7 Ups & 5 Downs From The Arrowverse In 2019

With Bats, Canaries and a major Crisis on its hands, this year was a big one for the Arrowverse.

By Michael Patterson /

2019 has undoubtedly been a big year for television as a whole, but it's safe to say that it's been equally as important for the Arrowverse.

Advertisement

The CW's shared universe of heroes, villains and multiverses expanded once more, as it welcomed a horde of new characters into its midst and even debuted another new show - all while preparing to close the doors on the show that started it all by kicking off Arrow's final season. On top of that, it also laid its final teases for a crossover the writers have been alluding to for over five years now and with that, the first three installments of Crisis On Infinite Earths hit our screens.

Yes, it's been a year of ups and downs for Arrow, The Flash, DC's Legends of Tomorrow, Supergirl and Batwoman as they battled the worst threats that the multiverse has to offer all while the writers attempted to put together narratives that would entertain their devoted legions of fans.

Advertisement

With the end of the year upon us, let's take our Waverider back in time and explore the best and the worst of the Arrowverse in 2019.

First, the downs...

Advertisement

Downs...

5. Legends Gets Too Silly

The CW

Legends of Tomorrow's very existence is a subversion of our expectations, as the show that was once lauded for being a dull Dr. Who rip-off designed to give B-rate heroes a chance to shine embraced the stereotypes and turned it into sheer brilliance. Mixing drama and depth with outlandish concepts and bonkers narratives, the show bucked the odds and somehow developed into the Arrowverse's best show throughout its second and third seasons. Unfortunately, it failed to get the mix right in its fourth.

Advertisement

Though still a highly enjoyable offering, it missed the endearing personality of Victor Garber's Martin Stein and brought in more in-your-face characters to make up for it. And even though it was already pushing the believability boundaries in 2018, the second half of the season earlier this year just became far too cartoonish.

It's a shame because this wasn't exactly a miss, but given what we've come to expect from Legends, it was far from a hit. Here's hoping when the fifth season arrives next year, the show will be back on form.

Advertisement

4. Weak Villains At The Start

The CW

This reflective piece will be doing a lot of comparing in terms of each show's first half seasons of 2019 and their second. And as far as villains go, it was mostly a good year for each show. Unfortunately, it didn't start out that way.

Advertisement

While Neron wasn't Legends' worst villainous offering and Supergirl was absolutely slaying things with Agent Liberty and Lex Luthor, it was stalwarts Arrow and The Flash that opened things on a sour note with disappointing villains.

The Flash was still stuck on the mind-numbingly dull Mr. 'This Ends Now!' Cicada who showed up, grunted a few syllables and then disappeared when overpowered on repeat until he was replaced with his niece Cicada 2.0. who virtually did the same thing. Meanwhile, Arrow attempted to change things up by having multiple villains take over from Ricardo Diaz but ended up dropping the ball in its development of Emiko - resulting in the rest of the Ninth Circle becoming mindless minions who the viewers just didn't care about.

Advertisement

This certainly set the stage for a revival for both shows in the winter season (which we'll get to later), but none of these villains had us on the edges of our seats.

3. Predictable Storylines

While all of The CW's shows can suffer from their tendencies to be on-the-nose, it mostly doesn't take away from the narratives they are attempting to tell. This year, however, the Arrowverse experienced a number of on-the-nose and predictable story moves that just highlighted a complete lack of self-awareness.

Advertisement

Supergirl suffered from it on a more episodic level in that certain episodes of Season 4 were weighed down by it, but this didn't impact the otherwise great season as a whole. Arrow, unfortunately, wasn't so lucky.

The flash-forward narrative promised a lot and delivered little, and perhaps the reason for that was because it was built upon the most predictable 'twist' in the history of the show as, for weeks, they had us wondering who the moody and unlikable Blackstar was - only to reveal that she was the daughter of Oliver and Felicity. Now, call this writer cruel but, it's hardly a twist when you reveal a mysterious character to be the core couple's child. We all saw it coming, and this resulted in a ton of predictable drama in 2019.

Advertisement

On top of that, an Olicity baby was the last thing that Arrow needed as it was still attempting to distance itself from its less-than-stellar days.

2. Crisis Comes At A Cost

The CW

Supergirl aside, the current seasons of the Arrowverse shows are mostly better than their predecessors, but it's clear that the production teams have been tightening their belts in anticipation for Crisis On Infinite Earths.

Advertisement

A crossover that requires plenty of antimatter waves, Shadow Demons and multiverse-traversing, it's understandable that the-powers-that-be would be a little more careful when it comes to spending their budget - hence why we haven't seen anything too large scale outside of a few moments. However, it's clear that this isn't all they're taking into account.

Have you noticed how Killer Frost has now suppressed her own voice echo so that she can appear more often? What about how the effects of Laurel's Canary Cry has only appeared on-screen once (she's used it plenty this season but we only hear it or see the after-effects)?

Advertisement

Yeah, it's clear that the showrunners are being more cautious when it comes to the little things too. Unfortunately, sometimes it's the little things that count.

1. Too Many Episodes

The CW

For yet another year, it just feels like the Arrowverse shows have a few too many episodes. It's hard to maintain a running narrative for a certain number of episodes (something Netflix's Marvel shows began showing us when multiple of their 8-13 episode-seasons lost their way midway through) so having to do so for 22 can be exhausting.

Advertisement

Now, don't get this writer wrong, if the narrative requires all of those episodes then good for it as the Arrowverse has given us some perfect 22-23 episode seasons in the past. However, it's been some time since we've seen any of the shows successfully maintain a high standard throughout the season, and the beginning of this year was an example of that.

Both Arrow Season 7 and The Flash Season 5 began to flail following their midseason returns, as the writers had to keep coming up with contrived obstacles in order to drag the storyline out until May. But, like, how many times were we expected to sit through Cicada showing up, losing and hightailing it before we call the competence of Team Flash into question?

Advertisement

Even Legends of Tomorrow felt like it was beginning to go around in circles as it came to the end of its 16-episode fourth season in May - something that had never happened before.

As Arrow proved in the fall, sometimes less is more.

Advertisement

Now, for the ups...

Ups...

7. Batwoman Begins (And Is Much Better Than Expected)

The Arrowverse family grew this year for the first time in almost three, as Batwoman joined the ranks. A show that had rubbed many people up the wrong way with its genuinely terrible first trailer, the show had a lot working against it long before it even hit our screens. However, that didn't stop it from producing a solid pilot episode and a mostly strong first half of a season.

Advertisement

With Ruby Rose's deliciously broody Kate Kane, some beautifully shot visuals and impressive fight scenes, Batwoman feels very different to the other shows in the Arrowverse, and it's worth watching alone just for Rachel Skarsten's incredible performance as psychotic villain Alice.

Any other year, an event such as a new show would be the biggest development that the Arrowverse experienced. This year, however, it's simply one of many...

Advertisement

6. Arrow Excels Without Felicity

The CW

Emily Bett Rickards' departure came as something of a shock to Arrowverse fans as it meant that we'd be bidding farewell to the quirky Felicity Smoak.

Advertisement

A character that has been divisive from the very beginning, she was once an adored recurring part of the series that eventually became the primary love interest of Oliver Queen - and after that, everything went south with the show changing her personality and ramming her down viewers' throats. Though the writers eventually redeemed the show by getting the balance right in Seasons 5 and 7, even on her best day Felicity struggled to make it past more than a few episodes without quickly falling back into her infuriating Season 4 tropes.

Still the question remained: Could a show that relied so heavily on one character (for better or worse) continue on without her? Fans of the comics longed to see it while fans of the character proclaimed that Arrow was nothing without her. Just how would it work out? The answer to that was revealed in the second half of the year, as Season 8 of Arrow didn't just work without her, it thrived.

Advertisement

We've long wondered what Arrow would have looked like without Felicity. The writers were too afraid to let go of her, but if they had done so much earlier, perhaps we would have had multiple incredible offerings like Season 8. That being said, it's nice that the show finally made it back on top for its final season.

On that note...

Advertisement

5. Arrow & The Flash Massively Improved In The Second Half

The CW

If you look back at the beginning of the year, you'll see that neither Arrow or The Flash were in great places. The former failed to follow-up the strong first half of its seventh season as a lack of interest involving its main villain resulted in the whole thing collapsing in on itself, while the latter's dull fifth season went round in circles over and over again (until it was ultimately saved by an incredible finale).

Advertisement

Thankfully, the creative teams of both shows took it upon themselves to ensure that the next seasons would be much stronger and it really does go without saying that they succeeded. Reinvigorated by the focus on the impending Crisis, The Flash found its heart for the first time in too long, while Arrow saved the best for last and produced its best season in almost five years.

It's taken a long time but the two shows that the Arrowverse revolves around are finally back at the top of the mountain.

Advertisement

4. Giving The Fans What They Always Wanted

The CW

It may have taken Arrow eight years to get the memo that fans had been repeatedly sending them but in the end, they finally gave fans the Green Arrow and Black Canary team-up they had wanted to see all along. With the concluding half of the seventh season finally seeing Earth-2 Laurel Lance transition into Black Canary, the eighth season saw her team up with her comic book love interest on a number of occasions.

Advertisement

When Oliver couldn't be in two places at once, Laurel was there to save Tatsu; when he needed to be sure that someone would protect Mia, he relied on Laurel to do just that; when choosing which of his teammates to bring to Russia with him, he chose Laurel; when he found himself trapped in a time-loop, he was there with Laurel; and finally, when he needed to hear some home truths on Lian Yu, he heard them from Laurel.

Make no mistake about it, Arrow has been very clear in its attempts to end the show how it begun: With Stephen Amell and Katie Cassidy at the forefront. Though the latter is playing a different version of the same character, we have still been gifted with more Green Arrow and Black Canary adventures than ever before - and that is a long overdue bonus in a truly great season.

Advertisement

3. Preparing For A Future Without Arrow

The CW

The news that Arrow would be coming to an end with its eighth season understandably caught fans off-guard. We all knew that the veteran superhero show had more days behind it than ahead of it, but we weren't ready for it to leave so suddenly - especially when it had already been renewed for Season 8.

Advertisement

The Arrowverse will look like a very different place without it, but that hasn't stopped The CW from preparing for the inevitable by laying the groundwork for two brand new shows to fill the Arrow-shaped hole. One will come in the form of a direct spin-off series focusing on leading lady Katie Cassidy's Laurel Lance/Black Canary, newcomer Katherine McNamara's Mia Smoak and veteran Juliana Harkavy's Dinah Drake/Black Canary. Its current working title is Green Arrow and The Canaries and following a backdoor pilot episode in the ninth episode of Arrow's final season, it will hopefully be picked up to series.

The second is the long-awaited Superman series, titled Superman & Lois, that will follow Tyler Hoechlin's Man of Steel and Bitsie Tulloch's intrepid reporter Lois Lane as the pair navigate life back on earth as parents of baby Jonathan Kent. A direct spin-off of Supergirl, fans have wanted to see Hoechlin's Clark Kent headline his own show ever since he debuted on the show - and now it's finally going to happen.

Advertisement

Arrow may be about to bow out, but its legacy will continue to flourish.

2. Supergirl Shines Bright

The CW

As far as each respective half season this year goes, there's a solid case to be made for the likes of Arrow Season 8, The Flash Season 6 and Supergirl Season 4 in terms of which one reigned supreme. However, taking the whole year of Arrowverse programming into account (that's both the spring and fall seasons), the most consistent of all shows has to be Supergirl.

Advertisement

The back half of the Girl of Steel's fourth season was nothing short of a triumph as, in spite of its political tone, it laid off its occasionally on-the-nose dialogue and allowed the natural progression of its storyline to take precedence with both the Red Daughter subplot and the reign of Lex Luthor giving it the chance to shine for the first time in too long.

Though its fifth season hasn't quite reached those triumphant highs, it's still been consistent enough to allow the Girl of Steel to hold her own against the admittedly brilliant comebacks of both Arrow and The Flash.

Advertisement

This really has been Supergirl's year.

1. A Crossover For The Ages

The CW

Five years of nods, teases and Easter Eggs came to fruition in December as Crisis On Infinite Earths finally kicked off. An Endgame of sorts for the Arrowverse, the first three installments served as the collective midseason finale for the shared universe of heroes, as the red skies finally showed up and the Anti-Monitor's wave of antimatter ripped through the multiverse, destroying every earth in sight - including Birds of Prey's Earth-203.

Advertisement

The annual crossover has become a tradition for The CW, with each new one upping the ante and taking the Arrowverse in a new and exciting direction. This one, however, took things that much further.

With an overwhelming sense of dread, admirably high stakes and DC Universe cameos galore, Crisis started with a bang and, so far, has lived up to the five years of teasing. It's been a main-event-level experience that you rarely get on television and it would have been at home in a more cinematic environment. And perhaps most important of all, it's set the stage for a game-changing 2020 for the Arrowverse.

Advertisement

So far, so great for Crisis On Infinite Earths...

-

Advertisement

What did you enjoy about this year in the Arrowverse? Tell us in the comment section below.