Dexter Cast: Where Are They Now?

The Bay Harbor Butcher may be retired, but they're not.

By Geoff Cox /

September 22nd marks the two-year anniversary of Dexter's series finale. After eight seasons of bloodletting and slide collecting, the show's conclusion was - to put it mildly - astoundingly divisive, with many fans still reeling to this day about the closure (or lack thereof) provided in the end.

Advertisement

While some of the series' later seasons were far from being as warmly received as its earliest ones, one thing that remained relatively consistent throughout were the performances behind a number of characters caught in the titular antihero's orbit. Love them or hate them, many of Dexter's coworkers, family members and enemies became just as big a part of the show's fabric as the serial killer himself, with the actors often doing their best even if the material in latter seasons may not have made it easy.

Over its run, the series featured countless recurring characters and special guest stars, including John Lithgow, Jimmy Smits and Julia Stiles, but for the main cast of actors who spent years of their lives on the series, they'll forever be remembered by fans for the characters they gave life to. Two years on, almost all of them have remained busy, so let's shine a light on those faces who were part of the main cast at some point or throughout the series run to see where they've all landed, starting with...

12. Aimee Garcia

The Role: Recurred as Angel Batista's younger sister Jamie in the sixth and seventh season before being bumped to the main cast for the eighth.

Advertisement

2014 was a relatively quiet year for Garcia, with the actress' only notable roles being a single appearance on NBC's now-cancelled About a Boy and a spot in José Padilha's RoboCop remake. She turned up on TV Land's sitcom Impastor this past July and has the film After the Reality on the way, a story about a reality show contestant who is forced to quit in the midst of production in order to deal with real-life drama.

As for next year, you can see her in CBS' take on Rush Hour, spearheaded by Scrubs mastermind Bill Lawrence and sans Chris Tucker and Jackie Chan, as well as the Sean Hannish-directed film Sister Cities, which follows what happens when four sisters reunite in the wake of their mother's apparent suicide.

11. Geoff Pierson

The Role: Recurred as Tom Matthews throughout the series until joining the main cast for its final season.

Advertisement

Pierson, long a recognizable face in the world of television, didn't slow down one bit after Dexter's conclusion. In 2014, he turned up for spots on ABC's Suburgatory, Fox's Enlisted, TV Land's Kirstie and NBC's About a Boy, all of which have since been cancelled. He also reprised his recurring role on Castle, co-starred in the Hilary Swank-led You're Not You and appeared in the Scorsese-produced crime drama Revenge of the Green Dragons.

This year's been a little quieter, with guest spots on TV Land's The Exes and ABC's The Astronaut Wives Club. However, he was also a part of HBO's Jack Black series The Brink, which was renewed this past July for a second season next year and sees PIerson playing the United States Secretary of Defense as part of the show's main cast.

10. Yvonne Strahovski

The Role: Though she was only billed as a Special Guest Star in the seventh and eighth seasons, her relevance as Hannah McKay to Dexter's final stretch might as well have made her a main cast member.

Advertisement

Last year, Strahovski co-starred with Aaron Eckhart in I, Frankenstein, guested on an episode of Louie and took part in Fox's limited series rival 24: Live Another Day. As for 2015, she starred alongside fellow Dexter alum Desmond Harrington in ABC's The Astronaut Wives Club, which concluded its first and last season this past August.

Coming up, you can find her with Adrien Brody in the film adaptation of Colin Harrison's 1996 crime novel Manhattan Nocturne, the pilot for Amazon's western drama Edge, as the voice of Batwoman in the direct-to-video Batman: Bad Blood and in the Marc Foster-directed All I See Is You, which also stars Blake Lively and Jason Clarke in a story following a blind woman whose vision is restored, allowing her to see new details that upend her life and her marriage.

9. Erik King

The Role: Sergeant James Doakes in the first two seasons until he was killed in an explosion courtesy of Lila.

Advertisement

Of all the cast members on this list, King seems to be the one who has been the least active on screen since leaving the series after the second season back in 2007. He showed up on Burn Notice three years later and last year on an episode of NBC's short-lived Growing Up Fisher, but the most notable thing was his single-episode return as Doakes via flashbacks in Dexter's seventh season.

Going forward, you can see him in Kellie Madison's horror film The Tank alongside Jack Davenport and Jack Coleman, which follows things going wrong for an isolated group of test subjects preparing for a mission to Mars, but otherwise he's more active on Twitter.

8. C.S. Lee

The Role: Forensic investigator Vince Masuka throughout all eight seasons of the series.

Advertisement

After Dexter ended, Lee continued showing up for guest spots on a handful of television shows, including Blue Bloods in 2013, Franklin & Bash and Criminal Minds in 2014, and Fresh Off the Boat and the second season of HBO's True Detective earlier this year. 

Coming up, he'll be appearing in the Patrick Stewart-led Starz series Blunt Talk and is currently in production on the science fiction film Everything Beautiful Is Far Away, which chronicles a trio's journey to find something better for themselves in a dystopian desert wasteland.

7. Desmond Harrington

The Role: Joined the main cast as Joey Quinn in the third season and remained a part of it to the end.

Advertisement

Last year, Harrington recurred on the A&E series Those Who Kill, which starred Chloe Sevigny and James D'Arcy and was cancelled after only one season. This past summer, he was part of ABC's The Astronaut Wives Club, though that series, too, was cancelled.

Going forward, you can see him next year in Nicolas Winding Refn's horror film The Neon Demon alongside Keanu Reeves, Elle Fanning and Christina Hendricks, which follows a young woman arriving in Los Angeles with dreams of becoming a model only to find herself caught up in a culture that's ready to eat her alive.

6. James Remar

The Role: Harry Morgan throughout the entirety of the series' run.

Advertisement

In 2014, Remar continued his recurring roles on Grey's Anatomy, the animated Beware the Batman and FX's now-finished Wilfred, turned up in the From Dusk Til Dawn series, had a voice role in Destiny, wrapped up voicing the role of Tonraq on Nickelodeon's The Legend of Korra and also joined the cast of NBC's Katherine Heigl-led State of Affairs, which was cancelled after its first season ended this past February.

He's got quite a lot of projects coming up that you can see him in, including the Ernest Hemingway biopic Papa, the Vinnie Jones starrer Decommissioned, the killer polar bear film Unnatural, the horror-comedy vampire film The Night Watchmen and a guest spot next year in MTV's new fantasy series The Shannara Chronicles.

5. Lauren Velez

The Role: Portrayed Maria LaGuerta through the series' first seven seasons until she was shot and killed by Deb.

Advertisement

Since Dexter came to a close, Velez has only turned up in a handful of television roles in the past two years, including CBS' Unforgettable last year and the modern Sherlock Holmes series Elementary this past March. She's also a part of Eli Roth's new demon hunter series South of Hell, though a premiere date has yet to be set.

Beyond that, you can see her next year alongside Sons of Anarchy's Kim Coates in the film adaptation of Image Comics’ Officer Downe, the story of a cop who repeatedly returns from the dead to fight crime, which is being directed by Slipknot’s founding member Shawn Crahan.

4. David Zayas

The Role: Angel Batista in all eight seasons of the series.

Advertisement

Last year, Zayas was part of the main cast in the failed George Lopez sitcom Saint George, starred alongside Helen Hunt and Luke Wilson in the surfing drama Ride, turned up in the musical Annie and began recurring as Sal Maroni on the first season of Gotham, a role he carried through until its season finale.

On the way, Zayas is a part of the The Lennon Report, which tells the story of the hospital workers who attempted to save John Lennon's life in the wake of his assassination, and is starring in Anthony Tarsitano's indie Lost Cat Corona. Next year, he'll be seen alongside Ellen Page in Sian Heder's Tallulah and in the indie drama Eli Moran, the story of a high school basketball star whose efforts to win the state championship and a college scholarship are endangered when he learns that he was adopted.

3. Julie Benz

The Role: Played Rita from season one until she was killed by the Trinity Killer at the end of season four.

After Benz left the series, she spent the next several years bouncing between film and television roles, most notably alongside Michael Chiklis in ABC's cancelled No Ordinary Family and in CBC's also-cancelled Patrick Wilson-led drama A Gifted Man. In 2013, she joined the main cast of Syfy's Defiance, which concluded its third season last month.

Soon you will be able to see her in David Hackl's Life on the Line, which follows what happens when a group of electrical lineman are caught in a massive storm and also stars John Travolta, Kate Bosworth and Sharon Stone, as well as the horror film Havenhurst, starring genre vet Danielle Harris as a young woman forced to confront the evil within her new apartment building.

2. Jennifer Carpenter

The Role: Debra Morgan for the entirety of the series' run.

Advertisement

Last year, Carpenter lent her voice to Capcom's The Evil Within, an episode of Robot Chicken and the direct-to-video Avengers Confidential: Black Widow & Punisher, in which she took on the role of Black Widow. In addition, she had a role in the low budget DTV horror film The Devil's Hand alongside Fear the Walking Dead's Alycia Debnam-Carey.

She also shot a pilot for the USA Network for a series called Stanistan, which would've seen her portraying an American Public Affairs Officer working in the Middle East, though the network ultimately passed on the project. However, on September 22nd, you can instead see her as part of the main cast in CBS' Limitless, a television follow-up series to the 2011 Bradley Cooper film. 

1. Michael C. Hall

The Role: Played the titular serial killer from beginning to end.

Advertisement

With Hall having been busy leading the Broadway revival of Hedwig and the Angry Inch last year, 2014 was pretty quiet for the actor on screen, only starring in the crime drama Cold in July as a man whose murder of a thief in his own home puts a target on his back by the deceased's vengeful father. This past summer, he voiced Batman in the alternate universe film Justice League: Gods and Monsters, as well as in an episode of the film's Machinima companion series.

He's also been lending his voice in a recurring capacity to Disney XD's Star vs. the Forces of Evil and is taking part in the upcoming documentary The Gettysburg Address. Next year, you can see him alongside Rebecca Hall in Christine, the true life drama about news reporter Christine Chubbuck, whose long battle with depression led to her committing suicide on live television in 1974.

Advertisement