Doctor Who: 10 Ways Patrick Troughton Made The Recorder Cool

By Chris Morley /

We all know everyone's going to be sad when the Eleventh Doctor exits stage left in 'The Time Of The Doctor'. So let's look back by looking even further back and have a little fun with the Second Doctor. There's that old saying that 'music soothes the savage beast' -so let's see if it works on a generation of upset new- Whovians! And who better to be our guide in that regard than the first incarnation of the Time Lord to display real musical prowess of any sort? From the moment he finds his beloved recorder following his recovery from his first regeneration in 'The Power Of The Daleks' it rarely leaves his side and comes in handy on a number of occasions. Ask anyone for memories of Patrick Troughton's Doctor and it'll most likely get a mention-as well as his bow tie & Beatle hairdo. Where William Hartnell was mostly a grumpy old man this incarnation seems more like your mad uncle or a brilliantly eccentric music teacher. And at the end of 'The Highlanders' he even gets a jamming partner when Scottish piper Jamie McCrimmon joins he,B en & Polly aboard the TARDIS. Sometimes though,all he needs is his trusty instrument. Oh my giddy aunt!

10. What Does It All Mean, Doctor?

In Michael Scott's 50th Anniversary e-short 'The Nameless City', the Doctor's recorder of choice is described as plain with blue stripes. And when we see it in glorious colour in 'The Three Doctors' that's exactly what we get. The Third Doctor seems to hate it with a passion but it gives rise to one of the best pop music gags classic 'Who' ever made.. The dandier of the three finds the recorder on his TARDIS console. Acknowledging it as a recorder, the scene is set for his previous self to appear. He then takes it from him and gives it a quick play. And that's not even the best bit. The two of them try to explain to Jo Grant that they're not just Time Lords, but the same one. 'I am he and he is me' says the Third. 'And we are all together?' comes the response. Not unreasonable. She then proves a little more in tune with popular culture than the two of them put together in explaining her jokey reference to the Beatles and 'I Am The Walrus'. Neat for sure. But then the Second steals the show. 'How does it go?' he innocently enquires-intending to learn it by heart and possibly blow the minds of the Fab Four themselves in a later adventure. Also notable for the first and probably funniest use of the 'I don't like it' TARDIS redecoration gag. See it here;

9. It Saved The Universe Once

Yes. You did read that right. The basics of 'The Three Doctors' are as follows- there's three of them for the first ever multi-Doctor adventure. Omega ( a legendary figure from Gallifrey's past) returns and isn't very happy. And yes, the recorder does indeed save the day. Huzzah! But how? Is he lulled by its twinkly tones? Quite. Well..not quite. There's some science involved. And while nasty old Omega does indeed lay hands on the prized instrument it quickly proves a big mistake on his part. By touching an object charged with energy from 'our' universe having dwelled in a pocket one of his own creation it becomes apparent the bonkers stellar engineer might do himself a mischief. It does mean the Second Doctor needs a new recorder at the end of it all. Still at least there are some positives - he's managed to demonstrate his undoubted mastery by playing 'Twinkle Twinkle Little Star'. Curiously this seems to annoy his later self but never mind.

8. A Note Of Brilliance

After he's plopped back into his own timestream by the Time Lords, the Doctor remembers very little of his meeting with his past & future selves. About the only thing he knows for sure is that he lost his recorder somehow. The Third never delivered on his promise to buy him 'a thousand more' to replace the cherished wind instrument but no matter. In the 1995 'Doctor Who' Yearbook there's a short story by future new-Who writer Justin Richards which sees the Second venture to an alien music shop with Jamie & Zoe Heriot in tow to buy himself a new one. A brilliant spin on the original 'ricordaire'-from which it gets its name. And what's that in English,you may ask? Simply 'to remember'. Which leads us nicely on... so when I say run, run!

7. Tuneful Troughton

One of the lesser-known 'Who' and indeed recorder facts is that the Second is believed to have treated viewers to no fewer than fifteen blasts of musical magic with a little help from his own choice 'ricordaire'. And that's just counting televised adventures. Even off-screen Pat Troughton was a keen & accomplished player and jumped at the chance to imbue his Doctor with similar skill. Fittingly his first performance of sorts comes in 'The Power Of The Daleks' on Vulcan, subsequently incorporating Scottish music in 'The Highlanders' and going on to get an airing in 'The Underwater Menace' while visiting Atlantis. To which we can add whileunder Yeti capture in Tibet in 'The Abominable Snowmen' and even in front of the Daleks in 'The Evil Of The Daleks'. Jamie goes so far as to force him to leave it in the TARDIS when the crew land in Australia at the start of 'The Enemy Of The World'. And if we delve into his book-based escapades the canny Scot's gone a step further & chopped it into pieces in 'Twin Piques' from the 'Short Trips' series. But the cosmic hobo somehow acquires a new one..

6. It Sets Up 'The Three Doctors'

'For the Second, his meeting with his First & Third incarnations takes place immediately following 'The Mind Robber'. After he, Jamie & Zoe make a full pelt escape from the imploding Land Of Fiction following the defeat of the Master Brain,the Doctor realises he's left something important behind and goes back to get it. That's right. His recorder has somehow hung back-and the 1992 'Doctor Who' Yearbook story 'Future Imperfect' explains just what happens before he has to head off & help stop Omega from causing universal mayhem. The man he thought he knew as 'Lemuel Gulliver' from 'Gulliver's Travels' turns out to be a fellow Time Lord. And an important one-Goth. Goth will later become Chancellor as seen alongside the Fourth Doctor in 'The Deadly Assassin'- here though he's working as a spy for the Celestial Intervention Agency. Having monitored the Doctor throughout 'The Mind Robber' he shows him cosmic energy being drained from Gallifrey through a black hole and before you can say ' any objections?' he's stood in the TARDIS with both his future self and a companion he's yet to meet.

5. It's Handy As A Weapon

We now leap into the wonderful world of comics. And in these lovingly-inked graphic tales the recorder takes on a new purpose of sorts. On screen its a more peaceable proposition- the Doctor using it to help him think or simply amuse himself. Here, though, it has its uses as a game-changing weapon. Take a look at 'Pursued By The Trods' where its used to communicate with a mammoth herd & persuade them to help him knock out the Trod power supply. He, John & Gillian (the Doctor's grandchildren, who appear solely in the TV Comic stories) later return to Trodos in 'The Trodos Ambush'. They don't find Trods though. The Daleks have turned up and somehow wiped out the native population as a fine how do you do. But some survivors befriend the Doctor-and so a nice transition from enemy to friend is complete. Plus he gets to bash a Dalek with the hardy recorder. All arachnophobes should like this next one. In 'Master Of Spiders' he uses it to ward off some giant arachnids by using his playing to interfere with the control device of the titular Master Of Spiders- breaking his hold on the insects and buying time to build a ray gun which he uses to destroy this particular Master's mechanical hidey-hole. Which just goes to show the best way to demonstrate your power over an errant daddy long legs is to adopt a 'Beatle cut'. Thenlearn some tunes on the recorder and lord it over the fiend.

4. It Inspires Nostalgia

Remember this from 'Castrovalva'? The newly-regenerated Fifth Doctor has a tootle and senses that he should be familiar with it. It doesn't fit very well with his developing personality though- so quickly dumps it in favour of cricket. Take a look at;Wonder if he ever secretly had a go at playing the 'Test Match Special' theme away from the prying ears of Adric, Nyssa & Tegan? We'll never know. But it was a nice homage to Pat Troughton by Peter Davison- and there are several more by subsequent Doctors. Sarah Jane Smith finds it in the secondary console room of the TARDIS in 'The Masque Of Mandragora', while the Sixth Doctor eventually remembers how he cherished it in 'The Two Doctors' when he stumbles across its original owner/player. And its there in the Eleventh Doctor's drawing room aboard his own new improved Type 40 in the interactive game/episode simply titled ' TARDIS'. There'll always be a place for it here even if its not as fashionable in school orchestras any more.

3. All The Retro/Cool Cosplayers Love It

Go to any fan convention and we can almost guarantee you'll spot someone among all the new-Whovians paying homage to the Tenth & Eleventh Doctors who goes for the retro look. They may get rarer with each passing year,as the generation who used to watch the Second Doctor's adventures have long been 'grown up' & most likely wouldn't dream of donning the ill-fitting jacket & trousers. But if you find someone who has ,and even gone to the trouble of finding the exact same recorder you must do just one thing. Stop them & get a photo as a nice reminder of 'Who' at its classic series best. Better yet- restart the trend yourself! Watch everything from 'The Power Of The Daleks' to 'The War Games'. Then learn the mannerisms,catchphrases & basic recorder skills. With the Eleventh incarnation's time coming to an end there's never been a better time to revisit the man who's technically his younger brother in so many ways.

2. Oh, The Possibilities...

We really hope there's a follow-up to the brilliant 'An Adventure In Space & Time'. Reece Shearsmith's cameo as the late great Pat may have been short but it was indeed sweet- and wouldn't it be great to see the Troughton era given the same treatment Bill Hartnell's just had? One of the best bits would undoubtedly be any scene in which Mr Shearsmith has to play the recorder. Worth watching in itself. Sadly a great many of the original stories in which the Second actually has a play are lost thanks to the short-sighted BBC of the Sixties and beyond wiping many of the master tapes- but if these lost moments can be recreated once again as Mark Gatiss did so lovingly for the Hartnellian years we could be in for a treat. Why wasn't the news that some 'lost' episodes of 'The Enemy Of The World' & 'The Web Of Fear' greeted with massed bow tied recorder orchestras? The idea might have been pinched from Monty Python & their coconuts (think of 'The Holy Grail'). It would have been an amazing spectacle!

1. It's So Very Him

As stated at the top of the piece and worth repeating! The recorder is intrinsically part of the Second Doctor's appeal. He might look like a scruffy eccentric music teacher or a member of a Beatles tribute band...but he served as the perfect antidote to the haughty authoritarianism of his past self. Throwing himself into adventures where the First had simply warned against rewriting history even when he,Ian & Barbara found themselves in the middle of it.He really was the ultimate calculating clown. That Pat managed to give his incarnation the quirk of playing what was even then such an unfashionable instrument and making it an indelible part of his charm is surely a testament to his ability. Some of the children who grew up watching him may even have been inspired to try making music of their own- and doesn't that just make it all the lovelier? If you're one of them,maybe know someone who is, or just plain love Doctor Two feel free to get in touch!