Television is, by and large, a long form medium. Yes, some shows intend to have limited runs, and some are so bad they dont get a chance to spread their wings, but generally speaking a show tells many stories over many episodes over a few seasons. As such, sometimes a premise will wear itself out. Other times, a change to the cast becomes necessary, and thus a change to a show becomes necessary. Television shows have to be willing to adapt to survive from time to time. Or, on occasion, they simply decide to change things up for the fun of it, or to breathe new life into the show or whatever. There have been a handful of shows that have changed their premise from what it was originally. Sometimes these changes work. Other times, they only give a show a brief second wind before the show is cancelled for good. Here are eight shows that decided to really change things up. They didnt just add a new character like The Brady Bunch with Cousin Oliver or The Mindy Project with about 800 different people. They completely changed course, for better or worse.
8. Archer
As an animated show, the Archer creators can do pretty much whatever they want to do anyway. It is a joke heavy, supremely goofy and raunchy cartoon that has done all sorts of ridiculous storylines. However, for a few seasons, those storylines all took place within the world of spies and espionage at the fictional ISIS, where the titular Sterling Archer and his cohorts worked. Then, when season five rolled around, Archer decided to throw a major curveball. In short, Archer became Archer Vice. That is to say, ISIS was disbanded and Archer and friends decided to become coke dealers. Really. The show about idiotic spies became a show about idiotic coke dealers. It was a bold move, but also completely reasonable within the world of the show. It wasnt a long term move, but for one year, Archer fans got to see these characters in a very different context.
7. Cougar Town
Cougar Town was, by the admittance of show co-creator Bill Lawrence, an American sitcom legend, a title designed to try and generate buzz, and was constructed with tongue firmly planted in cheek. It also, quite possibly, ended up being a real barrier of entry for folks. Early on, the show had a story that hewed somewhat closely to what you think it was about. That is, if you are thinking it is about an older woman, here played by Courtney Cox, dating younger men. That could not sustain a show, and it was not asked to. Cougar Town quickly turned into a show about a group of middle aged friends hanging out and drinking wine and cracking jokes and all that stuff. Many sitcoms eventually turn into hangout shows, but usually they dont start with such a hooky premise. Alas, that name still sticks around like an albatross.
6. Bob
Bob Newhart is one of the biggest names in sitcom history. The Bob Newhart show is still highly revered, and even Newhart had some success, and even tweaked itself just a bit, even if the premise stayed the same. That cannot be said for Bob, the forgotten Newhart vehicle. The show only ran for two seasons, but that was enough time for some major changes. During the first season, Newhart was a comic book writer who was hired to bring back his old 50s character Mad-Dog, and the show was about him dealing with being back in this changed world of comic books. Then, at the end of the first season, everybody got fired and the comic book was cancelled. So, in the second season, Bob was hired as the president of a greeting card company, and had a whole new set of characters. It didnt take, and Newhart couldnt find himself a third sitcom hit.
5. Valerie/The Hogan Family
Valerie Harper is best known for playing Rhoda on The Mary Tyler Moore Show and, fittingly, Rhoda, but that was not the end of her career. In the mid-80s, she was given a new show to star on, called Valerie, where she played Valerie Hogan, the mom of a family trying to keep things together and such. Then, after two seasons, Harper started holding out for more money, and an ugly fight, and a lawsuit, unfolded. During this time, the creators of the show said enough was enough, and killed off Harpers character. Of course, since she was the titular character, that was kind of an issue. Still, they pressed on. They brought on Sandy Duncan to be the new star, and also changed the title to Valeries Family: The Hogans. Then, they went with The Hogan Family, to get Harpers name off the show completely. It ran for six seasons total, on two networks, with three different titles. Thats a lot for one show.
4. New Girl
This is not simply about the fact that, after a few seasons, Zooey Deschanels Jess is no longer a new girl. Shes been around for quite some time, in fact, and has even dated another one of the main characters and so on and so forth. However, this would not have happened early on when the show was operating under its original guise. At first, Jess was, if you put it the way FOXs marketing team did, adorkable, but really she was quite odd and weird and disconcerting. The character was not merely a quirky but lovable gal. The first few episodes were about the guys dealing with this strange woman suddenly in their lives, but coming to her defense anyway. Then, New Girl decided to soften the Jess character, and make her more relatable and less potentially unsettling. Oh, and one of the three male roommates was replaced, but then he came back because apparently the show felt there werent enough characters to try and juggle. It hasnt worked out great.
3. Two Guys And A Girl (And A Pizza Place)
Before Ryan Reynolds was the Green Lantern, he was the star of a sitcom called Two Guys, a Girl and a Pizza Place. You can probably guess what it was about. The two titular guys worked at the titular pizza place in Boston, and then a girl would show up too. After two seasons of this, Reynolds character decides to go to medical school, and his buddy drops out of college to get a job as a counselor. As such, the pizza place completely disappeared from the show in season three, and the show became Two Guys and a Girl, and it ran for another season after the change.
2. Veep
Armando Iannuccis first venture into American television, Veep began life as a look into the life of Vice President Selina Meyer, played by the peerless Julia Louis-Dreyfus. Much of the humor came from the relative lack of import to her position in the political realm. However, that was not a dynamic premise, and could have worn out its welcome. As such, Veep decided to ramp up the stakes. During the second season, the President decides he wont run for a second term, so the show becomes about Meyer running for President. Thats not all, either. Toward the end of the most recent season, Veep changed things up again, as the President decided to resign, meaning Meyer became President. When the show began, Meyer was stuck in a position of little to no power. Now, shes the most powerful woman in the world, giving the show a whole new realm of comedy to delve into.
1. Laverne & Shirley
Laverne & Shirley was always about the two gal pals in the title, and also Lenny and Squiggy and other such characters. For the vast majority of the shows run, the two worked as bottle cappers at a beer brewery in Milwaukee. However, for the sixth season, the show decided to pick up and move to Burbank, California. There, they got jobs as gift wrappers, which makes sense. What makes less sense is that all their friends and family decide to move with them. The show went under one more, somewhat significant tweak for the final season. You know, just the loss of one of the main characters. Cindy Williams, who played Shirley, was pregnant, and decided not to return, even though her name remained in the title. The show couldnt survive without Shirley, and somewhat inexplicably, the series finale was a backdoor pilot for a show that never came to fruition.