Arrow: 4 Characters That Absolutely Cannot Die (And 4 That Can)

At this point, anyway.

By Laura Hurley /

The fourth season of The CW's Arrow has overall been much lighter than the third. The dark moments have admittedly been super dark, but there have at least been some smiles among the doom and gloom. On the whole, however, there has been a shadow hanging over each of the eight episodes that have aired since the season premiere. The flashforward at the end of the first episode, which saw a wrecked Oliver Queen standing over a grave and telling Barry Allen that he's off to kill a bad guy. has had fans speculating since October about just whose body has been buried. Prior to Season 4, it was easy to name ten characters that could not be killed off. Now, following the devastating midseason finale, the list has gotten smaller. There are of course reasons to not want characters to die. Each of them have at least a few redeeming qualities, but the show is ultimately going to kill the spare whose death can make a big impact without costing too much in the long term. There are some candidates for the grave who just make more sense than others. This is a spoiler-free look at the characters that the narrative of the show at this point absolutely needs in order to logically carry on...and those it can do without in Season 5.

Advertisement

Can't Die...

4. John Diggle

Who He Is: John Diggle is a former soldier whose life changed forever when he was hired as Oliver Queen's bodyguard. He's since found a purpose beyond following the idle rich on their frivolities and become as much a hero on the homefront as he was overseas. He's found a dear friend in Felicity, a surrogate brother in Oliver, a family of his own with his wife and daughter, and now a mask and code name as a full-time field member of Team Arrow. Why He Can't Die: Although Team Arrow is overflowing with muscle these days, Digg is invaluable for his experience as well as for his weapons of choice, and the other non-Oliver masks of Team Arrow just do not have the presence at this point to fill the void that would exist if he were to die. Also, David Ramsey has said that John Diggle is used as the character that Oliver will become five years in the future. Digg presents a healthier template of life as a vigilante to which Oliver should aspire, and that won't work at all if he is unceremoniously killed by the end of Season 4.

3. Samantha Clayton

Who She Is: Samantha Clayton is the woman who managed to alienate a healthy portion of the audience in her single major appearance on the show. She is the mother of Oliver's child who hid his son from him for nearly a decade, has demanded that he lie to those he loves about the existence of his kid, and who may or may not have secretly cashed a check for a million dollars while claiming to take the high road. Why She Can't Die: Samantha can't die for purely practical reasons. Arrow is not a show on which the hero can have a kid on any sort of regular basis. Quite aside from him being in constant danger by sheer proximity to both Oliver and the Green Arrow, Oliver hasn't run out of stories so much so that he needs a child in his life to spice things up. As long as Samantha is alive, the show can have the melodrama of Oliver having a kid who pops up from time to time without needing to deal with him for more than a handful of episodes. Samantha needs to stay.

2. Thea Queen

Who She Is: Thea Queen is the beloved baby sister of Oliver Queen. She's outgrown the bratty entitlement of her first season on the show and evolved into a strong young woman. Despite an unfortunate stretch in which she was drugged by her biological father and forced to do his dirty work, she has chosen to use the skills that he instilled in her to fight to save Star City as the vigilante known as Speedy. Why She Can't Die: Thea pretty much died about six months following the premiere of Season 3; Thea dying six months following the premiere of Season 4 would just be repetitive. Oliver has already reacted to her imminent demise, and she's already gotten a climactic fight with a supervillain. Twice in two years would be too much. Thea is also Oliver's last untainted connection to what good there was in him before the island. Most of those who knew him as Pre-Island Ollie would have known him for his awful public persona and terrible hair; most of those who saw the good heart underneath the loathsome veneer and have not been epically wronged by him are dead and buried by this point. Thea is the last one standing.

1. Felicity Smoak

Who She Is: Felicity Smoak, M.I.T. class of '09, is the computer genius extraordinaire without whom Team Arrow would be nothing but a group of physically fit folks in leather and masks. Her lightness despite occasional immersion in the thundercloud that follows Oliver Queen around has made her invaluable to keeping the show something other than a total angst-fest. Oliver's fiancee as of the end of the midseason finale, Felicity has arguably become the most important female character on Arrow. Why She Can't Die: There are an awful lot of problems that can't be fixed by punching, and Felicity is how Team Arrow finds most of the bad guys and gathers most of the information instrumental to taking them down. The show needs for there to exist a Team Arrow, and Team Arrow absolutely needs Felicity. More important, however, is that Oliver absolutely needs Felicity. Arrow is still Oliver's show, and characters' relevance can be ultimately be measured by the importance of their relationships with Oliver. The only character to whom Oliver's growth as a character has been consistently connected has been Felicity. Besides, no way could Oliver get over her death after how their relationship has been built up. Oliver in the flashforward was not a man who had lost the love of his life.

Can Die...

4. Alex Davis

Who He Is: Alex Davis is Oliver€™s campaign manager. Oliver seems fond-ish of him, and he€™s been romantically connected to Thea. As of right now, Alex is one of only a handful of characters frequently featured but with no clear connections to either Damien Darhk or Team Arrow. Why He Can Die: Alex dying would be a way for Arrow to take the easy way out. Murdering a character innocent of helping either the good guys or the bad guys would be nice and tragic, and getting rid of Oliver€™s campaign manager would be a solid way for Arrow to kill somebody off without really shaking up the status quo very much. Of course, there is the question of just how Alex would be murdered for Oliver€™s reaction in the flash forward to make much sense. Oliver wasn€™t nearly wrecked enough for Thea or Felicity to be in the grave, but kind of a lot would need to happen for him to be that wrecked for Alex. Still, Alex is super killable.

3. William Clayton

Who He Is: William Clayton is Oliver€™s biological son with Samantha Clayton. Approximately nine-years-old by Oliver€™s estimation, William appears to be a healthy and happy boy who totally doesn€™t need to move to Star City because of an untimely death for his mom. Why He Can Die: Cruel as it may seem, Oliver€™s kid is way more expendable than Oliver€™s baby mama. William dying would remove the possibility of the show coming to a full halt so that Oliver could play dad to a pre-teen and add a depth of tragedy that even those viewers most frustrated by the baby mama drama would have to feel. Oliver would quite understandably be upset by William€™s death despite not really knowing him, and it would make a certain degree of sense for Barry to show up at the cemetery. Arrow always gets pretty dark toward the end of the season; William dying could definitely work by the time of the flashforward. There is the question of whether or not Oliver could recover from the death of his child at the hands of his latest nemesis, but that question is not nearly enough to mark William as safe.

2. Laurel Lance

Who She Is: Laurel Lance is one of the two members of Team Arrow who actually seems to have a real day job. She may not spend a whole lot of time at the office as an attorney, but she does at least work somewhere unrelated to Oliver. She€™s a masked member of Team Arrow as the Black Canary. Why She Can Die: Of all of the members of Team Arrow and of almost all of the regulars, Laurel is the character that most easily lifts right out. Without her Canary Cry, she€™s the most impractical fighter with her close combat weapons, and the show very rarely uses her for her role as a lawyer. She€™s also the character with significant enough of a relationship to Oliver that he would absolutely mourn her but with whom there€™s enough of a disconnect that he could get over her death. Laurel hasn€™t had a plot of her own ever since Sara was resurrected to be shipped off to the spinoff. Dinah Laurel Lance as Black Canary may be a big figure in comic lore, but the show does not hold to comic canon, and Laurel lifts right out.

1. Quentin Lance

Who He Is: Quentin Lance is currently a captain of the Star City Police Department who was bamboozled into working for Damien Darhk. He€™s currently functioning as a double agent by reporting on Darhk to Team Arrow. Why He Can Die: Quentin was formerly safe mostly because he was Oliver€™s source within the city government; with Oliver now poised to become mayor unless somebody else enters the race or he drops out, Team Arrow will have resources within the city that extend further than what Quentin could provide. The signs are all there. Quentin is being given an arc to redeem his relatively despicable behavior at the end of Season 3, and he€™s currently in a very precarious position as Team Arrow€™s inside man within H.I.V.E. It€™s entirely possible that all of the clues to Quentin kicking the bucket sooner rather than later are red herrings so that a €œGotcha!€ death of somebody else will take the audience by surprise, but at this point, Quentin€™s odds of surviving Season 4 are not too great. Which characters do you think can or can't die on Arrow? Share your thoughts down in the comments. Like this article? Follow us on Twitter: @WhatCultureTV