'Digimon' has always been stuck under the shadow of its more popular counterpart, 'Pokemon'. Coming out two years after the juggernaut franchise, the 'Digimon' anime only lasted for four seasons before taking a three-year long break, returning for a fifth season, and then taking another three-year long break before getting a sixth. 'Pokemon', meanwhile, has been going strong since 1997 and continues to churn out movies and games in addition to new episodes, while 'Digimon' is little more than an afterthought in 2014. A mere footnote in the minds of most people who grew up in the 90s, 'Digimon' is usually seen as a copycat or imposter to the much more lucrative 'Pokemon' franchise. The similar name and premise invited many comparisons between the two shows. Some warranted, others less so. However, now that the first seasons of both shows are available to view on NetFlix, it's become clear when revisiting each show that while 'Pokemon' is the better franchise, 'Digimon' was the better show. And so, this list will outline the main points which prove the superiority of the 'Digimon' anime when compared to the 'Pokemon' television show. Before you read this, please note that I am a fan of both shows. I'm merely trying to shine a spotlight on the less beloved of the two franchises. Also, I have not seen the later seasons of either show so most of my points will be referring to only the first season of both. Since I cannot discuss in great detail what goes on in the later seasons, I can only make broad generalizations about what I've read about it on the Internet. So, while some may argue that 'Pokemon' got better as time went on, I would argue that it only took 'Digimon' 54 episodes to get it right the first time and to tell a better story. Anyways, on with the list. Obviously, some light SPOILERS will be sprinkled throughout.
8. The Digimon Could Talk
Since 'Digimon' came two years after 'Pokemon', upon first viewing of both shows as a child, I found it weird that Digimon could speak human languages. However, now that I've grown older, I find it much more conducive to an enjoyable show that each Digimon has a distinct voice and can speak complete sentences. Sure, the high-pitched voices of the In-Training Level Digimon can get pretty annoying but, fortunately, they don't stay in those forms for very long. And even then, they're still a lot more tolerable than hearing certain Pokemon repeat their own names over and over again. If only some of the other, more annoying, Pokemon had followed Meowth's example and learned how to talk, they'd be a lot more likeable. Dialogue is an important aspect of any show. As such, it helps to have characters interacting with each other to further develop their character traits and relationships with other characters. Being unable to do so severely limits what you can do with a voiceless character and hinders the storytelling aspect by limiting the amount of stories you can tell. I'm not saying it's impossible, just more difficult. Especially when you consider that there are over 150 characters in your repertoire that are incapable of speech. So not only does it make the Digimon better and more interesting characters with clear and understandable motivations, unlike their Pokemon counterparts, but it just makes for a better show when the heroes have a recognizable voice and can easily communicate with each other.
7. Divolution Wasn't Permanent
On 'Pokemon', a big deal was made about evolving Pokemon in the episode, "Electric Shock Showdown". In that episode, Ash thought about using a Thunder Stone to force Pikachu to evolve into Raichu so that he would be powerful enough to take on Lt. Surge's Raichu and earn a Thunder Badge. However, Pikachu adamantly refused to let Ash do this. Because in the world of 'Pokemon', evolution is permanent. While it adds an interesting wrinkle to the proceedings, this plot device also has its drawbacks. By keeping Pikachu as he is, it severely limits his character's growth, both literally and figuratively. As the perpetual underdog, it begs the question of why Ash doesn't use more stronger Pokemon when Pikachu isn't enough to best another trainer. Maybe if they had implemented the use of levelling up like they do in the games, it would make sense for Ash to keep Pikachu from evolving. But they didn't. Which means that they had to make up less believable scenarios about the bond Ash and Pikachu share and their mutual determination to be the best in order to explain how Pikachu is eventually able to overpower much stronger Pokemon. It's fairly hokey and lacking in logic, especially when Ash blatantly chooses to disregard basic rules like using certain types of Pokemon to exploit weaknesses. Digimon, on the other hand, don't have this problem. Instead, they're able to devolve back into their original forms whenever they run out of energy so digivolving doesn't result in the permanent loss of a character. This adds its own unique wrinkle to fighting battles. If the Digimon aren't well-fed, they can't digivolve into their more powerful forms. But if they're over-fed, they'll digivolve into an uncontrollable form that will demolish anything in its path. So there's still an element of strategy to consider. and it's done in a logical way. Not only does it provide an explanation for why Digimon can't stay in their most powerful forms all the time, but it also allows each Digimon to provide various uses depending on the form they're in. For example, Gomamon can command fish to form a raft that The DigiDestined can float on but Zudomon, his Ultimate form, can't. But by having access to both forms so long as he's not hungry, Gomamon becomes invaluable for more than just his most powerful form. It's a riveting aspect of the show that's used to great effect on more than one occasion.
6. Tags And Crests Are Better Than Gym Badges
Simply put, the tags and crests in 'Digimon' served a purpose. They allowed The DigiDestined to use them in conjunction with their Digivices to allow their Digimon to digivolve even further. Gym Badges, on the other hand, merely serve as a means to be allowed entry into a tournament. And Ash doesn't even have to beat a town's Gym Leader to earn them in some cases. Also, anyone can earn a Gym Badge, which means that there are numerous other trainers out there with similar badges. However, the crests were specific to each DigiDestined Tai had the Crest Of Courage, Matt had the Crest Of Friendship, Sora had the Crest Of Love, Mimi had the Crest Of Sincerity, Izzy had the Crest Of Knowledge, Joe had the Crest Of Reliability, T.K. had the Crest Of Hope and Kari had the Crest Of Light. Each of them had to prove themselves by displaying each trait before the crest was made available to them. So, even though it was tailor-made for their specific use, they still had to earn it. Now, whereas the Gym Badges do make for snazzy ornaments to adorn Ash's trademark vest, they really serve no other purpose than to act as decorations, especially once Ash eventually loses the tournament they're required for. Sure, the argument could be made that they're reminders of the numerous milestones Ash has accomplished throughout the years, but so are the friends he's made and the Pokemon he's captured. Both of which are less likely to outlive their usefulness, unlike the Gym Badges. The tags and crests, on the other hand, are vital to The DigiDestined's success and continue to serve a purpose. So, as far as trinkets go, they're definitely the better collectible. Plus, they look cool.
5. The Villains Weren't Treated As A Joke
Is there any more pathetic "villain" than The Team Rocket Trio of Jessie, James and Meowth? When they're not being blasted into the sky, they're being made to look like fools in a plethora of other different ways. Whether it's being soundly beaten by Ash and Pikachu, cross-dressing for no reason, or having their commands ignored by their own Pokemon, Team Rocket are clearly buffoons that aren't to be taken seriously. But even the Gym Leaders that Ash faces aren't really much of a threat, seeing as Ash has a tendency to do the same thing that Goku from 'Dragon Ball Z' does and befriend his enemies. As such, his Rogues Gallery is nothing more than a list of people he hasn't become friends with yet. And that lack of a proper villain makes everything seem superfluous in the long run. 'Digimon' on the other hand had a lot of proper villains, all of which were more than capable of being evil and tormenting The DigiDestined in interesting ways. Sure, they had a few "joke villains" like Etemon and DemiDevimon, but they were still treated as legitimate threats and caused numerous problems for our heroes. Plus, as The DigiDestined grew wiser and their Digimon became capable of digivolving to more powerful forms, the new crop of villains they wound up facing also became tougher to beat. The Dark Masters and Myotismon were all worthy adversaries, which made their eventual defeat all the more rewarding and overall satisfying.
4. The Stakes Were Higher
With a better class of villain also came greater dangers. Unlike in 'Pokemon' where most battles only resulted in a disheartened Ash or Pikachu, the battles in 'Digimon' were life and death. Although they were in The Digital World, Izzy made sure to explain to the others that a death in The Digital World would also result in similar consequences in the real world an aspect of the show that was toned down, for obvious reasons, but nevertheless was still prevalent throughout the rest of the episodes. Eventually, the situation was made even more dire when Myotismon and other dangerous Digimon began appearing in the real world, breaching the barriers between both worlds. That meant that the fate of two worlds was left in the hands of mere children. Stakes don't get any higher than that. But even before the later battles, The Digidestined had it rough right from the start. Not only did they have to survive long enough to figure out their situation in the beginning, but they also had to face off against larger Digimon like Kuwagamon and Shellmon back when their own Digimon were just relegated to their Rookie forms. Luckily, they were able to use their Digivices to level the playing field soon after, but don't overlook the fact that the threat of being eaten or destroyed at any moment, or even just starving to death, was entertained as an actual possibility. To see that in a kid's show is pretty harrowing stuff.
3. It Had A More Serious And Consistent Tone
Everything about 'Pokemon' is meant to be light-hearted and fun; Team Rocket's botched plans, Brock's lusting after every woman, Misty's anger at Ash for wrecking her bicycle, etc. Now, obviously, with it being a kid's show, that's perfectly normal and acceptable. However, after over 17 years of telling the same basic story over and over again, it can also get pretty tedious, especially after numerous repetitions taking place within the same episode, which is why most fans grow out of it at some point. Don't get me wrong, having a light-hearted show is fine. But it also limits the kind of stories you can tell and lessens the impact of the more emotional beats that you may want to include in later stories. For example, one of the best episodes of 'Pokemon' is "Snow Way Out", where Ash gets stuck in a cave in the freezing cold and all of his Pokemon come out of their Pokeballs to wrap themselves around him in order to give him warmth. It's a beautiful moment that has stuck with me for almost two decades now. But its impact is significantly lessened by the cheesy denouement that followed soon afterwards. Rather than build on the bond being formed between Ash and his Pokemon, the episode ends on Team Rocket hamming it up once again. It's just completely unnecessary. Plus, let's be honest, how seriously can you take Ash's various predicaments in any given episode when you know that each one ends with a "Poke-Rap"? 'Digimon', on the other hand, lets things play out naturally. They didn't rapidly switch gears from solemn to silly just to provide a cheerful conclusion to a story within a singular episode. And that more consistent tone made the show all the better for it.
2. It Had A Great Balance Between Serialized And Episodic Storytelling
Their refusal to quickly wrap up a storyline in order to achieve a cheery conclusion by the end of an episode leads me to my next point; 'Digimon' was, for most kids, their first foray into serialized television and story arcs. They provided numerous cliffhangers over the course of the show's run, even if an episode wasn't billed as a two-parter. Things weren't always neatly wrapped up by episode's end. The DigiDestined would be separated for multiple episodes and you would be left wondering for weeks at a time how they would be able to find their way back to each other again. This not only kept things interesting but also upped the danger factor. After all, the only thing worse than being trapped in a vast new world you're unfamiliar with is being trapped there alone. And therein lies the beauty of 'Digimon'. It challenged you as a kid. Not only did episodes end with cliffhangers but each of the first season's 54 episodes is divided into four distinct story arcs. This, in turn, made you want to watch the next episode right away to see what would happen. It's a simple but effective trick to retain viewers but it had seldom been done on children's television before. Most shows, like 'Pokemon', had short stories that could quickly be resolved in under 22 minutes. 'Digimon' had episodic chapters that told one complete story, while still being accessible enough for the average child. And each one built on the other to lead up to their grand finale. Which brings me to my final point...
1. It Had An Ending
The premise of 'Pokemon' is simple; Ash wants to be the greatest Pokemon master of all time. Unfortunately, it's a task that is near-impossible to ever fully accomplish, which is why it's the perfect premise for a children's TV Show and the basis for a lucrative franchise. There is no foreseeable end point to Ash's quest to become the best. However, the drawback is that you constantly need to find a new audience and draw new viewers in. People grow up and grow out of liking 'Pokemon' so, to keep it interesting, you need to make subtle changes to the formula. 'Digimon' never had this problem because, rather than force The DigiDestined to relive similar adventures in different locations with different Digimon, they allowed them to grow up. Some got married and had kids, some became rich and famous, but all were allowed to move past their childhood adventures. Most TV Shows intended for children have a habit of neglecting coming up with a proper conclusion for their story. This is because, in addition to most of their tales being stand-alone, most shows aim to stay on the air for as long as possible. So it's not really in the best interest of longevity to wrap up story lines with definitive endings. If Ash were to ever fully realize his dream of being the best Pokemon Master, there'd be no point in continuing his story. So, instead, most kid's shows opt to do a soft reset at the end of every episode, which is why Ash is constantly stuck on a loop of trying and never quite accomplishing his goals. 'Digimon', meanwhile, provided a satisfying conclusion to their epic adventure. The villains were vanquished, both worlds were saved and The DigiDestined actually fulfilled their destiny. They set out to do something and they actually did it, unlike Ash, who always seems to fail whenever it matters the most. Then, in the second season, save for T.K. and Kari, they introduced new characters and built upon what they had already established. In fact, each subsequent season of 'Digimon' tried to do something different and creative with their story. And while none of the later seasons were ever as successful as the initial premise, the people behind them have to be admired for trying something different and attempting to evolve along with their audience. That's why, although 'Pokemon' is clearly the more successful franchise, 'Digimon' is more worthy of revisiting.