9 Historical Inaccuracies In BBC's Wolf Hall

Henry VIII was actually very protective of his crotch size...

By Chris Waugh /

The BBC's adaptation of Hilary Mantel's novel "Wolf Hall" received much critical acclaim for its portrayal of the rapid rise of King Henry VIII's chief minister Thomas Cromwell - yet it also garnered much criticism for several historical inaccuracies which featured in the show. Damian Lewis's portrayal of Henry VIII was fresh and quite magnificent, while Mark Rylance was brilliant as the opportunistic figure of Cromwell - whose rapid rise is facilitated by the demise of Thomas More (Anton Lesser). Yet to what extent was Cromwell's ascension to effective second-in-command in England achieved in the manner portrayed by the BBC's six-part series? Cromwell was confirmed as Henry VIII's chief minister and principal secretary in April 1534, but in truth he had long since been the King's closest confidante and most-trusted general. For once More had refused to acknowledge Henry VIII's split from the Roman Catholic Church, Cromwell was elevated to the King's right-hand man and he helped to organise the monarch's divorce from Catherine of Aragon and the subsequent wedding to Anne Boleyn. But how much power did Cromwell actually wield? And to what extent was he a sympathetic figure as the BBC portray, rather than a scheming, Machiavellian character? Furthermore, how accurate for the time were the costumes and manor houses used? Well, here are nine prominent historical inaccuracies which affect the BBC's adaptation of Hilary Mantel's Wolf Hall.

9. Tudor Codpieces Were Far Larger Than Those Used In The Show...

Tudor codpieces were all about show - the flap which covered the front of a man's nether regions were usually huge during Tudor times in order to accentuate a their genital area. Despite this, the makers of Wolf Hall deliberately reduced the size of the codpiece used in the show - in order not to offend American viewer. Mark Rylance, who played Cromwell, admitted that "very small codpieces that can be tucked away" were deliberately used because people in America "may not know exactly what's going on down there". Who knew that Americans were offended by such things?

8. Thomas More Was Actually An Honourable Family Man

One thing that is almost certainly true about Henry VIII's lord chancellor Thomas More is that he was a family man who loved his children. In BBC's Wolf Hall, however, Cromwell is presented as a stereotypical early-modern man who saw his daughters - Margaret, Elizabeth and Cecily - as less important than his son, John. He is shown as doting on John while treating his daughters less affectionately. However, More was extremely liberal and forward-thinking for a Tudor man in terms of how he treated his own female family members. For example, More insisted on his daughters being given the same classical education - in Greek, Latin and mathematics - as his son. In September 1522, More even praised Margaret for her letter writing skills after she composed a note to a bishop.

7. Despite The Series Being Titled "Wolf Hall", Barely Any Of The Action Actually Takes Place There

For the BBC series - and Hilary Mantel's book - to be titled Wolf Hall, you would assume at least some of the action would take place at the manor house in Wiltshire. However, due to the fact "Wolfhall" or "Wulfhall" was also the principal residence of the Seymour family - a member of which was Jane, Henry VIII's third wife - then Hilary Mantel decided on this as the name for her series. Interestingly, the Latin saying Homo homini lupus ("man is wolf to man") was also another inspiration behind the title due to Cromwell's opportunistic - and in some ways Machiavellian - nature. Henry VIII did stay at Wulfhall in 1535, but this is not something which is highlighted throughout the series. Although not technically an inaccuracy, it is a historical frustration to limit the amount of the series actually filmed at Wolf Hall - particularly seeing as Jane Seymour is not among the more important of Henry VIII's wives with who Cromwell's relations soured.

6. Tudor Court Tapestries Were Far More Vibrant In Colour

A deliberate inaccuracy, the tapestries which adorned the walls of Tudor courts were in actual fact extremely vibrant in colour and not the dull, faded shades we see today. Time has faded and mellowed the tapestries, but during Henry VIII's duration on the thrown they would have been close to garish in shade. However, director Peter Kosminsky admitted that he did not want to use the original, vibrant tapestries because modern-day television audiences are used to seeing the duller, less harsh colourings.

5. Cromwell Was Ruthless And Extracted Confessions By Torture

Historian Simon Schama has been particularly critical of Wolf Hall's portrayal of Cromwell as a "much-maligned, misunderstood pragmatist" - because the evidence clearly suggests he was anything but. As Schama explains, Cromwell was "a detestably self-serving, bullying monster who perfected state terror in England" - and who continuously called upon torture as a method for extracting confessions from suspects. Despite this, Cromwell is seen throughout the BBC's adaptation as someone who the audience should sympathise with - who is misunderstood and was actually far less callous than history has subsequently portrayed him. Unfortunately for Cromwell, on this count history has actually been correct in how it has depicted him.

4. Catholics Were Not Necessarily Evil, And Protestants Were Not Always The Good Guys

Catholic bishops - including the Right Reverend Mark Davis of Shrewsbury and the Right Reverend Mark O'Toole of Plymouth - have slammed the portrayal of Thomas More as an opportunistic schemer. Although More certainly was ruthless in many ways - he happily allowed six Protestants to be burned alive for their religious beliefs - he has subsequently been canonised as a Catholic saint, and he did everything in his power to protect the traditional religion in England. Mantel has criticised Catholicism in the past - accusing the Church of "cruelty" and "hypocrisy" - and it is clear that her own views have influenced her portrayal of both More and Cromwell. More, the Catholic, is seen as backwards and vindictive whereas Cromwell, who agrees to Henry VIII's demands of a separation from the Church of Rome, is depicted as progressive, forward-thinking and liberal. In truth, perceptions of both probably lie somewhere in the middle. More was certainly not "saintly", but he was also not a vindictive schemer - he refused to acknowledge King Henry VIII's Church of England split because he was a devout Catholic. Cromwell on the other hand did show progressive, liberal thinking, but he was not wholly moral himself.

3. Kate Phillips Is Certainly No Dead-Ringer For Jane Seymour

Paintings of Henry VIII's third wife Jane Seymour are certainly not flattering - she is depicted as having a double chin, a huge forehead and thin, pursed lips. However, the actress who plays her in Wolf Hall - Kate Phillips - does not resemble any of those features. In fact, she has one chin, a normal forehead - and is pretty. Although paintings can never accurately portray the exact appearance of a person, Phillips is certainly no resemblance to the only physical evidence that exists to suggest exactly what Jane Seymour looked like. On saying that, everyone knows exactly why Phillips was selected for the TV portrayal...

2. Some Of The Houses Used For Filming Were Not Built For Another 50 Years

Montacute House features prominently throughout Wolf Hall, with Henry VIII and Cromwell even walking around the grounds in one particularly important scene - yet the residence was not even constructed until 1598, 51 years after the King's death. In addition, Barrington Court - which also features - was not completed until the late-1550s (although construction was started in 1538), while Chastlelton House was not built until the early-1600s. Henry VIII achieved much throughout his reign - but stepping foot in grand houses 50 years before they were completed was certainly not among his accomplishments.

1. Henry VIII Was Far More Clued Up To Cromwell's Scheming Than He Is Given Credit For

Cromwell's influence over Henry VIII is without doubt. He was arguably Henry's closest confidante, particularly later in his reign, and the King's chief minister did give birth to many policy initiatives undertaken during the 1530s - including religious reform and the introduction of new treason laws. But the portrayal of Cromwell as somehow holding sway over King Henry VIII is just simply inaccurate. Henry listened to Cromwell and followed much of his advice, but Cromwell was not the puppet master who controlled the nation through the King. Yes, Henry did eventually agree to Cromwell's suggestion to wed Anne of Cleves, but he was initially hesitant and he did not consummate the marriage - annulling it six months later. Cromwell almost certainly was a Machiavellian, opportunistic type - but he did not dictate policy. King Henry VIII was very much in charge, proven by Cromwell's arrest and subsequent execution in 1540.