DC's Titans: 9 Reasons It's Already A Dud

A rough start for DC's latest.

By Jack Pooley /

Warner Bros.

The long-awaited new DC series Titans has just premiered, and while the critical response has been tepidly positive so far, it's honestly tough to be convinced on the basis of this utterly underwhelming season opener.

Advertisement

It is of course entirely possible the show will find its footing before the end of its 12-episode first season - as is the case with so many series - yet this first hour provides precious little evidence that Titans will deliver anything beyond creatively stagnant, tonally jarring mediocrity.

The show was of course subjected to much criticism after the first trailer landed online, and while Titans isn't a flaming trainwreck beyond saving, it's definitely fighting on the back foot right now. If it's going to fulfil its huge potential, a lot will need to change over the next few episodes to prevent fans from quickly tuning out.

Advertisement

From the show's damning first episode, though, these are the easy indicators it could very well end up DC's answer to Inhumans. Yikes...

9. The Performances Are Incredibly Hit & Miss

Warner Bros.

Even if Titans' cast ends up growing into their roles in the future, the performances from the principal actors don't inspire a lot of confidence right out of the gate.

Advertisement

The season premiere focuses primarily on Robin (Brenton Thwaites) and Raven (Teagan Croft), neither of whom are especially convincing on the basis of this opening episode.

Croft in particular gives a stilted, wooden performance as Rachel Roth, over-affecting too many of her line readings and basically making hackneyed acting choices for almost the entirety of her screen time. Considering the awesome potential the character has, it's a damn shame.

Advertisement

Thwaites fares a little better as Dick Grayson, but he simply lacks the acting chops necessary to imbue his character with the necessary anger and gravitas. Ultimately he feels more like a kid playing dress-up as both detective and superhero. He's certainly got the looks to play the part, but there's little indication here of the ability.

In fact the only promising aspect of the ensemble so far is Anna Diop as Starfire, who boasts a greater screen presence and more restrained approach to her appearance than her castmates.

Advertisement

Hopefully things might pick up a bit when the quartet of heroes converge and start riffing off one another, but it's hard to have a lot of faith right now.

8. It's Trying Too Hard To Be "Mature"

Warner Bros.

Titans is a "mature" re-imagining of the Teen Titans replete with graphic violence and profanity, but there's a profound difference between a show that merely features adult content and a show that's actually for grown-ups.

Advertisement

Sadly the overwhelming vibe from the first episode is that it's trying way too hard to be edgy and not-for-kids, what with Robin's over-the-top murder of drug dealers in an opening fight scene, and his unintentionally comical utterance of "F*** Batman", which plays even sillier in context.

As a result it's tough to know who the show is really for: a lot of Teen Titans fans will be put off by the gnarly violence, yet those who enjoy R-rated thrills will probably find it too fundamentally silly to take seriously.

Advertisement

There was probably a firm middle-ground here somewhere, where Titans could serve as a gritty spin on the source material without seeming like such a try-hard attempt to be brooding and serious, but ultimately it ends up feeling rather desperate.

7. The Badly Edited Fight Scenes

Warner Bros.

Most superhero TV shows admittedly struggle to deliver entertaining and dynamic action sequences, because the production deadlines are so rushed there's little time to put any effort or artistry into them (see: any Netflix Marvel show that isn't Daredevil).

Advertisement

While there was some passing optimism that Titans, with its focus on brutal violence, might buck the trend, that's sadly not the case at all. Director Brad Anderson renders the episode's action a mostly incoherent mess, with a headache-inducing amount of cuts making it tough to savour what's going on.

It's certainly possible that subsequent episodes could improve upon this as different directors jump aboard, but it sets an irritating aesthetic from the outset, meaning you can't even enjoy the tonally-jarring action on its own merits.

Advertisement

6. The Embarrassingly Awful CGI

Warner Bros.

Again this is another problem in most superhero TV shows: their budgets are tight enough that something has to give somewhere, and it's usually in the VFX department.

Advertisement

Titans mostly doesn't overdo it with the CGI, thankfully, but almost every single visual effect in the premiere looks rather rough.

For starters, there's Raven's naff-looking phasing effects, the blatant CGI fog pumped into Robin's first fight scene, some digital mountains pasted into the background of the "Vienna" sequence, and Starfire's video game-esque super-powered visuals.

Advertisement

The worst offender by far, though, is the embarrassingly ropey introduction to Beast Boy, who first appears as a CGI tiger that looks like it was thrown together in a lazy afternoon by an intern.

The effect when he transforms from tiger to human form is especially laughable, and typifies that this show clearly needs a bigger cash injection if it's going to do these characters justice.

Advertisement

5. It's Shockingly Dull

Warner Bros.

Though many of theses issues could be somewhat forgiven if Titans were fun or interesting, perhaps the worst sin it commits is simply being incredibly dull and boring.

Advertisement

Robin, for instance, basically acts out the risible cliches of a police procedural TV show for most of his run-time yet with no self-awareness whatsoever, while Starfire's Vienna excursion feels plodding and drawn-out while revealing precious little about the character.

It's just too low-energy to be much memorable or even basically intriguing, and considering how first impressions count for a lot, it's an extremely discouraging sign for the show moving forward.

Advertisement

4. The Tone Is All Over The Place

Warner Bros.

Tone is an important aspect of any movie or show: you need to keep a consistent mood and be careful about switching things up in order to avoid giving your audience mood whiplash, and again, it's something Titans has no handle on whatsoever.

Advertisement

Though the premiere is fairly humourless for the most part, there are a few goofy quips throughout the episode which don't land at all, while many unintentionally comedic moments upend the mostly serious tenor (Raven's schizoid hallucination calling her a "slut" out of nowhere, for example).

This seems to be a pretty consistent problem with DC properties at the moment, sadly, and while it's respectable that Titans isn't just trying to replicate the MCU's broad style and tone, it's also clear that the show has something of an identity crisis going on.

Advertisement

3. The Atrocious Dialogue

Warner Bros.

Quite why anyone let Razzie-nominated writer Akiva Goldsman (Batman and Robin, The Dark Tower) work on this show and expected good results is anyone's guess. While he at least co-wrote this episode with the more esteemed Geoff Johns and Greg Berlanti, it's still an utter mess of nothing-plotting and laughably bad dialogue.

Advertisement

As is again a problem with many superhero shows, the script is overly reliant on expository dialogue to establish character motivations and move the plot forward, rather than letting the visuals do the bulk of the storytelling. In the very least, maybe portion the exposition out a little more sparingly, no?

That's not to forget the comically bad banter as Dick Grayson plays cop: it evokes the feel of a mediocre fan film rather than a show officially endorsed and produced by DC Comics.

Advertisement

At least Goldman is thus far only credited on this single episode, and we know that Johns wrote an episode later in the season by himself, so things could certainly pick up from this point.

2. It Looks Cheap & Generic

Warner Bros.

It's disappointing that Titans has no real visual identity of its own and basically looks like...every other cape show you've ever watched.

Advertisement

The cinematography in particular has an unfussed, garish digital look to it, while some embarrassing location doubling tries to make the U.S. resemble Vienna by just pasting some mountains in the background and inserting some blatant shock shots of the Vienna city centre.

We've already talked about the roughshod visual effects, but on a more basic visual level, there's little creativity or imagination to what we're looking at. It all feels pulled straight out of the superhero TV show playbook, where deadlines are tight and shots have to be achieved as quickly as possible.

Advertisement

1. Clint Mansell's Surprisingly Forgettable Musical Score

Warner Bros.

Fans were justifiably excited when it was announced that the brilliant Clint Mansell (Requiem for a Dream, Mass Effect 3, Black Mirror) would be co-composing Titans' musical score with Kevin Kiner, so disappointing it is that the music in episode one feels so damn workmanlike and, yes, generic.

Advertisement

Sure, the series' theme tune is decent enough and easily the most Mansell-esque thing here, but otherwise all of the incidental music sounds like it was cranked out by any hack composer with no real ideas of their own.

It's not exactly clear quite how much involvement Mansell will have with the week-to-week music, but from what's on offer in the premiere, one suspects most of the work's been left to either Kiner or uncredited studio musicians.

Advertisement

It's not good at all, and considering the potential for each of the four heroes to have their own recognisable themes, the music instead feels shockingly lacking in personality.

What did you think of Titans' season premiere? Shout it out in the comments!

Advertisement