Game of Thrones has never failed to shock audiences, for better or worse. From the first episode it was clear this was a show like no other. Typical television drama might involve a handful of characters, a modest budget and a simple plot, but Game of Thrones has always felt more cinematic. That's because, rather than conforming to expectations, the show has aimed to transcend what television is capable of, forcing us to re-imagine what we expect to see when we tune in for an evening of television. This is not always necessarily for the better. Fans and critics alike have argued about the gratuity of violence and sex, as well as more fundamental issues such as pacing - at times the enormous cast can appear bloated and become a hindrance rather than a strength - but it can never be said the show isn't engaging. With such a massive budget, and source material from the pages of one of the most popular book franchises ever, Game of Thrones has provided some of the most startling, unique and surely influential moments in television history. Some have been praised unanimously by fans and critics; all have stirred controversy. These are the eight shocking scenes from the show which have had (or will have) a lasting impact on television and pop culture.
Advertisement
8. Cersei And Jaime Are Discovered
Winter Is Coming | Season 1 | Episode 1 What better place to start than with a scene from the first episode. The audience was already aware this was an unusual TV program, with a number of locations, sprawling cast and fictional customs crammed into the episode's first 45 minutes, but the final scene really was startling. Bran climbs to the top of the highest tower in Winterfell and unexpectedly stumbles upon the Queen having sex with her brother Jaime. Most shows would have ended the episode at this point - the perfect 'cliffhanger'. However, this was not the case. Jaime instead strides to the window and pushes Bran out. Of course we learn an episode or two later that Bran will live (minus his ability to walk), but the subject matter and cruelty in this one scene really pushes the boundaries of what an audience can expect from a television show. Incest and infanticide are rarely dealt with at all on prime time TV, let alone in the same scene. Whether it's your cup of tea or not, it's certainly bold. Ever since the first episode, the show has eschewed 'cliffhangers', and particularly in relation to the bigger, more important episodes, opted to make something more self-contained. This is not merely coming from Game of Thrones - it is a hallmark of many top shows at the moment - but it's certainly leading the charge.
7. The Battle Of Castle Black
The Watchers on the Wall | Season 4 | Episode 9 Game of Thrones is responsible for expanding the scale on which television can now operate. With an increased budget comes greater spectacle, and there are a number of scenes which could be chosen to represent this. Usually the penultimate episode of each series is the one when the viewer expects an epic battle scene that could rival cinema for grandeur and scale. Blackwater might have been chosen, but overall the visual effects just weren't quite up to scratch. The Battle of Blackwater, however, was really brought to life in a way that could not have happened on another TV show. It is revolutionary because it was the first time television truly challenged the ambitious set-pieces of cinema. Four seasons had built to this moment, as Mance Rayder and his Wildlings finally descend on Castle Black. Jon and his crew are perilously short of men and resources but fight on manfully, defending the wall until Stannis rides in to save the day. The scene is also notable for its effective use of CGI, with giants and mammoths laying siege to the castle to the castle, and for once, on television, not looking out of place. At one point the camera pans 360 degrees across the entire battle, with 100s of perfectly choreographed extras mingling with the main characters to create an awesome on-screen spectacle. It's rare see a scene of this scale and ambition outside of a handful of cinema releases each year, so hopefully we'll begin to see more of this stuff on TV from now on.
6. The Death Of Oberyn
The Mountain and the Viper | Season 4 | Episode 8 This may sound a little strange but Game of Thrones is increasing realism on TV. It might not make sense immediately, what with this being fantasy and all, but its true. In most other shows, the good guy always wins, even if his opponent is 8 feet tall and make exclusively from chain mail and muscle. In Game of Thrones, if a character comes up against a giant, or a dragon, or the most fearsome warrior in the land, they lose. No scene exemplifies this better than the battle between Oberyn Martell and The Mountain. The Mountain is a rapist and a child murderer, so of course we want Oberyn to win. Even as we get a good look at the size difference between the two of them we think he's got a fighting chance. It doesn't work out that way of course. The bigger man wins. If you're an underdog, that has to be played out in the scene. Of course the underdog can still win - just look at Tyrion at Blackwater - but the victories for the little guy are kept relatively low to keep us guessing. Leave it to a fantasy TV show to keep our expectations in check.
5. The Battle of Hardhome
Hardhome | Season 5 | Episode 8 Carrying on the theme of transcending what a TV show is capable of in terms of scale and budget, we arrive at Hardhome, which does everything The Battle of Castle Black started, but with better execution, and arguably more ambition. While Castle Black was a case of reaching for the sort of action cinema is capable of and achieving it relatively convincingly, this is more about perfection - this epic scene really wouldn't look out of place in a Lord of the Rings film. This is revolutionary television because it once again broadens the capabilities of the medium, proving television is not just the place for soaps and costume drama, but for live action on an epic scale. Kit Harrington recently revealed the show had received a substantial boost to its already hefty (by TV standards) budget. While television dramas still have to be more thrifty with their spending, episodes like this prove its possible to expand what is possible if done with care.
4. Sexposition
You Win Or You Die | Season 1 | Episode 7 Whether the influence of this particular scene will turn out to be a positive one is open to debate, and it has been argued The Sopranos got there first, but 'sexposition' was a term coined specifically to describe a technique used in a scene from Game of Thrones. Petyr 'Littlefinger' Baelish is in his brothel, advising his prostitutes on how to pleasure their customers. He has the girls make love while he talks to them. As the scene progresses, the viewer slowly realises that when Littlefinger talks about manipulation, he is talking about himself as much as the girls in front of him, leading him eventually to disclose his motives, confirming our suspicions that it is him playing the role of puppet-master to Ned Stark. 'Sexposition' may be a term retrospectively applied to shows like The Sopranos and Deadwood, but it was applied for the first time to this scene. It has naturally caused controversy, not simply for its gratuitousness, but for what some deem an exploitative, overly self-conscious method of storytelling - some more cynical critics suggesting the writers have chosen to wrap up a long section of dialogue in a distracting sex scene so the viewer won't become bored. A further criticism is that exposition of this nature shouldn't really be appearing in a high-quality TV drama anyway, and that the audience should learn the story organically rather than being told it. Whatever your position, it's certainly a storytelling technique which became popular because of the show.
3. Stannis Kills His Daughter
Traditional storytelling on mainstream film or television has a fairly strict code that it adheres to. The good guy might suffer a crisis of identity, or act like a dick for a bit, but he never, ever burns his daughter alive to appease the Gods. Since first appearing on the show in Season 2, Stannis has become a sort of Game of Thrones anti-hero: hard-boiled and misanthropic, tortured but ultimately one of the 'good guys'. That's a mistake we made though; we confused honour or a seemingly predictable set of behaviour patterns with goodness. In actuality there is no good or bad in Game of Thrones. An anti-hero such as Stannis can do good things or bad things, can move backwards or forwards, but he is not innately one quality or the other. Game of Thrones is changing the way we view character. It is doing so by returning to the mythology of Ancient Greece, with petty Gods and problems encountered which are difficult for modern audiences to empathise with. To most viewers Stannis committed the ultimate crime when he killed his daughter, but the story emulates the story of Agamemnon which has existed for millenia - in other words its not new, it's just unfamiliar, uncomfortable territory for TV.
2. The Red Wedding
The Rains of Castamere | Season 3 | Episode 9 Like with Oberyn's and Shireen's deaths, this scene is one which flies in the face of traditional TV storytelling, leaving everyone who watches it shaking their head in disbelief. While TV teaches us to believe that good guys always win, or that if they don't, they go out in a blaze of glory, The Red Wedding showed audiences around the world that this won't be the case anymore, no matter how much they want it to so. Robb Stark's military campaign to avenge his father is gathering pace, and he has defeated the Lannister's in battle already. Robb, his mother, and allies attend the marriage ceremony of Walder Frey's daughter to Edmure Tully. As the marriage ceremony ends, and the celebrations begin, the traditional Lannister tune 'The Rains of Castermere' is struck up. Lady Catelyn's suspicions are further aroused when she notices Roose Bolton is wearing chainmail. Quickly Frey's men descend on the Stark's and it becomes clear that an extraordinary betrayal has taken place. The Stark's and their followers are completely obliterated. The reason this scene changed television forever is that it provided the audience with something it had never seen before - arguably it was something they never wanted in the first place, and therein lies the genius of it. While most television shows preserve their protagonists at all costs, Game of Thrones does the opposite, killing off the honourable good guys because it doesn't consider honour a virtue; rather, it is a weakness. This scene in particular makes us question the values we bring to television and tells us we're wrong. It destroys our expectations and desires and gives us something unimaginable instead. Very few TV programs were willing to do this before this scene - how many will do so in the future is hard to tell.
1. The Death of Ned Stark
Baelor | Season 1 | Episode 9 This is where Game of Thrones' ability to shock and make us completely rethink how TV told stories began. Sean Bean was the focus of press interviews and the show's marketing campaign in preparation for its release, and was the central focus of nearly all of the episodes until this point. Of course, readers of the books knew what was coming, but most viewers did not. After being named Hand of the King, Ned finds himself following a trail of clues which lead him to a revelation he could have done without: that Cersei's children are not the King's after all, but her brother's instead. Rather than shrewdly keeping this quiet, he confronts Cersei and says the throne will be given to Stannis Baratheon, now the the King is dead. Naturally Cersei disagrees, seizes him and sentences him to death. On the scaffold, Ned is convinced to make a false plea to save his life, but to no avail, he is executed anyway, and chaos ensues. Never before had television created a main character and made the actor a central feature of press and advertising, only to kill him off before the end of the first season. Audiences didn't know what to think or view because this had never happened to them before. Right before the sword comes down, an army is supposed to appear which frees the captive. Unbelievably to those who were unfamiliar with the books, this didn't happen. It is arguable that the Red Wedding carries greater shock value, but this was the first example on the show, and possibly of television in general, of audience expectations being horribly subverted. The main contribution Game of Thrones has made to television has been in the storytelling - that all characters are expendable in order to further the plot; that there are no real 'central' characters any more; and that good guys really do finish last. This scene encapsulates all those things perfectly.