The recent finale of Doctor Who saw the Cybermen given their best material since their reintroduction in 2006. As a race the Cybermen hold a lot of promise - there are so many directions they can be taken in but most of their stories in the new run of Doctor Who have been rather lacklustre. Constantly the Cybermen are marginalised or out-shadowed by a larger threat or something with more prominence. The majority of their recent appearances have been wasted; they were likely only included to save money on creating a new monster, but such ideas come across as lazy. Several of their stories during the original run are rightly deemed as classics - The Tenth Planet and The Invasion amongst them. Admittedly some of these original episodes are poor too, but in comparison to their most recent appearances they don't appear all that bad. So why have the Cybermen came across as poor of late? Their 2006 reintroduction saw a parallel version of the silver menaces many had known for years - this alternate version allowed for a new continuity to begin afresh for a new viewership, but once that parallel world - or Petes World, as the Doctor dubbed it - became shut off forever (or so it seemed) it became harder to make the Cybermens appearances plausible. These Cybus-Cybermen exhausted all possibilities in the second series. Once they were all sucked back into the void they shouldn't have been able to return. Alas they did. What followed was several poor attempts at giving them some form of credence and, like the Daleks before them, they became a bit of a laughingstock. To celebrate their return to form (well, almost) here is a definitive ranking of their new series appearances. Click next to find out which came in last.
9. Closing Time
Closing Time is a prime example of the Cybermen being included in a story to keep the budget low. The Cybermen costumes were already in storage so not much in terms of threat was needed to be created for this story. Not that much threat was included anyway. The Cybermen only fleetingly appear several times as they bizarrely attempt to take over the world by using a shop as a masquerade. They were utilised extremely poorly and were probably only added because Craig Owens last appearance was panned due to a lack of a threat. All of this could be forgiven, of course, had love not conquered the Cybermen. Never in the preceding years had such a rubbish conclusion been given to defeat these silver menaces. Quite why it works now nobody knows. The viewers are expected to believe that Craig, and Craig alone, loves his son more than any other converted human on the planet. Well not many viewers did accept it, and Closing Time is generally regarded as a wasted opportunity.
8. A Good Man Goes To War
Yes, the Cybermen barely feature in this sensational episode, but at least they aren't defeated by love. The Twelfth Cyber Legion are introduced in this episode - and promptly vanquished. They bring nothing to the story, and are only included because A Good Man Goes To War served as the mid-series finale. However their appearance does allow Rory to become ruthless and demand answers. This was another wasted opportunity though. The Twelfth Cyber Legion appeared to have amassed a grand army, something which could have recurred. Viewers werent given answers to how this army had grown, why, or why the Cybermen were simply monitoring the area of space rather than trying to convert it. Surely an awesome battle episode could have ensured between the Doctor and the Cybermen? Sadly not. The Doctor blows the Cyber Legion out of space despite being nowhere near - something which he was unable to do when his friend Craig was nearly converted. Yeah, that seems plausible
7. The Next Doctor
Cyber-shades? Nothing more needs to be said really. Oh, maybe the Cyber-King. The Cybus-Cybermen somehow escape the void (by stealing Dalek technology, which the Daleks themselves didn't utilise for some unexplained reason), become pals with a human, kidnap children and use them as labourers, and raise a dreadnought ship from the Thames. Again, nobody knows quite why. All of these bonkers scenarios play second fiddle to the apparent appearance of the next Doctor, however. As such the Cybermen once more become secondary and their appearance is another letdown. At least the Cyber-Shades haven't returned though.
6. The Pandorica Opens
Now the good stuff. Like the preceding stories the Cybermen are out-shadowed here by the many returning threats, but the lone Cyberman beneath Stonehenge is used extremely efficiently. In this swashbuckling scene viewers were finally able to glimpse inside of the Cybermens helmets - and found out that they housed a skull. But the half-destroyed Cyberman here proved more powerful than most of their other appearances. The helmet attempted to kill Amy by snapping her head in its vice and strangling her with its snakelike chords. The scene may have been short, and Rory may have been able to destroy it by impaling it with a sword, but at least they became scary again. Even if it was only for a few minutes. They appeared again at the end of the episode (as did pretty much every monster in the new series) and again in the following episode - as a stone statue. Doing nothing. Once more.
5. The Time Of The Doctor
In the Eleventh Doctors swan song the Cybermen were out-shadowed by the Daleks and the Weeping Angels. Oh, and the regeneration of the Doctor, of course. A recurring thread is forming here. Whatever happened to the Cybermen being the primary focus? That said, they are used rather efficiently - aside from Handles, that is. They appear fleetingly but they do manage to turn wooden (somehow) in order to infiltrate the defences of Trenzalore. This was a thrill to watch for many as the Doctor turned the Cybermans weapons upon itself. The wooden Cyberman was good as a one-time thing, but probably shouldn't appear again.
4. Army Of Ghosts / Doomsday
As thrilling as the war between the Cybermen and the Daleks was, a better outcome would have been to see these two armies join forces. Then the Doctor would have been in real trouble. The highlight of this story is surely the millions of ghosts turning into Cybermen as the silver army took over the world. Here the Cybermen were also able to deliver sass to the Daleks, partly convert several Torchwood employees, and be all round an intimidating presence. The war between the Daleks and the Cybermen was rather poorly executed on screens, but that can be forgiven due to the show's limited budget. What was shown was still impressive, even if the Cybermen were defeated rather easily. The return of the Cybermen and the Daleks only really served to draw Rose from Earth and thus cut her off completely from the Doctor but at least both races were employed masterfully. Here they appeared to be a proper threat to the human race.
3. Nightmare In Silver
This episode should have been so much better than it was, especially considering Neil Gaiman was writing it. The human characters took too much of the screen time here. The easiest solution to make this episode better would have been to axe the Maitland kids - something which thankfully happened in the eighth series. That said, when the Cybermen were used, they were used brilliantly. Their upgraded form gave them several new abilities, a deeper voice, and the power of super-speed. Added to this was a more insectile version of the Cybermats, a Cyber-Planner to dictate proceedings, and a collective consciousness for the Cybermen known as the Cyberiad. This one story changed so much about the Cybermen, and made them altogether more scary. They just failed to appear properly until midway into the episode. Perhaps it should have been a two-parter? The Cybermen here employed the use of tombs, indicating that the Mondasian menaces had returned to Doctor Who. Either that, or the Mondasian and Cybus versions of the Cybermen had amassed into one. Either way the new design was streamline, brutal, and beautiful.
2. Dark Water / Death In Heaven
Once more the Cybermen became secondary to the malevolent Mistress, but they did become creepily chilling once more. Definitively so. The Cyber-tombs were used again here to house the Cybermen who were given the ability to convert the dead, producing some effective shots of silver hands bursting from graves. Admittedly the Cybermen did become zombie-like here and thus rendered pointless, and love managed to defeat the Cybermen again, but all of this can be forgiven due to how they were used throughout the episode. The body of Danny Pink rising as a Cybermen was chilling; the Cybermens ability to fly and attack the Valiant was thrilling; and the Cybermen once more descending from Saint Paul's was spine-tingling. Had they been the primary focus Dark Water and Death In Heaven probably would have become their definitive new Doctor Who story. But their secondary appearance can be forgiven because of how brilliant Missy was. Hopefully shell return to torment the Doctor again.
1. Rise Of The Cybermen / The Age Of Steel
No other new Doctor Who story has quite managed to capture the extent of the Cybermans aim - to convert anything and everything into one of their own. Here they even converted their own creator against his will. This was a proper origin story which, whilst not disregarding what had come before, still managed to create something altogether new and brilliant. They were properly scary here. Teased throughout the first part, their full unveiling towards the end was a triumph. As was their grasp on London as they marched through the darkened streets and took control of the general populous. But what made the Cybermen scary here was their complete lack of emotion and their stoic determination. Recognising what an asset their creator John Lumic was, the Cybermen went against his wishes and converted him into the leader, achieving their ultimate and only purpose - to convert. Of course Rise Of The Cybermen and The Age Of Steel were nowhere near as brilliant as their 1966 introduction, but it is a worthy followup. More stories like this - showing the full extent of their evil - need to be created. Stories in which the Cybermen are the primary focus. What did you think of our ranking? Would you have changed any of the positions? Let us know in the comments below.