Breaking Bad vs Dexter: 4 Ways Dexter Lost To Walter White

By Richard Church /

Endings are a very difficult thing to pull off well. So much has to be tied up in order to give the story and the characters a proper conclusion, especially if it is the ending to a much loved series. In the past we've seen very mixed reactions to the conclusions of series, such as Lost, Battlestar Galactica, Smallville or The Dark Knight Rises due to complaints that not enough was tied up satisfactorily. This Fall two of the most acclaimed televisions series ended in memorable ways. One ended very well, the other very, very badly. Dexter's finale was, in my opinion, a disservice to not only the fans, but largely to the entire show. Breaking Bad's ending, on the other hand, respected and honoured everything that had come before. In this article I'm going to discuss why Dexter's final season failed to deliver on several fronts compared to Breaking Bad's much talked about, and much better, ending. So, without further ado, let's examine how the Bay Harbour Butcher lost to Heisenberg.

4. Very Few Consequences

Consequences were a very big theme Dexter and Breaking Bad. Dexter Morgan and Walter White both lived double lives that risked exposure at any moment, usually having to come up with inventive lies on the spot to get themselves out of trouble while also keeping their secret from a family member in law enforcement. The choices both characters make occasionally come back to haunt them, but in Walter White's case they come back on a very recurring basis whereas in Dexter, with the exception of seasons 5 and 7, the consequences of his actions are hardly ever brought up. Given the cliffhanger Season 7 left off of, it was very surprising to see the season flash forward 6 months after LaGuerta's death, rushing past the entire investigation. It was still very good to see Debra's guilty spiral as she obviously blamed herself and Dexter, but where were the reactions from Masuka, Quinn and, most of all, Batista, her former husband? Comparing it to Season 5, Rita's death affected everyone in the precinct. The time jump forward was a huge disadvantage to the final season because we did not see the immediate consequences of LaGuerta's murder. Breaking Bad, on the other hand, dealt with the consequences of any small action, especially when it came to a death. Gale's death for instance had a huge effect on several of the characters and he only appeared in three or four episodes. His death had lasting consequences for the rest of the series. It would have been nice to have seen that level of damage in Dexter's final season.

3. Forgotten History

Piggybacking off my last point, the later seasons of Dexter showed a very short memory when it came to most of the supporting characters and series events. Most of the time the show seemed to ignore the fact LaGuerta and Batista were married at one point, but the glaring problem is actually in the character of Joseph Quinn. After Rita's death Quinn's eyes fell on Dexter for playing some part in her murder, if not the actual crime itself. He investigated his suspicions only to be told off by LaGuerta. This is a large issue I had with Season 7: instead of giving Quinn a lame and rather unbelievable love story with a Ukrainian stripper, why not bring his suspicions about Dexter back by having LaGuerta recruit him? Apart from Debra and Dexter, LaGuerta was the only other person who knew about his investigations into Dexter's double life. It would have made perfect sense for LaGuerta to go to him for help while creating a bigger conflict given his feelings for Debra. Likewise, Dexter often forgot both Quinn and Batista were actually good detectives. In Batista's case, this is a guy who pieced together a vital clue of the Ice Truck Killer investigation off a hunch and determined the suicide of a man who cheated on his wife wasn't all that it seemed based on the amount of pictures he had of his wife and family. Most of the time he wasn't an idiot, but Season 8 failed both these character by not having any suspicions around LaGuerta's death. Granted, Dexter covered it up as best as he could, but Batista fully believed Laguerta did not attempt to frame Dexter in the Season 7 finale, yet came around to believing she had by the time 8 began. Maybe he was convinced because of the false evidence, but because of the time jump it didn't ring entirely true for his character. Quinn lacked his own deductive skills in the final season by not being suspicious of Dexter or Debra's behaviour. In fact, Debra admitted right to his face she killed LaGuerta and he thought she was being metaphorical! The great thing about Breaking Bad was it never forgot its own history. Every event, no matter how small, was important and came back around again. The show never forgot who any of its characters or what their main traits were whereas Dexter often did for the sake of the plot.

2. Insignificant Character Deaths

Though there were several deaths in the final season, the most notable being Dr. Vogel and Debra, the majority of them were entirely new characters who had just been introduced, allowing very little emotional investment in them. Wouldn't it have been wiser, being the final season, to raise the stakes by killing a long standing character to emphasize no one was safe? Or not even someone who had been around since the beginning, such as Jamie?. I had thought for sure she would end up a victim of the Brain Surgeon instead of Dexter's friendly neighbour. Though Breaking Bad's body count may have been fairly low in the final season its two significant deaths were undoubtedly Hank and Gomie. Those two were around from the very beginning and while Gomez was a supporting character who didn't get much backstory throughout the series, he was always recognized as Hank's faithful partner and friend. Hank, of course, was the show's real hero and his death hit hard for the characters and fans alike. Since so many of the deaths in Dexter were newly introduced characters the final season failed to provide a ripple effect the way Hank's did. Jamie's death could have done that as she was connected to Dexter, Batista, Quinn, Harrison and even Debra, but they chose instead to pick off Zack Hamilton, Dexter's neighbour and Dr. Vogel, three characters who had very little relation to any of the larger cast. Hank's death not only hit the entire White family, but was the catalyst for the show's final events. It satisfied and broke fans' hearts in a way Dexter did not come close to.

1. Lack Of Meaningful Character Development

The final entry of any story typically works to bring it full circle and offer complete closure. So if Breaking Bad was about Mr. Chips becoming Scarface, I like to think Dexter was about Pinocchio becoming a real boy. One thing I will give the Dexter finale credit for is that it tried to come full circle, even succeeded to a certain extent, but it failed in a supreme way. In the very first episode Dexter asserted he was not human, stating "If I could have feelings for anyone at all, I would have them for Deb". This somewhat came full circle when Deb went into a coma, making Dexter admit now that he had feelings he didn't want them anymore after suffering the loss of Debra. Though I'm not a huge fan of Dexter's decision to dump Deb's body into the ocean, I have to at least acknowledge the symbolism of that action since she was technically his last victim. However, it seems as though the writers decided against their premise by rejecting all of the development Dexter had gone through at the last minute. This was a man who fully believed, partly because he was conditioned to think this way, he could not fall in love or care for others only to get married, have a child, care for his wife's own children as if they were his own and fall in love again. Even when Dr. Vogel told him his feelings for others are not authentic he rejected this hypothesis. The finale did a complete 180 on his belief and values. Dexter thought it was a better idea to leave his child in the custody of a wanted fugitive in order to keep him safe, believing himself responsible for Debra's condition and causing pain and suffering to everyone around him. While this is true to an extent, there was never really any authenticity to this belief. The one big argument which could be made in favour of his choice is, as previously discussed, his role in Rita's death, but he had come to peace with his responsibility in that long ago. His decision to abandon everything he knew and cared about didn't seem real or make sense. At least Walt's self-imposed exile not only made sense, but was a very reluctant exile. He didn't want to leave his family behind for any reason, but the situation forced him to. Even then he tried hard as he could to accomplish what he had originally set out to do: provide them with a lot of money for their future. Walt's own journey hit a startling point when, in the finale, he finally admitted everything he did was to make himself feel important. It was known to everyone for a while his family just became an excuse to cook meth, but he never admitted it until he had absolutely nothing left, forcing him to face the truth. Walt's character development rang truer than Dexter's because it accounted for every action he took over the course of the series whereas Dexter's realization largely focused on what he did in Season 8 rather than the series as a whole.