8 Ways Star Trek Just Isn't Star Trek Anymore
Not that it's necessarily a bad thing...
Since its debut in 1966, Gene Roddenberry's sci-fi spectacular - Star Trek - has had to change with the times. Series, films, video games and more have all bore the Star Trek logo in the fifty years since its debut, and while one would think that this need to evolve is a ubiquitous trait of pop-culture everywhere, there are those out there who feel, for whatever reason, that Star Trek has lost its way.
Except it hasn't.
The Trek of today is just as representative of the Roddenberry concept as The Original Series, and while there are certain traits that would intimate that Star Trek isn't what it used to be, the changes that have taken place have only enhanced those older works. In a literal sense, then, yes, Star Trek isn't Star Trek anymore. But there's a reason for that, and while all those changes haven't always worked, Star Trek - like any other franchise - has had to adapt to survive and, more recently, thrive.
This isn't an attempt to admonish the Trek of old, but it's equally true that both CBS and Paramount's most recent efforts have managed to reinvigorate a declining franchise. It's a new style of Star Trek, and even if it isn't like the old one, there's a real reason for it.
It's Trek, but not quite as we know it. And while there are both positives and negatives to be gleaned, it's clear that the Trek of today, is vastly different to the Trek of old.
8. The Darker Aesthetic
By far the biggest talking point of Discovery so far has been its tone, which has ventured into horror territory on plenty of occasions.
That would make sense, given how it was originally envisioned as a Bryan Fuller work, but there's more to it than just that. Discovery takes place in a time before the Enterprise, before Kirk, Spock and Scotty. Prejudice is rife, war is prevalent, and while the show subsides on the hope of a better tomorrow, it is clear that Discovery's world is a far cry from the one we've seen elsewhere.
Star Fleet, caught in the midst of being militarised, is central to this narrative, and it's totally refreshing. The idea that the USS Enterprise was a science vessel and one equipped solely to explore the galaxy is a stellar concept, but it's one made even better by the debate surrounding the fact that, for all its utopian credentials, Star Trek is a series about a militarised vessel operating under a military structure.
It's one we've rarely seen up until now, and while that may alter the tone, it's a vital reappraisal that reiterates Discovery's credentials as a bold and uncompromising depiction of Roddenberry's original concept.
7. It's More Accommodating To Newer Audiences
By far the most frustrating thing about criticism directed towards modern Trek - and, to that end, other franchises too - is that they've been 'diluted' by attempts to appeal to a broader market, as if having more people enjoy the thing you also love could ever be a bad thing.
The point is that this more stylised, more representative Trek, doesn't just follow in the footsteps of TOS (particularly in relation to its attempts to represent marginalised groups), but goes one further in trying to broaden the franchise's demographic. A name as big as Star Trek can't subsist entirely on an ageing fandom, and while nostalgia is definitely the 'in' thing right now, there's a balance to achieve in getting it right.
Paramount's films (Into Darkness aside), were exemplary in getting that aspect across. JJ Abrams' original 2009 effort rooted its science squarely in classic Trek by introducing a timeline concurrent to the mainstream one, and Beyond - the third film in that series - continued down that path by emulating the bridge dynamic of the original Enterprise crew.
The difference is that there's more action to roll in with the science, and while that does set the modern shows and films apart from those older incarnations, it's a modernising process Star Trek couldn't afford to shirk.
Yes, it's not the old show, but to say it's abandoned its own identity is just blatantly dishonest.
6. It Can Compete On Both Fronts
While Star Trek has had periods where it's competed on both the big and small screens simultaneously, it's never managed to main maintain a presence as consistently as it has now.
The original Star Trek films only came after TOS' had ended, and while the franchise experienced a resurgence in the nineties, replete with a series of spin-offs following on from Star Trek: The Next Generation, its cinematic efforts lagged behind. The lukewarm reaction to Star Trek: Enterprise only seemed to aggravate its diminishing role both in Hollywood and on TV.
Now, with Paramount's films continuing - and with Discovery going strong (as strong as a show can go on CBS Access) - Trek is on the strongest footing it's been on for a while, if not ever.
The delineation between the TV and film versions of Star Trek might be stark, but with a revitalised presence in pop-culture, things can only look up from here.
5. It's More Action-Oriented
While Trek's newfound focus on action has caused justifiable upset in the wake of Abrams' films, there's nothing wrong with a bit of excitement to mix the technobabble up from time to time.
And again, that's not to say that old Star Trek wasn't exciting either. The series has always prided itself upon its ability to deliver suspense with or without a mega budget, and while that's an element Trek continues to exploit, there's more variety when it comes to set-pieces.
Now we get to see the Enterprise darting around in dogfights; Kirk, Spock and Bones fighting in life and death scenarios. Both elements are emblematic of this new kind of Trek, and while claims that this type of action is at odds with the series' foundations make sense in some respects, the focus is only symptomatic of the franchise's wider evolution.
That isn't to say that Star Trek post-'09 is nothing but action either. While action sequences have taken a more prominent role in Trek stories, they slot in seamlessly with those older, more indelible elements we've come to associate with Star Trek since its creation.
The fact there's more of it isn't necessarily a bad thing, and with the advent of new moviemaking techniques and a bigger budget to boot, it could be said that the kind of action we've seen recently only further realises Roddenberry's initial concept.
4. Not Black Or White, But Shades Of Grey
Star Trek: Discovery has its flaws, but there's no denying that its premise poses a fascinating and uniquely important question to Star Trek as a whole.
Set in the years before Kirk, Spock and the rest would venture on their five year mission to explore new worlds, in a world drastically different to that one, Discovery's asks the uncomfortable question of just how, exactly, Roddenberry's humanistic, almost utopian future, came to pass. We find out that the Federation aren't all sunshine and rainbows, and with Jason Isaacs' Gabriel Lorca leading the way in terms of duplicity, we have a face to put to that mantra as well.
Yes, Discovery isn't like the Star Trek of old, but that's exactly the point. Utopias aren't conjured out of thin air, and while Discovery does take place in dire straits, it's a series built on hope. Every single character in Discovery is fighting for the kind of tomorrow we see in TOS and TNG and, while they'd undoubtedly be vexed by the fact the fight keeps going, the main thing is that Discovery has to exist in order for those shows to feel achievable, in the grand scheme of things.
3. The Serialised Format Can, However, Work To Its Detriment
Star Trek: Discovery is a clever TV show, but one thing that's missing is the procedural nature of classic Star Trek shows. Anyone jumping into Discovery has to go from the very beginning, and while there's an argument that Star Trek could've done with a format change, serialised television isn't the thing you'd exactly associate with the series.
Growing up, Star Trek was totally absorbing because you could, irrespective of where you found the show, get invested in one episodic adventure whenever you felt like doing so. There were multi-episode arcs - certainly - but nothing as intricate as what we've seen with most modern day TV shows, which play more to binge-watching trends and are built largely on the post-Game of Thrones climate the industry currently finds itself in.
With Discovery, there's no way you replicate that feeling. Serialised storytelling is the 'in' thing right now and, no matter where you look - be it TV, comics or otherwise - the decline of the procedural has been laid bare for all to see.
Having a show like Discovery is totally fine, but it's equally true that fans of those older, more procedural Trek shows aren't being catered for right now.
2. The Lack Of Bridge Dynamic
Further to Discovery's serialised format, another thing that's been lacking is a proper bridge dynamic. No doubt this has emanated from the fact that Lorca himself is a dubious fellow, and Burnham's position on the Discovery is... complicated, but it wouldn't hurt to get that element back in the future.
Perhaps not in Discovery, but in another Trek TV show? Absolutely. TOS had Kirk, Spock, Sulu and Uhura to name but a few, and TNG had Picard, Worf, Ryker and Data. Even Discovery has the characters to make that dynamic work, with Saru, Lorca and Burnham in particular all having a great dynamic to suit a procedural Star Trek show.
Again, it's not so much that Discovery needs a bridge like the old series, but to pay homage to that old formula, or to even play around with it for an episode or two, would be a great thing to see.
1. Because It Has To Be
Whether you're a Trek fan or not, it's pretty clear that Star Trek had to change in order stay relevant. Not that Star Trek doesn't have a kind of timeless relevance already about it, but it had been dangerously absent from the conversation for years until before the Abrams films, and non-existent on TV for the better half of a decade until Discovery came around.
There's also the fact that this new approach has been largely vindicated by consistent box-office receipts, positive critical reception and the fact that Star Trek, although always a cultural phenomenon, is experiencing a resurgence. Without those changes it's possible that this wouldn't have happened, and whether you're a fan of these new shows or not, it's imperative that Star Trek continues to feature everywhere it can.
It might not push all the right buttons all the time, but the Trek of today - while different to the Trek of old - is every bit as exciting, compelling and progressive as the original Roddenberry concept.
How do you feel about Star Trek today? Have you noticed any changes? Be sure to share your thoughts in the comments below!