Brexit: The Uncivil War Review - 4 Ups & 4 Downs

Does Benedict Cumberbatch's Brexit drama pull too many punches?

By Simon Gallagher /

Channel 4

When Channel 4 and HBO revealed the first trailer for Brexit: An Uncivil War, it was immediately obvious that it was going to be a divisive, explosive film. Coming smack-bang in the midst of the political fallout from the leave vote - in a time when Theresa May is apparently still wrestling the finer details of her own deal as if it were some colossal sea monster - it's about as pertinent a film as you'll ever get to see.

Advertisement

Usually, these things come out when the dust is settled: Brexit: The Uncivil War was dropped into the middle of the storm and to a certain extent will have lost some of its audience because of that. And also, it has to be said, because of the perception that it's in some way fetishising the fallout rather than simply telling the story. To those who chose that line of thinking without seeing it, it's important to level a rebuttal. This film needs to be seen.

There are things to genuinely praise about it and inevtiably there are those that deserve frank criticism. So let's get into it.

Advertisement

First the negatives...

Downs

4. The Working Class Stereotypes

Channel 4

There is undoubtedly some truth in the fact that Vote Leave consciously targeted less affluent areas and voters hit by higher unemployment rates - as well as those who hadn't voted in the General Election (perhaps because of feeling disaffected) - in order to propagate a certain mind-set, but the way the film portrays working class people is a little... reductive.

Advertisement

Any time there's anyone shown on screen who isn't involved in political circles directly and who comes from a working class background (which is invariably sign-posted), they're invariably a bubbling pool of illogical emotion, unable to engage with the "real facts." Obviously, this is something Vote Leave consciously tapped into, so showing it to a certain degree is fine, but it's unfortunate how far it goes.

The only time anyone working class isn't cut from that limited cloth, they're a wordsmith capable of immense oratory skills that rather handily offer a potted summary of the key issues behind Euroscepticism. The focus group sequences in particular are laughably skewed this way.

Advertisement

In the end, just as we see very vividly in Cumming's pub focus group sequence, the working class have no voice in this story. It's all related by someone else. If you want to watch something that tells the true story of political consequence, watch I, Daniel Blake.

3. It Skirts Some Issues

Channel 4

For something that feels like it has such an agenda AND which seems to want to paint itself as being completely impartial at the same time, The Uncivil War seems rather careless when it comes to relating some pretty key information and dealing with some intriguing issues.

Advertisement

Every time the film threatened to engage with something particularly controversial - like the fascistic approach to the propaganda beneath the surface of the Leave campaign or the real depth of the data misuse that the campaign was run on - it's all awfully superficial. Instead of really engaging, we're left with a broad picture that skips over some of the most interesting parts, particularly when there is so much clamour around underhand activity, corruption and simple, abject failures.

What the film wants to show is one man's incredibly impressive quest to undo government traditions and use new technology to manipulate a vote in devilishly clever ways. That IS a compelling story, but when it's a true one and that focus comes at the cost of some of the other real elements, it's a shame.

Advertisement

2. It Revels Too Much In Its Monstrous Characters (Without Offering Real Assessment)

Channel 4

The biggest problem with Brexit - particularly for anyone who believes the people who masterminded the successful Leave campaign shouldn't be celebrated - is that it delights a little too much in how cunning its monsters are. And they are monsters, more than real people.

Advertisement

There's an element of the way American Psycho revels in Patrick Bateman's monstrosity here too: the characters like Cummings, Boris Johnson, Michael Gove, Nigel Farage, Arron Banks and Douglas Carswell are presented in a way that you might expect a caustic political satire like The Thick Of It to, but it's ostensibly a "true story" telling of the events of the Brexit vote.

That contradiction weirdly makes the caricatures, which range from deadly accurate to just comical enough to suggest parody, come across as sort of affectionate, Spitting Image-style portraits. We're simultaneously invited to believe they're toxic by material that paints a very real picture of them as villains, idiots, fools and Machiavellians, but also told insistently that it's trying to remain impartial.

Advertisement

This SHOULD have been a pitch black comedy. They should have just done it as an episode of The Thick Of It with Cumberbatch in as a guest star. The conflict wouldn't have been there then.

1. It's Massively Irresponsible

Channel 4

Even as you're watching Brexit, you have to wonder whether they should have made it. It's almost like watching a film about a high-profile court case that's actually happening at the same time. It feels uncomfortable and disquietening to be able to look out of the window and see the consequences of what the fictionalised thing on the TV is portraying.

Advertisement

But even beyond that, it feels like the film-makers should have waited, rather than stigmatising the whole Brexit issue even further. The sad reality of this feature is that it will cause changes in opinion and not necessarily all for the positive (in the film-makers' eyes, at least). The vindication and validation of Vote Leave will attract new backers, the cartoonish grotesques on that group's fringes will no doubt push others to the "other side."

This was propaganda and you have to wonder whether it was really the right idea when there are literally cases being fought about the people involved and the very same actions being portrayed.

Advertisement

And now to the positives...

Ups

4. The Supporting Cast

Channel 4

This may be Benedict Cumberbatch's show, but the acting talent around him is very, very good too.

Advertisement

As anyone who has ever seen him in anything will attest, Rory Kinnear is brilliant in everything and eminently watchable, so seeing him here as Remain key player Craig Oliver is great. Likewise, John Heffernan is great as Leave lobbyist Matthew Elliott.

The other performances are more like caricatures as they seek to ape real figures and for the most part they're ingenius. Simon Paisley Day is brilliant as Douglas Carswell, Oliver Maltman is excellent as Michael Gove and Richard Goulding shines as Boris Johnson. They're so good in fact that their performances come across as almost affectionate.

Advertisement

Even more minor performances like Nicholas Day as John Mills and the wonderful Mark Gatiss as the voice of Peter Mandelson stand out as both thoroughly well-researched and brilliantly executed.

Paul Ryan and Lee Boardman also shine as Nigel Farage and Arron Banks, but they're given rather more obviously barbed material to work with. We're clearly supposed to feel a certain way about them, but there's no faulting the performances.

Advertisement

3. It Stops Short Of Lobbying

Channel 4

It would have been very easy for The Uncivil War to use its prime slot on Channel 4 and HBO as a sort of plinth to tear down the leave vote or to show how stupid the Remain campaign were in their failings. But, thankfully, for the most part, the film does stop short of lobbying for either of those messages.

Advertisement

Yes, there are moments that feel VERY much like propaganda, but in focusing more tightly on Dominic Cummings' story, that's mostly negated. There is no celebration in the victory nor too much lamentation either (though the sequences showing Boris immediately after Leave was announced as the winner and Cummings effectively redundant at the end do seem to have that sort of agenda to them).

There is no way this could have remained entirely impartial, but with so much opportunity to go either way and make a vehicle for either side to campaign through the mainstream media (and not the press), it's impressive that it was so restrained to that end.

Advertisement

2. It Tells A Genuinely Interesting Story

Channel 4

At least someone is telling the story.

Advertisement

The Brexit story is one that has many, many elements that we don't know about. There are many elements that we will NEVER learn about, thanks to this wonderful idea that government should govern to the will of the people, but not to their knowledge. It's all very much "for the good of the people, whether they know it or not."

To that end, actually seeing the story of Cummings' involvement, when things like political strategy and lobbyism are left out of the usual election/referendum story because it's seen as somehow dishonourable in the "war" of party conflict is a refreshing change.

Advertisement

We don't get to see these dark arts much on TV (aside for things like The Thick Of It and that's obviously satirical) and it's an important thing we all ought to know about. Especially as the idea of someone as brilliant and apparently dangerous as Cummings masterminding something that so many people thought was the independent will of the people is the stuff of the highest drama, usually.

1. Benedict Cumberbatch's Performance

Channel 4

As already qualified, this film's biggest selling point is Benedict Cumberbatch's phenomenal performance as Dominic Cummings. He is almost unrecognisable as the Durham-born strategist thanks to a "make-under" to change his hairline and the commitment he's put in to capture as much of Cummings' nuances as possible.

Advertisement

Cumberbatch has spoken about the challenges he faced in the performance and revealed how hard he studied Cummings - from his physical tics when talking to very specific vocal characteristics - to get there. The reward for that hard work is very clear in the performance.

Special mention has to go to his accent, which is a softer North East accent, flecked with Geordie but with the refined edge of someone who left the region (as Cummings did to attend Oxford). It's so minutely well observed that it deserves awards on its own.

Advertisement

What did you think of Brexit: The Uncivil War? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.