8 TV Scenes Everyone Always Gets Wrong

How many times do we have to say you aren't supposed to like Rick before you get it?

By John Tibbetts /

Objectivity in art is a myth. There is no truly, 100%, objectively correct interpretation of a piece of media. Everyone always has a take, and even if the creator comes down from on high and tells their side of the story, it's ultimately just another reading of the work.

Advertisement

With that having been said, there are people whose takeaway from a work is just, well, wrong. No two ways about it, they're just wrong.

Whether they're projecting themselves onto the work, reading it in bad faith, or are just fundamentally not getting it, there are a lot of ways people can miss the point something is trying to make.

You would think a visual medium like television, where every single detail down to the dust on the furniture on the set is under meticulous control, would mitigate this somewhat. And you would be wrong. These are the scenes from beloved television series that a disturbing amount of people just cannot wrap their heads around.

8. Jerry And Pals Go To Jail - Seinfeld

The selling point about Seinfeld was that it was a show about nothing. While in some cases this was true, what the show turned out to actually be about was four funny, but absolutely terrible human beings, and their mundane problems caused by them being terrible human beings.

Advertisement

Many fans miss out on this - a running theme you're going to notice on this list - and so, to them, the ending comes out of nowhere and makes no sense.

Now, granted, the finale does have quite a few logical flaws - ask any lawyer worth their salt and they'll tell you that the trial is a NIGHTMARE of legal flaws and fallacies - but the idea was to end the series with Jerry and pals getting their comeuppance for nine seasons of being mundanely infuriating.

Which puts it quite a bit above other comedies about so-called "horrible" people who never really face consequences for their nonsense.

7. Daenerys Burns King's Landing - Game Of Thrones

The final season of Game Of Thrones was a kind of disastrous ending that we don't see that often. Plenty of great shows have bad endings, but season 8 of GoT didn't just disappoint fans, it took a show that RULED THE DAMN WORLD, and wiped it off the face of pop culture forever.

Advertisement

With that having been said, sticking up at all for this season can cause one to lose all credibility and be subjected to truly vicious mockery. But if your writer cared about that sort of thing, they wouldn't choose to be the only vocal defender of Rise Of Skywalker, now would I?

How the show handled Daenerys' fall from grace was not well executed at all, but the idea that her burning down King's Landing came completely out of nowhere is simply wrong. This is a woman who has only ever had and needed one solution for her problems: if it's in my way, it burns.

King's Landing was in her way, so King's Landing burned.

Daenerys' fall represents a character's most admirable trait - in her case, her unwavering conviction and belief in her own righteousness - being turned into her greatest failing. Turns out that people with that kind of conviction can be real a**holes when they're suddenly on the other side of the argument.

Which more fans would understand... if the actual execution of this downward spiral wasn't a complete clusterf*ck. Again, this season is bad, no argument here.

6. Number 6's Escape - The Prisoner

The Prisoner is a show that's very easy to get wrong, since its particular type of insanity is the kind that LOOKS like they're making things up as they go along. Audiences were, understandably, expecting the ending of the show to answer at least one question they'd been asking since the whole mess began: what the actual Christ on a cronut is going on????

Advertisement

Well they didn't get that, because, something that audiences missed while asking that question is that they're the only ones who give a damn about getting answers.

Number 6, our protagonist, would just like to not be a prisoner in this madcap nightmare of a town anymore. Some answers would be nice, which is why we do occasionally see him looking for some. But one can imagine that after 17 episodes of getting d**ked around, Number 6 would really stop caring. So, in the last episode, he finally manages to escape Number 1 and their cavalcade of mind games and manipulations, driving off into the sunset.

The show was never interested in giving answers, so why should the audience?

5. William's Fidelity Test - Westworld

The thing about having a cast that's mostly made up of robots that are specifically designed to feel and act as human as possible - to the point where they start developing sentience - is that the writers can start to play around with who is and isn't a robot.

Advertisement

Now, if you'd seen the original 1973 movie or, if you're one of THOSE weirdos, read the original novel by Michael Crichton, then you probably already know the twist that William, The Man In Black, is one of the hosts and was unaware of it the whole time.

But the show, like your scribe, knows damn well 90% of you didn't even know there was a movie, let alone a book. So the scene in season 2 where William is subjected to the staff's famous fidelity test at the hands of his supposedly dead daughter Emily, came as a shock to everyone. Was he a machine the whole time? Then how did he even have a daughter, let alone manage to kill her?

Well, as it turns out, stated by Emily's actress Katja Herbers, this is the show messing with our perception of time again. The scene takes place an indeterminate amount of time in the future, where at some point, either one or both of them were replaced with hosts.

4. The Ending - The Sopranos

Man oh man, is this ending infamous. In fact, just calling it "infamous" is akin to saying that Machine Gun Kelly and Megan Fox are a tad odd.

Advertisement

For those who don't know, seeing as how this ending came a LONG time ago, the ending of the hit HBO series The Sopranos, sees our protagonist Tony Soprano sitting down for dinner with his family, knowing full well that he's living on borrowed time. His mob buddies have deemed him a liability, and are no doubt planning to - well - do what the mob does best when they "deem someone a liability".

Except the show never gives you that closure. You don't even know, when the door to the diner opens and Tony looks up, that it's the mob or his daughter showing up late. The screen goes to black right as he looks up. And then boom, show over, thanks for six seasons folks! Have fun with Game Of Thrones in four years!

Yeah, people were pissed. They screamed that they wanted closure for Tony's story, but the creator of the show - David Chase - held firm, deeming that closure to be unimportant. Was it his daughter walking through that door, or the mob? It honestly doesn't matter, says Chase.

And honestly, your writer see his point. I mean obviously Tony's dead, it's just a matter of when it's going to happen. It probably was his daughter walking through that door, but Tony can never be sure, just as the audience can never be sure. However much time he has left, Tony Soprano will live that time terrified of when his chickens will finally come home to roost.

3. Steven Sparing The Diamonds - Steven Universe

Online discourse about Steven Universe is most aptly compared to a dumpster full of used diapers that is on fire. Everyone that has an opinion on this show has a tendency to state that opinion in as toxic a way as possible. Especially if you ask them about the ending to the show's original run.

Advertisement

To a lot of fans, the show's pacifistic nature was always at odds with its galactic war premise, and to those same fans, the ending is the worst example, with Steven literally talking down White Diamond (basically Emperor Palpatine if he were a ten-story-tall lady made of space diamonds) from ruling the universe with an iron fist.

But it's important to keep in mind a few things: one, Steven sparing them is NOT forgiving them, very big difference. Talking them down was simply his best option because - and the show is quite clear about this - fighting the diamonds would have been suicide. Steven would have lost. Badly. Sure, Steven Universe Future would later clarify that he either did or currently does have the ability to destroy the Diamonds, but that's just not in his nature.

Also, and this might be a bit of a meta-ing too far but there is no way that Cartoon Network was going to let this SHOW FOR LITTLE KIDS end with a triple homicide. That just flat out was never going to happen.

2. The One Who Knocks - Breaking Bad

These last two entries are the most egregious examples we have by a country mile.

Advertisement

Walter White has become an icon, but sadly in the same way that Tony Soprano, Tyler Durden, and the last entry on this list have become icons. Objects of veneration by a very particular kind of men who completely miss that they are not meant to like these characters at all.

Just look at how these fans prop up the "I am the one who knocks" scene from Breaking Bad as a symbol of badassness. When, in reality, Vince Gilligan and his team wrote that scene to show Walter as, well, what he is: a sad, pathetic d**k playing at what he thinks a badass looks like. Which, judging by this scene, is someone who angrily shouts down his own wife when she dares to voice an opinion he doesn't like.

Walter White is one of the most compelling protagonists in television history, but he is most certainly not a character to aspire to be. And the rant you all adore so much is one of the biggest proofs of that.

1. Pickle Rick - Rick And Morty

What was meant to represent the epitome of Rick Sanchez's flaws as a character was instead coopted by a fandom hellbent on missing the bloody point of the whole thing.

Advertisement

Pickle Rick, as an episode, as a concept, was made with one purpose: to expose Rick for the sad, lonely, emotionally stunted manchild he is. He turns himself into a pickle for the sole motive of getting out of having to go to therapy. He then goes on this insane adventure where he builds himself a body out of rat guts, fights a building full of armed soldiers, blows up that building full of armed soldiers, and then finally makes it to his therapy session. Where the therapist proceeds to give Rick the dressing down of his life.

Now, granted, the fact that Rick takes nothing away from this dressing down but eye-rolling annoyance in the long run might be why so many fans missed the point being made here. But let's be real with ourselves, someone who idolizes Rick would have missed the point anyway.

Pickle Rick is a truly hilarious episode of a truly hilarious show. But a good many of its hardcore fans don't realize that the episode is laughing AT them, not with.

Advertisement