8 Silly TV Plot Conveniences Made Possible By Utterly Stupid Writing

Can you feel the awkward desperation? In these cases, TV audiences certainly could.

By Charlie Oldfield /

TV: the home of such glorious creations as The Inbetweeners USA, Mrs. Brown's Boys, and the great detective show Elementary. Not glorious in the sense of being brilliant, obviously, but more in the sense of a wet turd sliding slowly down a bathroom wall, leaving a sickly trail of brown regret behind it. We're not here to talk about those shows, though, despite what the title may lead you to believe. The focus of this article is those shows that are actually pretty good, maybe even great, but have one notable moment that hangs over them like a black spot, coming about after the writers trapped the plot in a corner and decided throwing dribble at the problem was the best way around it. Misery's Annie Wilkes famously said: "It doesn't have to be realistic, it just has to be fair," and yet our list certainly doesn't agree, bringing forward the cases where the writing became so utterly ridiculous many viewers felt (and still feel) cheated out of their time. It should go without saying, yet we'll say it anyway: spoilers aplenty ahead.

8. Farewell To Brian - Family Guy

This is probably the most topical item on our list, yet at the same time it is also a classic example of stupid writing. Recently in Family Guy, main character Brian Griffin was killed off and replaced with a fairly uninteresting Italian stereotype, causing the internet to explode with chants of 'Bring Back Brian,' demonstrating how people care a whole lot more about the show than many of us would dare to believe. Of course Brian was always going to come back (anyone with half a brain could see that), but the speed and stupidity in which it was done gives it a place on our list. In essence the show pulled a Superman, simply having a character go back in time and stop the fatal incident taking place, in this case using a baby's time-machine rather than flying around the world really fast. What makes the time-machine get-out-clause even worse is that Stewie had actually destroyed the device before Brian's death, only to get another one two episodes later. Time travel is the ultimate stupid plot convenience enabler, yet Family Guy isn't a show claiming any great narrative, so we can't vindicate them too harshly.

7. Plane Crash - Breaking Bad

Nobody panic! Before you all start throwing knives at your computer screen and hoping to hit me, let's get a few qualifiers out the way: one, Breaking Bad is a great show, not perfect perhaps, but great, so don't think its inclusion on our list is a suggestion of anything otherwise; two, it makes our list more because of suspected cowardice than stupidity, yet it's similar enough to the titular topic for us to justify its inclusion; and three, this isn't an attempt to fish for views (which some of you were doubtlessly ready to accuse me of), as if we wanted to do that we'd have written 'Eight Reasons Breaking Bad Sucks.' Throughout the second series of Breaking Bad, then, viewers are given brief snippets of footage from the aftermath of some event set to take place in the series finale, upping the suspense of what's to come and thus keeping viewers engaged. It becomes quickly apparent that the event, whatever it was, took place at protagonist Walter White's house, with police forensic specialists picking-up items strewn around the garden and putting them in evidence bags (including Walter's glasses, heavily suggesting he was involved in what went down). Some of the footage shown later in the series reveals two dead bodies in front of Walter's house, both covered to keep anonymity. There is no way viewers are expected to see this and not assume at least one of them is a main character. In the following episode, after a drug lord finds out Walter secretly has a brother-in-law in the DEA, viewers are shown there are not just two bodies in front of the house but that there are tens of them scattered up and down the street. Cue anticipation for a major confrontation and show-changing consequences! Well... not quite. Instead of getting a big end of series showdown, all that happens is two planes crash above Walter's house, resulting in hundreds of people that didn't get a second's screen time being inconsequentially killed off. Before you say it, yes we are aware it is a direct result of Jesse's girlfriend dying that the plane crashes, but so what? The crash itself makes absolutely no difference to the plot or the characters, with Walt and Jesse already feeling so guilty over the dead girl that a bit of extra angst couldn't matter less.

6. Robot Doctor Decoy - Doctor Who

There are so, so, so many examples of bad writing in Doctor Who, but we've settled for this one in particular. A few series back the Doctor apparently dies in the first episode, getting shot by someone in an Astronaut costume in front of his wife and companions. His death is confirmed later on when a database containing all dates from the past and future listed the day of the shooting as the Doctor's death, meaning there's no chance it was anybody else (a problem we will get to shortly). However, a robot is introduced mid-series that can take on the appearance of any living thing. At the time some speculated this might be used to fake the Doctor's death, but fans quickly rejected the idea as stupid. Then, when it came to the end of the series, this speculation turned out to be true. The robot takes the form of the Doctor and gets shot so that our hero's enemies think him dead and he can henceforth do whatever he likes. Not only is this an example of unbelievably stupid writing used to further the plot, it also doesn't make sense. The Doctor does so much after this event, including regenerating (only once so far), that any creature/robot/database with vague time-travel abilities should know immediately that the death was fake. Consequently, it is both unrealistic and unfair, making no sense and insulting viewers with its blatant stupidity.

5. Return Of Bobby - Dallas

Come on kids, sing along with us! Everyone knows what Dallas did, even those (like myself) who know literally nothing else about the show, so let's get it over with. On the show, the writers killed off a main character. It was a big moment for the show, displaying a level of bravery still rare to be seen on American television, giving it an edge that many of its competitors lacked. Then came the shower scene. A long while after the character died, an episode had a young woman wake up in bed to the noise of a shower going. Getting up, she walked into the bathroom, confused as to who could be in her house, pulled back the shower-curtain and oh-my-gosh there he was, Mr. Dead-Guy having a shower. We don't mean in a scary Stephen King way you understand - that would have been a very different direction for the show to go in. No, it was the guy who should have been dead, who, after seeing the worried girl in the bathroom with him, gave her a hug and said: "Hey, hey, what's wrong? Don't worry, it was just a bad dream, all a bad dream." Actually that probably wasn't the exact wording, yet it gets the gist across alright. What was meant by this heart-warming scene was that the many hours of television seen between the characters death and his appearance in the shower had all been a dream, making it utterly inconsequential and a waste of time to even watch.

4. Sylar Lives! - Heroes

Heroes, for those not too quick-on -the-mark, is a show about superheroes. Set in the real world, the show follows the story of many different characters that discover they have extraordinary powers, such as the ability to fly or turn invisible, and how this affects their lives. The villain, or at least the only one anyone remembers, is called Sylar, played by Zachary Quinto. There are a few points over the show's run where stupid or lazy writing allows irritating plot conveniences, most of which involve teleporting, multiple-personalities, or time-travel, yet we are pushing those to one-side in order to focus on two highly similar examples involving Sylar, as these are the most interesting to talk about/the most note-worthy. At the end of series one everything gets wrapped up quite nicely; serial-killer Sylar gets stabbed to death, the protagonist finally accepts himself, and the plot generally gets tied-up in a lovely little bow. At the start of series 2 however, we learn that Sylar is actually fine, having been fixed up by a mysterious none super-power company called err... The Company. Great imagination there, ah guys? Anyway, saving the villain was a fairly cowardly move on the production's part, clearly realising he was a popular character and thus deciding to drag him out until everyone's sick of the sight of him. It demonstrates not only that the writers had no plan post series one, but also that they didn't really understand or think much of their audience, with Sylar being the first in a long line of characters the show just refused to kill off. Our second problem follows on from this. After coming back, Sylar spends three series absorbing the powers of other heroes, meaning that by the middle of series 4 he is invincible, a shape-shifter, a telekinetic, able to fly, and able to do pretty much anything of which one might be able to think. Knowing they could no longer kill the character, Sylar is sedated and, using the powers of a mind-reader/controller, convinced he is someone else and doesn't have any powers. This is a great concept, as it means Sylar would forever be trapped inside the prison of his own body, yet not even aware that was the case. And then, come series five, and they just... well, had him remember again. Seriously, that was it: he just remembered again. This is a desperately used plot convenience used to unnaturally extend a show's life-span. It was the last-straw for viewers and the show was cancelled after series 5.

3. Wishing Really Hard - Doctor Who

Doctor Who really is ripe with stupid writing, and who are we not to take advantage of that? Once more we're talking about the death of the Doctor, but this time from a little earlier, when the titular character sacrificed his own life in order to stop the entire Universe plopping out of existence. The series finales had been gradually escalating for years, going from the Earth being threatened with destruction, then the galaxy, then the universe, and finally the entirety of space and time. Cracks in the fabric of reality threaten to delete everything that ever had or will happen, with the only way to stop it being for the Doctor to kill himself and remove himself from the timeline because reasons. Consequently, nobody alive is able to remember the Doctor due to him being erased from their minds, meaning there can never be a way for someone to clone him or bring him back to life. Post his deletion from time, companion Amy Pond is teleported to a wedding (her own), which she'd kept being put off due to adventures with the Doctor. Now here comes the problem, and it's a doozy. Even though we are told moments before it would be impossible for anyone to remember the Doctor, Amy gets distracted by a shiny thing at her wedding and is instantly reminded of him. Then, with the Doctor held firmly in her minds eye, she brings him back to existence by closing her eyes and wishing really hard. That, dear readers, is quite literally what happens.

2. Millionaires No More - Only Fools And Horses

Our penultimate choice was once considered the funniest thing on British television, capturing the national zeitgeist and using it to make the show relatable in a way few others have ever managed. For those of you who don't know, Only Fools and Horses is about two working class brothers who keep trying get-rich-quick schemes that inevitably fail, with one of the older brother's many catchphrases being: "This time next year we'll be millionaires!" It left viewers rooting for the protagonists to finally make it, and eventually they did! The characters find a watch that, when sent to auction, gets them tens of millions of pounds. The final scene has the brothers saying goodbye to their stingy working class flat which they had lived in since childhood, a moving affair which left some viewers in tears. Rags-to-riches stories aren't exactly rare on the British Isles, yet Only Fools and Horses crafted their's with such love and originality it stuck in the public's mind more than almost any other. But why let a dead donkey rest? It's always best to kick it a few more times to see if you can get anything else out of it, don't you think? No? Well the makers of Only Fools certainly did. A few years after this moving episode the writers decided to have the characters lose all their money in stocks, a rather childish plot convenience used to drag the show's corpse a few more feet and rake in whatever cash they could. The move actively damaged the legacy of the show, rendering the moving episode that previously served as the finale a triviality that meant nothing to the overarching plot.

1. The Old Ones - Being Human (UK)

Few series have fallen from grace as spectacularly as Being Human, but this isn't about the show's abysmal fifth series. No, the show makes our list because of the finale of series 4, aka the most disappointing finale of all time. Revolving around a friendship group consisting of a werewolf, a vampire, and a ghost, the first three series have frequent mentions of these monstrous being called The Old Ones, a race of thousand year old vampires set on taking over the world and spoken about in hushed tones by even the vilest of bad-guys. Series 4 sees the arrival of The Old Ones. Numerous flash-forwards show Earth in ruins after the successful take-over by the group, with humans only kept alive in slave-form in order to preserve a source of food for their vampire overlords. Earth's only hope is a baby called Eve (not at all cliche...) prophesied to destroy the vampires, and the show seems to be building to some war or huge 40 Days of Night style confrontation. How could these Old Ones, these villains more strategic and cunning than the finest human generals, smarter and more adaptable than Sherlock Holmes himself, possible be stopped? Well, rather easily as it turns out. Having written themselves into a corner with these unbeatable nasties, the writers produce what can only be described as the most anticlimactic scene in television history. Step one: the writers put the entire group of ancient vampires in one room, with these wise beings apparently seeing no problem with this despite being hunted by one of their own and a ghost with a history of supernatural murder. Step two: Mad ghost woman bursts into the aforementioned room carrying baby Eve and a bomb, yet only a single Old One thinks to leave. Mr White, the group's leader, suggests they are under no threat from this mad ghost with a bomb, despite it being a day before their invasion is set to begin and the ghost's obvious fatal threat. So, thanks to the vampires making no attempt to stop her, the ghost enters the room, talks briefly about the baby and how its death will save the world (during which time the 'strategic genius' vampires simply stand still and watch her) before blowing herself up. That's it, all gone, villains dead. Four series building to a brief conversation and a bad CGI explosion. Are there any notable examples you think we missed? Share your thoughts in the comments.