8 Ways It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia Could End

How will Paddy's Pub finally close its doors?

By Michael John-Day /

The prospect of It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia coming to an end is as undesirable as seeing Rickety Cricket in lingerie.

Advertisement

No fan wants Paddy's Pub to close its doors, as the series is still hitting highs and is one of the most unique sitcoms on TV. Still, nothing lasts forever, and if the series' antics have taught viewers anything thus far, it's that this show will end spectacularly.

Always Sunny has had a couple of brushes with finality, as there have been some times when it's felt right for the series to stop, with the two most notable being the climaxes to seasons 12 ("Dennis' Double Life") and 14 ("Waiting For Big Mo"). But, those brief ending moments were only a tease, as the show is still going strong.

If it's going to stop at some point, it needs to do so with something that's on-brand, and the following eight endings are definitely of that sort. While not all of these would be necessarily satisfying, they are all directions that would make sense and seem like likely choices for the FX programme to go in.

8. Cricket Takes Control Of Paddy's

It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia is filled from top to bottom with characters who suffer some of the worst lives imaginable. There's poor Dee, who's constantly mocked by her friends, Bill Ponderosa, whose addictions have driven his life into a downward spiral, and even Charlie, who legitimately lives like a gremlin. Still, they all pale in comparison to the misery of Rickety Cricket.

Advertisement

The former Father Matthew Mara went from being an upstanding member of society to a low-life who is more akin to a dog than a man. This downfall came entirely at the hands of the gang after they involved him in their schemes and fed into his dangerous lifestyle. When it comes to the end of this series, Cricket should be there, and it would be incredible to see him take a prime seat.

Seeing Cricket somehow take control of the bar would be an excellent ending twist, as it would be wicked irony. He could even put the gang into the same position they put him in by abusing their labour and lording his power over them. Of course, it wouldn't be a happy ending for the gang, but it would be a perfect final note for this "dog orgy" veteran.

7. They're All Figments Of Frank's Imagination

It's safe to assume that Always Sunny's ending could flip the show on its head, as that would be very typical for the writers. While this idea does sound crazy, there are already fan theories fluctuating amongst the fandom that feed into it.

Advertisement

In this ending, there would come a reveal that Frank is a lonely and unstable man who imagines all of his friends, possibly even personifying pet animals that he has around the bar. You may say, then what about season one where Frank wasn't there? The answer to that is simple; season one was a backstory Frank made before arriving - which explains why it was so different to the new seasons.

Regarding each characters real-life counterpart, the fan theories also step in. Dennis could very easily be a cat, as he's arrogant, prone to fits of rage/scratching and even married a feline fanatic (Maureen).

Charlie would undoubtedly be a rat, as the show is constantly comparing him to those little ones. There's no argument that Mac isn't a dog in human form, as he's loyal to a fault and always acts as a bodyguard - despite being terrible at it. Then, there's Dee, and well, "Dee's a bird".

This would be a genuinely ridiculous ending, but ridiculous is Always Sunny's middle name.

6. They Are Trapped In Virtual Reality

Always Sunny in Philadelphia has an interesting outlook on technology, as the show does like to poke fun at the trivialisations of modern tech, but always from a distance. The gang almost seem removed from society thanks to how little they respond to smartphones, iPads, electric cars and more. But, what if that is for a reason?

Advertisement

The show has dabbled in virtual reality before, in the episode "PTSDee", where Mac and Frank got post-traumatic stress disorder from playing a VR war game. Still, they brushed past the subject and focussed more on the emotional aspects that the game brought about rather than the technology itself.

So, what if there isn't much technology in their world because they are all trapped inside virtual reality and choose to live somewhere that's nostalgic for them, i.e. somewhere with less tech. It sounds completely out of left field, but the wild card nature of the show means it can't be entirely written off.

Plus, this would act as a perfect example of how the business stays afloat with so few customers. Sure, Frank is rich, but the bar should be haemorrhaging money and never seems to. Possibly because it's not even real?

5. Everything Took Place In A Courtroom

People have been debating how this show could end for some time, and this concept has been brought up very often. It would be a perfect way to end the show, too perfect almost, as many fans could end up being disappointed by what would be a rather predictable ending. Still, sometimes the most obvious move is the right one.

Advertisement

Imagine this, it gets to the final episode, and something typically absurd happens that puts the gang into trouble with the law - which they are pretty used to at this point. However, instead of providing viewers with a solution, the scene suddenly cuts to the gang in a courtroom, revealing that everything fans have seen from season one to that point has been a story they've weaved to get themselves out of trouble.

This flashback format has been put into practice on multiple occasions, with episodes like "The World Series Defence", "The Maureen Ponderosa Wedding Massacre", "The Gang Goes to Hell", and many more. Therefore, it would be entirely sensible to reveal that the whole show has been one big flashback to justify their actions.

Whether it would be satisfying or not is uncertain, but it would be perfectly Always Sunny.

4. It Just Kind Of Ends

The ending of the fourteenth season teased a finale as the gang all discussed that it was time to leave, implying a symbolic end to the show. However, they came back just afterwards and made it clear they weren't going anywhere, and fans breathed a sigh of relief as this would have been a lacklustre way to end.

Advertisement

While this list has enjoyed plenty of over-the-top speculation on the wild and crazy ways that this series could end, it's also important to address the fact that it could go in the opposite direction. Sometimes shows don't get the chance to go out in a blaze of glory, and unfortunately, Always Sunny could be a prime piece of steak for the grill of disappointment.

Always Sunny is a very niche show, and while it's found huge appeal, there's always the possibility that it gets shut down before it's intended to. Whether that's through cancellation or the loss of the broadcaster, it would mean that the show could end without a tonne of fanfare.

Even ignoring the possibility of the show ending prematurely, the writers themselves might still choose to let the last episode quietly filter out, either to keep it open for more or just to let the show close in a dignified manner.

3. The Gang Are Insane

You probably don't need much convincing on this one, as the Always Sunny gang are some of the most erratic, wild and unpredictable characters on TV. Not only do they act awfully, but each of them displays some drastic mental health concerns, with Frank and Dee both having spent time in a psychiatric ward (or "nitwit school" in the words of Frank).

Advertisement

But, Frank's life as Froggy and Dee's choice to "set a bitch on fire" aren't the only signifiers of insanity in the gang. There's Charlie, whose fume inhaling is clearly a sign of trauma, Mac whose years of repression between his sexuality and religion has undoubtedly caused some significant problems, and Dennis, a man who seems one bad day away from being Ted Bundy - and may have already had that day in secret.

Ultimately, the show could use this as a direction for the conclusion, revealing that the whole group have been in a psych ward the entire time. It might be a little outdated in the modern TV climate, but the show has never been one to stray from convention and political correctness without making a good point of it, so you'd have to trust that they'd do the same here.

2. It Was Hell All Along

If viewers have learned anything from shows like The Good Place, it's that the old concepts of fire and brimstone as eternal damnation have faded in favour of ironic torture. One such example is sticking multiple toxic people together and forcing them to create misery for each other, which can be seen in this group.

Advertisement

Always Sunny has already dipped its toes into the idea of the gang being in the afterlife, so why not shock everyone by going all the way? The appropriately titled "The Gang Goes To Hell" could even prove to be the point where they made it into the eternal abyss.

Although the idea of placing the loveable - yet awful - cast into such a scenario is unbelievably dark, it's also something that would make sense narratively, as it's already been subtly addressed In "Paddy's Pub: The Worst Bar In Philadelphia". This episode concluded with the critic the gang accidentally kidnapped declaring that he won't press charges because their existence is a "Hell on Earth" already.

Ultimately, the gang will probably end up suffering the consequences of their actions, and showing that they're already being punished would be a great way to do that.

1. The Gang DIES

Death comes for everyone, and when you play with matches this often, you're eventually going to start a fire.

Advertisement

As sad as this would be, since fans have come to love Charlie, Dee, Dennis, Frank and Mac like family, it wouldn't be too surprising if they ended up biting the bullet. The gang are constantly putting themselves in harms way unnecessarily, and thus, their grizzly end will surely catch up to them at some point.

There are plenty of roads to walk down regarding how they could die, as they've made plenty of enemies. Perhaps the McPoyles will return with a vengeance, or the "Random Guy" could get back at them for blowing up his car. No matter what happens, it would have to be epic, such as a fire at Paddy's or a giant explosion.

This kind of ending would be dark and horrible, but that kind of mean-spirited humour is exactly what the fans love about Always Sunny. "The Gang Goes To Hell" even stated to play with the idea of them dying, and it had fans on the edge of their seat, so the writers already know it can work.

Advertisement