Doctor Who: 10 Beautiful Things About 'The Time Of The Doctor'

In all great tragedy, there is great poetry.

By Mark White /

In all great tragedy, there is great poetry. No timeless character has ever left a stage without having the finer details of their life woven together with elegant majesty, and the last incarnation of the Doctor was always going to be a character more timeless than most. But Matt Smith's swansong is not a tragedy, but a triumph; it's a lap of honour for a Doctor who turned so many onto the show, ignited so many imaginations and embodied so much. 'The Time of the Doctor' may divide opinion - when is opinion on a Moffat story ever unanimous? - but it is in many ways, the only way to wave goodbye to the Eleventh Doctor. Because actually, in places, 'The Time of the Doctor' is a beautiful piece of television. Yes, trying to cram three hundred years of story into an hour might not have worked, but there are few other words fit to describe the intricacies of the episode, the meanings behind the images, the details and the performances from the actors involved. Here are ten of the most beautiful things about the fall of the Eleventh.

10. Clara Is Us (still)

I've written at length about how Clara is a huge metaphor for the fans; her diary syncs with the show's and she's always been there for the Doctor in the background. When you think about it, the Doctor only visits her when he visits us: she travels with him once a week, like us. She has a job and a life away from the Doctor, like us. He picks her up for specials. The '...of the Doctor' trilogy only solidifies this metaphor. Only a true Doctor Who fan would know that it doesn't matter what his name is, and only a true Doctor Who fan would get emotional seeing their Doctor using the Moment; just like us, she has her Doctor, but knows them all, unlike any companion. And her Doctor's regeneration is a defining moment for Clara's character, just as it is for everyone she represents. Because it was Clara that didn't want the Doctor to go, not the Doctor himself. It was like she was speaking for us again, and that she was our lead into the show. Which a companion always should be, but that's easier than it sounds: how on Earth do you go about conveying an ordinary girl's reaction to the bloke she fancies combusting into Malcolm Tucker? Clara's side to the story was perfect though. It's how we'd react as fans of the Eleventh.

9. Handles Means More Than You Think

There have been plenty of parallels between Sherlock and the Doctor, especially during last year's Christmas special, when Eleven impersonated Holmes. It's only natural when you look through Steven Moffat's writing credits and notice two rather large peaks. But does the Doctor's Cyberman head, Handles, remind you of Sherlock's skull? If you wish to make a more literary comparison, I offer you Yorick, of Hamlet. And if you've never read/seen Hamlet, try The Lion King first. No Cyber heads in that, but lots of Hakuna Matata. What I'm trying to get at, is that there's a significance in the Doctor carrying around a skull, whether it's a sci-fi skull or not. Skulls are often used to evoke the theme Memento Mori ("Remember you shall die" in English); they're not just used for funereal effect, they're there to show how ephemeral and fleeting life can be. Handles didn't just supply the most surprisingly sad moment of the episode, he brought the Doctor closer to death, in imagery at least. Genius.

8. The Rose Connotations

It's important not to forget the people that you were, he said. And the Doctor really is the same person as he was hundreds of years ago. There wasn't nearly so much fan-service in 'The Time of the Doctor', perhaps because we had Tom Baker appear in the last episode. But one reference wasn't so much a reference as a connotation; this was a story about the progression of one character nearing death, and the relationship between a Doctor and his companion. It made sense to draw upon the episodes that did the same. When the Doctor sends Clara home, it's certainly reminiscent of his Ninth incarnation saving Rose in 'The Parting of the Ways'. Or what about when he tried to save her in 'Doomsday' by sending her to Pete's World with her family? There's a nod perhaps to Jack - Clara clings to the TARDIS to prevent being left behind - but the Rose connotations definitely answer a question: the Doctor will always save his companions from anything that even resembles the Time War. And that's lovely, isn't it?

7. There Was A Reference To Matt's Shaved Head

There were a few articles that speculated whether Matt Smith would even appear in the Christmas episode this year, given that he'd shaved his head. How would it grow back in time? If only we all knew about Karen Gillan (spoilers). The new-look Matt is something that's been addressed in the fandom, joked about, and even mentioned during the Doctor's Proms cameo, when he claimed he swapped his hair for a ticket to the show. So it was nice to see it referenced when the Doctor appeared, bald, claiming that he took a razor to his quiff when he was bored. Again, it's the little nods to the fans that make episodes special. And winking through the screen is a sweet way to do that. We know the Doctor really did shave his head. Whether it was because he was bored or not, we'll never know.

6. The Drawings In The TARDIS

The Doctor was always a lonely god under Russell T Davies, but when Steven Moffat stepped up to helm the show, he became a hero in a fairytale. The signs are there throughout Moffat's tenure: the Eleventh Doctor becomes a story overnight in Leadworth, before saving his own life by telling Amy the story of a madman who stole a magic box and ran away. Smith's TARDIS interior was "whimsical" according to Moffat, but underwent a more mechanical makeover during Eleven's alone time. Again, it was Clara reading a story about a magical man in a box that brought the Doctor to life again. So naturally, as the Doctor's clock hands meet at Twelve, the mechanical TARDIS became decorated with drawings, just to take the Doctor back to the start. The TARDIS was once again playful and colourful, just like the Eleventh Doctor himself, and just like the legend of the Raggedy Doctor.

5. The Speech

Each Doctor has a fitting end for their character. The first regeneration saw the grumpy old man of the TARDIS keel over and die of old age; the last regeneration saw the Tenth Doctor having customary trouble letting go. The Eleventh Doctor's been both old and young in striking contrasts, fighting an impossible war alongside Amy and Clara. His demise reflected this, but his speech really brought out the statesman in Eleven. It was poetic, and moving, from the comparison to life being just a breath on a mirror to the Doctor comparing himself to any of us; in an anniversary year, when we're the facing the last of the original thirteen incarnations, it was fitting that the Doctor should remember everyone he's been, but again, we got a heart-warming nod to Matt. "I'll never forget when the Doctor was me," he said, and it was a parallel to both Tennant's and Eccleston's last words: we felt the actor behind the Doctor, the actor that we've grown to adore. We've got two people we're saying goodbye to. We love the Eleventh Doctor, but we love Matt Smith just as much.

4. The Long Song

During David Tennant's era, the Doctor's musical theme was whispery, enigmatic and evocative. It made sense for a man steeped in such mystery and mythology to only be associated with the spaciest of sirens singing a single "ooh". But when Matt Smith became the Doctor, he was suddenly scored with an adventurous melody that rung in Whovians' ears long after episodes had ended. The transition from lonely god to fairytale hero can be shown in those two pieces of music. Tennant's regeneration was soundtracked by the huge Vale Decem. The same "ooh" riff magnified by a full orchestra, it was a lot like 'The End of Time' itself. But Matt's regeneration instead brought 'The Long Song', a track that played during his speech in '...Akhaten', but one that summed up his time in the TARDIS. It's optimistic, but it's tinged with a saccharine sadness. It's both hugely moving and empowering all at once, as the lyrics sing the Eleventh Doctor to sleep; "Rest now, my warrior. Rest now, hardship is over." The impossible war ended, and the Doctor died in peace to the most wonderful hymn.

3. The Doctor Finally Grew Up

He'll be known as the young Doctor, despite living to be older than all the others; all the others combined maybe, he's lost count. Even the lasting image of Matt Smith in 'The Time of the Doctor' will be of a 30-year-old regenerating, and not the older, prosthetics-aided Doctor that withered on Trenzalore. But the centuries that elapsed over this hour-long episode are actually irrelevant: this is the story when the Doctor finally grew up after three whole series. He wished he didn't run out on the people he cared about, and here, for once he didn't. He stayed in Christmas, but more significantly than that, he turned around a huge part of his character. He's the Doctor who doesn't like endings; he sulked on a cloud because of an ending. And yet, he stood there, in the TARDIS, accepting his fate, and knowing that as long as he remembers his story, it doesn't matter if it's the end. Just as long as he makes it a good one.

2. He Drops The Bow Tie

You might have seen 'A Christmas Carol' earlier on Christmas Day; it was repeated on Watch. And if you look at Kazran Sardick's attire, he starts wearing a bow tie when he becomes friends with the Doctor. It's icon of the Smith era; even Clara's outfit in 'The Time of the Doctor' had bow ties on it. And similar to the use in 'A Christmas Carol', is it not fitting that in his last moments, the Eleventh Doctor dropped his icon upon the TARDIS floor? It was almost a sign that he's not going to be replaced. It's not a case of one in, one out; this new Doctor is a new man, a new character, and he won't pick up where the last one left off. He dropped the bow tie because that's the end of its tenure, not the continuation of it through another actor. Capaldi might be wearing his clothes, but he's not the same character.

1. Amy Is his Imaginary Friend

How could the Karen Gillan cameo not be the most beautiful part of the episode? What's wonderful though, is that it completes a circle. She was the first face for him, but to her, he was an imaginary friend. She exists in the past, having adventures with her imaginary Raggedy Doctor, and he can't see her anymore. But likewise, he's now a thing of the past too. She's his imaginary friend. "Goodnight, Raggedy man" ends the fairytale for the both of them. Times, as the Doctor says, change. But wouldn't it be fantastic... absolutely fantastic... if the Doctor's Twelfth incarnation was Scottish because he was thinking about Amy when he regenerated?