The Scariest Joker We've EVER Gotten...
Batman: Caped Crusader season two is bringing a very different Joker to the table...
Look out, Gotham! Joker's back in town - but don't make the mistake of thinking this is your average, ordinary Clown Prince.
Batman: Caped Crusader returns to our screens July 31st, and the show - situated in the 1940s and concocted by DC Animated Universe veterans Bruce Timm and James Tucker - is doing something very different with the Dark Knight's arch-foe. He's lean, he's mean, and he's decidedly un-clownish, and while that might seem like a departure from the Joker most DC fans are familiar with today, it's actually harkening back to the character's Golden Age roots, and in a way that could make for one of the most refreshing and indeed unnerving depictions of a Batman rogue we've ever seen.
Batman: Caped Crusader landed with somewhat of a ripple in 2024, making its debut on Prime Video after being carelessly tossed aside by the then-incoming Warner Bros. regime led by David Zaslav. This, despite it being concocted by Timm - the key architect of the beloved Batman: The Animated Series - and having secured the services of renowned comic book writers Ed Brubaker and Greg Rucka, both of whom cut their teeth on Batman in the early 2000s with the critical smash Gotham Central comic alongside artist Michael Lark.
Caped Crusader also boasted something few modern superhero adaptations can lay claim to: a fearlessly unique premise. Timm and co-showrunner James Tucker elected to root this new Batman show specifically within the historical context of the 1940s, adhering to Batman's pulp-noir roots and all the gritty horror those initial Detective Comics issues contained. Golden Age incarnations of iconic Batman villains like Clayface and Catwoman had the spotlight thrown on them, while more modern Bat rogues were also given a 1940s twist, such as Harley Quinn and Onomatopoeia. The end result was something supremely atmospheric and supernatural, with the season finale teeing up a confrontation between the Dark Knight and his most iconic adversary, the Joker.
True to the show's ethos, though, this Joker was positioned as anything but the all-singing, all-dancing clown DC readers have grown accustomed to in recent decades. The snippet we were given promised a more menacing, steely, and cold-hearted villain - a monstrous figure with a calculating cadence, and one who, ironically, you might have a hard time picturing with a smile.
It's an adjustment that promises to smash through the notion of "Joker Fatigue" altogether, and also encapsulates why Caped Crusader is such a clever interpretation of the Batman mythos. Timm and co. are wielding the history and genre influences of the World's Greatest Detective with deadly precision, and with the Joker, they may have found their killing punchline.
[Article continues on next page...]
Batman: Caped Crusader Season 2 Rediscovers The Man Who Laughs
Batman as a character has been presented to audiences in many guises, but there is a modern interpretation that has somewhat calcified over the last two decades. This Batman is usually drawn from the Frank Miller mould, inspired by the masterful Year One and Dark Knight Returns, with a healthy sprinkling of Jeph Loeb and Tim Sale's The Long Halloween thrown in for good measure. These adaptations tend to adhere to the character's crime-drama components, sidestepping the fantastical or supernatural elements of the comics to juxtapose the neon-filled zaniness of Joel Schumacher's films. (Those films rock, for the record, but DC as a brand isn't so keen.)
It's a sentiment that feels somewhat antiquated in an era of Spider-Verses and Infinity Wars - and there is of course a healthy variety of Batman stories being told across comics, film, and television, exemplified by the Absolute Batman comics and also Caped Crusader - but still, the character persists in mainstream interpretations as a grounded, gritty vigilante bereft of fantasy, as reflected in Matt Reeves' The Batman and Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight trilogy.
The Joker, for the most part, has followed in lockstep, with most modern interpretations drawing upon Dennis O'Neil and Neal Adams' iconic reinvention of the character in the 1970s. For film and TV especially, the imperious legacy of The Dark Knight's Joker and Heath Ledger also looms large. Taken together, it certainly feels as if the Joker - like Batman - has experienced a sort of flattening in his portrayal, often being boiled down to a formula of maniacal laughter and drawn-out monologues without the humour to complement.
But again, like our vengeful Caped Crusader, Joker hasn't always been the same character. He's been a Silver Age prankster, a criminal mastermind, and even, in some instances, an unlikely ally. That very multiplicity is also informing his portrayal in Batman: Caped Crusader's second season, with the show taking Joker back to his silent movie roots to conjure a visage of circus horror that's been lost since the character's formative moments. He's stoic, calm, and utterly ruthless, as was teased in the final sequences of Caped Crusader's first season.
In a discussion with Entertainment Weekly, Caped Crusader showrunner James Tucker expanded upon the rationale behind this new interpretation of the character, who it is now also confirmed will be forced by House of the Dragon actor Matthew Neadham.
By following the character's initial inspiration - that being Conrad Veidt's Gwynplaine from the 1928 silent film The Man Who Laughs - Tucker and co. decided to tap into the horror of silent cinema, noting the pale, chalk-white makeup utilised by actors and the uncanny, ghostly feeling it could inspire. This led the Caped Crusader team to "reinterpret Joker as a character who basically came from silent movies, who came from German expressionism." In this case, the temperature of the makeup informed this Joker's personality. "He's kind of a cold character in this interpretation", Tucker says, confirming that this Joker is a huge departure from the criminal jester we're all acquainted with.
The first season of Batman: Caped Crusader was already cinematically minded, pulling from film noir and classic horror to cultivate its unique interpolation of Batman's world, so to see that season two is also leaning into German expressionism is particularly exciting. Disorientation, the dreamlike, the grotesque - these are all qualities that are right at home with Batman, and Joker more than any other character should be the perfect conduit.
[Article continues on next page...]
The Joker Comics (& Classic Movie Villains) That Will Inspire Batman: Caped Crusader Season 2
What makes Batman: Caped Crusader work so much for me ultimately is that it's as much a tribute to the Dark Knight's Golden Age as it is a recalibration of that era, taking into account compelling historicisms and genre influences from the first decade of Batman stories. It's Bruce Timm's gorgeous 75th Anniversary short stripped back and unvarnished, and a firm declaration that the Dark Knight's mythos doesn't have to be drawn in just one way.
For the Joker, the decision to root the character in expressionistic influences - to contrast the silent with the fundamentally loud nature of superhero storytelling - is dynamite, but arguably just as exciting is that the show seems to have extrapolated a different meaning for the character by interrogating the imagery of his first comic book appearance.
Bob Kane's pencils in Batman #1 aren't particularly dynamic, but instead eke out an uncanny horror from their stillness. That very lack of motion, the monoexpressive nature of Joker's face, is what has manifested Caped Crusader's new Clown Prince, who from the very beginning was depicted as a ruthless killer light on banter and high on cruelty - a medieval marauder who tortured Gotham's elite. From the brief snippet seen of Joker in the trailer, it looks like we'll be getting some kind of twist on that first appearance, which was memorably retold as Batman: The Man Who Laughs by Ed Brubaker and Doug Mahnke in 2005.
Where Caped Crusader will be taking more modern cues from, however, is in the relationship between Batman and Joker. Whereas the Clown Prince was depicted as a theatrical, scheming murderer who was inconvenienced by Batman in his first appearance, the Joker today is very much wedded to the Dark Knight, to the point where their relationship is almost seen as symbiotic. (As Mark Hamill's Joker famously quipped in Batman: The Animated Series, "without Batman, crime has no punchline.")
Going off the trailer for season two, it looks as though this Joker will be similarly fixated on Batman, doing what he does so that he can "awaken" the Bat, only this time executed with a methodical, patient cadence. That lends this Clown Prince a different kind of menace, evoking more the scheming hands of expressionistic villains like Dr Caligari or Mabuse, and less the anarchic trickster established in DC canon. Those figures are also echoed in the ending tease of season one, where Joker, cast in shadow, calmly and ruthlessly refines his toxin on a captive audience.
[Article concludes on next page...]
Batman: Caped Crusader Shows Why DC Is At The Top Of Its Game
Despite being put out to pasture by Warner Bros. leadership in 2024, Caped Crusader embodies everything that's great about DC in this current moment. It's fresh, inventive, and unbeholden to any sense of brand synergy, with the guiding strategy instead being to back talent to tell the stories they're drawn to as custodians of the publisher's iconic stable.
It's a far cry from the days of the New 52, where comics, games, and movies all seemingly had to be aligned along similar aesthetic boundaries. Instead, the message now from DC seems to be "let em' cook", whether that's Bruce Timm and James Tucker on a 1940s-set Batman show, or Scott Snyder and Nick Dragotta on the manga-inspired Absolute Batman, or James Gunn on Superman and its upcoming sequel, Man of Tomorrow.
In every medium, creator-first storytelling seems to be the aim of the game - a principle that's also ensuring the less-explored, cult-favourite corners of the DC Universe are getting their time in the spotlight, as per recent announcements at San Diego Comic Con that new comics focusing on Etrigan the Demon and Jonah Hex are on the way as well.
Batman: Caped Crusader might have been discarded by Warner Bros., but it's forming a quiet but no less compelling part of that lineup. The only thing it's lacking is the marketing push it deserves, but hopefully, with a little help from a newer, scarier Clown Prince of Crime, this second season will land with a crash, bang, and whallop to get more Bat Fans paying attention.
--
Batman: Caped Crusader season two starts streaming on Prime Video July 31.