Arrow Season 7: 4 Ups & 2 Downs From 'Emerald Archer'

Arrow's 150th episode pays tribute to the past while looking to the future.

By Michael Patterson /

The CW

Contains spoilers from Arrow Season 7, Episode 12.

Advertisement

Last week's emotional episode of Arrow saw multiple characters confronted by demons from their own respective pasts - demons that were preventing them from moving forward. On reflection, this is actually quite ironic, as the past would also go on to play a pretty major role in this week's instalment, the show's 150th episode: 'Emerald Archer'.

Employing a unique documentary-like approach, the episode took a look back at the impact that vigilantes have had on Star City over the course of the show's near-seven year run - a story move that ultimately served as the perfect backdrop for the rise of new vigilante hunter Chimera. Furthermore, it also saw the continuation of some of the season's underlying storylines and even gave us an expected, albeit brief, sneak peek of Star City's grim future.

Advertisement

All in all, 'Emerald Archer' was, in many ways, a love letter to everything that has made Arrow the success that it is today while remaining firmly grounded in the show's current storylines, and the result was near-perfection.

First, the positives.

Advertisement

Ups...

4. The Documentary Format

The CW

On one hand, 'Emerald Archer' was an adventure that saw the heroes of Star City attempt to take down a new vigilante hunter. But on the other hand, it was something quite different.

Advertisement

Opening with its own Warner Bros. logo before launching into some gritty amateur footage of vigilantes on the streets (all neatly rounded off with some fancy narration by Kelsey Grammer himself), the episode's documentary format, which looked at the rise of vigilantism in Star City, served as the perfect vehicle for the show to pay tribute to its past (more on that later). However, it also provided the creative team with the opportunity to change things up, presenting the show's recycled format in a different light and, in a sense, refreshing it.

An example of this is the first fight scene between Oliver and Chimera, in which the crew follows the Green Arrow into an abandoned building where he squares off against the vigilante hunter. The beauty of this is that we got to watch the entire scene unfold through the crew's camera and it was, quite frankly, beautiful.

Advertisement

With long dimly-lit corridors, intentional shakiness and heavy-breathing, the documentary's camera added a found-footage effect to the entire sequence which, combined with the heart-pounding music, made for a genuinely suspenseful and thrilling scene. Not only did this restore a more grounded feel to Arrow (that the show has been missing in recent years), it set the entire episode apart, portraying it as the visual spectacle that it deserved to be.

3. Honouring The Past

The CW

There really is no point in honouring the past without honouring what made it so great, so it was refreshing to see that Arrow's 150th episode was, for the most part, well aware of that. Thanks in no small part to the documentary format, 'Emerald Archer' provided us with the trip down memory lane that we were all hoping for. From new camera angles of old footage to newly-filmed interview segments, it was rife with heartfelt little tributes to the show's glory days.

Advertisement

The interview segments allowed us to see the return of Arrow legends Quentin Lance (Paul Blackthorne) and Thea Queen (Willa Holland) as well as some of the show's most beloved recurring characters like Sin (Bex Taylor-Klaus) and Season 5 vigilante Rory Regan/Ragman (Joe Dinicol), while also making time to feature former Arrow characters like Legends of Tomorrow's Sara Lance (Caity Lotz) and The Flash's Barry Allen (Grant Gustin). Furthermore, other characters received tributes in the form of previously unseen footage, such as the original Laurel Lance/Black Canary and Helena Bertinelli's Huntress.

However, it didn't stop with the visuals as the plot itself was so closely connected with the past that it was impossible to go more than two minutes without thinking about it - thanks to the vigilante hunter himself, Chimera, who had collected the masks of Huntress and Ragman, suggesting that he may have harmed them.

Advertisement

All of this ensured that, while many important present-day events occurred, this episode was as much about honouring the past as it was about embracing the future, and thankfully, it all went hand-in-hand.

2. More To William Than Meets The Eye

The CW

One of the episode's high-points saw the return of Oliver's son, William Clayton, who was welcomed back by his father and Felicity during an incredibly awkward moment (with the documentary crew present to film the whole thing). Actor Jack Moore hadn't been since the beginning of the season when Felicity sent William off to boarding school for his own protection and, for some reason, didn't bring him home when Oliver returned.

Advertisement

William apparently didn't take too kindly to being left out of the loop as he threw a tantrum over Felicity's virus' invasion on his tablet. However, he would then drop a major bombshell when he revealed that he had been expelled from school. Despite that, it's clear that there is more going on here than we know about.

Though much of his role in the episode proved to be incredibly problematic (more on that later), it's clear that the character is going through quite a lot and, if it's handled correctly, it could prove to be one of the show's most important storylines. As William is often shoved into the background, we don't get to see that much of what's going on in his head, but this episode has suggested that this may change going forward.

Advertisement

In a few short scenes, Moore gave one of his finest performances yet, with one particular moment being admittedly quite moving, so let's just hope that he's given enough screen time in the coming episodes to allow us to truly empathise with William - because this is definitely a start.

1. Making Progress

The CW

Throughout the season, Mayor Pollard has made it incredibly clear that she refuses to tolerate vigilantism in Star City. This intolerance made her Town Hall debate with Oliver the perfect backdrop for the vigilante slayer's attack as the villain showed up and, quite frankly, raised hell. However, knowing that the SCPD wouldn't be enough to stop the armoured monster, Oliver agreed to let his friends help him and, as a result, Team Arrow was back.

Advertisement

Their eventual defeat of Chimera saw Mr. Terrific, Wild Dog and Spartan surrounded by the SCPD and taken into custody. Despite Laurel's efforts to help them, their violation of the Anti-Vigilante Act ensured that prison time was in their future. That is, until Mayor Pollard, somewhat moved by the fact that Dinah used her Canary Cry to save her life, came to rescue as she instructed the former Black Canary to deputize all of Team Arrow - making them official agents of the SCPD.

After almost a year-long break from Team Arrow, it will finally be nice to see them back in action on the show, and their return will undoubtedly move the story forward, as its growing increasingly obvious that it's going to take a whole team to defeat Diaz and his Longbow Hunters.

Advertisement

It made complete sense for one of the foundations of the show to make its long-awaited comeback in the 150th episode and, following that impressive fight scene, it's clear that we're going to see a lot more of Team Arrow going forward.

Now, for the negative...

Advertisement

Downs...

2. Discrepancies Surrounding William's Return

The CW

While it was admittedly nice to finally see young William back on the show, his return came with its own issues. The character's upset over the fact that Oliver and Felicity didn't bring him home over the holidays was rather understandable (totally with you on that one, kid). However, when all fell apart, he turned to his best friend to talk about it.

Advertisement

Who is his best friend, you ask? Why, Zoe of course. You know Zoe, right? The vigilante-championing daughter of Rene Ramirez? Yeah, well apparently they're best friends now because they started texting each other when William was away - which was an incredibly convenient way for the writers to tell us "oh these two are friends now, got it?". Rene's shock at their sudden friendship, and hilarious protective-dad jokes, added a little more believability to it, but it didn't exactly make viewers buy their friendship.

William's sudden expulsion also proved to be quite problematic because of the simple fact that Felicity was unaware of it. Surely the school would have called Oliver and/or Felicity to notify them that the child they were entrusted with had been expelled from that very boarding school?

Advertisement

Outside of the odd episode or two, Arrow often fails to give secondary characters the development they need, and William has unfortunately fallen victim to that in the past. Now that we know the character will play a major role in the future, it's imperative that the groundwork is laid properly. Thus, instead of being told about it, we must actually see his development.

1. Reduced Use Of Long-Running Cast Members

The CW

While the Arrow writers did a great job honouring the veteran actors who were no longer a part of the show, they failed to truly honour some of the ones that were. Obviously lead actor Stephen Amell had a ton of screen time because he plays the protagonist, while David Ramey and Emily Bett Rickards played a slightly reduced (but acceptable) role. However, the two other Arrow vets, Katie Cassidy and Colton Haynes (both of whom have been a part of the show since the beginning), were sorely overlooked.

Advertisement

Given that Cassidy was the Arrowverse's very first leading lady, not to mention the fact that her current character (Earth-2 Laurel/Black Siren) is one of the most important characters of this season, there would have been plenty of convincing ways to feature her more heavily, especially given Siren's ties to Earth-1 Laurel. The interview segment (intercut with scenes of the Black Canary) barely scratched the surface of the insight that this Laurel could have offered to vigilantism, given that she's a former vigilante-turned-District Attorney, and it's ridiculous that we're expected to buy that the producers of the documentary wouldn't have thought so too.

While Laurel did feature in the episode briefly, Roy Harper was absent altogether (with the exception of old footage). Now, given that the character is currently playing a major role in the flash-forwards arc, wouldn't it have made sense to feature him in at least one flash-forward throughout the episode? Like Cassidy, Haynes has been an integral part of the show since Season 1 and, it didn't make any sense that he wasn't utilized.

Advertisement

Arrow wouldn't be what it is today without these two and, quite frankly, they both deserved major roles in the show's 150th episode.

-

Advertisement

Did you enjoy Arrow's 150th episode? Tell us in the comment section below.