8 Problems With Torchwood: Miracle Day

By JG Moore /

Torchwood€™s always been a strange programme. Fittingly described by Charlie Brooker as being like €œa hitherto secret episode of Postman Pat in which Pat runs down fifteen villagers while masturbating at the wheel of his van€ it began life desperately trying to distance itself from its mother programme Doctor Who by being sexy and violent. It started life on BBC3 and BBC2 for its first two series, eventually graduating to BBC One in 2009 for the critically acclaimed five part miniseries Torchwood: Children Of Earth. After that, the series more or less fell off the radar with plans for an American remake on Fox luckily being axed. Then came the news that there would be a Series Four. Co-financed by American cable network Starz, Torchwood: The New World (its initial title) was promoted as a globe-trotting ten part thriller set in a world where suddenly, nobody is able to die, something that is initially referred to as €œthe Miracle€ but eventually sees the world fall into hell. Fans were hyped and the day of the first episode came. But as the new series wore on, it showed signs of fatigue and it was evident that the programme had taken a downward turn since Children Of Earth. Why was Miracle Day so flawed? Let€™s look further into it...

8. It€™s Too Americanised

One of the more quirky facets of Torchwood is that always been very Welsh. It€™s set almost exclusively in Wales with a predominantly Welsh cast and the occasional good natured dig at the country and its people through the dialogue. But because Miracle Day is partly financed by an American cable network, they€™re suddenly able to call some of the shots, leading to the bulk of it being set in America. Children Of Earth was largely set in London but that makes sense as Torchwood€™s base is destroyed after the first episode and the attention of alien menace the 456 is on the UK government because of their previous dealings with them. But there€™s not really an explanation for most of Miracle Day being set in America other than that old adage of American network executives that people don€™t want to watch something that€™s outside of their frame of reference. So because of that, the series gets relocated wholesale to America with the flimsy explanation of the CIA rendering Torchwood, which makes no sense since the CIA has no connection to or authority over Torchwood especially since that, at the start of Series Four, it is defunct. But to keep established fans watching, there€™s the need to have parts of it set in Wales which leads to a ridiculous amount of continent hopping whenever a subplot in the UK needs advancing. Also, at 50 to 55 minutes long, each episode€™s five minutes shorter than it would have been had this been a series made with the BBC put first. Then again, this may not be such a bad thing given that probably the worst thing about the series was...

7. The Pacing

Miracle Day was far too long. Ten consecutive episodes (which was a number presumably ordered by the American backers) is far too long for a single story arc especially when some of the episodes are just filler. By the end of the sixth episode, we still barely know anything about what caused the Miracle or who€™s masterminding it. As mentioned, there€™s a massive amount of filler. Almost all of the second episode could have been cut without much bearing on the story but because they€™ve got to make the required episode count and have at least one budget-saving episode, we get almost an entire episode of Gwen and Jack on a plane being rendered. Admittedly, part of the episode is the discussion of how the world€™s medical system needs to be completely reformed because of the Miracle but that could have easily been shifted into a more streamlined second episode beginning with the rendition flight landing in America. As well as this, we get two episodes spent investigating the Overflow Camps (camps set up to treat and/or destroy people that overstretched medical facilities can€™t handle) which, other than featuring recurring character Vera Juarez€™s death and revealing what happens to peole that have been designated Category One (people who are braindead but physically can€™t die are incinerated), has no effect on the rest of the story. After two episodes spent infiltrating the Camp, in which the only significant thing that happens is Vera dying, we€™re told about massive public outrage over the Camps but don€™t really see it (which breaks the golden rule of €œshow, don€™t tell€) but nobody does anything about it after the purpose of the camps are revealed to the public which makes the whole thing a bit redundant. Episode Seven could have been massively stripped down as well. Cut the subplot of Jack and Italian immigrant Angelo€™s relationship (which went nowhere and made the episode feel a bit like Queer As Folk meets The X Files) and instead have a much shorter flashback in which Jack gets seriously injured in a fight and then heals which someone sees and thinks he€™s the devil, thus leading into the plot of him being held prisoner, killed repeatedly, and his blood being harvested and sold. Plus it would have much more of an impact on Jack to come face to face with his captor and repeated murderer on their deathbed in the present than him seeing an ex-lover in the same situation. After all, there€™s got to be quite a few of those scattered around time and space. Also, we€™re only told about the destruction of blood banks in Buenos Aires and Shanghai (facilities that were controlled by the Three Families (the people behind the Miracle) and held stocks of Jack€™s blood) that took place immediately after the Miracle in episode nine. Once again we€™re told not shown and it€™s only slotted in a few lines of dialogue right when it€™s relevant, with no foreshadowing whatsoever. Like I said though, there were just far too many episodes (five would have been perfect) and to meet that episode count there was just way too stuff much shoehorned in there that was either too drawn out or not developed enough. Which leads me to the next issue...

6. The Subplots

Miracle Day is a veritable Aladdin€™s cave of sub-plots. And, along with the pacing, that is its largest failing. As well as the main plot of nobody being able to die and the reasons for that, we€™ve got paedophile murderer Oswald Danes€™ rise to stardom after he is released from prison on a technicality, amoral PR agent Jilly Kitzinger moving through the ranks of the Three Families, Rex€™s relationship with Vera (which luckily ends pretty finally by the climax of episode five), Gwen€™s family problems, Esther€™s family problems, the mole inside the CIA, and Jack€™s relationship with Angelo. There are probably a few more that I€™ve missed there but that€™s at least seven subplots all jostling for screentime at varying points. A cult called the Soulless were featured heavily in the promo material with some press packs even including a Soulless mask but in the end they mean diddly squat. We get a few shots of them, one or two mentions of them and that€™s it. Wham bam thank you totally irrelevant plot point that didn€™t need to be in there at all. At other times, things just skipped over either because so much has been stuffed in, or because it€™s the easy way out. The eighth episode ends with Jack being shot (the Miracle removed his immortality making him the only person on Earth who can die) and the episode ends on a cliffhanger as Esther drives away with him. The next episode begins two months later with Jack pretty much in good health and the only explanation of how they got from America to Scotland despite all nations having closed their borders was that they got some people to smuggle them in. This is also the explanation for Oswald gets to Wales from America for the final few episodes despite the fact that he's a convicted murderer and paedophile. Had this been an ongoing series (in a similar mould to Survivors or The Walking Dead), the huge amount of subplots would have worked as the writers would have around twenty-four initial episodes to leisurely set them up and let them develop. But because it€™s a story that can€™t even satisfactorily span ten episodes in the way it€™s written, the majority of the subplots are drawn out too much, left dangling, or resolved unsatisfactorily.

5. The Tone

As mentioned, when it began, the writers of Torchwood desperately tried to set it apart from Doctor Who by making it swearier, sexier, and gorier. This calmed down as time went by, making the series look less adolescent but it was still thoroughly adult. Then came Children Of Earth. It was gritty and violent but in a more subtle way. It was as much a political thriller as it was a sci-fi one. Good news all round. Torchwood had finally matured and was worthy of its new timeslot on BBC One. But then came Miracle Day and all of that development seemed to go out the window. Russell T. Davies and co seem to have taken advantage of Miracle Day being co-financed and broadcast (at least in America) on a cable network free of strict regulations to cram as much body horror, intense violence, and hardcore sex into it as possible. Torchwood was a bit like this at the start but even though it was gory and filled with swearing and sex, it was daft and campy. Miracle Day tries to jettison as much lightheartedness as possible and make it straight-up depressing. The knock-on effect of this is that it feels a bit jarring, as there are still elements of the slightly campy tone of the first two series in there. As for the violence and the body horror, it just feels kind of unpleasant really. The gore itself isn€™t too much of an issue (at least not for me anyway) but there are just other bits that are so dark they feel out of place. Over the course of the series, we get a middle-aged woman being drugged and then put into a car crusher, someone being shot through the throat, the mass incineration of people who are still technically alive (and some of whom are still semi-conscious), Vera being burned alive, and the mention of a Rwandan genocide being foiled by the Miracle which the killers work around by bashing people over the head with hammers, chucking them in a mass grave, and then paving over it. Thankfully we never actually see that last one. As well as this, one of the most prominent recurring characters is a pedophile murderer who is completely unrepentant, repeatedly saying his victim should have run faster and eventually killing himself after the Miracle is reversed so that he can chase her into hell, his last words being €œKeep running, Susie€ It€™s understandable that a world without death would turn to crap and fair play to the writers for exploring that. But sometimes it€™s just far too visceral. And as for the sex scenes, I just personally don€™t think that they add much to the story and are a bit unnecessary. A dark tone is to be expected from something like Miracle Day but in a few places, I think they just went too far.

4. The Inconsistency Of The Miracle

Maybe it€™s a lack of cohesion on the part of the writers but the way the Miracle works just seems really inconsistent. The broad idea of it is this: humanity is in a state of undeath. People can grow old, suffer fatal injuries, and contract diseases with all the effects of them but they just won€™t die. Throughout the series, people find a way around this by coming up with ways to become brain-dead like jumping off of high roofs. Granted, it€™s an interesting part of the story but it makes no sense when, in the first episode, we see a suicide bomber still fully conscious hours after he sets off the explosives that are strapped to him and is subsequently decapitated, and a few episodes later a woman is murdered by being put through a car crusher and we see one of her eyeballs darting about in the wreckage. I don€™t profess to be an expert in human anatomy or neuroscience (In fact, I failed AS Level biology twice) but I€™m pretty sure that setting off a huge bomb that€™s strapped to you and then being decapitated or being put through a car crusher is enough to make you brain-dead even if physical death is impossible. And as for Oswald Danes, even though the lethal injection he is given couldn€™t kill him, surely it would seriously screw up his body and mind. Yet he never suffers any ill effects despite having harmful chemicals designed to kill pumped into his body. It just feels like the writers were plodding along and didn€™t bother to work out the finer details of the miracle until the characters had to know. And finally, two things relating to how the Miracle works: 1. There is nothing special about Jack€™s blood. His immortality is a result of Rose botching his resurrection after absorbing the Time Vortex, making him a fixed point in time and space. 2. Ignoring the first point and accepting that Jack€™s blood caused a new biological template for the human race, then surely everyone should have his healing powers instead of just being in a state of permanent undeath. After all, Rex gained immortality after replacing his blood with Jack€™s.

3. Rex And Esther

With a new series, came new characters to replace the dead ones (though thankfully there€™s no Ianto substitute for fans to get needlessly worked up about and literally build a public shrine to). The Torchwood Institute€™s latest recruits are CIA agent Rex Matheson and junior CIA analyst Esther Drummond Broadly, they€™re exact copies of former characters Owen Harper and Toshiko Sato, both of whom were killed off in the finale of Series Two. Esther is a shy genius without much aptitude for fieldwork but has incredible computer and data analysis skills. Sound familiar? The original casting call even gave her name as Esther Katsui, implying that the character would be of Oriental extraction, and stated that actors of all ethnicities bar Caucasians would be considered. So other than her race eventually being changed, she€™s more or less exactly the same as Tosh. As well as our Tosh substitute, we€™ve got Rex. He€™s undead with a fatal wound in his chest. Just like Owen (Eventually). He€™s sarcastic, reckless, and insults his colleagues. Just like Owen. And he has an awkward romance with a member of the team (as much as Vera Juarez can count as one) which is cut short by her being murdered. Just . Like. Owen. The only difference between the two of them is that, sadly, Rex never died permanently and now probably never will. The big problem with Rex, other than him being a copy of Owen, is that he€™s a bit of a knob to be honest. He€™s a hypocrite, angrily ranting at Esther for visiting her sister while they€™re on the run because it would enable people to trace them, and then later visiting his father. This would be a good instance for someone to call him out on it and take him down a peg or two except that the other characters never find out. He€™s supposed to be a hero but his hypocrisy is never discovered by anyone and never has any repercussions. But the main problem with him is that he€™s a complete moron. In the first episode, after he checks himself out of hospital mere hours after an injury that would have been fatal were it not for the Miracle (a moronic idea in itself) he grabs a bottle of pills off a nurse's tray and, without even looking at the label, he necks the entire bottle. Then in episode six, when a clearly unstable Overflow Camp administrator has him tied up, Rex tries to convince him to reveal how badly the Camp is being run to the authorities and tells him that he has incriminating video footage of the Camp€™s mismanagement. So while tied up by someone who€™s clearly mentally unstable and has already killed someone, Rex tries to convince to him to tell his bosses how badly he screwed up, and reveals that he has video footage of the murder. No CIA agent should be this stupid. Overall, he€™s just dislikeable, lacking any of the charm that the other characters in Torchwood had. And as for Esther, she just never really contributes. She€™s there to do the techie stuff and to die in the last episode. Other than her fight scene at the end of the sixth episode, she doesn€™t get many real moments to shine and, a lot of the time, just feels like a spare part. Still, at least it€™s better than Rex€™s particular brand of contributing to the team.

2. The Blessing

I€™m going to go ahead and address the elephant in the room right now. Who the hell designed this thing? No creature/organism in sci-fi has looked this much like a vagina since the Sarlacc in Return Of The Jedi. Okay, maybe that giant Facehugger at the end of Prometheus but the point still stands. And to add to the Freudian nightmare that is the Blessing, it sucks in blood like some kind of fleshy vacuum cleaner. Which makes you really wonder what happened to the guy who was pushed into it. But anyway, unfortunate character design aside, this is just a really stupid idea. The human race is living in symbiosis with an enormous organic underground crevasse that, coincidentally, has never been discovered by anyone in the course of human history except the Three Families and which changes the entire condition of the human race the moment someone pours Jack€™s blood into it. It also reveals the inner truth of yourself to you when you approach it. Because why not? But the most annoying thing is that we never find anything about it. After nine and a half episodes of buildup, waiting to find out what exactly this thing is and how it€™s able to change the whole of humanity, the answer we get is literally €œWe don€™t know€. That€™s what the Three Families tell Torchwood and, by extension, the audience. The thing is just there and they€™ve worked out how to use it to an extent but have no clue what the hell it is, where it came from, or what it does. Thanks, writers. What a satisfying conclusion. Oh and on another note, the Blessing runs right through the Earth. So how the hell do the characters face it while standing?

1. Practically No Aliens Or Paranormal Stuff

Admittedly, Torchwood has experimented with the absence of aliens before such as the Series One episode in which the antagonists were cannibals and several episodes that focussed on people coping with time displacement and had no real enemy. But these were small one-off episodes. This is an enormous ten part series with a single overarching narrative yet the only remotely alien stuff we get is some kind of parasitic worm that has absolutely no bearing on the plot and gets about half a minute of screentime before Jack blows its head off, and of course the Blessing. Which is somehow worse than no strange creatures at all. The story is way too focussed on the whole €œhumans are b*****ds€ angle and the wider idea of what would happen to a world without death to include an engaging paranormal antagonist. This is the series that gave us Weevils, alien blowfish on cocaine, and psychotic time travellers like Bilis Manger and John Hart. But here there€™s just not enough alien intervention. It would have been easy to work in an alien race somehow, perhaps having them in the background having planned out the Miracle to destabilise the human race to make invading the planet easier. The lack of aliens makes it feel less like Torchwood and more like a totally separate entity. Have any thoughts? Leave a comment...