decades, Gotham City has so often simply been the city which is the backdrop to so many of Batman's battles.

Advertisement

What Gotham the show did so well, is that it allowed its titular city to breathe and become its own beast. Sure, anyone who’s ever read a single Batman comic will likely be aware that Gotham City is intended to be its own character, yet we’ve never seen that play out in a way anywhere remotely close to how the city was handled in Gotham.

By not solely focussing on one person’s journey, and by exploring so many corners of Gotham’s dingy streets, the series managed to make Gotham City its own monstrous locale. Each Gotham building, each Gotham street, each Gotham room, they all felt like individual beings in their own right.

Advertisement

Never in the world of Batman – well, bar possibly the iconic Batman: The Animated Series – has Gotham City been treated with so much respect and care by a creative team.

4. We Got To See Bruce Working On His Own

FOX

Bruce Wayne has obviously spent time working on his own in the comic book world, yet that’s becoming an increasingly rare sight to see these days.

Advertisement

While Batman has so often had a Robin by his side, there’s also been Batgirls, Nightwings, Red Robins, Batwomen, Red Hoods, Oracles, Spoilers, Catwomen, Batwings, Blue Birds, and so many other sidekicks and partners assisting the World’s Greatest Detective as he looks to fight the good fight.

The point being, it’s rare to see Bruce working on a largely solo basis.

Advertisement

In Gotham, while Alfred, Selina Kyle, and Jim Gordon would all work with Master Bruce at points, audiences got to see plentiful examples of Bruce Wayne working on his lonesome, stewing over his problems, questioning his own city, and trying to get himself to his absolute mental and physical peaks.

What Gotham did so well, is that it set Bruce up with the unrelenting determination and the sheer will to win that would become such a major part of the character upon him becoming Batman down the line. And by having Bruce not being too reliant on anyone else in Gotham, the series allowed for these attributes and that mentality to really shine through.

Advertisement

3. Fleshed Out Penguin For The Casual Fans

Fox

To those who maybe don’t spend all that much time reading comic books, Oswald Cobblepot is often viewed as a freak of nature who has a bunch of goons at his disposal and who waddles around eating fish.

Advertisement

While elements of that are indeed true, the Cobblepot of the comics is also an underhand, ruthless mob boss who is more interested in taking out his fellow crime lords than snacking on a salmon.

In Gotham, Robin Lord Taylor delivered a stunning incarnation of Oswald as he went from pot-washing lackey to all-powerful crime boss throughout the series’ five-season run. For the more casual comic book fans, this five-year journey provided the perfect encapsulation of what makes The Penguin such a brilliant character.

Advertisement

Not only is Penguin a multi-layered character in Gotham, he’s also depicted brilliantly as a power-hungry rogue who is looking to ascend the murky world of the city’s crime families.

2. It Didn’t Overly Rely On The Freaks

Fox

Of course Gotham served up its fair share of camp, erratic, vibrant supervillains, but the series didn’t lazily fall back and just rely on the ‘freak’ corner of Batman’s rogues gallery to carry the show.

Advertisement

So often in the Bat-books, the narrative will be solely focussed on one of the Caped Crusader’s freakish villains. That’s all well and good, yet there’s always the temptation to allow this ‘freak of the week’ to take centre-stage at the expense of the greater world of Gotham City and its more non-powered characters.

In the Gotham TV show, while such villains were allowed to flourish and were showcased well, the series also retained its identity of being a show about regular people in a corrupt and dirty city. More time was afforded to the war between mob bosses than it was to simply highlighting a crazed supervillain. And in doing so, Gotham shone a spotlight on how everyday people can be just as vicious and underhand as any over-elaborate, amped up to 11 comic book rogue.

Advertisement

1. Showcased The Bond Between Bruce And Alfred

Fox

Throughout its five-season run, Gotham was littered with some fantastic performances – and none were better than Sean Pertwee’s portrayal of Alfred Pennyworth.

Advertisement

As far back as the Batman mythos goes, Alfred has always been at the side of Master Bruce as his faithful servant and de facto father figure. Throughout the decades, we’ve all heard a million times over how it was Alfred who was left to raise Bruce after the tragic death of Thomas and Martha Wayne, and it was Alfred who has had to stand by Bruce’s side as he’s embarked on his mission to clean up the streets of Gotham City and beyond.

Now while we all know about this facet of Bruce Wayne’s life, rarely have the comic books fully showcased in great detail those younger years in which Alfred had to deal with a troublesome teen who was reeling from the death of his parents and the realisation of what a murky city Gotham really is.

Advertisement

By the time Gotham came to a close after five seasons, it was the bond between Bruce and Alfred that stood out as one of the very best elements of this particular exploration of Gotham City.

Failed To Improve Batman's Mythology...

4. Too Much, Too Young

Fox

The original mission objective of FOX’s Gotham was for the show to serve as a series spotlighting Jim Gordon’s early days in Gotham City. As a clean cut cop arriving in a corrupt city, Ben McKenzie’s Gordon was pegged as the central focus of the show.

Advertisement

Before you knew it, the spotlight initially put on Jim began to be shared out amongst a slew of supporting players. And one such player, was David Mazouz’s Bruce Wayne.

Having a TV series set in Gotham City and with Bruce as a character, that was always going to result in young Master Wayne eventually becoming a key component of the series – and that indeed proved to be the case. Now while having Bruce as a main character in the show was fine, what wasn’t so fine was how the 12-year-old Bruce Wayne became so connected to so many Batman villains.

Advertisement

Not only did Bruce establish a relationship with Jim Gordon from an early age, Gotham also saw the future Caped Crusader have run-ins with earlier versions of Catwoman, The Penguin, The Riddler, The Joker, Ra’s al Ghul, Hugo Strange, The Mad Hatter, Mr. Freeze, Poison Ivy, Bane, Scarecrow, The Court of Owls, and so many more.

While it was fun to see such interactions in the bubble of the Gotham TV series, this all made zero sense in regards to the greater mythology of Batman and his world.

Advertisement

3. The Batcave Was Already There

Fox

Part of Bruce Wayne’s journey to becoming Batman is constructing what would become known as the Batcave. In Gotham, however, the Batcave already existed way before Bruce became the Dark Knight.

Advertisement

Teased during the closing moments of the show’s debut season, Season 2 would see the Batcave revealed in all of its glory. Only, of course, it’s not yet referred to as the Batcave.

Instead, it was revealed that Thomas Wayne had his own secret working area underneath Wayne Manor. Thomas used this space to investigate some of the more questionable antics that were being undertaken in his own Wayne Enterprises, and this space would go on to become the show’s take on the famed Batcave as time progressed.

Advertisement

Granted, Jeremiah Valeska, Ecco and pals managed to cause some damage in this pseudo Batcave, yet that doesn’t take away from the fact that seeing any sort of precursor Batcave courtesy of Bruce’s father just felt far too contrived and convenient.

2. Jim Gordon Knows

FOX

While the established canon of the Batman books has usually seen Jim Gordon officially unaware that Bruce Wayne and Batman are one and the same – even if it is implied that Gordon maybe knows more than he’s letting on – it seems impossible for Gotham’s Jim to be blind to the fact that Bruce is the vigilante patrolling Gotham City’s darkest corners.

Advertisement

In Gotham, we had five seasons of Bruce Wayne and Jim Gordon being close friends and even working together to take down some of the city’s bad guys and gals.

For a masked symbol of vengeance and justice to then all of a sudden begin to torment Gotham’s underworld, it would be illogical for Gordon to not know that this was Bruce Wayne.

Advertisement

At least in the comics, it took Gordon a while to begin to put the pieces together about who Batman really is – even if he keeps that information to himself – but Gotham makes it so that Jim would know from the get-go that the man behind the cape ‘n’ cowl could only be Bruce Wayne, which majorly detracts from how the unseen future landscape of Batman and Gotham City would be.

1. He’s Basically Batman

Fox

As Gotham’s final episode drew to a close, audiences were given a glimpse into a future in which Bruce Wayne has fully embraced the moniker of Batman. But the real truth of the matter is that we’d all pretty much seen Batman already.

Advertisement

In the comics – in particular Frank Miller’s seminal Batman: Year One – we see a 25-year-old Bruce returning from his worldly travels, having honed his physical abilities, sharpened his mind, and returned to Gotham City with a determination to rid the city of its vile and vicious criminal element. Needing a symbol that will strike fear into the streets of Gotham, a bat crashing through a Wayne Manor window gives Wayne the inspiration to take on the mantle of Batman.

The thing is, in the Gotham TV show, Bruce Wayne is pretty much already Batman before the series finale's ten-year jump into the future. He’s already been out patrolling the rooftops. He’s already been tinkering away with gadgets. He’s already been targeting Gotham City’s most infamous of characters. And he’s already been wearing an outfit that is essentially an ear-less, cape-less Batsuit.

Advertisement

For the last season or more of Gotham, we were basically watching Batman-lite – with a large part of Bruce’s comic book ascension skipped over and fast-tracked.