Broadchurch: 5 Predictions For Who Murdered Danny

By Rob Sellars /

9pm on Monday night sees the final chapter of Broadchurch come to a close on ITV. The crime drama has been nothing short of a revelation on British TV screens for the past eight weeks, enjoying both critical and public accliam, attracting an average 7 million views each episode, and delivering a tour de force in suspense and intrigue. With an outstanding cast, lead by the unusual double act of the dark and haggard David Tennant and the relentlessly chirpy Olivia Colman, Broadchurch has lead viewers on a merry dance around the fictional south-coast seaside resort. After the body of 11-year-old Danny Latimer was found on the local beach, the viewer joined Tennant and Colman as they battled devious journalists, distraught family members and creepy residents - from psychics to plumbers to vicars - in a desperate hunt for the killer. Borrowing from the likes of The Killing, Broadchurch has taken the full series to solve one murder, meaning that the storytelling has had to be more clever, the twists more subtle and the red herrings more numerous. It has meant every aspect of Broadchurch, from the writers and producers to the exemplary cast, have had to work even harder to keep the audience's attention. Much like the BBC's new rural drama The Village, Broadchurch is not afraid to take its time, developing stories slowly and methodically, so that you barely take note of issues such as DI Hardy's health problems or the fact that Mark Latimer was playing away from home, until their importance is staring you in the face. Supposedly only 29 people - the cast and crew of the final episode - know the identity of Danny Latimer's killer. And after Broadchurch producer Richard Stokes tweeted on Monday morning "#Broadchurch tonight- don€™t miss the beginning and please watch to the very, very end. Thanks for joining us on the ride." it is clear that they are not going to make it easy for the rest of us to figure it out. So with the finale of Broadchurch airing on Monday night, here are five prime suspects for who killed Danny.

5. Nige Carter

The character of Nige Carter had his moment in the spotlight in episode seven of Broadchurch, after ambling along for much of the series. Joe Sims has played Nige with a permafix goofy grin and vacant look, making many think the plumber, who works for Danny's dad Mark, was nothing more than a dim witted bystander. However his role as ringleader of the angry mob that harassed newsagent Jack Marshall raised a few eyebrows, but it was his collection of crossbows and the whispered arguments with creepy caravan dweller Pauline Quirk that put him on the suspects list. And then he stole a charming chocolate Labrador, and people were ready to throw away the key. In the penultimate episode, Quirke's character Susan Wright had been taken into custody, where she revealed that she had seen Nige on the beach the night Danny was murdered, and also that she was in fact his birth mother. Nigel's father was a child abuser who killed his own daughter, then killed himself in prison, leaving Nigel, their newborn son, in care, perhaps with some dark genetic tendencies. With a few explicit threats Nige drove his newfound mum out of town after they had both been released at the end of the episode, but suspicions still hang over the crossbow wielding, roast dinner cooking plumber. Especially after Dean revealed that Nige and Danny used to go animal catching with him at night, supposedly with the permission of Mark and Beth. Did he kill Danny? The evidence is certainly stacking up against Nige - the weird collection of weapons, the family background, the secret night time trips with Danny - and he has shown the slightly demented tendencies so beloved of TV killers. But with the various reveals about Nige's true character in episode seven, it would probably now amount to a disappointing reveal if it turned out to be him. Suspect rating: 7/10

4. Steve Connelly

Steve Connelly slipped on to our screens while supposedly rigging the police station with a better communication system following the murder. Played by Will Mellor, the character was always going to be more than a passing electrician, and so it proved when he declared to DI Hardy and DS Miller that he was a psychic and Danny was talking to him from beyond the grave. Initially dismissed by Hardy as a weirdo craving attention, Connelly's 'information' that Danny was killed in a boat started to look a little too accurate for comfort. Beth would later turn to Connelly in desperation to find the killer, before Hardy put a stop to it, something Connelly did not take kindly too. It seemed at this point that the 'psychic' had played his part in the enquiry, but then in episode seven it was DI Hardy's turn to seek his help, asking for any information he might have. His brief appearance could have been a subtle suggestion that Connelly was yet to play a bigger role in the mystery. Is he psychic? Is he just someone so desperate for attention he would insert himself into the bereaved family home? Or could it be that Connelly is the killer, and has returned to the scene of the crime to torment his victim's family and distract the police? Did he kill Danny? There is little hard evidence to suggest Connelly played a part in Danny's death, but if he is not psychic, how did he know about the boat? And why is he so desperate to talk to Beth and the family? There is no clear motive, but if Connelly genuinely thinks he can talk to the dead, who knows what the voices in his head might have told him to do. In the world of TV thrillers though, Connelly just seems too obviously weird to have been the killer. Suspect rating: 4/10

Reverend Paul Coates

The bookies third favourite to be the killer, nervous vicar Paul has been a bit of an enigma throughout the seven episodes of Broadchurch. He admitted he had struggled to integrate himself into the local community, trying everything to get them to come to church. After Danny's murder, Rev Paul was quick to get himself on TV and become Beth's confidant. He later revealed he suffered from insomnia - so he was probably awake when Danny died, and that he taught IT classes at the local school - so had a direct connection to Danny. On top of that he is a recovering alcoholic, and was seen with his hand on the knee of Tom Miller, Danny's classmate. And on top of that, he also admitted to DI Hardy that Tom had threatened to accuse him of abusing Danny if he handed other a potentially incriminating laptop. The vicar is an intriguing puzzle for sure. The vicar, played by Arthur Darvill, has made regular appearances in every episode of Broadchurch, however is yet to be a key focus of one episode. So in the same way that the focus on Nige last week perhaps rules him out, could it be that Paul's big moment is to come in the final episode? Perhaps in his desperation to reaffirm his own faith and to get people to come to church - which they did after the murder - Paul felt he could justify taking the life of young Danny Lattimer. Or maybe Paul's determination to defend Jack from accusations of child abuse were actually a sign of his own dark character. One thing is for sure, the vicar is not in the clear yet. Did he kill Danny? There have been plenty of pointers throughout the series to cast suspicion on Reverend Paul Coates, from his troubled past, to his night wanders, to his too-close-for-comfort chat with Tom. Could all these be more red herrings, something apparently so enjoyed by the Broadchurch writers? Or could it be that the local vicar has committed the ultimate sin? Suspect rating: 9/10

Tom Miller

Like Reverend Paul Coates, Tom Miller, a classmate of Danny and son of DS Ellie Miller, has been a regular fixture on our screens, however he is yet to come to the fore. The young boy certainly has plenty of suspicious tendencies though. His probing questions about what would happen to the killer were weird at least, while the fact he deleted all texts and emails from Danny just after his apparent friend had died certainly raised a few eyebrows. His attempt to smash up his laptop and the fact that he declared he hated Danny all along anyway have lead some to wonder if Broadchurch is heading down a dark path, starting with one 11-year-old dead and finishing with another revealed as a killer. The cliffhanger of episode seven saw DI Hardy have a moment of revelation when he finally got hold of the recovered emails from Tom's computer. Did the emails show Toms guilt? What could drive an 11-year-old to kill? It all seems too dark and too impossible, especially for the mainstream media. Plus how would Tom have driven the boat to the beach, arranged Danny's body and then set fire to the boat? Surely you would need to be a grown man for all that? What is perhaps much more likely, is that Tom is trying to cover for someone much closer to home. More on that next... Did he kill Danny? The chances of the Broadchurch writers revealing an 11-year-old to be their brutal killer are just too slim. But did he have some role to play in the murder or in the attempt to hide it? Perhaps. Suspect rating: 2/10

Joe Miller

The bookies favourite, Joe Miller is the stay-at-home father of two, and husband of DS Ellie Miller. Loving, caring, well-known around the town - surely the traits of a killer? Ellie is more often than not out of the house, leaving her husband to do what he wants, while Joe didn't take too kindly to his wife looking for Tom's laptop, which looks set to be a key piece of evidence. Most importantly, there has so far been nothing substantial to suggest Joe had any part to play, yet he has remained a prominent fixture throughout the series. His son Tom certainly seems to have been trying to hide something related to the death of Danny. Could it be an incriminating piece of evidence that would reveal his dad to be the killer? Was something going on between Danny and Joe that lead to Tom falling out with his former friend? And perhaps most intriguing, if it wasn't Nige that Susan saw on the beach with Danny's body, which other bald, white male from the town could it have been I wonder? On top of that, we already know that Joe has used the boat previously which was used to carry Danny's body. Did he kill Danny? In terms of storyline, there is nothing too concrete which points the figure at the erstwhile Joe Miller. But in the world of TV murder mystery, the suspicion hanging over Joe is looking more and more unavoidable. Suspect rating: 9/10 So who did kill Danny Lattimer? Which Broadchurch resident is to be revealed as the killer at the heart of this compelling drama? Do you think it is one of these five, or do you have a different theory about who is the Broadchurch killer? Comment below.