Doctor Who: 15 Most Disastrous Stories Of All-Time

Those times when the strain has taken its toll and standards slipped a bit.

By Jonathon Carley /

Doctor Who fans are amongst some of the most passionate fanatics in the world. Mention wobbly sets at your peril. Yet some aspects of the programme are inexcusable and to be honest, we'd rather wish they had never happened. Always, the series has tried to push the boundaries of what it is possible to do on television. Compare Star Wars of 1977 with Doctor Who in the same year; the effects are incomparable, yet arguably at the time Doctor Who was at the top of its game, just as now. Doctor Who is an immensely difficult programme to make. Nevertheless there are times when the strain has taken its toll and standards slipped a bit, so here is a list of Doctor Who stories that became complete disasters.

15. The Chase

The title, for starters isn't exactly the most exciting and the story. A late replacement for another Terry Nation script, 'The Chase' is just as lacklustre. It does exactly what it says on the tin. As for the Daleks, the law of diminishing returns kicks in without mercy. The 6 episodes are a series of near misses between the Doctor and the Daleks throughout time and space as the Daleks embark on an assassination mission. They could have carried this on for months if they wanted as the writing is that unstructured. Also the Daleks in this story are absolute goons incapable basic tasks, stumbling over sums and on one occasion trundling into the sea. Uncharacteristic for a species that has just discovered the secret of time travel! The other major production problem was the Mechanoids. Despite allowing one of the best battle scenes of the series to take place, the props were built far too big causing a multitude of practical problems. As a result, they were never brought back again. There are few positives to this story. The Mechanoids are impressive but are never seen again, the Daleks are at their most moronic, and while a touching moment, the departure of Ian and Barbara is a serious loss to the series.

14. The Lodger & Closing Time

I include these together as they are fundamentally the same. The only difference being, one has Cybermen, the other doesn't. Starting with 'The Lodger', I actually had high hopes for this as I was familiar with the comic strip by Roberts on which the story was based. The flaw with the televised version was that the 'likeable' regular character of Mickey Smith is replaced by James Corden (Yes that is a legit complaint) as it feels like a contrived rehash of the Russell T Davies era format. Also both episodes also share a problem of just feeling in the way of the finale. 'Closing Time' in the arc heavy Series 6 is a serious culprit of this. What is worrying is what nearly happened to 'The Lodger'. For no particular reason, Roberts intended to add an antagonist from the past; Meglos. I can't even think of a way that would make sense never mind be desirable. 'Closing Time', is the sequel that no one asked for and made it a further damaging outing for the Cybermen, where 'love' proves to be lethal to them... again. This was supposed to be the Doctor's big send off before going to his 'death', in reality it is underwhelming. The thing that makes this a disaster is that anyone thought it was a good idea to do it not just once but twice.

13. The Space Pirates

The day this 6 part serial is found will be a sad one, because it could have been something we actually wanted instead. It really throws writer Robert Holmes' reputation into question. Only Episode 2 exists, and it shows 'The Space Pirates' to be a convoluted mess of facial hair, dodgy accents and wooden acting. It is a hotch podge of science fiction campness and clichés, masquerading as an outer space Western. As an indication to its absurdity, there is a whole scene depicting an egg being boiled, which gets more screen time than Patrick Troughton. With certain stories, the saving grace is the main players. Their involvement keeps things moving, and they act as a conduit for the audience to have their questions answered. Here the TARDIS crew are trapped aboard a space ship away from the action and feels like a waste of a strong regular cast. There is nobody to put the boot up the story. Never mind being lost, this story should never have happened in the first place, yet the BBC held on to the one existing episode because it had 'Technical Historical Significance'. And 'Power of the Daleks' doesn't? This story embodies the kind of silliness and goofiness that the current series is criticized for at times, but turned up to 11.

12. The Armageddon Factor

The climax of the season long 'Key to Time' arc was written by Bob Baker and Dave Martin, a lot was demanded of them for this story. The extended run time of 6 episodes might have been a good opportunity to build up suspense, tension and development but instead the story spends hours introducing excessive, irrelevant and ridiculous elements to fill time only to be hurriedly disposed of by the end. Artistically it's all a bit of a muddle too. There is a space station seemingly made of stone on the inside, whilst an opposing planet is built like a vision in beige and peach by Ikea. Wouldn't it make more sense aesthetically to switch those around? Filling a space station with concrete is just daft! What about the story arc? The first scene of the series' opening episode featured the White Guardian, who dispatched the Doctor on a quest to locate the pieces of the Key to Time. However here he is pretty much forgotten about. The climax of 'The Armageddon Factor' provides a rather muddled resolution. 'The Black Guardian' appears pretending to be 'the White Guardian', in order to claim the Key, only for the Doctor to re-disperse the key in time and space. Apart from undoing the work of the entire series, the White Guardian is currently probably still waiting for the Key to Time to restore the balance in time and space.

11. The Beast Below

'The Eleventh Hour' delivered honourably as an opening to Series 5, but I have always been of the belief that you can often tell the quality of a series from its second episode. Moffat himself has said 'The Beast Below' was a tough script to love, and upon airing it didn't bode well for this new era. The plot itself was bland and by the numbers at best. The dilemma and revelations presented come entirely through exposition, which gets very tiresome. You can see in the script Moffat's efforts to make things interesting, but it just makes the script less coherent. It makes the Doctor's reaction at the climax border on melodrama as he claims he'll have to change his name due to his actions. It is also the first instance of a villain, the Smilers, that looks good but ultimately does nothing. Something that has happened frequently since. But also the episode came at a time running up to a UK general election, so some of the linking themes about voting and other political parallels, felt like a very dull message being thrust upon us. Viewers of the Star Wars Prequels with know, politics, do not make sci fi interesting, if anything, they do the opposite.

10. Trial Of A Time Lord

Heaven knows why, but Producer, John Nathan-Turner and Script Editor, Eric Saward thought it would be a great idea to reflect the series 'trial' status after being recommissioned after hiatus, in the programme by putting the Doctor himself on trial. Not the best way of confidently relaunching the series. To its credit, the majority of the season is surprisingly ok and I'd go so far as to say underrated. It is only marred by the 'courtroom scenes' splicing their way into the action at uncomfortable regularity. A mistake was undoing Peri's fate at the last minute, nullifying one of the highlights of the series as well as raising other awkward questions. But as with 'The Key to Time' there was a lot of pressure for a good pay off at the end of the series. Robert Holmes, wrote the first 4 episodes and was intended to write the final two for the finale. He completed the first part and drafted notes on the final episode, that would draw the whole series to a close in dramatic style. However Holmes succumbed to illness and died before completing the episode. Script Editor, Eric Saward attempted to finish the script based on Holmes' notes and Nathan-Turner rejected it, after which Saward left the programme. Pip and Jane Baker were commissioned to write the very last episode from scratch, at short notice. To be fair it isn't a bad effort but it's a shadow of what could have been. Finally of course, this was Colin Baker's final appearance as the Doctor. BBC execs ordered that Colin Baker be replaced, effective immediately. It was an exceptionally cruel move on their part and deprived a Doctor, who had actually developed considerably for the better, a proper send off.

9. The Dominators

Throughout the 60's, the producers of Doctor Who were always looking for something to match the popularity of the Daleks, with varying degrees of success. 'The Dominators' featured one such experiment; the Quarks. The Quarks in themselves are curious little creations and memorable designs, but they were too easily defeated, being blown apart like cardboard. Their biggest flaw however is their subservience to the titular Dominators. Aside from looking ridiculous, the Dominators spend the whole 5 episodes swabbling like children. As such it is extremely difficult to take them seriously as any form of threat. Together they're like an all conquering Laurel and Hardy. One of the Dominators, Rago is the sensible, measured one. Toba, his second in command is the trigger happy half wit, intent on killing everything in sight. Turns out, Toba actually had the right idea, which communicates a very poor message. The basic plot is the Dominators drilling to the core of the planet and dropping a bomb down the shaft to make the planet nuclear. The whole exercise is padded out with the drilling being held up and started again for various reasons. This tedium lead to the 6 episodes being condensed it into 5. Even that is a stretch. 'The Dominators' was forgotten almost immediately and the Quarks were never seen on screen again, but featured in Doctor Who comics without their Dominator masters.

8. The Curse Of The Black Spot

If this is on anyone's lists of favourite episodes, I will be extremely surprised. This episode simply could not do anything that 'Pirates of the Caribbean' has done better. In addition, the whole wave (excuse the pun) of pirate mania in recent times has largely subsided. Due to the limitations of simple filming practicalities, the episode was shot while the ship used as the location was in dock in calm water, absolutely killing the swashbuckling atmosphere and therefore feels completely lifeless. In addition, the pirates don't actually do any pirating. They have their loot and just want to go home. Rory is killed again and comes back to life, which is by this time just getting tiresome and predictable. The Doctor is also exceptionally erratic, changing his theories on the 'Siren' every 5 seconds, making it hard to keep up with what is contradicted. But the biggest problem is how sloppily the episode was put together. I am of course talking about the pirate who disappears without explanation half way through the episode. Obviously the siren took him but it's only by the end of the episode and the fact the matter wasn't explained otherwise that you are left to draw this conclusion. Similar criticisms can be leveled at 'Journey to the Centre of the TARDIS', also written by Stephen Thompson.

7. Love And Monsters

Ironically I have no love for 'Love and Monsters'. Like 'The Space Pirates' the regulars aren't in the story much to make things bearable. The weight is put on Jackie Tyler's shoulders to give some sense of continuity with the main series. In a fairly impressive piece of guest miscasting Marc Warren plays Elton Pope who has been obsessed by the Doctor since he was a boy. The part doesn't really play to Warren's strengths, it would have been more interesting to see a skeptical and flawed lad have his eyes opened to the bigger world around him. As written, the already fawning Elton, a personification of fandom, doesn't have much room for development. Finally, the big problem with this story is how contrived it is, written around the inclusion of the Abzorbaloff. This was a creation of a ten year old as part of 'Blue Peter's' design a monster competition. While the concept has some weight, its realization resembled a great big hairy bogie. Added to that, it was hammed up by Peter Kay with a bizarre amalgamation of performance choices. The episode as a whole is a car crash of not bad ideas but ultimately add up to less than the individual parts. Also there is the dodgy relationship with a paving slab gag.

6. Fear Her

If I told you that the slot for this episode was initially going to be filled by a script from Stephen Fry, I think you'd agree that I could leave it at that. Following on from 'Love and Monsters' there is far more consensus that this episode stunk! Also Billie Piper gives us her best axe wielding Jack Nicholson impression. The episode kicks off the whole 'Love conquers all' victory that is borderline vomit inducing. Especially seeing as in the following story the Doctor makes a point of ruining perceived 'magic' with science. But also some of the darker themes are incredibly undermined, such as child abduction. There are posters all over the street about lost children, yet there isn't a single police officer in sight. The kids are left to play in the back alleys and front yards unsupervised. I'd say that was pretty poor parenting. 'Torchwood' would tackle a similar theme more effectively later that year. Matthew Graham, lead writer and creator of the incredibly popular 'Life of Mars' actually wrote this episode, which is unbelievable given how bad it is. This didn't improve much for 'The Almost People' and 'The Rebel Flesh' years later.

5. Time And The Rani

Time and the Rani makes some of the other stories on this list seem like masterpieces. Look at the set up, you have Sylvester McCoy in a wig dressed as Colin Baker, regenerating into Sylvester McCoy without a wig dressed as Colin Baker, Bonnie Langford screaming her face off and Kate O'Mara pretending to be Bonnie Langford . Oh and a giant testicle, I mean brain. Sylvester McCoy often gets a bashing as does Bonnie Langford, rather unfairly. Consider, if Bonnie Langford is given a script that reads 'Mel screams', there's only so much she can do with that. You can see that the players are all embarrassed to be spurting this drivel. The script is a mess and the plot is absurd even by Doctor Who standards. The audience are treated as mugs and is deprecating to the series as well as the lead character. Furthermore, the action is stopped dead half way through for the Doctor to play dress up and choose his new outfit! Written by the husband and wife writing team of Pip and Jane Baker, it becomes clear that writing in a domestic setting, it must be hard to constructively criticize each other's ideas. The saddest thing of all is that it is an undignified end to the Sixth Doctor, regenerating after supposedly falling off his exercise bike during a 'tumultuous buffeting'.

4. Underworld

I watched 'Underworld' and simply couldn't follow it, mainly because it is incredibly boring. So I read the story breakdown, which is also incredibly boring. I can only deduce therefore that Underworld is incredibly boring. I suppose the most obvious problem here is the production values are dreadful. The story is mostly shot against Blue/Green screen, because there wasn't any money to build more than a handful of sets. This leaves this story with some of the worst special effects in Doctor Who history. The script couldn't fill its allotted run time. Some shots are repeated to pad out the story, other scenes are contrived to fit around not so much the plot but the run time. Rather than save a comrade immediately they just wait until the writer says they can do something. It's like they know they're in a bad television programme. The actors, including the regulars also seem to be bored stiff too, just like the audience, waiting for it to end. A personal complaint relates to the inspiring chant the Minyans have; 'The quest is the quest'. What does that even mean? Is it some kind of existential philosophy? That is like saying an apple is an apple. Of course it is! It's an apple! That is by far the dumbest thing about this script and it's repeated about a thousand times. It was considered scrapping the story altogether and allotting the budget to, 'The Invasion of Time', but this was ultimately rejected.

3. Timelash

Timelash is just an awful script, played out by an awful cast, regulars excluded and is pretty much inexcusable. Colin Baker and Nicola Bryant as the Doctor and Peri really struggle to keep a terrible story going. It's like watching people drown. There are only two guilty pleasures. The first of which is the Borad, as a physical creation is actually one of the best designs and make up jobs throughout the 80's. There is just nothing to substantiate it narratively. The second guilty pleasure is the guest appearance of 'Blake's 7' actor Paul Darrow, having the time of his life gatecrashing the rival programme, gnawing at the scenery and it is infectious. But the script is still absolute drivel. Timelash was originally submitted by 'Casualty' writer Glen McCoy as a story featuring the Daleks. Script Editor, Eric Saward requested the Daleks be removed, and the script resubmitted. The result is a story that barely holds together, with multiple scenes of waffling dialogue. In addition, the climax has a massive plot hole that simply can not be explained. Rather the writer chooses not make an effort to explain it opting for the smug 'I'll explain later' explanation. Oh yes H.G. Wells is in this as well, and he's an irritating little twerp and a disappointing use of such a potentially interesting character. Did I mention that there is also deadly tinsel in this story and one of the key antagonists is a sock puppet. Yup! The execution of Timelash is just dire and represents all that was bad about late 80's Doctor Who.

2. Warriors Of The Deep

Writer Johnny Byrne would have been better off creating an original monster for his purposes, as his script and the series history to not link at all, despite novelisations and reference books being available. Byrne writes his script around an unseen story, which introduces all number of continuity headaches. One aspect of this is the Silurians have a pet cyborg called the Myrka. It's a great big rubbery thing that knocks down a great big rubbery door and is immune to great big overacted judo kicks. Like 'Underworld' the guest cast may as well have been played by sacks of potatoes as they spurt abysmal dialogue. This is one of the few stories where nobody other than the regulars survives to the end, yet if anything it's a blessed relief. The biggest plotting issue by far is in the first 10 minutes of episode 1 after the reptilian Silurians and Sea Devils are introduced, the Doctor spots canisters of gas and states the following, "Hexachromite gas is lethal to marine and reptile life.". In no programme would dropping such an unsubtle plot point like that be excusable. 'Warriors of the Deep' is said to be one of the worst produced stories of Doctor Who, due to various industrial and indeed political disputes going on at the time. It's a miracle that this story was made, but I think some would prefer it never had been.

1. The Twin Dilemma

It's too easy to pick on 'The Twin Dilemma' because it had a tortured conception, execution and reception. The production team made the unusual choice of having the Sixth Doctor dance on the Fifth Doctor's grave by putting 'The Twin Dilemma' immediately after 'The Caves of Androzani' as the last episode of the series. Putting any story immediately after 'The Caves of Androzani' is going to make the latter look bad, but as it is, we have possibly Doctor Who's best story followed by possibly the worst. Our main antagonist is a giant slug called 'Mestor' who looks like a sack of manure, and his henchmen, the Jacondans who look like they have been covered in wallpaper paste and thrust into the stuffing section of a pillow factory. The actual plot is farcical, suffering from a similar sort of absurd science as 'Time and the Rani'. The melodramatic performances also destroy any credibility the story might have had. It's hard to see the light at the end of the tunnel and I think some of that comes down to the scripting stage seeing 'negative' as more dramatic, but also a lot is asked of Colin Baker for his first performance as the Doctor. Often the stories are shot out of production order and the first to air story is shot later on, to let the lead settle into the role. Making 'The Twin Dilemma' part of Davison's last series made that impossible, but also meant that the audience's lasting impression of the 'unstable' Doctor was a negative one and that sour taste would have lingered all through the series break. Everyone's thoughts on disastrous Doctor Who stories are different, the ones listed here are just a few exceptionally troubled examples. What are your thoughts, should any other stories have made it into this list? Let us know in the comments.