Black Mirror: Ranking Every Episode From Worst To Best

How does Bandersnatch compare to previous Black Mirror episodes?

By James Hunt /

Netflix

Ever since its debut way back in 2011, Charlie Brooker's Black Mirror has held viewers in its grasp, frequently staring in disbelief at the dark reflection of humanity on offer.

Advertisement

It was ahead of its time when it debuted on Channel 4 all those years ago, and it remains as such now, with the release of choose your own adventure movie Bandersnatch. The show may have made a leap from Channel 4 to Netflix, but it's retained much of Brooker's sharp writing and skewering of technology and society.

It's a show that often works best when it feels like it's only five minutes in the future, but let's take a look back at the past of Black Mirror to how it all stacks up, from elected politicians having sex with porcine animals to an agonising choice between Sugar Puffs and Frosties.

Advertisement

20. The Waldo Moment

Channel 4

Black Mirror, despite its dark satire, very rarely gets overly political. And based on the end result of The Waldo Moment, that's definitely a good thing. The Waldo Moment sees a comedian who voices a cartoon bear decide to enter his creation into the race to become a Member of Parliament, which goes further than anyone thought possible.

The show's most political episode is also its worst - yes, it scores some points for being particularly prescient when it comes to Donald Trump's Presidency, but that alone isn't enough to cover up its flaws.

Advertisement

It's not that The Waldo Moment is terrible, but its plot and humour rarely feels well drawn, especially compared to how sharp the rest of the show generally is. It looks better now, but the ideas all feel undercooked, before descending into unearned dystopian chaos at the very end.

[James Hunt]

Advertisement

19. Men Against Fire

Netflix

Despite being down at the bottom here, there's nothing really "wrong" with Men Against Fire. It's a competently put together episode with decent performances and a couple of exciting sequences. The problem is that, for a Black Mirror episode anyway, the central hook doesn't have all that much to it.

Advertisement

It's easy to guess that the supposed alien "Roaches" the military main characters are being sent out to kill aren't going to really be alien at all, but rather human "undesirables". This theme itself is certainly relevant and worth diving into - and the idea of regular soldiers being manipulated to make genocide seem like a game has formed the foundation of so many other great stories - it's just the episode is so heavy handed with its execution that the overall message comes at the expense of compelling storytelling.

In a way, you kind of wish Men Against Fire was a little worse, then at least it would elicit feelings stronger than a shrug of the shoulders.

Advertisement

[Josh Brown]

18. Black Museum

Netflix

Black Museum had lofty ambitions. After four full seasons telling unconnected stories, this finale was built on the promise of joining all of them together, with those previous tales all being attractions located within the titular museum. Home to "authentic criminological artefacts", the episode follows main character Nish's visit to the isolated attraction, as she's shown around and given the full story on three of the items held there.

Advertisement

The wraparound narrative and anthology structure is evocative of White Christmas, but unfortunately Black Museum doesn't boast the same connective throughline which made that episode such a standout. There was no real show-stopping short story either, and the references to other episodes - which came in the form of key items that fans would instantly recognise - are mostly just there as background iconography, with the thrill of seeing them again overshadowing the fact that the filmmakers weren't really doing anything interesting with their inclusion.

Some of the stories are still enjoyable, and it is cool to see the entire history of Black Mirror brought together for the first time, but there's the constant feeling that the episode didn't quite live up to its true potential, and might have only subtracted some of the mystique from this universe, rather than added to it.

Advertisement

[JB]

17. Crocodile

Netflix

Season 4 is when it started to feel like Charlie Brooker was, to an extent, running out of fresh ideas. There were still some excellent episodes, but a few too many were simply mired in the show's usual fatalism without much new to say.

Advertisement

Crocodile is one such offender. It tells the story of Mia, who woman who helps her friend cover up a hit-and-run. Years later, he wants to confess, leading her to murder him as well, and things spinning further out of control. A new device allows the person investigating these crimes to see the memories of the person they're interviewing, uncovering the past traumas.

The episode, which is set in Iceland, is one of the best looking of the entire series, but it never does much with its setting, characters, or Recaller technology beyond complete bleakness for bleakness' sake, relying upon that and violence to shock viewers rather than telling the complex stories we've come to expect.

Advertisement

[JH]

16. Metalhead

Netflix

Even though he's only directed two episodes, David Slade feels like a major part of modern Black Mirror's style. Bringing over the same grounded bleakness that made his films (including the best Twilight movie - yes, really) so hauntingly memorable, Slade's abilities have only added to the texture of Brooker's show. Unfortunately, his first episode, Metalhead, didn't quite have the script to really allow him to let loose.

Advertisement

The story itself was still good, of course. As streamlined as BM gets, the ep was essentially one long chase sequence, following a group of survivors attempting to escape virtually invincible human-hunting robots, all set against the backdrop of a dystopian British countryside (so, just the regular British countryside, then). From the opening minutes, Slade ensures that the premise is as tense and suspenseful as it should be, and the lethality of these killer robo-dogs is enforced at every step. Violence is quick and nasty, to the point where death actually seems preferable to survival.

It's the rare Black Mirror episode that doesn't have any subversive twist hiding up its sleeve (bar an ambiguous final reveal, anyway). While that might make it seem a little basic compared to some of the show's best outings, in the case of Metalhead, simplicity isn't necessarily a bad thing.

Advertisement

[JB]

15. Fifteen Million Merits

Channel 4

A skewering of reality TV shows such as X-Factor, Fifteen Million Merits takes place in a dystopian future where people must cycle to power their surroundings and earn credits. Bing (Daniel Kaluuya) meets Abi (Jessica Brown), and convinces her to make a bid for freedom via a talent show.

Advertisement

There's a lot of good stuff in this episode - we're past the point of any instalment being considered bad now - including the two central performances, with Kaluuya showing why he'd become such a force in a few years time. The trouble is that's the part that holds up best, with the rest of Brooker's critique of capitalism and talent shows feeling dated.

It's also an episode that simply exists to make a point. There's zero subtlety here, with Brooker instead hitting viewers over the head with a sledgehammer to drive his messaging home, and is much longer than it needs to be, but Bing and Abi just about hold things together.

Advertisement

[JH]

14. ArkAngel

Netflix

Like a few other episodes covered so far, the main problem with ArkAngel is that the plot plays out exactly how you expect it to. It could maybe be argued that the fatalism of these dystopian narratives - the fact that these characters always succumb to the darkest results when put in control of this futuristic tech - is kind of part of Black Mirror's grander thesis, but here it just feels like lazy storytelling.

Advertisement

It's still emotional, thanks in no small part to the dedicated performances from the two leads, and boasts some of the most beautiful cinematography the show has seen so far, but ArkAngel sees Booker playing around with familiar ideas, and there's the sense that there's nothing left to say about them that hasn't already been said in previous episodes.

Had this released a few years prior it could have jumped up higher, and it is still an enjoyable, solid episode which only feels inferior when compared to instalments that have tackled similar themes, only better.

Advertisement

[JB]

13. Hated In The Nation

Netflix

Hated In The Nation is a peculiar episode of Black Mirror, largely by being such a conventional police thriller. It’s the kind of story we’ve seen play out on screens big and small for decades, albeit with a sci-fi bent.

Advertisement

Its core premise is exactly what you’d expect from the show, with a pair of detectives investigating the deaths of people who were targeted online. It looks at the culture of outrage and how people are vilified on social media, alongside robot bees for good, terrifying measure. It’s also the longest episode of the show (Bandersnatch excluded), clocking in at 89 minutes, which it doesn’t exactly stretch but never fully justifies either.

There’s a lot to like here, from Brooker’s clear ambition, to the buddy-cop pairing of Kelly Macdonald and Faye Marsay, and the mystery at its heart. But there’s also not much to love, because we’ve seen all of these things before.

Advertisement

Hated In The Nation has a few neat Black Mirror touches, but it’s also the only episode of the show that feels like it could exist somewhere else. This could quite easily be its own series, which robs it of that slightly more intangible uniqueness of other Black Mirror episodes, even if all its component parts more really well.

[JH]

Advertisement

12. White Bear

Channel 4

A highlight of Season 2 (and easily the nastiest of that run), White Bear is essentially a single white-knuckle chase sequence that builds towards one of the best rug-pulls in the entire show. Following Victoria, who wakes up with amnesia, a strange symbol beaming out of her TV and a horde of people outside who are concerned with nothing but recording her on their phones (that "phone zombies" motif feels a little dated now, admittedly), the initial set up is as exciting and mysterious as anything the show has ever produced.

Advertisement

Fortunately it doesn't really let up from there, blending some brilliantly tense action set-pieces with the increased mystery surrounding this woman's past. The final twist defines the entire episode though, with it being revealed that this entire scenario has been purposefully orchestrated. Victoria is actually a criminal, party to the murder of a young child. Every day she's forced into this traumatic scenario as part of her sentencing, without any idea of why she's being punished and unable to escape the perpetual torment.

Like The National Anthem, White Bear taps into the voyeurism and pleasure society takes from seeing terrible people being punished, and the warped sense of "justice" that comes with this torment. It's as on-the-nose as Black Mirror has ever been, and the twist isn't for everyone, but it undoubtedly leaves a lasting impression.

Advertisement

[JB]

11. Bandersnatch

Netflix

In lieu of Season 5 - although that is still happening - we got Bandersnatch, an interactive Black Mirror film that puts you in control of the narrative. Sort of.

Advertisement

The Choose Your Own Adventure mechanics riff on the books and computer games of old, and it's the latter that most informs what Bandersnatch is. It's not really a film or an episode of Black Mirror, but a game. Starting off in the life of Stefan, a programmer who wants to make his own video game, we're forced to make a series of choices to progress his story and ultimately define his life. Sugar Puffs or Frosties? Accept or Reject? Yeah or F**K YEAH?

Each choice weighs heavy upon you, making this a lot of fun to 'play'. Where Bandersnatch is lacking, though, is in story. Its narrative is incredibly slight, there's little-to-no actual character development, and only one of the many endings comes close to being satisfying. Taken as a movie, or thought of next to other Black Mirror episodes, Bandersnatch doesn't really work. As an ambitious interactive effort, and looked at as a game, though, it's something you can get a lot out of, which is why it's middle of the road here.

Advertisement

[JH]

10. Playtest

Netflix

It's rare for a Black Mirror to be "fun", but while Season 3's Playtest isn't exactly a rollicking good time, it certainly enjoys revelling in its virtual reality set up. Browsing positions for oddjobs online, protagonist Cooper finds himself as the test subject for a new video game product, an augmented reality experience that's realised through a microchip implanted under the player's skin.

Advertisement

Obviously, the "game" malfunctions pretty much straight away, and the character's worst nightmares are brought to life before his very eyes. Through some genius horror-inspired sequences, Cooper is haunted by general human fears like spiders and serial killers, constantly unaware where the game ends and real life begins. Later though, these nightmares become much more personal, with Cooper questioning whether or not he's suffering from the same symptoms his father developed from dementia in his final years.

Trapping a character in their memories and dreams isn't exactly a new concept, but Black Mirror executed it so confidently, and with such energy (partly thanks to director Dan Trachtenberg), that in the end, the familiarity doesn't really matter.

Advertisement

[JB]

9. USS Callister

Netflix

Commonly referred to as 'the Star Trek episode', USS Callister sees a frustrated co-founder of a successful online game trapping clones of his colleagues inside a version themed after his favourite TV show, embarking on Trek-esque escapades with him as the hero figure.

Advertisement

With its bright colours, cinematic scope, and overt use of comedy, USS Callister stands out as being different from the majority of Black Mirror episodes, but there's also much more to it than its homages.

Underneath all that is a meaty story that tackles a range of important and relevant topics, such as workplace harassment, toxic masculinity, and Gamergate. The sci-fi tropes are then used and deconstructed in order to deliver the story and its messaging, rather than simply being for show, resulting in this being an episode as terrifying as it is humorous.

Advertisement

[JH]

8. Nosedive

Netflix

The first episode launched after the series was picked up by Netflix, Nosedive was a return to form after the disappointing Waldo Moment. Taking aim at social media this time around, the premiere threw viewers into a world where the Uber formula had been pushed to the extreme, and everyone had an online rating which could affect everything from living arrangements to job prospects.

Advertisement

It's the central performance by Bryce Dallas Howard which makes the episode so special, though. With her every move and word being monitored and rated, the expected, forced cheeriness at the start slowly gives way to a manic desperation by the end, with the pressure of living up to the ideal version of herself tapping into anxieties most viewers at home no doubt share (on a smaller scale, admittedly).

It's a real showcase for how great Black Mirror's art design can be as well. When the show isn't in the suitably bleak reality of Britain or America, it indulges in these near-future reflections that manage to say so much through costume, colour and aesthetics alone. Nosedive wasn't exactly a reinvention of the series, but it proved that Brooker could still retain the tightness of the original run while enjoying the fruits of an expanded scope and budget.

Advertisement

[JB]

7. Hang The DJ

netflix

The romantic nature of this episode, along with its more upbeat tone, means it (unfairly) draws heavy comparisons to San Junipero, but there's a lot going on here that allows Hang The DJ to stand on its own two feet as one of Black Mirror's better episodes.

Advertisement

Taking place in a walled-off society where people are matched into romantic relationships with an expiry date, until the person can find their ultimate partner, we're given the story of Amy (Georgina Campbell) and Frank (Joe Cole), who've been paired together, albeit briefly.

What follows manages to be a pitch-perfect satire of apps such as Tinder, with a bit of Siri thrown in for good measure, that gives the episode the kind of technological relevance and relatability that helped make the show so great in the first place. It's smartly written and never unbelievable, but best of all is the central relationship at its core, which feels authentic and sweet without ever being overly sentimental.

Advertisement

[JH]

6. The National Anthem

Channel 4

The very first episode of Black Mirror is, arguably, not an episode that really represents what many people expect the show to be. The setting is the present day, there's no sci-fi technology driving the plot, and the narrative itself is relatively straightforward. However, the inaugural outing is stunning in the way it drives home the series' main theme of making an outlandish premise a biting, introspective comment on modern society.

Advertisement

It cuts so deep because, despite the infamous focus of the episode, the central question is less "Would you f*** a pig on national television to save someone's life?" and more "Would you tune in to watch someone else f*** a pig to save someone's life?". Sure, seeing Rory Kinnear's Prime Minister deal with the moral dilemma, both personally and publicly, is harrowing and intoxicating at the same time, it's the images of the stunned faces of everyone who tuned in to watch the act unfold, as comedy turns to horror, revulsion and regret, that really gives the episode its power.

Your own voyeurism reflects the haunted faces of the public watching in the show, and like all good BM episodes, it makes you think about your own shortcomings.

Advertisement

[JB]

5. Be Right Back

Channel 4

With Black Mirror’s love of telling dark stories, there are plenty to episodes to shock and scare us. But Be Right Back does something different: it’s an instalment that will leave you in tears.

Advertisement

The story uses technology to ground itself in the present, but its themes are timeless, with Charlie Brooker turning his gaze to death, grief, and love. To put a Black Mirror spin on this, he looks at the question of what happens to a person’s online profile after they die, what should you do with their phone number in your phone’s contacts, and advancements towards living on beyond death.

What we get is a savvy drama from a tech standpoint, but a profound, sad one as an analysis of grief and the ways in which it can affect people. Hayley Atwell and Domhnall Gleeson both five beautiful performances as Martha and Ash, a young couple tragically torn apart, with the latter dying in an accident but then living on as an android.

Advertisement

Surprising, sentimental without ever being schmaltzy or too saccharine, and with a poignant, powerful, and very much human story, this is one of Black Mirror’s saddest, but also one of its absolute best.

[JH]

Advertisement

4. White Christmas

Netflix

The most successful Christmas stories tend to be warm, sweet, and heartfelt, capturing the true spirit of the season. Black Mirror isn’t an obvious fit, and yet the pair goes together like pigs and blankets.

Advertisement

In a horribly, brilliantly dark Yuletide tale, we find two men (played by Jon Hamm and Rafe Spall) stranded at a remote outpost in a snow-covered wilderness. They tell each other tales to pass the time, spinning into three mini-stories.

Hamm and Spall make for a superb double-act, each making their characters complicated humans who retain your sympathy while doing terrible things, which is one of Black Mirror’s greatest strengths. Continuing those strengths are how it tackles our reliance on technology and the burgeoning use of artificial intelligence, making a suitably scary festive story, and the separate strands all start to coalesce by the end.

Advertisement

Layering twists upon twists, the episode builds to one of Black Mirror’s greatest ever endings, and you’ll never listen to I Wish It Could Be Christmas Everyday the same way again.

[JH]

Advertisement

3. Shut Up And Dance

Netflix

Shut Up and Dance works so well because of how much it makes you see yourself in its characters. After being introduced to Kenny, a meek teenager in a job he doesn't like and in love with a girl way out of his league, the plot kicks in when he's messaged by a hacker group. It turns out they've invaded his PC via a virus and recorded a video of him masturbating, threatening to release it to everyone he knows unless he completes a series of increasingly dangerous tasks for them.

Advertisement

When you're already a social outcast, a video of you jackin' it circulating around school, or being sent directly to your parents, would practically be the end of the world. With this in mind, you're fully on Kenny's side as he completes each traumatic trial, even when he's forced to fight to the death for his freedom.

Along the way you realise it's not only him who's involved in this grand game, with other characters, a serial adulterer and a pedophile, also receiving similar messages. The thing is, all of these characters have done pretty bad things, and in hindsight it seems kind of unjust that Kenny is being punished for watching porn.

Advertisement

A final twist reveals that he isn't quite so innocent though, and the video is circulated despite him doing everything he was told. His mother calls him, distraught, and it's then when you know something isn't quite right, but it's not until she lets out in disbelief a cry of "Kids, Kenny! You've been watching kids!?" that you get it.

The fact that you never even questioned the morals of this loathsome character delivers a gut-punch unrivalled by any other episode, and leaves you feeling ugly in ways few other TV shows can.

Advertisement

[JB]

2. The Entire History Of You

Channel 4

A rather low-key episode in the grand scheme of things, The Entire History of You rounded out Season 1 with an emotional powerhouse of a story. Chronicling a couple (played pitch-perfectly by Toby Kebbell and Jodi Whittaker) struggling with a relationship after the reappearance of a former partner, the technological twist is that, in this reality, everyone has the ability to rewatch and access their memories at any given time.

Advertisement

Of course, while this tech has its benefits, it also enables a culture of overthinking and pining for the past. It's truly upsetting to see these characters unable (or unwilling) to be in the moment, perhaps most uncomfortably summed up in one scene where the two are having sex while watching memories of themselves making love far more passionately and intimately than they are currently.

The brilliant thing about the episode (and all the Black Mirror greats), is that the technology here isn't to blame for the eventual breakdown. Sure, it amplifies the problems between the pair, but those feelings of jealousy, regret and complacency are intrinsically human issues, and have been the cause of breakdowns in relationships for hundreds of years. It's not as flashy as other episodes, but it's the perfect companion to our number one...

Advertisement

[JB]

1. San Junipero

Netflix

Black Mirror has earned a reputation for having devastating or gutting plot twists, which meant that as San Junipero's love story went on everyone was waiting for the gut punch. And waiting, and waiting. The genius of this episode, though, is that it managed to subvert our expectations but without betraying what Black Mirror 'is'.

Advertisement

Taking place in California in 1987, we find party loving Kelly (Gugu Mbatha-Raw) and introverted Yorkie (Mackenzie Davis) meeting and gradually falling in love, while everything else conspires to keep them apart.

Making full use of the bigger budget that came with the move to Netflix, San Junipero is dripping with style, its soundtrack and visuals combining to service up a classic slice of the American Dream, but with a technological spin that perfectly complements the story. Led by stunning performances from its two leads, it's the kind of story that both warms your heart and tugs at its strings, and whereas most Black Mirror episodes speak to the power of technology, this one speaks to the power of love.

Advertisement

[JH]

How would you rank the Black Mirror episodes? Let us know down in the comments.

Advertisement