American Horror Story: 10 Most Hated Episodes
Sometimes even the best shows have an off day or two or five or ten...
American Horror Story has had its ups and downs. With such a strong premiere, high hopes go hand in hand with every new season. With rotating cast members playing different characters every season, the show quickly became its own phenomenon.
Season 1's Murder House brought the haunted house back into the mainstream, opening the door for other successful shows such as Haunting of Hill House. Season 2's Asylum proved that the show's premiere wasn't a fluke. Strong writing and storytelling blended with the powerhouse acting of the recurring cast.
Season after season, American Horror Story continued to show-off its unique way of world-building and playing on the different forms horror can take. From family dramas to the dead wanting revenge, the writers found ways of keeping each season fresh and not overly repetitive.
But even the greatest show makes a few missteps. American Horror Story is no different and as the seasons went on, as actors came and went, and as the promise of delivering something bigger and better grew... it's no surprise a few episodes fell flat.
From filler episodes to awful characters to poor wrap-ups of, overall, relatively strong seasons, these 10 episodes are proof that even the best can lead to the worst.
Spoilers ahead!
10. The Ten Commandments Killer (S5E8)
A lot of fans would argue that Season 5 was probably when the series started its downfall from the fantastic earlier seasons. Perhaps most of the argument came from the lack of Jessica Lange, as she left the series following Season 4, and the introduction of Lady Gaga playing a major role in the show.
Season 5, aptly named Hotel, takes place in the mysterious Hotel Cortez in Los Angeles. One of the main storylines follows a homicide detective, John Lowe, in his search for the Ten Commandments Killer. His obsession affects his home life with he and his wife drifting apart following the disappearance of their son, Holden.
Episode 8, titled "The Ten Commandments Killer," reveals that John Lowe was the killer all along and was influenced by the ghost of the Hotel Cortez's owner, James Patrick Marsh, down the dark path.
This reveal was greeted with the season's lowest ratings. Many fans found it predictable, the presented timeline in the flashbacks made little-to-no sense, and that the episode overall was dull.
As Drew Grant wrote in the Observer:
In true AHS style, the writers seem to have come to the conclusion that Lowe was the killer only after having written the first couple of episodes.
Style over substance rang true throughout the episode, trying to make the reveal seem as dramatic as possible, while fans called it many episodes prior.
It attempted to give the audience a jaw-dropping moment, but only ended up whimpering into a 36% on Rotten Tomatoes.
9. Rest In Pieces (S9E8)
American Horror Story's ninth season, 1984, started promising for most fans.
But by the time the season reached its penultimate episode, Rest in Pieces, fans were once again left with the familiar AHS plot lines and habit of the writers to create filler episodes when they run out of ideas.
The needless time jump to 1989, introduction of new characters while sidelining more interesting ones, and an over explanation of Final Girls confirmed to many fans this season would end on a whimper.
The episode is filled with the familiar ghosts trapped in a location doing what they do familiar to American Horror Story fans, but they slow the pace. Some loose-ends were tied up, but not in a satisfying way.
In other words, it's simply another filler episode that many felt had little-to-no impact on the overall story. But there were still good moments that kept the episode from being the worst of the series.
And though some fans would argue the acting in this episode in particular was weak, others would argue it perfectly captured the theme of the season.
80s slasher flicks were themselves notorious for bad acting and some strange plot lines. But with the first half of the season considered fairly strong acting-wise, perhaps it was the flaws in the writing that were the true issue.
However, Ramirez's love for Billy Idol did provide some entertaining scenes.
8. The Seven Wonders (S3E13)
American Horror Story: Coven was, overall, a well-received season.
The addition of new faces (including Gabourey Sidibe, Kathy Bates, and Angela Bassett) with the familiar recurring cast built the season up as one of the best, continuing the show's impressive track record. And as the season played out, it achieved most of that promise. But the season finale left many fans feeling a bit let down.
The titular coven loses its head witch, the Supreme (played by Jessica Lange), in the penultimate episode. Her daughter Cordelia steps in temporarily to lead until the next Supreme is determined. The finale's whole plot is figuring out which of the four young witches in the house will rise to the position.
In order to crown the new Supreme, each of the candidates must perform all of the Seven Wonders: Telekinesis, Concilium (mind control), Pyrokinesis, Descensum (astral projection), Transmutation (teleportation), Vitalum Vitalis (reviving the dead), and Divination.
Each girl fails in one of the wonders, but with a little push from fellow witch Myrtle, Cordelia enters the competition. Cordelia ultimately wins, becoming the new Supreme. She then goes on to reveal the existence of witches to the public and opens the doors of the Coven to all.
It wasn't an awful finale, but it didn't live up to the high expectations of the season. It felt pointless to build up Misty as the favorite to become Supreme especially when she's the first to fail. And ultimately, none of the four young witches achieved the title.
7. Bullseye (S4E6)
American Horror Story: Freak Show was an alright season. It wasn't awful, but it wasn't the best.
The sixth episode, like the season, wasn't awful. But it was something a lot of fans of American Horror Story hate... a filler episode. Every character had a moment, but overall it didn't necessarily DO anything.
As one critic wrote:
This is like Alice in Wonderland up in here -- everyone just comes and goes so quickly.
Though the knife-throwing scene was entertaining, the rest of the episode felt drawn out with no real payoffs. We learn more of Elsa's obsession with becoming famous no matter who she steps on. Dandy discovers Dot hates him and only allows Bette to fawn over him so they can use his money for a possible separation surgery. Jimmy believes Elsa sold the twins off, angry at his mother for blindly trusting Elsa's word. Maggie plans to kill Ma Petite, but then doesn't.
Subplots were thrown at the audience seemingly out of nowhere. Elsa and Paul's tryst, Paul and the candy-striper from the hospital in Episode 1 who are, apparently, in love, and Del and Desiree apparently taking the night off from the Freak Show (seriously, where were they?).
But overall, fans really felt the loss of Twisty the murderous Clown, who died two episodes prior.
Too much was packed into a 73 minute episode. For an already okay season, the episode just felt meh.
6. Don't Be Afraid Of The Dark (S7E2)
The first episode from American Horror Story's seventh season to appear on this list (but not the last), "Don't Be Afraid Of The Dark" introduced interesting new characters into the season... but that's about it.
Continuing to build on the growing paranoia and ham-fisted message that fear turns anyone into what they hate most, the second episode is filled with more clowns scaring the daylights out of Sarah Paulson's Ally. The fear becomes too much for her after she discovers a clown in her bed. Caricature liberal Ally goes out and buys a gun to protect her home, easily throwing away her beliefs and letting her paranoia overpower her logic. Fans usually enjoy Paulson's emotional acting, but it felt like the writers wanted to see how many episodes (and how long) they could get him to cry on screen.
The predictability of the season's message was already thrown in the audience's face in the premiere episode of the season (more on that later) and continuing to play it up to its extremes was tiring.
Even with the introduction of new couple, the Wiltons, the repetitiveness of the episode and character extremes may be making a point... but it's not one the fans need to be told every five minutes.
5. Checking In (S5E1)
The fifth season of American Horror Story already had a large uphill climb before it even began. With the departure of series favorite and powerhouse Jessica Lange, fans wondered who would step in to fill her large shoes.
When it was announced Lady Gaga would be joining the cast, there were mixed feelings throughout the fandom. Some were curious to see how Mother Monster would fit into the story. Others felt it was a shameless attempt to draw in new audiences.
From its first episode, Hotel didn't hold any punches. Introducing many of the major players quickly, it still didn't prove to many fans that Gaga was a good fit. Many felt she fit the style of the Hotel Cortez, but her acting left a lot to be desired. Too much music video visuals and not enough compelling character.
But Gaga wasn't the only misstep. Seemingly an attempt to return to the shock and horror of the rubber man from the very first season of American Horror Story, the appearance of the Addiction Demon was touted as the most disturbing scene in the history of the series.
But as with Gaga's performance, it felt more included for visual needs instead of compelling storytelling.
Overall, the opening episode of the fifth season was praised for its appealing visuals, but panned for lack of depth and interesting characters and story.
4. Chapter 10 (S6E10)
Roanoke was a strange divergence from past seasons. Very little was released plot wise and fans didn't even know the title of the season until episode one. There were rumors, but nothing was ever confirmed. It was all a mystery.
The decision to shoot the season like a paranormal documentary was unusual, but worked in its favor. The first half of the season was the documentary. You had those being interviewed and a re-enactment playing alongside it.
The second half of the season switched it up. Following the success of the documentary, the producers bring the cast and real-life people back to the Roanoke house during the blood moon to capture the hauntings live. With many not believing the story to be true, it all goes downhill when the ghosts appear and begin killing everyone off.
The season overall was received with mostly positive reviews. The season finale was met with more of a question mark. Taking place after the events of the return to the Roanoke house, the finale chooses to focus on the only survivor, Lee.
Though fans were given a wonderful surprise cameo of Lana Winters, the episode seemed to be less of a wrap up and more of a footnote to the story. Perhaps it was due to the numerous change of shooting styles (documentary, interview, etc) or maybe it was due to the rushed conclusion of the story, either way, the finale of Roanoke was a strange ending to a relatively solid season.
3. Election Night (S7E1)
Politics will always be polarizing. American Horror Story decided to incorporate this polarization into its seventh season. In particular, the extremely divisive 2016 US election in which Donald Trump became the 45th President.
It could've worked, but ultimately... didn't. It wasn't so much that the writers went too far one way or the other (though many reviews claim that's true). The problem was: why bother?
Why include the real life politics? Ally and Kai became true satires of both sides and though politics and cults may go perfectly hand in hand, bringing real life politics only oversaturated the audience.
Perhaps it would've worked better to not include the real life election since the rest of the season doesn't seem to rely on the outcome as much as this opening episode. True, politics was probably always going to be part of the season's story, but somehow the divisiveness of the 2016 presidential election didn't add any nuance or interesting message.
Really, it felt more like taking two extremes and making them beyond caricature into outright over-the-top boring. Other themes seemed to be better executed (bad neighbors, phobias, etc.) but the addition of something many in, not only America, but the world were already exhausted with just made this opening episode a disinteresting, unappealing start to the seventh season.
2. Sojourn (S8E8)
If there is one thing American Horror Story fans hate, it's filler episodes. Every season has them. Every season is guilty. But when the inevitable filler episode happens to come out on regularly-reserved-for-shocking-episode Halloween week? Prepare for all out war.
That's what happened during American Horror Story: Apocalypse's eighth episode, Sojourn. In general the episode wasn't terrible, a common note for most filler episodes, but it happened to play the week of Halloween. Traditionally in AHS history, the Halloween episode is one of the strongest in the season.
Therefore, fans went into the episode with already high expectations. Sojourn didn't meet those expectations. Flashing back to show how Michael Langdon became the Antichrist, fans were bored with another flashback of the time before the bomb. Though the episode was interesting in showing what became of the baby from Season 1 (Michael was the son of Murder House characters Vivien Harmon and Tate Langdon), it put the brakes on the season building to a fight between Michael and the witches from Coven.
But the major error of the episode according to most fans? The characters Mutt and Jeff, two cocaine-addicted Satanists who work for a robotics company. Fans hated these comic reliefs who felt out of place in relatively more serious episode, finding them annoying and outright pointless.
Possibly the only thing keeping this episode from the number one spot is a strong monologue from Sandra Bernhardt and Sarah Paulson's many fantastic looks... but these only save the episode by a little.
1. Valerie Solanas Died For Your Sins: Scumbag (S7E7)
Cult makes its final appearance on the list in the number one spot. American Horror Story loves its flashbacks. Sometimes they add to the story and sometimes they bring groans from the fans. This is a case of the latter.
The episode bounces from 1968 to 2016, relaying the story of real-life radical feminist Valerie Solanas, the woman who shot Andy Warhol. It shows how she formed SCUM (the Society of Cutting Up Men) and wrote her SCUM Manifesto following Andy Warhol's mistreatment of her (losing a script she wrote).
On the surface, some may think this episode is hated due to the casting of Lena Dunham in the role of Valerie Solanas. Dunham is a notorious, vocal feminist who has received hate from time to time, but she's not wholly to blame. It's fair to say her acting was a bit over the top or her performance scenery-chewing, but the real problem is with the entire flashback.
It should've been reserved as a short opener instead of the focus of the episode. And the attempt to try to tie Valerie to the Zodiac Killer fell flat. The twist came out of nowhere and felt more like a ham fisted way to add something interesting to an already eye-rolling moment.
Though it was a valid attempt, the main complaint from fans was how the episode seemed to slam on the brakes. Perhaps if it occurred earlier in the season or was shortened, it could've worked.