American Horror Story: Apocalypse - 3 Ups & 2 Downs From 'Traitor'

The plot (mostly) thickens.

By Stephen Patterson /

FX

Contains spoilers from American Horror Story Season 8, Episode 7.

Advertisement

American Horror Story: Apocalypse delivered in every way possible with its Murder House-themed episode last week, which was always going to be a tough act to follow.

The drama nonetheless continues in Traitor, which proves to be a much more subdued instalment for the post-apocalyptic series.

Advertisement

After the events of last week, the witches of Miss Robichaux's Academy are now aware of Michael Langdon's true identity, and they're hellbent on putting a stop to the Anti-christ once and for all. It's tough for Cordelia, as her power begins to wane since a new Supreme has been chosen. There are quite a few more throwbacks to the days of Coven, which die-hard fans of the show will likely appreciate.

Unfortunately, it's not an entirely plot-driven episode, as the narrative stalls in quite a few places, and the writer opts for moments of comic relief instead of hard-hitting drama, which ultimately dilutes the seriousness of the upcoming apocalypse.

Advertisement

The Coven-esque episode provides us with many great moments, but the slow narrative progression - not to mention the glaring absence of Michael Langdon - makes Traitor one of Apocalypse's weaker instalments.

Ups...

3. The Return Of Papa Legba

FX

When we learned that American Horror Story was going to be revisiting two of its best seasons, there were a lot of characters that we thought about seeing again. Papa Legba, however, wasn't on this list, which is what makes his shocking return all the more exciting. In spite of the fact that he's responsible for sending Fiona Goode, Delphine LaLaurie and Marie Laveau to the underworld, the heinous hell-dweller has a special place in our hearts, and Apocalypse wouldn't have been complete without a flying visit from him.

Advertisement

Legba is easily one of AHS' most recognisable creatures, and he was also an important part in creating the unforgettable Coven aesthetic. His brief re-appearance aids in recapturing the vibe of the witch-themed season.

Although Cordelia is unable to broker a deal with Legba during this episode, one can't help but speculate if the Supreme witch manages to win him over at a later point. Remember, when the apocalypse does arrive, Cordelia and her friends are safe and sound, and several of her witches are even integrated into the Outpost (though without their abilities), so there's evidence to suggest that an other-worldly spell does take place. Will Legba perhaps have something to do with this?

Advertisement

2. Myrtle's Resurrection Finally Explained

FX

Going back to Coven has been nothing but a delight. The witch-inspired season remains one of AHS' finest outings, and every subsequent season of the show has failed to live up to it. Revisiting these characters and locations has been as spectacular as we could've hoped, although there has been one question on our lips: How the hell (pun intended) is Myrtle Snow alive after being burned at the stake in the final episode of Coven?

Advertisement

The post-apocalyptic season already explained how Madison, Misty and Queenie came back to life, and this episode sees Myrtle's missing puzzle piece to be filled in. It was pretty clever on the writer's part to have Cordelia pushed to the brink with worry, as this allowed her to forgo her morals and resurrect her friend for the sake of the greater good. This finally brings the inconsistencies to a close, which means we can now completely lose ourselves in the narrative.

1. The Coven Throwbacks

FX

As you can likely tell from the previous entries, much of Traitor's appeal lies in how it manages to re-capture all of the things that made Coven so great. In addition to Legba's visit and Myrtle's backstory filled in, this particular episode captures the tone of Coven in so many ways. For example, the witches working together to bring down Michael is reminiscent of how the women brought down the witch hunters in Season 3.

Advertisement

The most visually pleasing moment arrives when Cordelia leads her coven towards the garage where John Henry was murdered. The witches are clad in black clothing, walking behind their Supreme, as the signature 'la la la' theme tune accompanies them. It's a wonderful scene.

Apocalypse has successfully re-captured the aesthetic of both Murder House and Coven. Dare it be said but, save for a few caveats (more on that later), this episode proves why Apocalypse is exactly the kind of sequel to the witch-themed season that we hoped it would be.

Advertisement

Downs...

2. The Lack Of Plot Progression

FX

While there is plenty to love about Traitor, the fact that it did little to advance the narrative doesn't go unnoticed. Sure, Cordelia and the gang figure out who Michael's accomplice is, and they successfully dispose of Miss Mead, but in the grand scheme of things, not very much happened. What's more, the episode is rather self-indulgent, wasting far too much time on pointless humorous segments.

Advertisement

The opening moments see Dinah killing an adulteress in order to perform magic on a rich woman's husband. The scene went on for over three minutes, and added nothing to the narrative. It gets worse after the credits, when viewers are introduced to Joan Collins' second character - an actress named Bubbles. Bubbles is truly great, but the same can't be said for the first few scenes in which she features. The character takes part in a B-movie, forcing us to sit through four minutes of her filming which, again, advances the plot in no way whatsoever.

1. Michael's Absence (And The Plot Issues Because Of It)

FX

Michael Langdon isn't featured in at all in Traitor. His absence is rather noticable, and it ultimately results in quite a few plot issues. Firstly, the witches are conspiring to kill him. We've seen what Michael is capable of in previous episodes - specifically in Return to Murder House - so therefore, wouldn't he be able to use his powerful abilities to detect that the witches are plotting against him?

Advertisement

Perhaps there's an explanation for that, or perhaps the show is waiting to later to reveal that Michael is aware of Cordelia's plan. However, the real issue caused by Michael's absence comes much later into the episode - namely when Miss Mead is kidnapped by Cordelia's coven.

The character is subsequently burned at the stake for her actions, which doesn't make any sense. Why? Well, because Michael has made clear his affection for Miss Mead on many occasions throughout Apocalypse's run. Surely, he wouldn't have left her to fend for herself, not at least before putting a contingency plan in place? If we stretch our imaginations and believe that he did leave her with no protection, wouldn't he have at least been able to sense that she was in danger?

Advertisement

The show gives a pretty weak excuse for the character's absence, as Baldwin Pennypacker comments on Michael's desire to be alone in the wilderness. It all felt rather contrived, and came off as though the show simply didn't have access to actor Cody Fern for this particular episode.

What did you make of Traitor? Tell us in the comment section below.

Advertisement