In some ways series eight is in a more secure place than Doctor Who has been in decades. The eras of the Sixth and Seventh Doctors were marred in part by some parties' desire to see the cancellation of the series, and then the early years of Modern Who were fraught with worries that this new enterprise could not possibly succeed. The worry emerged not only at the being of Eccleston's run, but in each change of hands thereafter. Despite some dissent that persists against Peter Capaldi, it is fair to say that Doctor Who is here to stay. Our loveable madman in a box has not only prevailed past cancellation, but did something truly unexpected last year by cementing himself as a global product with the world record-setting simulcast. But the fiftieth anniversary, what with its multitude of events, specials, and just general celebration, is a very tough act of follow. On the heels of such excitement the upcoming series could get overshadowed or deemed unmemorable. And with a certain Matt Smith prompting fans everywhere to wonder if there is another party in store for Modern Who's tenth birthday, it gives 2014 the challenge of standing out in its own right. Not only can series eight meet this challenge, but with the combination of a promised fresh start in the plot and Capaldi's passion and talent, it has the potential to be the best series yet. To find out what decisions are essential to making the most out of series eight, please read on.
10. Embrace New Voices
No, not these kinds of voices. The first item on a list of must-haves for a successful year are new single episode writers. While the greatest criticisms are usually shot at showrunnerswith good reasonthere are a host of other writers in Doctor Who's hallowed history who also earn our praise and ire. Many of these other voices come with a distinctive flair. Mark Gatiss pens a lovely bit of historical fiction, Gareth Roberts can create a companion-worthy sidekick in half an episode, and Neil Gaiman is near unparalleled at building complex mythologies and worlds. But precisely because of the wide range of what is possible in the Doctor Who franchise, their spin can feel repetitive. Unlike many other television programmes that need the same pool of writers for narrative consistency, the ever-changing world of Doctor Who allows for continually fresh viewpoints. Thus, the best thing anyone can do for series eight and beyond is to continue to find the people out there ready, willing and able to challenge the TARDIS crews in new and interesting ways. At this point it is all but guaranteed there will be at least one new writer for the upcoming slate of thirteen stories. Doctor Who neophytes have a high bar to live up to, but their fresh perspective is exactly what is needed.
9. Stop Drawing Attention To Special Effects
This is not a public service announcement from luddites; effects are a vital and beloved part of science fiction and fantasy, and everyone can appreciate what Doctor Who has achieved as it pushes modern technology to its best, year after year. It would be absurd to do away with the wonders of present-day technology; no one is exactly pining for wobbly Styrofoam of days gone by. Even Midnight, one of the stories that seems sparse with special effects, needed those glistening shots of the diamond city to get the most out of that story. Doctor Who is, was, and will be, a sort of television time capsule, as much a cinematographic artefact as a cultural one. That said the last series itself was an attempt to showcase that very range: the best the CGI crew and the pyrotechnics team and everyone else had to offer. What changed recently was that discussion about effects made that especially clear. Series seven speculation was bogged down with terms like "epic" and "Hollywood-style blockbuster" which resulted in such a focus on special effects that the result onscreen could not live up to the hype. Take the promotional poster for Bells of Saint John above. The actual motorbike scene looks less impressive with the image in mind.The FX teams at Doctor Who do truly amazing work, but have been recently over-scrunitised compared to the rest of Modern Who. It is critical that series eight returns to putting the stories and performances first allowing visual effects to support, not dominate, world building.
8. Make An Effort To Address Criticism
Doctor Who, like any large entity, has a lot of critics. Some are more thoughtful, some less, but all of them have very strong options on what is going right or wrong in the Whoniverse. Most concerning are the critics who grapple with issues of demographics, like race, gender, and age. The amount and gravity of their criticism has continued to escalate and it is troubling. There are others who feel the objections are too harsh or too numerous, who cry that everyone's gone mad with political correctness for making a suggestion that they feel destroys the integrity of Doctor Who. It is beyond the scope of this article to advocate for any individual change, but most can agree that casting, plot and dialogue decisions are required to improve the diversity and multicultural sensitivity of the programme overall. Even if you are among those who vehemently disagree with the vast majority of this discourse, having unhappy critics with concerns makes the fandom a less happy place offscreen. Regardless of whether the production team disagrees with the changes proposed by critics, it will be important to the success of series eight for them to continue to be aware of what is being said. Both what comes across on our television screens as well as comments made behind the scenes will be judged by how they respond to these concerns.
7. Toss In A Surprise Or Two
On the lighter side of things, managing to pull off some sort of surprise is especially important for series eight. A well-placed shocker is always good for a programme whose fundamental spirit is the unexpected. But because surprises were such a big part of last year's festivities, it becomes especially important to find a way to add one in this year. Series eight cannot risk the impression that last year has pulled out all the stops to impress us. It must instead remind us it has magic left all its own. While this gets harder and harder to do in the age of instantaneous global information sharing, even if it gets spoiled a touch early the effort will be worth the reward. The life of the Doctor is all about serendipity, so try as we might and speculate as we do, it is secretly wonderful when things land somewhere we were not planning for either.
6. Tone Down The Plot Complexity
Enduring narrative threads are one of the nicest changes brought about by Modern Who, but the end of the Eleventh Doctor's era became just a bit too orderly. Every element of the plot was eventually stitched together and particular events lingered for years requiring multiple run-throughs of his tenure to really get it all. Whilst it will make his era particularly impressive to watch as a wholewhen the Whovians of some still distant tomorrow are catching themselves up on the Doctor's historyit is a problematic strategy to continue going forward. This type of plot serves to reward loyal viewers for their long-term devotion, but it comes at the risk of turning away both new and casual viewers. Doctor Who attempts to be multi-layered offering a slightly different experience for loyal and casual fans. A truly best series yet needs to avoid both new and casual viewer alienation. The best of what Doctor Who has to offer cannot be an experience for just loyal week-to-week fans. We were all new to the Whoniverse once, and the best stories will always welcome new Whovians-to-be. Also in the spirit of making Doctor Who more audience-inclusive is the next point on this list.
5. Get A New Sense Of Humour
If anyone is in doubt about the nosedive family friendliness has taken over the course of Modern Who please check out this rundown of the Doctor's recent raunchiness. It is not all bad, an innuendo or two makes the older members of the viewing audience feel they are in on something. Surely no one wants to return to the point in time of such censorship where as Peter Davison explained, he wasn't allowed to put arm around female companions because that would imply something naughty had gone on in the TARDIS. Being more open-minded about the Doctor romantic interests has had an upside. Still with a new Doctor aboard comes the hope that we find some classier form of comedy than discussing the intricacies of sex with a Zygon. There are less tired and overused ways to bridge the gap between young and old than reinventing the "sonic screwdriver equals manparts" joke. For the true best series ever instead of resorting to dumping everyone's mind in the sewer, series eight should derive its cleverness in other aspects of the story. Swap dirty jokes out for obscure historical references, or puns, or large words that will improve vocabularies of the less verbally dexterous.
4. Find A Villain For The Ages
Whilst it is true that every era of Doctor Who has challenges and opportunities where villains are concerned, the pool of existing recurring villains feels especially exhausted as Capaldi takes his turn at the console. Someone certainly has the task of adding onto the storied history of the Daleks and other truly iconic Whoniverse baddies; however the best possible villain development for series eight is the addition of one more magnificent Moffat monster. Both the Weeping Angels and the Silents as special creations of showrunner Steven Moffat, had their own layers of narrative during these past few series. Now that these arcs have rather tidily concluded, series eight would feel emptier without a signature monster of its own to take their place. Finding new foes for the Doctor has been a place where Moffat's talent shines brightest, and hopefully he has at least one more rattling around in that curly-coiffed head of his to challenge the Twelfth Doctor.
3. Really Explore The Companions
For much of Doctor Who's history companions existed largely in a vacuum. Their lives were often wholly dismantled shortly before their travels with the Doctor, like in the case of orphan Victoria Waterfield, and in the end many of their lives were heavily rerouted by his influence. Few Classic Who travellers ever expected to return and face the lives they had left behind. At the start of Modern Who we saw the damage life with the Doctor can wreak on those who travel and the people that love them. Amy and Rory gave us a glimmer of a struggle of a different sort. They revelled in the allure of both worlds, caught in the pull between their lives both inside and outside the TARDIS. Clara has been a product of her mystery, a puzzle to solve, until now. With her mystery concluded, and the Doctor freshly regenerated, Clara's character can be taken in new directions. Additionally, now that all sorts of relationship history has been established, we can really get to know Clara and Danny in their own right. Series eight is a chance to discover them both as individuals and as a unit. All of this freedom means that series eight has time to work toward forging a bond between the companions and the audience, and it is that deep bond that carries a lot of the emotional punch of Doctor Who. Companion-related triumph and heartbreak has a chance to be at the forefront of events, and it is a chance the Doctor Who team should seize. Speaking of heartbreak...
2. Bring On The Dead
Amy and Rory were dead but not dead, same too with River and Clara. Lately it is as though Gelth have swarmed the entire plot, forever keeping alive those who should have passed on. Death is a hesitant choice for long-term companions on Doctor Who: Leela's original exit was to be a heroic sacrifice to save the Doctor. Or there was Peri, who had an alternate ending to explain away her death which was so dissatisfying it took multiple media to correct. It seems all things considered companion death is preferred with a dose of time can be rewritten. That said it is not as though it has never been done. Notwithstanding the beautiful and tragic end of Cas in the Night of the Doctor, another heartwrenching death is still in order. Let us embrace our inner Earthshock, and without universe-restarts, or take-backsies, or parallel universes, blow someone to bits. No need to be picky: shot, stabbed, poisoned, drowned, set aflame, or anything will doperhaps a Rasputin of a companion who suffers all of the above! Even if Clara confetti is not in your set of Doctor Who hopes and dreams, there are other equally suitable options for a sacrificial lamb. Whether it is an unlikely hero like Gustav Lytton, or tragedy of a companion that never was like Jabe of Cheem, well-executed character deaths are important. In Doctor Who we see dozens exterminated, upgraded, or even eaten. Sometimes much like Doctor must, we forget about the individual tragedy of each lost life. But when death is foisted into the spotlightwhen someone we have really gotten to know is ripped awayit makes the bigger tragedies: the wars, the Pompeiis, the lost species, all the more painful. This sublimity of death is a feature equally prominent, equally necessary, and equally well done throughout all of the Doctor's lives. It is one feature that ties all of Doctor Who together, and it was difficult to think of a single more important feature for a great series. But there is one other must-have that did ultimately top that.
1. Give Clara A Great Sendoff
To make the top entry on this list the suggestion had to be unique to series eight. Many things are rightfully important to making any good series of Doctor Who, but this series in particular should be defined by Clara's departure. It is a risky statement to make given that her farewell is not confirmed for series eight, but there is no better way to cap off a great year than to shake things up again. Companion departures have become like regeneration, major markers of the programme's journey. From the First Doctor's beautiful goodbye speech to Susan to the much debated heartbreaks of the Modern Who era, a companion's farewell is forever etched in the collective memory of the fandom. Amy and Rory's send off made brilliant use of the Weeping Angels, but without a monster of Clara's own, a new strategy will be necessary. Clara is a particularly unique challenge due to her echoesthe Clara copies scattered throughout space and timeand seeing that tackled will be very interesting. Moffat and crew could choose to continue with nods to Classic Who and give Clara a more quiet farewell. Send her heading off to live a life she has never really had, free from responsibility for the Doctor. However, it would be better and far fairer to her character, to see her go out with some sort of bang. It will be difficult to top becoming a galactic queen, suffering a complete mind wipe, or receiving one's own human doctor, but finding a positively brilliant goodbye of Clara's own will complete series eight in a way that nothing else possibly could. Think Clara should live on for one more year? Is there something missing from your ideal vision of series eight on this list? Please drop a comment below!