If the hope of Trekkers around the world for the new Star Trek movie was to delve into the relationships and backgrounds of the characters, or to explore deep-seated questions of intergalactic politics and morality, they were deeply mistaken. More than likely my fellow Trekkies walked out of the movie amazed at the visual effects but as Star Trek movies go found the movie unsatisfying. I hear them ask: Where are the plotlines that make me think? Where the heck are the discussions about that oh so provocative and seemingly self-serving prime directive? Where are the new worlds? In the new movies J.J Abrams does a wonderful job of sidelining any heavy thought provoking issues. He puts the characters in situations in which neither the characters nor the audience has to think about what the right course of action is. Vulcan is blown up we have to get the bad guys. There is a rogue officer/ terrorist on the loose we have to catch him. However, if you are thirsting for more plot, more thought, more character development and more dare I say it - civilization with a hint of cowboy diplomacy then Star Trek Deep Space Nine may be your cure. Take this trip down memory lane with me as we rediscover the most awesome of plotlines ever developed for Star Trek, plotlines that still have relevance today and the type of plotlines that have kept Trekkies coming back to Star Trek over and over again. Welcome to Deep Space Nine.
8. The Dominion War
What happens when the Federation and its allies go to war? Unlike the new movies, there are no whispers of war here. You see the battles, the deaths and the Klingons in all of their glory. Star Trek DS9 is no Klingon tease. In this series we saw the slow march to war. With each exchange between the Federation and the Dominion war became a little bit more inevitable. This storyline begged the question of whether war could have been avoided? Should the Federation have honored Dominion boarders and stayed on their side of the wormhole instead of insisting on exploration space exploration or was war assured the moment Sisko discovered the wormhole? This incarnation also examined how the rules of war seemingly change for the loosing side. Was it right for Captain Sisko to lie to get the Romulans in the war on the side of the Federation? Was it right for a Federation admiral to stage a shut down of Earths power stations in order to prove the vulnerability of Earth? How much freedom were humans willing to give up in order to feel safe against only two Changelings who happened to be on the planet. Sound familiar? Im just sayin!
7. The Cardassians
Ah, what do you do with neighbors that think they are the natural rulers of the entire Alpha Quadrant? Neighbors that you have already went to war with only to have it end in a ceasefire? You try to give them what they want! There is another name for that appeasement. Deep Space Nine shows the long history of appeasement towards the Cardassians starting with Star Trek: The Next Generation. The Federation gave them border colonies that were once under Federation rule, creating the Maquis, colonist who fought the Cardassians for their homes and way of life. The Federation also turned a blind eye for fifty years to the occupation of Bajor. But no good deed (questionably) goes unpunished the Cardassians entered the war on the Dominion side. Should the Federation have dealt with the Dominion when they had the chance before the inclusion of the Dominion? Does appeasement ever work? Or does it make the appeased want more, more power, more territory?
6. Terrorism The Maquis
We have all heard the adage, one mans freedom fighter is another mans terrorist. However Deep Space nine asks the question: What make a terrorist a terrorist and a freedom fighter a freedom fighter? How does a group fighting for their homeland turn into a terrorist organization? Who is in charge of the definitions? Are the Maquis terrorist? Why, because they did not abide by the Cardassian-Federation treaty, a treaty they were not consulted on. How much should you give up to be a part of a wider organization? Should you give up the right to fight for your home so that the greater Federation may live?
5. Religion
Two religions were outlined in Star Trek Deep Space Nine. The Prophets of the Bajorans and the Changelings of the JemHadar The Bajoran people are a deeply spiritual people. They believe in their gods, i.e. the Prophets and these gods are tangible. Proof is not needed of their existence, however, faith is needed as proof that they care for the Bajorans. The running question of the series is: How can an entire planet have faith in gods that did nothing to intervene in the atrocities that occurred during the occupation of the planet. Well there was that one time when they made thousands of Dominion ships disappear in the wormhole en route to the station BUT they also exacted a penance from Sisko for doing so. If the Bajorans are hands off gods, the Changelings are control freaks. They have literally created the people that worship them, the JenHadar, who also double as their army. In the series, even Sisko reveres the Prophets as gods eventually but the Changelings never receive this treatment. Are gods only gods when they are all powerful but yet do not intervene? When they live up to our highest ideals of morality? When they literally create their own worshippers? What constitutes a god? Even if you have gods should you be willing to die for them.
4. Racism
From the first interracial kiss between Kirk and Uhura, Star Trek has never been afraid to address the subject or make us feel awkward about our prejudices. Star Trek Deep Space Nine was no different. In a poignant episode, Captain Sisko experiences a vision given to him by The Prophets in which he is transformed into Benny Russell, a African American, sci-fi writer in the 1950s who had a vision for a story that included a black commander of a space station (hint, hint). The publisher would not accept the story because it was thought the public would not accept a black commander. The storyline dealt with Bennys inability to come to terms with this fact, the fact that he could not dream in color. In the end Sisko is reminded that he is the dream as well as the dreamer.
3. Romance
One of the things that will drive your crazy about the new Star Trek movies is that Uhura and Spock are only in a relationship on paper. They dont touch, they dont talk, and you never see them in a truly intimate moment, a moment where you feel as if they really do have some connection. It is almost as if they are brother and sister who give each other pecks on the cheek from time to time. This is not what you get from DS9. Both the actors and the writers go all in. If someone is in a relationship on DS9, they are in a relationship. You get to see the loving moments such as when Odo touches noses with Kira or when you see a wedding photo beside Worf and Jadzias bed or when Keiko decides to wear OBriens favorite dress despite the fact that she is tired. That way when they do argue the audience can hope for reconciliation because something precious may be lost. Right now, I dont care if Uhura and Spock make it or not. DS9 also explores the full range of relationships from Dax and Worf, exploring how we can be clueless and miss what is right in front of us. To Odo and Kira beautifully exploring the awkwardness of turning a friendship into a relationship. Kieko and OBrien explore married life, career compromises and raising a family and Sisko and Cassidy explore tragic love, falling for someone that you know can only end in heartbreak especially when The Prophets tell Sisko that his path is his to walk alone.
2. People Working Together
In past incarnations of Star Trek, everyone was a Starfleet officer; everyone knew Starfleet protocol on every matter and everyone respected the chain of command for the most part. There was no grit. This incarnation of Star Trek however, managed to showcase people working together who had nothing in common, had their own agendas and didnt necessarily have Starfleet protocol to end all debate and bickering. Yet, they managed to work together. Garak and his shifting alliances but his loyalty to the Cardassians, Kira, who has a loyalty to Bajor, Worf who has a increasing loyalty to the Klingon Empire, Quark whose only loyalty is to money and Odo whose only allegiance was to justice came together to ensure a smooth running station. So why cant Spock and Kirk agree on the rules that they have pledged to uphold?
1. Major Character Growth
One of the real downfalls of the new movies is that there is no character development. You always return to where you were in the beginning. Kirk and Spock are still frenemies, Spock and Uhura are still ambiguous and there is no relationship building between the other characters. Deep Space Nine gives you nice character progression throughout the seasons. One cannot say that Kira is the same person that she was when the series began. When the series began she would have let Cardassia be sacked and burned instead of helping them in their fight for freedom from the Dominion. Odo is not the same either, while during the first season he did not value friendships, now he does. Jadzia Dax became more comfortable in her skin as an incarnation of Dax, she felt worthy of the symbiont she carried that is before she died. Quark developed a conscious of sorts and did not just rely on greed. Nog became the first ever Ferengi Starfleet officer. Everyone grew. Also long lasting friendships were born. Kira stopped looking at Sisko as just the emissary. Sisko and Dax deepened a friendship that has lasted through three lifetimes. Jadzia Dax and Bashir turned what used to be simple flirtations into friendship built on respect. Bashir and Garak forged their friendship over weekly dinners during the whole of the series. Jadzia Dax and Kira became best friends. Quark finally started to respect his brother, Rom. These people were intertwined in each others lives and because you saw the friendships and bonds form naturally highly emotional scenes between the characters became more believable and less forced unlike the scene between Kirk and Spock in Into Darkness Thats my list! What are some of your favorite Star Trek plotlines?