8 TV Shows Saved By Ridiculously Last Minute Changes
The shows you love were almost terrible.
If you’ve ever imagined what it’s like to write a TV show, you might think the finished product matches the initial creative vision of the visionaries behind the scenes. In reality, though, things are very different.
Re-writes, re-shoots and completely random unexpected events can mean that the TV show you watch on screen bears little resemblance to its original form. Sometimes, these changes are for the worse, but often they can completely save a show from obscurity.
It's true: not every change is a disaster on a par with Fred Flintstone having an alien friend or Cuckoo swapping out Andy Samberg for Taylor Lautner, so let's take a look at the changes that rescued their shows, rather than ruined them.
8. Frasier Was Almost About A Housebound Paraplegic
Frasier stands the test of time as one of the greatest
sitcoms ever made, one of the few spinoffs to match and surpass the show it
span off from in terms of both quality and longevity – although Cheers was
still a great show in its own right.
But everyone’s favourite pompous radio psychiatrist was almost very different. Actor Kelsey Grammer, who played the character on Cheers, was reluctant to play the same role again, and so initially co-creators David Angell, Peter Casey and David Lee came up with a new idea. They cast Grammer as a housebound, paraplegic publishing magnate instead. Thankfully for all concerned, Paramount thought it was terrible and insisted on a Frasier Crane spinoff. The good doctor was relocated from Boston to Seattle and the rest, as they say, is history.
Except it isn’t – there was still one more big change for Frasier before the show would hit the screen. The role of Roz Doyle, Frasier’s spunky, unlucky-in-love friend and producer, initially went to Lisa Kudrow. After a few rehearsals it was decided that Kudrow, although funny, was not the right fit for the character, and Peri Gilpin was cast in her stead. Kudrow didn’t need to be downhearted for long though, as she soon landed the role of Pheobe Buffay in a little sitcom called Friends. You might have heard of it.
7. An Ex-American Football Player Was Going To Run Cheers
A classic ensemble comedy about a Boston bar where everyone knows your name, Cheers still holds up even today, unlike many of its peers. The sitcom launched the careers of Ted Danson, Kelsey Grammar and Woody Harrelson, amongst others, but at least of one of them came close to never descending those steps down to the Cheers bar.
The original idea for Cheers featured a former American football player behind the bar, with Married With Children’s Ed O’Neill considered, along with actual ex-football player Fred Dryer. In the end Ted Danson won the role but his lithe frame made the American football backstory unsuitable. Instead, Sam’s character was re-written as a former pitcher for the Red Sox baseball team.
Dryer did later appear in a guest stop as a sportscaster and old friend of Danson’s Sam Malone, but it was clear that without Danson’s easy going charm Cheers would not have lasted for an amazing 11 series.
6. J.D. Was Going To Be Revealed As Mentally Ill In Scrubs
Unlike other shows on this list, Scrubs didn’t undergo
drastic changes from the pilot episode. Though the tone of the pilot is
somewhat inconsistent, often leaning more towards the drama than comedy side of
things, Scrubs’ key elements – voiceover, flashbacks, fantasy sequences,
realistic medical cases – were all there.
It took a while for the show to find its feet, though. Early on, writer and creator Bill Lawrence was so worried the show wouldn’t be deemed funny enough by the general public that he added in “comedy” sound effects. He later admitted the sounds were “annoying” and they were gradually phased out in Season 1. But the really big change that helped save Scrubs didn’t appear until the second series, and all it took was the show's renewal.
The sitcom was under near permanent threat of cancellation throughout its run, so much so that it’s amazing it made it to nine seasons, but Lawrence was so sure they would not make it past one year that he had a big twist planned to bow out with. If you re-watch Season 1, you’ll notice that the nameless Janitor, played by improv genius Neil Flynn, does not interact with any character other than Zach Braff’s J.D.. The reason for this is because Lawrence planned to reveal that The Janitor was in fact a figment of J.D.’s imagination at the end of the first season.
Thankfully, the show was picked up for another year, Lawrence dropped the ill-conceived “the main character has a serious mental
illness” plot twist and integrated The Janitor into the main cast. This allowed
for more improvised jokes and monologues from Flynn and opened up the
possibilities for more comedic b-plots that helped Scrubs achieve classic status
– for a few years, at least.
5. Jack Shepherd Was Due To Die In The Lost Pilot Episode
To say Lost was divisive is probably underplaying it. The drama about a group of plane crash survivors marooned on a mystical island pretty much divided people into two groups - those who felt the writers had a grand plan behind all the red herrings and mysteries, and those who felt they were chancers making it up as they went along.
The truth, as ever, is somewhere in the middle. Two of the co-creators, J.J. Abrams and Damon Lindelof, did write a "series bible" to outline the show's complex mythology, but it's undoubted that unplanned changes and uncertainty over how long the show would have to tell its story effected their grand vision.
In fact, the show's mythology had to be amended early on - Jack Shepherd, de facto main character and leader of the Oceanic survivors, was never supposed to lead his friends off the island (then back again).
The original plan was for Jack to be played by a big name - Michael Keaton was in mind for the role - for the audience to believe he would be the main character and then, in a classic Lost bait-and-switch, he would be killed off in the pilot, leaving the audience to watch the rest of the castaways survive without their leader. Network executives, in a rare showing of foresight, thought audiences would react badly to the death of a heroic main character so early on, and insisted Jack live. The pilot was retooled and Jack became a key player instead of an attention-grabbing cameo. Whatever you think of Lost, it's undeniable that the show was much the better for it.
4. Captain Kirk Didn't Exist In Star Trek's Original Pilot
There have been a lot of Star Trek series, but we’re going
back to the 60s to the original run for this one. Everything about the original
series is iconic, from the costumes and sets to the actors – William Shatner and
Leonard Nimoy have become synonymous with their roles as Captain James T. Kirk
and Dr. Spock that even the retooled and rebooted blockbuster film versions of
Star Trek feature lead actors largely doing their best Shatner and Nimoy impressions.
But as amazing as it may seem, Shatner wasn’t the shoo-in for the Captain Kirk gig that you might have thought. In its 1965 pilot episode called The Cage, Shatner wasn’t even recording the captain’s log. Instead the role went to Jeffrey Hunter (best known for co-starring with John Wayne in The Searchers) and the character was called Captain Christopher Pike. Nimoy was there as Spock, though his character was not First Officer and displayed many more human characteristics than the cold, logical Spock fans would later come to know and love. The actual Spock-like role went to a character called Number One, played by creator Gene Rodenberry’s then-wife, Majel Barrett.
NBC chose not to pick up the pilot, deciding it needed more action and was too “slow” and “cerebral” for audiences. Instead of rejecting the show outright, though, the network ordered a second pilot, and this became the show’s first official episode. The second pilot featured Captain Kirk, with Shatner in the role (reportedly after Hunter had turned down filming the second pilot to concentrate on his film career) and had jettisoned Number One in favour of promoting a newly logical and less human Spock. From then on, the show was able to boldly go where no man has been before.
3. The Big Bang Theory Was Unrecognisable
The Big Bang Theory is a comedy juggernaut that is soon to enter its tenth season, having grown into America’s biggest sitcom since it first aired back in 2007. It took some time for it to be picked up by a network though – its original pilot was put together back in 2006 and had to be significantly retooled before it would make it to air. Even creator Chuck Lorre admitted that “it sucked”.
Main characters Sheldon and Leonard were kept on for the series proper, but the original pilot’s female lead Katie – described as “a street-hardened, tough-as-nails woman with a vulnerable interior” – who moves in with the two scientists after a break-up, was replaced by Penny; a sweet, naïve, somewhat dim wannabe actress. In addition to her, the characters of Raj and Howard were created as fellow nerds and work colleagues for Sheldon and Leonard.
The much-changed version of The Big Bang Theory struck a chord with audiences much more than the original attempt did, and it hasn’t looked back since.
2. Seinfeld Would Have Had A "Sassy" Waitress As A Main Character
As we've seen already, it’s not unusual for TV shows to change drastically between
the pilot episode and the main show proper. The pilot is often an opportunity to try
out ideas and characters and see how they play with the audience.
Seinfeld was one show that made drastic changes from the pilot episode, and the changes helped it become one of the greatest sitcoms in history, instead of a forgotten entry on a list called “The Worst Pilots in TV History”.
Some changes were cosmetic – the show was originally saddled with the unwieldy and portentous title The Seinfeld Chronicles and breakout character Kramer was called Kessler, and for no particular reason he had a dog. Monk’s Diner, where the gang would often hangout, was called Pete’s Luncheonette. But the biggest difference between the pilot and the show it became was the fact that there was no Elaine. Instead, the only female influence was a waitress at Pete’s named Claire.
When the show made it to air as Seinfeld, Kessler was Kramer and the dog had gone, as had Pete’s Luncheonette and Claire, and most importantly Jerry’s ex-girlfriend Elaine was a bone fide member of the main cast of loveable misanthropes. Sitcom history was born.
1. Jesse Was Supposed To Die In Series 1 Of Breaking Bad
The one thing every Breaking Bad fan can agree on is that they love Jesse Pinkman. He's the show's resident loveable junkie and drug dealer, but he almost didn’t last long enough to become a fan favourite. Series creator Vince Gilligan originally had an entirely different plan for Aaron Paul’s character, and it was only an unexpected writer’s strike that saved his bacon.
Gilligan’s plan had been for Walter White’s protégé to meet his end in season one’s final episode at the hands of maniac drug cartel leader Tuco, but the 2007 strike by the Writer’s Guild of America (WGA) cut the show's debut season short at just six episodes, rather than the originally intended nine.
In the gap between sasons one and two, Gilligan and his production team decided that Jesse was too great a character – and Paul too great an actor – to discard after just a handful of appearances. The decision to keep the character alive spurred the show onto true greatness, Jesse’s moral disillusionment growing as a mirror to Walter’s ever-increasing thirst for power and legacy. Were it not for a strike and an unexpectedly short first season, Breaking Bad would have been very different, and probably so would Paul's career.