Community: Ranking Every Season From Worst To Best

Was Season 4 really that bad?

By Noah Dominguez /

Community is quite possibly one of the most iconic sitcoms of the last decade.

Advertisement

Between its diverse cast of hilarious (not to mention prolific) actors, delightfully over-the-top episodes that utilized a unique genre-hopping style, incredible attention to continuity, as well as the fact that it's one of the most quotable shows to ever air on network television, it's not hard to see why this series gained and maintained such a dedicated fanbase.

Despite backstage drama, which involved the departure of major characters and even the firing of series creator Dan Harmon, Community is a show that managed beat the odds and carve out a rather impressive run for itself. The series aired on NBC for its first five seasons before moving to Yahoo! Screen for its sixth and final season, resulting in a grand total of 110 episodes.

At this time, fans are still waiting on a potential Community movie to be made (there's still hope!). But in the meantime, we do still have six seasons to look back on fondly, even some of the show's seasons just aren't as great as the others.

6. Season 5

Community Season 4 is often considered by fans to be the worst of the series, due in large part to the fact that it was the only season to be made without series creator Dan Harmon at the helm. In reality, however, it's actually Season 5 that's the weakest of the bunch.

Advertisement

To be fair, Season 5 had a lot working against it. Sure, Harmon was back, but Chevy Chase was gone. And by the time the season was only halfway through, so too was Donald Glover. The infamous backstage drama he was reportedly at the center of aside, Chase's Pierce was an exceptionally funny character. Meanwhile, Glover's Troy was arguably the the most consistently hilarious character in the entire series.

Sure, Jonathan Banks' Buzz Hickey had his moments, and it was certainly nice to have John Oliver back as Ian Duncan following an extended absence, but they were hardly any replacement for Pierce and Troy.

Season 5 also suffered from one too many self-indulgent jokes, most of which poked fun at Season 4, almost as if Harmon was trying a little too hard to say, "I'm back." Meanwhile, holiday specials fell by the wayside and certain plot threads (such as Abed's relationship with Brie Larson's Rachel) were left underdeveloped.

Credit where it's due, Season 5 was still pretty solid. The show was still very funny, Harmon's return provided a fresh dose of wit, the remaining actors adapted to the altered dynamic as best they could and the season mostly delivered as far as its concept episodes were concerned.

Even so, Community Season 5 spent so much time "apologizing" for Season 4 that it never really took the time to develop an identity of its own. Couple that with dangling plot threads and the departing character leaving major voids, and you have the arguably the weakest season of an overall fantastic show.

Best Episode: Cooperative Polygraphy

Worst Episode: App Development and Condiments

5. Season 4

As stated before, Dan Harmon's non-involvement in Community Season 4 has led to it being dismissed by a lot of fans. All things considered, however, it's really not that bad at all.

Advertisement

Paranormal Parentage was a fantastic Halloween special, episodes like Basic Human Anatomy and Heroic Origins were hilarious in their own right, and the Thanksgiving-themed Cooperative Escapism in Familial Relations provided a great deal of earned emotional payoff regarding Jeff Winger's personal character arc. What's more, this was also the last season to feature the entire iconic, original cast from start to finish.

Season 4 did certainly still have its problems, the most glaring of which was the fact that it was the first to be affected by the series being cut down to 13 episodes per season. Working with practically half the numbers of episodes as before clearly took some getting used to, as the pacing definitely felt more than a little bit off.

Also, while the Harmon thing does tend to get overblown, the writing in Season 4 admittedly doesn't quite live up to that of the previous three seasons. This is most apparent in Economics of Marine Biology, which is arguably the worst single episode of the series.

Even so, Community Season 4 was an exceptionally fun (if a bit short) ride that's not nearly as bad as some fans make it out to be.

Best Episode: Cooperative Escapism in Familial Relations

Worst Episode: Economics of Marine Biology

4. Season 6

Much like Season 5, Community Season 6 had a lot working against it going in. For starters, the series was axed by NBC and was picked up by the obscure Yahoo! Screen. The show also had to contend with the departure of another major cast member, with Yvette Nicole Brown's Shirley being absent for the vast majority of the season.

Advertisement

Despite this, however, Season 6 managed to roll with the punches and end up being a genuinely great outing that was arguably Community's funniest since Season 3.

First of all, while the potshots at Season 4 were still present, they weren't nearly as prevalent, nor as distracting as before.

Secondly, while three of the original cast members now being gone was a hard pill to swallow, Season 6 did a much better job at compensating for this than Season 5 did. While no one could ever really replace Troy, Pierce and Shirley, the season did bring in some great new faces.

Keith David's Elroy Patashnik gelled with the other characters much better than Hickey ever was, and Paget Brewster's Frankie Dart helped reshape the main group's dynamic in a meaningful way. This was also helped by Jim Rash's Dean Pelton and Ken Jeong's Ben Chang having their roles upped. (Plus, Brown did still manage to sneak in a pair of cameo appearances.)

By this point, the show had also gotten much, much better at making the shorter seasons work. Season 6 was occupied by numerous funny, heartfelt and expertly-paced episodes, which culminated an an incredibly emotional finale.

Now to cross our fingers and hope the #SixSeasonsAndAMovie prophecy is finally fulfilled.

Best Episode: Emotional Consequences of Broadcast Television

Worst Episode: Advanced Safety Feature

3. Season 1

From the very beginning, it was fairly obvious that Community was a show that was destined for greatness, even if NBC didn't always see it that way.

Advertisement

The series' debut season, which premiered in 2009, introduced audiences to a peerlessly entertaining main cast that could very well be seen as a who's who in the world of comedy. Joel McHale, Gillian Jacobs, Donald Glover, Alison Brie, Danny Pudi, Yvette Nicole Brown and Chevy Chase seemed like an odd bunch in the beginning, but their chemistry would prove to be undeniable.

Better yet, Community Season 1 also introduced a strong supporting cast to help keep things interesting, including top-level performers like Jim Rash, Ken Jeong and John Oliver.

The cast was still learning to gel and adapt to Community's trademark genre-hopping style, so Season 1 didn't put out a seemingly endless amount of comedic masterpieces in the same way Seasons 2 or 3 did. However, it did find its footing sooner rather than later, resulting in hysterically terrific episodes like Modern Warfare, Comparative Religion and Contemporary American Poultry.

Season 1 also introduced many of Community's long-standing running jokes and themes, making it more integral to the DNA of the show than your average first season. In turn, it's hard not to acknowledge it as being one of the best.

Best Episode: Modern Warfare

Worst Episode: Football, Feminism and You

2. Season 3

Community Season 3 is a lesson in patience if ever there was one. The first few episodes, while certainly good, did admittedly feel a bit weaker in comparison to the genius of Seasons 1 and 2. However, any and fall fear that the season wouldn't be able to live up to its predecessors was quickly put to rest by Remedial Chaos Theory, which is arguably the single-best episode of Community's entire run.

Advertisement

Following its magnum opus, Season 3 only continued to pump out a vast amount of top-notch episodes. More specifically, Community Season 3 provided some of the series' very best concept episodes, such as the video game-themed Digital Estate Planning, the war documentary-style Pillows and Blankets, as well as the Law & Order-inspired Basic Lupine Urology.

Of course, lest we forget the epic, multi-episode arc detailing Chang's hostile takeover of Greendale Community College, which forced the study group to rally together and reclaim their school.

On a slightly bittersweet note, Season 3 also represents a unique period in Community's history, in which the chemistry between the original main cast members was at its absolute best for an entire 20+ episode season, effectively making it one of the funniest, best-flowing, most delightfully jam-packed seasons of the entire series.

Best Episode: Remedial Chaos Theory

Worst Episode: Documentary Filmmaking: Redux

1. Season 2

When trying to determine which season of Community is the best, it could honestly go either way between Seasons 2 and 3. Ultimately, however, for it's sheer volume of great, hilarious, or otherwise iconic episodes, it's Season 2 that gets the nod.

Advertisement

There's absolutely no denying that Season 3 hit some serious highs, but Season 2 was really where everything clicked into place, so to speak. The show had truly found its voice by fully embracing its genre-hopping style, the cast had learned to gel exceptionally well with one another, the writing was at its wittiest and Joe Russo's direction was at its best. (Honestly, Advanced Dungeons and Dragons deserved an Emmy.)

There are so many episodes in Season that could easily be considered not only the best of the season itself, but some of the best in the entire series. This entire 24-episode run was simply just that great. In fact, Even the season's weaker episodes are far, far above average as far as mainstream TV comedy is concerned.

If you're just getting into Community and want a single episode that represents the show at its best, Season 3's Remedial Chaos Theory is the episode for you. However, if you want to see the show at its most consistently brilliant over a period of time, it's time to settle in and give Season 2 a watch.

Best Episode: Advanced Dungeons and Dragons

Worst Episode: Competitive Wine Tasting

Advertisement