Doctor Who: 10 Biggest Cop Out Endings

Think there's nothing worse than a great episode ruined by a terrible ending? Read on!

By Mark White /

Imagine you're sat watching your favourite show, engrossed. Laughing with the characters, edging further and further off your seat with the drama, and tearing up when appropriate. It all boils down to the last five minutes... and it's such a let down, you tut, stand up, and head to the kitchen to make a cup of tea. There are a fair few TV shows that this scenario is applicable to, not least Doctor Who, a show that seems to divide its fandom right down the middle on a weekly basis. Just take to Twitter five minutes after the credits have ended; it would seem that episodes are either unbelievably incredible or undeniably poor, and the resolution of the episode plays a massive part to play in that. Just after the show's ended, we judge it by the finale, so regardless of how good a story is, you really have to tie it up well to make a good impression. But which are the worst offenders for an ending that's come out of nowhere? Let's take a look at the top ten and decide, and remember, these bizarre endings don't actually take away from the quality of the episodes. Which ones do you think are the biggest cop-out endings? Comment below!

10. Love and Monsters

Famously disliked by nearly every people that's ever watched the show, 'Love and Monsters' featured Peter Kay dressed as an alien, and implied sexual encounters between that bloke from Hustle and a paving slab. Okay, the episode's really not that bad; it had its flaws without doubt, but it was well set-up and an interesting insight into a world of people all searching for the Doctor. The ending though seems just a bit rushed; the Doctor shows up, and says he won't help Elton from certain alien doom. Rose has a go at him for hurting her mum - something that he really didn't mean to do, by the way - and the Doctor just stands by for this, before telling the victims of the Absorbaloff that they should pull in different directions to destroy the beast. It's quite a message - you don't need a hero, you can kill aliens all by yourself - but it comes a little too late, given that all but one of LINDA are dead by that point. And instead of saving Elton's love Ursula completely, the Doctor sonics her into the pavement. Elton sort of gets a happy ending, out of nowhere with what's left, and let's face it, that's not a lot. But if you're happy dating a paving slab, it's great.

9. Boom Town

Another Russell T Davies episode, 'Boom Town' features another big, green, rubbery alien in the shape of the Slitheen. It's an interesting balance for the most part in which the Ninth Doctor is faced with a killer; the conversations they have are fascinating, and the acting is brilliant. But towards the end, Margaret Blaine reveals herself to still be a villain; no surprise there, as she takes Rose as her hostage, and starts to demand rights. But then suddenly, the heart of the TARDIS opens. Margaret is transformed into an egg, and given the opportunity to live her life over again. And whilst it's debatable where this light is actually coming from - isn't the heart of the TARDIS the Eye of Harmony? - that's not the main gripe of this ending. Both Margaret and the Doctor seem to be going somewhere, coming to terms with their pasts, and then we're given the moral that it's okay, you can just reverse time in Doctor Who. It might set up 'Bad Wolf' well, but some kind of prior warning would've been nice.

8. The Power Of Three

There is a large section of the fandom that claim the sonic screwdriver is overused. Rubbish, I say. It doesn't save the day nearly as much as you might imagine; but then I'm confronted with 'The Power of Three', and I really have no reply. 'The Power of Three' is another example of a wonderfully set-up invasion story. The episode focuses on the character dynamic between the Ponds and the Doctor, and seems to be moving towards an exciting climax. The Shakri turn up, and the Doctor's scared of him: he's heard stories since his childhood about this dreaded foe, and to conquer it... he needs to wave his sonic screwdriver, and then all will be well again. It's understandable that this episode had such a rushed ending, given that it was never about the invasion in the first place, but the characters. But why was so much dread placed on the Shakri, then? Why was the episode paced like this? Why didn't the ending revolve around the companions, and how the Doctor needs them so badly? Easily the worst offender of the "Sonic Solves All" argument, and one that many can't defend, unfortunately.

7. Voyage Of The Damned

"I'm the Doctor. I'm a Time Lord. I'm from the planet Gallifrey in the Constellation of Kasterborous. I'm 903 years old and I'm the man who is gonna save your lives and all 6 billion people on the planet below," he said. "You got a problem with that?" In actual fact though, the Doctor didn't save everyone. What was promised to be a heroic victory for the Time Lord ended up with Kylie Minogue fighting a head in a tank. Again, we got to see the burden of the Time Lord, we saw that he must outlive everyone, but somehow, it wasn't a particularly satisfying conclusion for the Doctor to save no one but the obnoxious bloke and the tour guide. Sadly, another Russell T Davies episode where a clever resolution was sacrificed in favour of more brooding from Ten.

6. The Wedding Of River Song

Spot the parallels between Doctor Who and Sherlock: the main character is killed, the companion is devastated; the main character actually survived, the companion never knew about the plan, and the companion is angry when they find out, only to warm up later. Whilst Sherlock took the route of planting clues to the fake death, Doctor Who chose not to, as it was revealed that the Doctor had used a Teselecta to hide in. Amy had even speculated that it might be a duplicate, a suggestion rubbished at the time. It was somewhat disappointing though that a whole series' worth of progression, of the Doctor reflecting on his role in the universe, and deciding it was probably best for him to die, was in fact cancelled out by a final five minutes that revealed him to have actually used Amy's idea all along. Unfortunately, Mycroft had no part to play in faking the death.

5. The Curse Of The Black Spot

Steve Thompson loves a twist. On the subject of Sherlock, his episode, 'The Reichenbach Fall' was a masterpiece that utilised a good few bombshells, shocking every one of the viewers in the process. 'The Curse of the Black Spot' however, was not quite as fruitful. The Doctor had a different theory on what was going on every five minutes. There was a clear line drawn between the siren and the pirate ship. And when it was revealed that the victims of the siren were still alive in a sick bay, but could never leave, it was an interesting conundrum heading into the final moments of the episode. So it was somewhat surprising that the Doctor let Rory die, so that Amy could resuscitate him. What, no final twist, Steve? No big clue that the Doctor's been missing all along, tying up the strands of the episode neatly? Oh. Okay then.

4. The Lodger / Closing Time

I might be the only person in the whole of Great Britain, but I love James Corden. I think he's a great actor, really funny in every role, and I think he's perfect opposite Matt Smith. A lot of people can't stand him though. And a lot of people hate the episodes that he's appeared in. It sort of made sense for 'The Lodger' to end in a big show of affection; that's what it was leading up to. It was ever-so-slightly unbelievable though that a Silent ship could be defeated by a young couple from Colchester. The Cybermen though? Sure, they were depleted, but it had already been established that there's no going back from a conversion. Even if you hear a baby cry. Writer Gareth Roberts actually joked with the idea that love had saved the day, but he didn't offer any alternate conclusion. Apparently, alien technology is built with the weakness that should people who care for each other come into contact with it, it spontaneously combusts. No it really does: there were big explosions about to happen in both episodes, had the Doctor and Craig not have left the vicinities immediately.

3. Cold War

Although 'Dalek' shares a close resemblance with Alien, it's a great episode. It details the torn mentality of a Dalek who's becoming slightly more human, and the culmination that it would rather die than feel emotion is a fitting end to a slaughterous story. 'Cold War' is extremely similar; the claustrophobia, the beast killing its way through the corridors, the balance between morality and murder. But it ends in such a way, that you actually question if you've missed something. Despite being told that there are no other Ice Warriors for light-years around, a ship of them come to find Skaldak in the nick of time. They beam him up, just as the Doctor's about to blow up the Earth, and the day's saved. The TARDIS is revealed to have been relocated to the South Pole, which explains that mystery, but doesn't actually move the plot along, and the Doctor expects that he'll meet the Ice Warriors again one day. It all seems rather convenient, goes against what's been established for forty minutes, and doesn't exactly tie threads together. Still, if the Ice Warriors return next series, maybe we can have an explanation for the erratic ending of 'Cold War'.

2. Journey's End

Rose becoming Bad Wolf was one hell of a deus ex machina, but it was a fantastic story, so why not? The resolution 'Doomsday', where the Doctor sends the Daleks and the Cybermen to hell used elements of the established story, so it made sense. The Series 3 finale, where the Doctor rises like Jesus to wipe the previous year of history was somewhat contentious. But the Doctor-Donna? Surely that's one deus ex machina too far? Russell T Davies is a master of the build-up; 'The Stolen Earth' united the Doctor's companions, and 'Journey's End' did a brilliant job of developing the Doctor's relationship with all of them, as well as his rivalry with Davros. It seemed like the Meta-crisis Doctor and Donna would save the world, but then they were also thwarted. It seemed like there was no hope, but then out of nowhere, Donna was given all of the Doctor's powers. Together, her and the Ten Clone then destroyed all the Daleks with the press of a button, and the Doctor was left claiming that he should have seen it all along: "The Doctor Donna: just like the Ood said!" What was an excellent set-up descended into the same old trick; the Daleks all died with a click of Davies's fingers, and Donna got her turn to be godlike too. Perhaps most upsettingly though, all that wonderful character development just vanished, as Donna completely forgot her life with the Doctor at the end of the episode.

1. Journey To The Centre Of The TARDIS

There are cop-out endings in every show, and writers try to avoid them, whether it's the clumsy "Doctor-Donna" prophecy, the use of a giant robot in an earlier episode, or just falling back on the themes of the show. But 'Journey to the Centre of the TARDIS' really took the cop-out ending biscuit because it didn't even try to avoid a lazy resolution. It was classic Steve Thompson; twist after twist after twist, labyrinthine as the TARDIS herself, but totally obscuring the progress of the plot. And then, towards the end, he gifted the Doctor and Clara with a "Big Friendly Button": a reset for the entire episode, nullifying everything that had happened. The episode was referenced in 'The Name of the Doctor', but didn't have to have been; it might as well have never happened - well, it never did happen, did it? - and many fans saw it as a huge anti-climax. The ending of 'Journey to the Centre of the TARDIS' was the ultimate timey-wimey reset though; it polarised viewers, as some thought it insulted them, and some thought was tongue-in-cheek genius. Whether you like any of these endings or not though, there's no denying the writers took an easy way out.